Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think high heels look a bit silly?

310 replies

postingfortraffichere · 21/09/2021 21:06

I'm a sucker for them (or used to be) but the more time goes by I'm starting to feel they have very little place in my wardrobe.

I feel overdressed and try to hard in them. I think it's hard to pull off the effortless look in heels. But I also feel like something is missing when I don't wear them on a night out for example.

I feel like it's yet another pointless trend for women to continue following - that are really uncomfortable and serve no real purpose.

I've also noticed younger women rarely wear them - have they seen the light?!

Or AIBU for feeling this way

OP posts:
user1471538283 · 22/09/2021 08:12

I'm small and I've always loved high heels. But now I'm older I just cant do it anymore. Should I ever go out in the evening to dinner I might force a pair on. But I used to dance all night in them. Nah.

Sunshineandflipflops · 22/09/2021 08:11

I used to wear heels for work (not really high ones, just a couple of inches or so) as I like how I feel them but as I have been WFH for 18 months I hadn't worn any until I went out for dinner at the weekend and I was so uncomfortable in them. Took them off as soon as I got in.

It wasn't just the heel aspect, it was wearing a very close fitting shoe when my feet have been used to loose sliders/sandals/trainers for the past 18 months.

Ethelfromnumber73 · 22/09/2021 08:11

I'm the height of an average 12 year old- it doesn't change that heels are ridiculous

PinkTonic · 22/09/2021 08:09

I think high heels can look good and I’ve always appreciated a bit of extra height in certain circumstances. I hate that some women who obviously struggle with them still clearly feel they need to wear them though, so it’s great that more comfortable and practical options are fashionable now. I won’t be wearing very high heels again but if I do plan a day in the office and pull out a more formal workwear outfit I might wear mid heels, or then again i might wear brogues or flatform loafers.

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 08:07

@arield nothing is wrong with being shorter, don't try and twist this into 'OP is now short bashing' because I'm not - at a guess it may be irritating for the person when your eyeline is much lower than everyone else's if you're incredibly short.

Though I have no idea, it was another poster who is short that said this so maybe ask that poster

OP posts:
JustLyra · 22/09/2021 08:03

I don’t really get why people can’t choose to not wear heels without being so snide about people who do. It’s baffling the way women often can’t resist being nasty about other women who make different choices.

Flat ballerina shoes are just as bad for your feet as heels, just in a different way.

I love heels, always have because I like being slightly taller than my short arse height. However, I’ve always only ever worn heels that fit properly (the lack of half sizes in a lot of shoe brands is why you see so many people walking out of their shoes) and my Nana always said “only wear heels you can run in as muggers don’t discriminate on shoe height”. I used to run for the bus most days in heels (the joys of an hourly service!).

It’s funny that people are so adamant that young people don’t do heels - some don’t. DD2 wouldn’t be seen dead in heels. DD1 however - she and her mates are still into the highest heels they can walk in.

arield · 22/09/2021 08:00

[quote postingfortraffichere]@EarringsandLipstick I guess I never thought about shorter women - that makes sense.

I suppose being a bit shorter I can totally see why heels would maybe be a preference. [/quote]
Why?

What's wrong with being shorter?

arield · 22/09/2021 07:54

@Pissinthepottyplease

The latest You’re Dead to me podcast (think horrible histories for grown ups) is all about the history of high heels. Apparently they were originally worn by men.
They were to keep riders' stirrups in the correct place. Then it went from there.
5128gap · 22/09/2021 07:53

@BoredZelda

And some flat shoes can make the wearer look dumpy, which isn't a youthful look.

And yet nobody suggests men look “dumpy” in flat shoes. Women are expected to wear crippling shoes to somehow look less “dumpy”?

I never got on with heels of any kind. I had a brief moment when I bought some chunky heeled boots when I first met my tall husband, I’m really short. After about 3 weeks, I send them to charity as they were just so uncomfortable. I’m happy in my flat soles, happy with my height and don’t need a pair of shoes to boost my self esteem.

Some women can carry them off, but most often the women I’ve seen walking in them look like they have shit themselves as they walk. Very unattractive.

Men's clothing is generally judged on the garment itself, how expensive or fashionable it is. Women's clothing is judged on how it far enhances the appearance of the wearer. In that way the flat shoe trend is a move in the right direction as generally they are worn for comfort or fashion not because the woman thinks they improve her appearance, so it really shouldn't matter if they look dumpy or not. Which incidently is far less derogatory than the comments about women in heels, including your own. If you want to use a conversation about shoes to make a feminist point, criticising the way other women walk doesn't help.
Slothkin · 22/09/2021 07:52

I bloody love heels but I have weird feet - I walk on my tip-toes naturally, so heels are really comfy. My podiatrist has insisted on hard-soled flats so I’m grumpily stomping about at the moment!

Standrewsschool · 22/09/2021 07:50

Chunky heels, not chipmunks (!)

