Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Simpsons.

62 replies

Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 09:50

Just wondered what people thought of this.

So The Simpsons has been a long running cartoon which has been on at around 6pm on ‘general tv’ for a very long time. I remember watching it as a kid myself, it was a normal thing just to be on the tv ‘in the background’ in our home.

A lot of the jokes of course, very political, went over my head, way too young for me to understand. When I was an adult I of course saw the programme in a different light of understanding. But otherwise, it was a common thing for us children to watch on my home and for others at school in my youth, so much I even remember sitting at my friends house and watching it with her family when I went over for tea (primary school).

So my DD is 10. Being a cartoon she’s sat and watched it briefly a few times when nothing has been on and she’s either eating her tea or just generally pottering around.

We have Disney plus, which she’s been watching more. Most recently, I’d say over the past few days she’s been watching the old reruns of The Simpson’s. I noticed the r rating was a 12 - which I didn’t think too much of, some mild sweating which she knows not to repeat but me and my partner sat down to watch with her the other day (it’s been years since both of us watched it!) and was surprised at how much we forgot the inappropriateness for a child of her age!
The swearing and the showing of cartoon ‘butts’ doesn’t bother me, it’s the constant references to sex I didn’t realise exactly how much there was - probably because when I was younger it completely went over my head enough for me to realise what was going on! I cringed at one point at a scene with Ned Flanders and a typical ‘tall sexy blonde’ and as much as she has not asked about sex yet I know she probably has somewhat of an idea, she does okay with older children at school. In my view now, some of the scenes are enough to guess that sex is a thing between adults and it happens frequently.

She has not mentioned anything I’m very surprised she did not turn around and ask what it was.

As much as I don’t usually mind her watching 12 rated things at 10 depending what it is - it had been enough for me to question this so I was wondering what everyone else’s take on it is? Do you or would you let your children of the same age watch it?

OP posts:
Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 13:02

@CreamFirstThenJamOnTop
It’s something that’s crossed my mind to sit down and have the talk with her. I remember my mum doing it (around 11/12?) wayyy too late. My dad even later at 16 tried to and I just laughed at him Blush. Proper cringey memory! I will have a look in to having a sit down and a formal chat about it I’d no idea where to start or how to even go about it though

@bubblebath62636 just to clarify, they don’t actually kiss, just make kissing noises at each other and call it snogging!

OP posts:
bubblebath62636 · 22/09/2021 12:47

she’s played pretend ‘dating’ games with her step sister before where they pretend to be boyfriend and girlfriend and they have pretended to ‘snog’
😲

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 22/09/2021 12:40

It started when I was 10 and I’ve always watched it…. so much went over my head that I didn’t get.
It is pretty much DHs favourite show and he and DD (6) watch it together almost every evening. Loads goes over her head, some things prompt questions and some she finds funny.

On another note….. at nearly 10 sure your daughter needs to be told about sex?? Just some basic info. Otherwise she’s likely to hear a lot of inaccurate info from other kids.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 22/09/2021 12:28

Monster House is good. Such a sad story at the end.

SalmonEile · 22/09/2021 12:26

I grew up watching the simpsons, most of the sex talk and innuendos went over my head completely, even when Marge was shown to be naked in bed with Homer I never really thought anything of it

However, I remember as a teen watching an episode with my much younger siblings where Marge and Homers sex life is dwindling so they start having sex in public because of the thrill. This then features a scene of them cuddling naked (homers ass Is visible so there’s no doubt about what they’re doing ) in a windmill on a mini golf course , they get discovered and flee through the town naked and then end up in a packed football stadium with every one photographing them , so they stop trying to cover themselves with their hands and relish in being photographed completely naked with all the eyes “leering “ at them. When the photos feature in the paper They try and explain it to the kids but end up getting turned on by the memory of it all and rush out of the house to go back to the golf course leaving the kids home alone.

Honestly I found that was the episode for me where the simpsons crossed over from “family viewing”
Another was Marge getting a boob job and everyone gushing over her huge boobs , there was even a song about it. compared to say the episode where Homer dances with the stripper or when Bart works at the burlesque house - while those dealt with adult themes the later episodes just seemed so much more explicit

SirenSays · 22/09/2021 12:11

Simpsons wasn't allowed in my house growing up. My mother has no time for anything animated, annoys the hell out of her. I never liked itchy and scratchy so that was fine by me.
I still remember my SIL having this exact conversation with my mother, that she'd put it on for my nephew and was shocked at how mature in places it seemed.

