Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preschool pressures

62 replies

Mrs2020 · 21/09/2021 22:55

My 3.5 year old has always been cared for by a family member or myself all her life (never been to nursery). We do lots of activities to try and help with socialisation more (especially given pandemic challenges over last 18months)- she goes to 2 sports/dance classes, various stay & plays and regular play dates. I also have a 1 year old boy, so they have each other to interact with. We do at least one proper day out in the week in addition (National trust, farms, etc). Obviously some days are less successful than others- but we have a fairly active week for the most part.

She’s confident, curious, happy and loves the company of other children. She’s meeting and exceeding “milestones”- she can read first stage books and do sums.

We’re getting a lot of pressure from family members and friends- they can’t understand why she isn’t in preschool. They believe she’s missing out and will struggle when she starts school next year as she’s not been in a formal environment without me. My husband thinks I should compromise and send her to 2-3 preschool sessions a week- he’s not unhappy with anything now but thinks it would give me more time to focus on baby alone.

Am I being unreasonable to want to look after her myself rather than sending her to a preschool? I don’t want to make things difficult for her starting school next year, but at the same time selfishly I’m loving all being together each day. I don’t want to be selfish and keep her with me, if she would have a better start from going to a preschool if that makes sense!

OP posts:
10ColaBottles · 22/09/2021 07:57

@thepinknecklace

Aw god another “my kid can read at 3.5 aren’t they soooo clever....” stealth boast post.

Do what you want OP.

I meant to quote this post.

No stealth boasting from me today. ! I clearly should have stayed at home with my mother 😂

10ColaBottles · 22/09/2021 07:56

@HikingforScenery

I agree with your husband. As you say, you “selfishly” want to keep her at home. Sounds like you know deep down that it’ll be good for her to get some exposure to a formal setting before school

The point here I agree with is that (apart from it being a poorly disguised stealth boast) the attendance at preschool isn't really about the academic stuff. It's about the socialisation in large groups, learning to line up (I mean properly!), take a turn amongst many, clear their plates to the washing up area after lunch, sit quietly in a big group and so much more.

You child is missing out.

MinnieMountain · 22/09/2021 07:53

If it help, have a look at the Early Years Foundation Stage. I think most preschools follow it.

Plotato · 22/09/2021 07:44

As someone at home with a baby and 3 year old - hats off to you! I cannot begin to imagine life if the 3 year old wasn't out of my hair at nursery some days. You need to do what's right for your family but I read an interesting thing about Germany recently, about how the right of children to have an independent life away from their family is held in very high regard - a very high percentage go to pre-school and home schooling is not allowed. I've been pondering it since - the point was made that it's not always easy for the parents but is believed to be in the best interests of the child. I don't know how culturally true this really is but I do think it's a different way of looking at it and that even young children should be allowed to explore friendships etc that aren't completely directed by their parents.

RampantIvy · 22/09/2021 07:39

I agree with everyone else. Preschool is not at all formal, and she could go for 2 or 3 mornings a week.

I agree that your argument for not sending her is more about what you want and not what your DD might want and need.

Preschool provides a gentle transition between being at home all the time and starting school.

Heronwatcher · 22/09/2021 07:27

I’m in two minds here, I can see their point. Starting school is very different from socialising with parents and in all honesty a few mornings a week will probably make things easier for her when she starts reception. You may be able to get a pre-school for her where she meets some of the kids who will be with her. I understand your position but I think you could maybe take a step back and think about what’s genuinely best for her in the long term. You’d still have loads of time with her if she did a couple of mornings, and you may get 15 or 30 hours free.

Jellycatspyjamas · 22/09/2021 07:24

Your child won’t be harmed by not going to pre-school, if you enjoy time home with her and she enjoys it just keep her at home. 4 is young enough to be starting education and there’s no reason why she won’t adapt to her new environment when the time comes.

kezziahcat · 22/09/2021 07:22

Do whatever suits you and your family op. My very clingy, pre school hating ds missed out on a lot of preschool because of covid and was fine starting school much to everyone's surprise. My dd goes for the free 15 hours (2.5 days) just because she loves it and I love the time alone. I think it can really benefit them socially and getting used to rules and expectations (there are a lot of them at school) but not essential.

Lasttimeneveragain · 22/09/2021 07:20

I had a similar age gap between my two.

We sent our eldest to school nursery at 3 mainly so my youngest had my undivided attention sometimes. I also sent my youngest to nursery at 3 because I went back to full time work then.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/09/2021 07:17

but at the same time selfishly I’m loving all being together each day

I'm glad others around you are putting dd first because you appear to be putting you first.

thepinknecklace · 22/09/2021 07:15

Aw god another “my kid can read at 3.5 aren’t they soooo clever....” stealth boast post.

Do what you want OP.

Seashor · 22/09/2021 07:14

I’m incredibly old now but I’m still annoyed that my parents never sent me to the village play school as it was then. It looked wonderful to my then three year old self. They had a massive sand pit and dolls and bikes. I had to walk by it but how I wished I could go. Are you making this decision for you op because you want your daughter at home, or for your daughter? Two mornings a week, what harm would it do!

BendingSpoons · 22/09/2021 07:14

We sent DD to school nursery 5 mornings a week at 3.5, after many queries why she wasn't going younger or for longer (entitled to 30 hours). She was nervous beforehand but settled in immediately. She then had a very disrupted nursery year due to lockdown. Whilst she liked nursery, I think she liked being at home more.