Standrewsschool · 22/09/2021 07:50

A friend commented how a lot of the younger folk were wearing chipmunks heels for a night out in her town, so perhaps theirs a trend back to them. Not full stiletto, but a chunkier version of them.

iglpgl · 22/09/2021 07:47

YANBU - horrible things, and totally unhealthy for the feet. Even pointy flats make me cringe when I think of those toes being squashed together! Barefoot/minimalist shoes only for me these days (not that I ever wore heels really).

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 22/09/2021 07:44

Flats are actually really bad too, for feet and posture. A slight raised heel (like formal men’s shoes) are much better, say osteopaths!

Angrymum22 · 22/09/2021 07:43

The midi shirt waister dress with trainers gives me the shudders. My mum was a middle aged shirt waister wearer in the late 70s/early 80s so I always equate them with that era.
Heals, even low ones, give you ankles even when they are non existent. And on another purely health level wearing a small heal prevents plantar fasciitis. After wearing flats for many years my feet were agony. Twelve months wearing a 1 inch heal solved the problem.
The current younger generation have taken suffering in the name of fashion to a whole new level. Botox and fillers!

bridgeofslides · 22/09/2021 07:37

@Garriet

I can’t wear them but I used to covet them. They’re definitely out of fashion now though, with the younger generation. I went into a branch of Schuh yesterday and there wasn’t a single heel to be seen, not even a kitten.
I've noticed this too. They used to sell irregular choose heels and another brand. You're right they are heel free! Loads of lowly flats though.
Idyllic · 22/09/2021 07:31

I haven't worn heels in ages. I always used to wear them when younger but comfort comes first now.
DD very rarely wears heels now. Even on a night out all the girls wear trainers now unless it's somewhere really formal. Far more practical I suppose.

arield · 22/09/2021 07:26

@UnsolicitedDickPic

I love high heels and I do feel like they pull an outfit together in a way I can't quite seem to achieve in a flat shoe. But, my God, I couldn't and wouldn't wear a heel again if you paid me.
Maybe the outfit would be more pulled together if you wore two shoes
RoseStar · 22/09/2021 07:25

Hmm interesting @5128gap . I’m the wrong side of 40 to attempt the younger look but maybe I’ll still to more classic / elegant than trying to be trainer trendy!!

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 22/09/2021 07:23

I used to love heels in the 90s

Never bought teetering uncomfortable ones, never stilettos. But a good heel? Yes. At 6ft (without heels) I’d tower over everybody. I used to like that, as a junior in a very male dominated industry. I’d wear quite dowdy suits (never felt right to try and look sexy in that world) but the heels helped give me confidence

I’d stride in them

Now I would not dream of wearing them. That kind of 90s office wear is gone gone gone

5128gap · 22/09/2021 07:23

[quote RoseStar]@5128gap are Vejas at risk of going the same way, I see them everywhere on middle aged women… or what about deisgner ones like Gucci ace? Tbh I find midi dresses v unflattering too, they seem to emphasis their tummy for so many people including me, something which we used to sort of be able to offset with heels and longer (or shorter) lengths![/quote]
Yes vejas too. I'm not sure about the Gucci ones. As I said, I think it's more the whole look. I was out in a big city the other night and all the older women were wearing midi dress, white trainers and denim jackets. The young women were more likely to be in block heel strappy sandals in bright colours, with the very young students in clubby clothes with platform style trainers.

VanGoSunflowers · 22/09/2021 07:12

I hate wearing heels. Really hate it.
I hate having uncomfortable feet and I like to move about swiftly. You can’t do that in heels.

RoseStar · 22/09/2021 07:11

@5128gap are Vejas at risk of going the same way, I see them everywhere on middle aged women… or what about deisgner ones like Gucci ace? Tbh I find midi dresses v unflattering too, they seem to emphasis their tummy for so many people including me, something which we used to sort of be able to offset with heels and longer (or shorter) lengths!

5128gap · 22/09/2021 07:06

[quote RoseStar]“@5128gap

Certain types of white trainer, especially when worn with a midi dress, have become very much associated with middle age

You’ve got me worried now.. which!? Or pic please?![/quote]
Its the whole look really of midi dress and trainers. As someone said it started as edgy then everyone did it, and as happens when youthful trends become widely adopted and older women wear them, they're no longer youthful and edgy, and young people move on. Some trainers are particularly popular with older women, supergas, sketchers, generic ones from M&S. Nothing wrong with any of them, but that look is no more the height of youthful style than heels are.

Mammyloveswine · 22/09/2021 04:04

@FrankButchersDickieBow

I have never been able to wear heels. My sisters said I walked like Oda Mae Brown when I wore them 🤣

I see people walking in them with their legs stomping forward and their bodies leaninh back, like Rachel from Love Island.

It's not a good look. Some people can carry them off. Some can't, but one thing I can say is that they never look comfortable on anyone.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