NeilBuchananisBanksy · 22/09/2021 11:47

I think you need to sit her down and talk about sex with her to be honest. She's old and for you to not have had the discussion is odd. Better to hear it in a safe way from you than from others...

aSofaNearYou · 22/09/2021 11:41

What about The Others with Nicole Kidman? Spooky, but not horror as such. It is a 12 rating though.

I was going to suggest that but actually thinking about it that's exactly what my parents thought when I was at that age and it terrified me! I would be much more worried about horror than sexual themes, it had much more of a negative affect on me as a kid.

mooongooose · 22/09/2021 11:39

*What about The Others with Nicole Kidman? Spooky, but not horror as such. It is a 12 rating though.

We used to be avid Simpsons watchers, but now we just don't watch it. I hate the violence between Homer and Bart and how Marge is so put upon. Sometimes it has some clever moments, but they seem to be less and less.*

I can't comment on the other shows you mentioned as I haven't seen them, but to me all the handwringing over the simpsons is a bit Helen Lovejoy. I just can't see the issue. Kids will see stuff like lingerie adverts out and about. We'd probably roll our eyes at a parent being precious over something like that, you know? Especially when kids are whispering much worse on the playground

It's all relative of course but I just think that basically everyone grew up watching the simpsons. The strangling with homer isn't good, but the fact it's a cartoon- it will never have the same impact as a live-action character doing the same.

I'm probably biased because I love the older simpsons episodes. It never occurred to me that a show like this would be inappropriate because I was playing GTA at 10 years old and turned out fineGrin

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 22/09/2021 11:37

DS3 had sex education talk at school in year 5 when he was 9. DS2 taught himself from books from about 6, apart from asking about a few practicalities when he was 9.

EvilPea · 22/09/2021 11:31

A lot of older tv (and songs) has ALOT of sexual references. Watching a lot of the older stuff on gold etc with kids is a bit Confused now. But it was just normal and went over our heads.
I wonder if some of these are older ones as well as the censoring issue.

longtompot · 22/09/2021 11:30

[quote Justbecauseofit]@mooongooose

I think that I’ve overthought it that much that I didn’t know whether I was being a shit mum by exposing her too early to that stuff or overreacting. It’s clear from the responses that it’s probably the latter!

She has said she wants to watch a horror film soon… mum can I please watch Annabelle?

Errr… no!!

So I’ve been looking at some not too scary but appropriate ones for her to watch and the best I could come up with was Signs 😂[/quote]
What about The Others with Nicole Kidman? Spooky, but not horror as such. It is a 12 rating though.

We used to be avid Simpsons watchers, but now we just don't watch it. I hate the violence between Homer and Bart and how Marge is so put upon. Sometimes it has some clever moments, but they seem to be less and less.

Macncheeseballs · 22/09/2021 11:28

Mine watched it and loved it, then moved on to friends, now that's got some pretty cringe bits in it

UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername · 22/09/2021 11:18

Mine are 11 and 9 and I'm not happy with them watching it. There are better choices for them. And it's not that they don't know about sex, we've spoken about it at age appropriate levels. I don't think they need to see quite so many dysfunctional and unhappy adults yet.

crystaltips98 · 22/09/2021 11:12

Lots of 'family viewing' American sitcoms feature sex, casual sex and sex talk as normal but then film married couples in bed in full clothing at opposite ends of the bed as if its taboo to be in a healthy relationship.

AmyandPhilipfan · 22/09/2021 11:02

I went on a course about 15 years ago about various things to do with child development and I remember the course leader saying ‘The Simpsons is a great cartoon but it’s not designed for children. It’s not appropriate for under 12s.’ So I never let my kids watch it. The older two are 12 and 13 now and I would be fine with them watching it these days.

Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 10:49

@aSofaNearYou yes I understand what you mean, it’s not going to harm her now at this age to have some exposure to it. I still see her and a baby I need to protect at times and as much as I do try and encourage independence and her growing up and I know I can’t protect her from everything I think as a mum you just want to cling on to their youth to stop them growing up don’t you. It’s hard to know where the balance lies sometimes.

