Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think high heels look a bit silly?

310 replies

postingfortraffichere · 21/09/2021 21:06

I'm a sucker for them (or used to be) but the more time goes by I'm starting to feel they have very little place in my wardrobe.

I feel overdressed and try to hard in them. I think it's hard to pull off the effortless look in heels. But I also feel like something is missing when I don't wear them on a night out for example.

I feel like it's yet another pointless trend for women to continue following - that are really uncomfortable and serve no real purpose.

I've also noticed younger women rarely wear them - have they seen the light?!

Or AIBU for feeling this way

OP posts:
stayathomer · 22/09/2021 03:55

I love the look of strappy heels with a night out dress or simple heels with a suit! In this way flats don't suit everyone and I think eg ballerina pumps definitely dont suit any of us that have bigger feet or more athletic legs and eg runners with dresses just make us look like we lost a pair of shoes! Saying that I don't think the vast majority of us could wear heels properly, I think we probably thought we looked better than we did as we limped along!

Porridgealert · 22/09/2021 02:57

I love heels. They make my legs look longer, me look slimmer and I always feel elegant in them. I'm not that bothered if young people think they're unfashionable because I see what young people think is fashionable and know that one day they'll look back and say, "what was I thinking?” We've all done that. 80s fashion anyone? So if you see a lone woman tottering down the road, give her a wave and I'll wave back.

1forAll74 · 22/09/2021 02:41

I can't wear high heels now, although I do like them. I tried a pair of high heels on in my bedroom the other day, I was doing a shoe tidy up,, but after a couple of years wearing sandal type things, I found that I couldn't stand up properly in the heels, and get the right body balance, and kept keeling over in the heels, like maybe twisting an ankle type thing.

theadultsaretalking · 22/09/2021 01:06

I have just come back from an impossibly hip wedding in France and most of young wealthy fashionistas there (I am none of those things, by the way...) were in heels - not stilettos, but fairly high heels still. So not sure how out of fashion they are to be honest.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 22/09/2021 00:48

I still wear heels, but not high ones, I have a mix of slightly heeled boots and boot shoes, I wouldn't wear a court shoe style as I agree they are not so fashionable, and really really high heels aren't either. Lots of young people though try to get a bit of height/fashion out of very clumpy shoes, heeled/clump trainers and so on, especially if wearing flares.

This thread does remind me though of the many attempts over the past 10 years to convince everyone that skinnies were totally passe and that no young people ever wear skinnies, and that to look good we should all ditch them. Now, it's true that baggier jeans are in, my girls wear them, but the style they wear them in which is crop top, show stomach, baggy jeans, trainers is just not one that at my age I could begin to emulate. They also occasionally wear skinnies or slim style jeans if they want to wear very baggy tops.

I was on campus this week and this show off your stomach/baggy jean look looked amazing on some of the students, but I don't think that means that if middle-aged women started wearing crop tops/baggy jeans/trainers they would look fashionable, we just look our age wearing that clothing.

In other words, there isn't a magic shoe that signifies youth, and you just look your age wearing flats or trainers, perhaps even more so as they can make a shorter person look a bit dumpy and if you have a matronly busom/not much of a waist, you look older. That's just my opinion of course.

The one place I've noticed that many students wear heels is for graduation. I've often seen them tottering across the stage, it's really noticeable. So there seem to be certain types of events that are still associated with heels, weddings probably the same.

Not all flats are healthier of course anyway, ballet flats provide no support for feet. Trainers can go sweaty/soggy although you can waterproof them. Flat sandals tear up my feet in summer. A bit of a heel isn't necessarily particularly bad for your foot. Wearing enclosed shoes made of plastic is also really horrid, and so many shoes are plastic now and not leather, they are really uncomfortable, and plastic heels are the worst.

Strokethefurrywall · 22/09/2021 00:40

I barely wear them at the office now, only on nights out to add to an exceptional outfit.
I have a stunning pair of Cher shoes by Badgely Mischka in electric blue and they match my staple “wedding/event” dress perfectly.

But since the day I started wearing heels on nights out, I’ve never ever returned home still wearing them. They’re always in my hands and my soles are usually black from dancing barefoot.

BiBabbles · 22/09/2021 00:14

I think some can carry most heels well and can make them look great. As others have said, it's all in what they want to wear most of the time. I don't tend to pay attention to shoes much, but the expectation of certain types of heels in certain environments can cause some foolish things.

When we were looking at secondary schools for my DD, it was really noticeable in one school that the male staff seemed to stride around while all the women I came across were walking very gingerly in very thin high heels. Those kind of very thin ones seemed impractical for a school environment and created a very odd and very visible difference between men and women.

I'm not sure if it was just fashion, though it seemed for all of them to be doing it, across ages, that there was some standard that they were trying to meet (nearly all of them were in pencil skirts too which wasn't helping & I don't think were high fashion at the time - it seemed some weird business suit type thing going on). It really put me off the place. I haven't really seen a place since with that very stark issue when it comes to heels, though as I said I don't tend to pay attention to that - this was just really obvious and awkward.

loafcake · 22/09/2021 00:13

I love high heels, I love the look and I love how they complete my fun outfits.

However, I'm 5ft 11 and absolutely tower over almost everybody I come across! As well as never even being bothered to wear an outfit to warrant them, I have been contemplating putting every last pair on eBay 😂

Flats all day for me, and by flats I mean slippers or trainers and that's about it 😂

DahliaMacNamara · 22/09/2021 00:06

I think they look great. I hope I never have to wear them again. My feet are fucked enough already. But I love the way they look.

olidora63 · 22/09/2021 00:01

Our manager late 50s who is same age as me and very skinny wears very high heels …she actually looks really common..no not jealous but think she looks very unprofessional …sorry!