I'm happy with our choice, and will do the same for DS but I think DD would have equally been fine to go straight to Reception. I disagree with this idea that we constantly have to prep them for the next stage, as I think sometimes they are better equipped to cope with later stages when they are more mature. Only thing is are you being prevented from giving the baby opportunities e.g. baby swimming because you have DD there?

HikingforScenery · 22/09/2021 07:12

I agree with your husband.
As you say, you “selfishly” want to keep her at home. Sounds like you know deep down that it’ll be good for her to get some exposure to a formal setting before school

bowlingalleyblues · 22/09/2021 07:05

My kids both went to preschool but:

  • They both cried settling into pre school and then again on starting school. So no guarantee of being less upset as a benefit.
  • My son has totally forgotten about the kids he was friends with at preschool and is now solely friends with kids in his class as he sees them every day.
  • DC2 has learnt things at preschool (some writing, phonics and numbers) but DC1 didn’t learn any of that, and just picked it up in the first term of reception and is meeting expectations.
  • they follow the same curriculum in reception as in preschool and seem to be doing all the same topics as my child has already done in preschool.

It’s good, there were benefits, but it’s not essential.

MinnieMountain · 22/09/2021 07:02

DS went to the pre-school attached to the school he was going to go to 5 afternoons a week from 3.5. We felt it would give him more variety and he’d meet other children. It was definitely worth it.

twoandeights · 22/09/2021 06:54

Your husband and family have a point I’m afraid. Preschool is called that for a reason. Pre school. Otherwise you are going to have a very tough first term at school. Preschool has multiple uses. If it’s attached to the school the preschool leader takes them in to meet the teacher and they have transition sessions. The preschool leader can spot any issues/delays and get things set up at the school for your child’s benefit before they start. They often have an influence over what teacher your child has and they all “go up” as a little group of friends. They help prepare them for sitting eating in the canteen, tie laces, get changed quickly into gym kit, the school day timings..it stops it being overwhelming for them. Plus she’ll be missing out on all the end of preschool parties and celebrations which are super super cute and you get to keep photos and it’s just lovely. Mini olympics, disco etc why wouldn’t you want her to be part of that?

MyOtherProfile · 22/09/2021 06:52

What @Aroundtheworldin80moves said.

Wagglerock · 22/09/2021 06:51

Mine same age DS goes to preschool a couple of days a week (I'm a SAHP and have a baby) - it's fantastic. He's learning all the soft skills that are hard to teach without 30 other kids like big group socialising, waiting his turn in a big group, queuing for the toilet, sitting for circle time, using his peg and remembering to bring his stuff at the end of the day. He was proud because he was picked to be the leader of his group when they had a fire drill.

It gives me clear days to do activities with the baby so she gets dedicated time, and I've got chance to get more stuff done round the house without having to ignore him to do it. He gets free hours and we never get anything free from the government so damn right I'm using them!

LemonDrizzles · 22/09/2021 06:41

A friend of mine went through something similar. In the end, she chose a nursery just on Friday mornings because that was the day/time they went to the local theatre. Perhaps try to find one that is activity based on a certain day of the week. For example, we have one that takes the children to swimming lessons one afternoon a week. I have to agree sadly that it is quite helpful for the reasons mentioned above to give your child a taste of nursery.

All the best

10ColaBottles · 22/09/2021 06:39

I find your attitude to be about your needs rather than hers.

Your husband has a view and say too. There's a compromise to be had. I'd arrange it from after Xmas then increase further in summer term when they get involved in school transition activities etc. It's fun for them.

Don't make it harder for her for your own benefit.

MaryBoBary · 22/09/2021 06:33

Agree with majority of posters, she will benefit from nursery and the school transition will be easier for her. It could be quite a difficult time if she's not used to being away from you/other close family members.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 22/09/2021 06:30

Big reason to send them... most find it fun. Not necessarily better than home, but different. Things my DDs did (different preschools) included...

  • themed weeks, like the time they had Afternoon Tea with the Queen (including making the cake and inviting parents, having made the invitarions). Or Chinese New year, where they made the 'dragon' and learned the dance.
  • joining in with school events, like World Book Day
  • different craft activities.
Sports day
  • forest school
  • trips to the nature reserve to do pond dipping etc.

Then at home we did different things, like trips out, baking, learning to ride a bike, swimming etc.

My eldest going to preschool meant the younger one got 1-1 time too, like the eldest got when she was young.

Ultimately, its your decision. There's no right answer really.

MovingSchmoving · 22/09/2021 06:29

I agree that the issue is not so much one of socialisation but of her being used to being with you all the time. Even if she sometimes goes to a family member without you (eg morning with granny) that is not the same as being left with a group of 20+ other children.

I also do feel a little bit for your youngest - presumably his older sister had you all to herself for the 2+ years before he was born. It would be nice if you could give him a bit of that 1:1 time too that isn’t just the odd hour here or there.

Elpheba · 22/09/2021 06:23

When’s her birthday? If she’s summer born have you thought about deferring? (Not for academic reasons- she’s clearly bright) but just so that she doesn’t have to rush into full time school next September. You still get funding so she could “do pre-school” next September and then school the year after.
I think it’s hard to go straight to school after no pre school at all- but I equally get not wanting to send her if you’re happy with how things are going.

Swipe left for the next trending thread