My partner is stricter with the girls, the amount of times “she’s still a child” is said in this house, it mainly comes from him rather than me. She’s not got a phone yet, but it’s the plan to get one this year for her birthday as she is playing out on the street at her dads house and I feel she’s at the stage where she will need one for safety. He still thinks it’s too young! We were brought up very differently though.

I will let her continue to watch The Simpson’s and I will prepare for whatever questions come my way Blush

OP posts:
BiBabbles · 22/09/2021 10:48

It is pretty adult, though as others said much of what was previously screened was edited and many things can go over some kids heads.

Not all kids about all of it though. I'm fairly certain it was Simpsons and something to do with Mr Smithers that resulted in my definitely under 10 self asking my mother how gay men had sex, her responding with "do you really me to tell you, cause I will if you want me to" with an expression I now know meant "but I really don't want to" so I said after a pause "No, I think I figured it out." But then I also grew up watching Beavis and Butthead (even dressed as Beavis for Halloween at 12, my brother was Butthead) so yeah...

It depends on the school when they cover those topics, though they should have their sex and relationship education information on their website (how well that's followed is a different matter). There will almost certainly be some kids at school who broach the topic at some point by now. I was slightly older when it was a big conversation in PE class around who knew what 69 meant.

I have a child who I thought was oblivious, but I've since learned that not all kids ask those types of questions, even when otherwise generally open and honest. They can have a different idea of privacy and comfort levels around topics they view as personal.

At that age, my DS had never asked (and literally left the room if someone else brought the topic up which should have been a clue) and if you asked him where babies came from, he would quote a science documentary about people coming from stardust. It was very cute if a bit concerning at that age.

He did in fact know, he just didn't want to talk or ask about it (this is also the child who didn't ask a why question until he was 6, and that one was out of annoyance than curiosity). He instead went to books, possibly his peers, and eventually the internet. We ended up having to do what he now calls "very thorough" relationship and sex education lessons because he would not ask anything and I could not tell what he knew (& he was home educated so I had to cover the topic in detail anyways which was entirely awkward and I bribed us both to get through it) which I've since done for all my kids before hitting secondary age. Once more and I'm gladly done with that.

aSofaNearYou · 22/09/2021 10:38

But alongside that in all honesty I think it's healthy for kids to see things that are bad/naughty etc on tv, as the stuff that is aimed at them is FAR more moralistic and squeaky clean than it used to be. I know the age old "it didn't do me any harm" thing is a bit of a cliche but I do think there's some truth in it, and it helps to build a more balanced and less coddled individual.

Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 10:36

@mooongooose

I think that I’ve overthought it that much that I didn’t know whether I was being a shit mum by exposing her too early to that stuff or overreacting. It’s clear from the responses that it’s probably the latter!

She has said she wants to watch a horror film soon… mum can I please watch Annabelle?

Errr… no!!

So I’ve been looking at some not too scary but appropriate ones for her to watch and the best I could come up with was Signs 😂

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 22/09/2021 10:36

Hmm, I think your focus is wrong on this one. There are some outdated ideas on The Simpson's that don't really fit with today's society, some of them have been mentioned already, and those I would question.

But just talking about sex I wouldn't be concerned about at all. Your daughter is at a perfectly normal age to learn about sex, and I'd expect the teenage years to be more of a challenge on that front now than they used to be, with young people having much easier access to the internet. A few cartoons mentioning it here and there beforehand is unlikely to do any damage.

LadyCatStark · 22/09/2021 10:35

Wait til she starts watching Friends! My opinion is most of it goes over their heads until they’re ready to know about it.

Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 10:30

@PoolNooodle

Yes it was a favourite show as a child I remember. South Park was as well come to think of it. I had the bedding and all the teddies there’s no way I’d let her watch anything like that!!

OP posts:
mooongooose · 22/09/2021 10:29

It's fine, come on. You watched it and said you didn't understand any of it yourself at her age. No now of us did! And the jokes are pretty mild anyway. Now if she was watching South Park, you'd have a point.

Justbecauseofit · 22/09/2021 10:28

@Rosebel she has just stared year 5. I think it wasn’t until year 6 where I clocked on and it was the gossip of the playground but then again information is more accessible these days isn’t it

OP posts: