Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DB young fiancée

118 replies

Whereartthou · 22/09/2021 08:53

Younger DB and I are in our late forties. As children we were very close. As adults less so as he became very bad tempered. Until this year he had never had a long term relationship. He often made comments about not wanting to tie himself down to a woman who would boss him around and get old. Despite his bad temper and occasional misogynistic comments he is not a bad person. He often admitted he wouldn’t make a good husband as he dislikes other people in his space and so would stay single. He was always good to my parents and to my DC. Recently, out of the blue, he has got engaged to a woman in her twenties - 20 years younger than we are. I barely know her yet. I’ve told him I’m happy for him and I am as I sometimes worried about him. However I feel sad that any residual closeness we had may now dissipate as he will focus on her and her much younger friends and eventually their much younger children. A part of me also feels that while I dismissed his occasional misogynistic comments about women, especially older women, as just his general irritability, now it seems as if there may have been truth to it after all. As I am older than him I feel a little odd about it all. I’ll be happy for him but…any thoughts in general out there? I should be glad he’s ok and just let him get on with his life, shouldn’t I?

OP posts:
MyPatronusIsACat · 22/09/2021 11:04

[quote Whereartthou]@stompythedinosaur
That women over 30 fall off a cliff in looks. That now I’m approaching 50 how does my DH feel about that? That he couldn’t stand to be told what to do by a woman.[/quote]
He think that women over 30 fall off a cliff in looks.

If your rude and misogynistic brother thinks this. Is he going to dump his new squeeze in a couple of years then? Because she will be 30 then yes?

Also, any man who thinks a woman starts losing her looks when she gets to 30 is a cunt.

IMO, and IME, it's an old myth load of bollocks that men age beautifully, and women turn into rancid hags. I know more women who are ageing - well into their 50s and 60s - who look fab. Nice skin, lovely hair, still got good teeth, figure still OK, and who are very attractive. Conversely, I know some men of the same age who are going to shit, with beer bellies/paunches, bald spots, saggy jowels, and yellow teeth.

Not saying ALL men are like this obvs! But more women than men look good past the age of 45/50 IME.

And your brother's attitude that 'no woman will tell him what to do?' WTF? What is wrong with him? Why does he have such a horrible attitude towards women? Are there deeper issues at play here? Is there something you haven't told us. Men don't normally despise women as much as this for no reason.

Bekind2yourself · 22/09/2021 11:00

In the gentlest way … I noticed you have mentioned your own age and relationship a few times. Is it possible you feel replaced by this new woman in his life …

“She’s in her late 20s, beautiful, intelligent and educated”

Perhaps you have been more affected by your brother’s views than you realise.

It’s not uncommon for us to start feeling invisible in our late 40s, especially when we compare ourselves to someone 20 years younger.

Apologies, if I’m on the wrong track but maybe worth reflecting on???

AnotherFruitcake · 22/09/2021 10:56

Your brother sounds like a pig -- even you admit he's bad-tempered and misogynist, and seems to have a lot of weird issues about women ageing, as though he's not in fact ageing himself, which you seem in part to share, given your worry that's he's going to become focused on his younger fiancée and her friends, while you age out of his 'interest-zone'.

Honestly, OP, I'd be unpicking why you seem to have internalised his unpleasant, ageist views, and hoping his fiancée doesn't end up doing the same.

dottiedodah · 22/09/2021 10:56

EnidFrighten Yes I agree totally! I think even though we have equality now ,it still seems strange that older (usually successful) men are almost revered for having"sown their wild oats" and then settled down with a beautiful young woman. Like you say, the other way about and suddenly its all a bit desperate ,cougar like behaviour !

FreeBritnee · 22/09/2021 10:54

I feel like there’s more to your feelings here. It sounds like you are threatened by an attractive 20 something year old coming into your family and having children. Have you got children of your own? Are you concerned your husband might find her attractive?

EnidFrighten · 22/09/2021 10:51

What does she get out of being with this misogynistic old fart bag with a secret heart of gold? Your relationship with him is your business. You're setting it up to blame her if your brother CBA keeping up with you. It's on him, he's not a child. I for one don't know why it's socially acceptable for men to start a family in late 40s when women would be called all kinds of names.

Joystir59 · 22/09/2021 10:50

He sounds like a right misogynist. I'd be worried about the wellbeing of his young fiancee, that's what I thought your thread was going to be about.