PyongyangKipperbang · 22/09/2021 00:00

you can dislike an article of clothing without making disparaging comments about the wearer

Completely agree..... and then we see comments like this....

the women I’ve seen walking in them look like they have shit themselves as they walk. Very unattractive.

ItsNotMeAnymore · 21/09/2021 23:58

I’ve never worn them. I think they look silly.
I don’t mind wedges though.
I think heels look a bit dated.

AmberLynn1536 · 21/09/2021 23:54

This is an interesting picture, Kate Moss watching her daughter on the cat walk at London Fashion week today, the fashionista front row are wearing a mixture of heels and flats.

To think high heels look a bit silly?
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 21/09/2021 23:54

‘you can dislike an article of clothing without making disparaging comments about the wearer, that’s the difference.’

Exactly. Some of the replies on this thread remind me of of a thread from a few years back which still tickles me.

Basically the OP was really upset because some ‘cool’ women were leaving her out of their group and she’d been to a wedding and requested the DJ play a song that ‘team cool’ thought was unfashionable. They sniggered and looked over a few times then the top cool woman went over to the DJ and asked him to stop playing the ‘uncool’ song and play ‘Titanium’ by David Guetta and Shia instead…which made me genuinely laugh out loud.

Just because you think somethings fashionable or unfashionable not everyone will feel the same way and that’s fine.

liddlelambsydivey · 21/09/2021 23:50

I'm 42 and have never worn real high heels in my life, and very short, chunky heels only rarely, on the dressiest occasions (wedding, for instance).

I try to dress only for myself, especially when it comes to comfort and safety. I'm 5'6", so only average height, but who cares how tall I look? I'm married, but even if I were still single, I don't think most men are only attracted to tall women.

BoredZelda · 21/09/2021 23:48

And some flat shoes can make the wearer look dumpy, which isn't a youthful look.

And yet nobody suggests men look “dumpy” in flat shoes. Women are expected to wear crippling shoes to somehow look less “dumpy”?

I never got on with heels of any kind. I had a brief moment when I bought some chunky heeled boots when I first met my tall husband, I’m really short. After about 3 weeks, I send them to charity as they were just so uncomfortable. I’m happy in my flat soles, happy with my height and don’t need a pair of shoes to boost my self esteem.

Some women can carry them off, but most often the women I’ve seen walking in them look like they have shit themselves as they walk. Very unattractive.

AmberLynn1536 · 21/09/2021 23:39

[quote postingfortraffichere]@AmberLynn1536 I love her response it's quite funny!

And I agree any women, or person has the right to wear whatever they choose,

But I still stick by that I can have an opinion on high heels and people shouldn't try and censor it!

[/quote]
Yes she is fab and she does wear some amazing clothes and shoes. Not trying to censor discussion at all, it’s the way it’s done as I expressed in my earlier post, you can dislike an article of clothing without making disparaging comments about the wearer, that’s the difference.

SoftSheen · 21/09/2021 23:38

I've literally never worn them.

NoddyMcdoddy · 21/09/2021 23:37

I used to love heels and have a wardrobe full of them. I bought a coveted pair of mid height red suede pumps in February 2020 as a birthday gift to myself and never wore them and now when I look at them I doubt I ever will.

I like a summer strappy heel for weddings and occasions I’m dressing up for and will continue to wear them and do not find them uncomfortable or difficult to walk in.

Recently bought a leather skirt that looks awful worn with flats so I will wear with a mid heel ankle boot.
A nice heel can really pull an outfit together however I can’t see me routinely wearing heels like I used to as I’ve just gotten way too comfortable in flats and trainers over last 18 months.

DD age 19 has never worn heels!

postingfortraffichere · 21/09/2021 23:37

@MiddlesexGirl agree. I'd definitely wear them for a wedding or black tie do for example

OP posts:
Rubyflint · 21/09/2021 23:35

[quote postingfortraffichere]@Rubyflint I think fir summer months wedges are still quite popular for evenings holidays etc [/quote]
Yes I think you’re right. Most weddings are in the summer so wedged are a good alternative to sinking in the grass in heels!

MiddlesexGirl · 21/09/2021 23:35

I'm glad high heels are no longer seen as required for work. Having said that I do struggle with a professional type shoe ... luckily I can get away with smart trainer types as the alternatives - loafers, ballerinas, other flats just don't suit at all.

But for a formal event or evening wear you can't beat a high heel for a touch of glamour. I feel altogether more stylish and confident. The shoe has to be well chosen .... have to be able to walk in it .... and if you can run in it too that's the ideal. Cobbles and steep downhills are a killer! But I won't be giving them up yet as they make me feel good.

Happymum12345 · 21/09/2021 23:33

I always think they look like pigs trotters, especially on chubby women. Some people look amazing in them, but I definitely look more trotterish than anything else!

postingfortraffichere · 21/09/2021 23:33

@AmberLynn1536 I love her response it's quite funny!

And I agree any women, or person has the right to wear whatever they choose,

But I still stick by that I can have an opinion on high heels and people shouldn't try and censor it!

OP posts:
Sparklfairy · 21/09/2021 23:32

I live in the centre of an historic city and the streets and pavements are cobbled and battered. I had to stop wearing stiletto heels (especially after a drink) before I broke my neck!

I have some lovely stiletto ankle boots which haven't been worn since I moved in Sad

That said, I've braved a chunky boot heel now and then, but I still have to concentrate when walking those fucking cobbles possibly clutching the arm of my date for dear life Grin