QueeniesCroft · 22/09/2021 10:48

I would say that out of the two of them he is the more likely to be hurt, or at least would take it harder if it fell apart

This exact thing was said about my husband and I. To the point that my father had a proper go at me about not hurting him(yes, my father is also a dick!). It was my husband's first relationship, at 41. I was (just) 20.

One of us has been abusive. It wasn't me. I honestly wouldn't be too concerned about your brother, but I would keep an eye out for signs of trouble, in case his fiancée needs help in the future. I have no help or support because it took me too long to see how it was being eroded. Don't let that happen to her, please.

Booboobadoo · 22/09/2021 10:33

[quote Whereartthou]@stompythedinosaur
That women over 30 fall off a cliff in looks. That now I’m approaching 50 how does my DH feel about that? That he couldn’t stand to be told what to do by a woman.[/quote]
He said these things to you?? These aren't nice things to say

Dozer · 22/09/2021 10:32

You seem to have ignored some red flags that your brother has sexist attitudes and issues in his social and sexual relationships.

He’s not a great prospect for his fiance. Being attractive, successful at work and socially, doesn’t protect women from men who are lacking, at best.

Helmetbymidnight · 22/09/2021 10:27

You honestly sound incredibly selfish.

Wha-at? Why?

Anyway, yes, I would just stand back and let him get on with it because what's the alternative?! :) and keep an open-mind about the woman he has got involved with - you never know - he might be ready to grow up.

MyPatronusIsACat · 22/09/2021 10:21

Sorry I don't know why I put that she was 23, I don't know where I got that from! I stand by the rest of what I said though.

MyPatronusIsACat · 22/09/2021 10:19

@LadyDanburysHat

I would be more concerned about this young woman who has found herself attached to a much older misogynistic man. You say you don't know her, but it have you tried to get to know her. You honestly sound incredibly selfish.
This. ^ @Whereartthou you are sounding weirdly selfish, as none of this has anything to do with you really, but...... YANBU to feel as you do.

I have to say though, and sorry if this offends you, your brother doesn't sound like a particularly nice person, and I am really worried for this young 23 y.o. woman.

I would be freaking out if my young 20-something DD came home and told me she was with a man old enough to be her father. Especially as he has explicitly said he never wants to be with anyone, and is very misogynistic and aggressive and bad tempered. OMG that poor young woman. You should probably warn her off him, but that may push them closer together,.

I seriously question the morals and intentions of a middle aged man getting with a woman who is barely out of her teens. Grubby, creepy, and sinister. And those are 3 of the better adjectives I can come up with!

mytortoiseisill · 22/09/2021 10:19

it's an adjustment for you OP. but hopefully a nice one :)

banana, my sil was the same for many years, it's much better now.

Whereartthou · 22/09/2021 10:18

@bananarama21 And yes - siblings who can’t let go are weird!!! I agree there so touché!

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 22/09/2021 10:16

I dont think you seem at all selfish! You are right to be concerned ,however they are both able to make their own decisions so nothing you can do really.DB sounds a touch misogynistic ,but if he treats her well and they are happy thats all that matters.So many middle aged and older men seem to want a young wife. Seems shallow really ,esp if she has a good job and is educated .Try to remain close if you can

Whereartthou · 22/09/2021 10:15

@PinkFootstool

Your DB sounds delightful.... I'm not seeing anything in your OP about this close relationship you're worried about losing. You said you're not that close anymore.

Why would you lose any relationship just because he's engaged anyway? Will he turn his back on you? Have you tried to meet the fiancée yet? What are you actually worried about here?

We were extremely close as children and I guess I’ve always hoped that closeness would spark again. We’re by no means on top of each other - we don’t meet that often as don’t live that close and we’re both busy with our own lives. But we work in the same field and keep in touch a lot - he’s very good in fact at keeping in touch and is often the one to suggest meeting. It’s just that whenever we do meet he seems to become suffocated by the simplest conversation after about 20 mins and can’t/won’t answer the simplest questions. Eg “This is delicious. What’s in it?” “Just random stuff. Why do you want to know?” He does this with all our family, not just me. I always hoped we’d get back to the funny, relaxed banter we used to have as kids. Maybe pps are right and his future DW will be the making of him. People are often funny about in-laws though, especially if there’s a big age gap and we’re boring old farts (in the eyes of a twenty-something). And of course there is his difficult obsession with younger women attitude. I did worry about him for a good while though as he seemed to be pushing everyone away and always seemed unhappy and irritable. So it’s great that he hopefully has a happy time ahead.
OP posts:
Bananarama21 · 22/09/2021 10:02

I found your post strange siblings should be craving life our for themselves. I remember sil being upset about losing her brother when I was pregnant with dd, it was bit strange she was single at the time but now has a family of her own.

Plumtree391 · 22/09/2021 10:02

@Whereartthou

She’s in her late 20s, beautiful, intelligent and educated. I’ve only recently been aware of the relationship but they know each other and their friends well. So I think she’s able to make her own decisions.
By late twenties most people are mature enough to make up their minds about who to marry.

She may be very good for your brother and you find he stops with the misogynistic comments which he probably only said off the top of his head. I hope he is good for her too.

My cousin was with someone seventeen years older than her, from her early twenties. They were very, very happy. Unfortunately he developed cancer and died in his late fifties. She was heartbroken, he was a lovely man.

Just think, you may have a little niece or nephew soon.

Whereartthou · 22/09/2021 10:02

@honeylulu

Ugh. Good luck to his fiancee.

It might be the making of him though. I've seen it happen before. Male friend from uni. Very much a man's man. Only interested in attractive blonde slim women. Was adamant he would never get married or have children. Would dump his (very nice) girlfriends once he got bored with them.

This all worked very well until he got to middle age and lost his own good looks, got fatter etc. Suddenly he didn't have his pick of young attractive women any more. He tried OLD but was still unwilling to compromise by dating women of his own age. The younger more attractive women weren't interested in casual dating a commitment phobic middle aged man. So he realised he had to offer something more. He did end up marrying a much younger woman in his 40s as she made clear she wouldn't stick around for less. We ribbed him a bit and he said well, he was still not going to have any children.

Guess what. Before too long they had a child. He was astonished to find that he loved family life and being settled.

This is exactly him!!
OP posts:
honeylulu · 22/09/2021 09:58

Ugh. Good luck to his fiancee.

It might be the making of him though. I've seen it happen before. Male friend from uni. Very much a man's man. Only interested in attractive blonde slim women. Was adamant he would never get married or have children. Would dump his (very nice) girlfriends once he got bored with them.

This all worked very well until he got to middle age and lost his own good looks, got fatter etc. Suddenly he didn't have his pick of young attractive women any more. He tried OLD but was still unwilling to compromise by dating women of his own age. The younger more attractive women weren't interested in casual dating a commitment phobic middle aged man. So he realised he had to offer something more. He did end up marrying a much younger woman in his 40s as she made clear she wouldn't stick around for less. We ribbed him a bit and he said well, he was still not going to have any children.

Guess what. Before too long they had a child. He was astonished to find that he loved family life and being settled.

PinkFootstool · 22/09/2021 09:54

Your DB sounds delightful.... I'm not seeing anything in your OP about this close relationship you're worried about losing. You said you're not that close anymore.

Why would you lose any relationship just because he's engaged anyway? Will he turn his back on you? Have you tried to meet the fiancée yet? What are you actually worried about here?

HarrietsChariot · 22/09/2021 09:51

I honestly don't see the problem here. Your brother has finally found someone he wants to settle down with. To me his comments like "he doesn't want a woman bossing him around" were a smokescreen, it was easier for him to deflect the reason for him being single than to confront the fact he hadn't found anyone.

The woman he's marrying is old enough to make her own decisions, yet young enough to divorce and find a new partner if this turns out to be a mistake.

TBH I do feel this is more about you, you've been so used to having him unattached that you are sad he will have someone in his life his entire focus is on.

CreepingDeath · 22/09/2021 09:49

Honestly, I think this is more about you and how you feel in yourself and your own relationship. I’m not saying your brother doesn’t sound like a jerk, he is! But his fiancé is an adult and has made her choice, however unpleasant ( a much older misogynistic husband doesn’t sound like a catch to me).

I do wonder if you grew up with a misogynist father figure? It would seem that your brother absorbed this attitude about women, but you may also have some internalised misogyny in how you view your worth as an older woman.

If you are having relationship problems that is another issue, the fact that you automatically assume it’s to do with your age and that your husband is suddenly going off you (as though you have sone sort of sell by date) is very telling.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 09:44

Of course women age as they get older, men do too. But he presumably knows his partner will also age?

I suppose the whole situation seems a bit sad and worrying for the young woman involved.