Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think high heels look a bit silly?

310 replies

postingfortraffichere · 21/09/2021 21:06

I'm a sucker for them (or used to be) but the more time goes by I'm starting to feel they have very little place in my wardrobe.

I feel overdressed and try to hard in them. I think it's hard to pull off the effortless look in heels. But I also feel like something is missing when I don't wear them on a night out for example.

I feel like it's yet another pointless trend for women to continue following - that are really uncomfortable and serve no real purpose.

I've also noticed younger women rarely wear them - have they seen the light?!

Or AIBU for feeling this way

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 22/09/2021 09:59

I love the look of heels but I can't walk in them so I only wear them for special occasions. Someone always asks me whether I am all right though! 🤭 I usually wear loafers for day to day

5128gap · 22/09/2021 09:59

@Icenii

It says that young people, who aren't shackled by 50 years of tradition or social convention, are choosing to do things differently, making a different choice which suits people better. It has nothing to do with looking like a young person

But many are still following trends. This time filers and botox.

Exactly. Young people aren't a homogeneous mass. For every young woman embracing comfort and practicality there's another who goes full on glam with all the trappings. Its completely up to them and should have no real baring on the choices of other women. Its understandable that some women have rejected heels, they can be restrictive and uncomfortable and if women don't want to wear them, great. No need to legitimate that choice by making out that women who make a different one look wrong, dated, ridiculous or...horrors!...OLD.
NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 22/09/2021 09:55

*strappy, although scrappy as well perhaps!

NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 22/09/2021 09:54

I live in flip flops but I do like mid-heel scrappy sandals for a dressy night out. I also like to wear stockings on those nights (yes, objectification, we’re consenting adults!) how do you manage that in flats without getting Nora Batty wrinkles round the ankles?

Would love to know as although I can still rock a cocktail dress, it’s increasingly difficult to find shoes that fit my ageing feet!

Candleinthebreeze · 22/09/2021 09:53

As a male in my 30’s I won’t lie I find stilettos very sexy on women, totally disagree they look dated I think they’re timeless, but as with anything in life everyone is or should be free to wear whatever they like.

I work in several offices and I would say 2/3 of our female staff, typically aged 18-50 are in heels virtually every day, there is no uniform policy I don’t care if my staff wear suits, football kits or clown outfits so long as they do the job they are paid to do.

10% definitely come in very casual, 90% make a big effort and wear suits etc for men and business type clothing for women, but this is entirely personal choice and nobody is under any pressure to wear anything of any style.

Anecdotally on the tube at the weekend I would say 10% of women I noticed were wearing heels, they are definitely still out there, thankfully! Yes I know I’m being shallow, hate me if you like I don’t mind

BoredZelda · 22/09/2021 09:51

But many are still following trends. This time filers and botox.

Again with the "many" I take it you have figures to support that? Because of the many, many young people I know, they are not doing this.

BoredZelda · 22/09/2021 09:50

A lot of men take steroids for bigger muscles etc, so they do do risky things for trends

Well done. You found the one thing which confirms the posters comment that men rarely take risks for vanity.

Icenii · 22/09/2021 09:39

It says that young people, who aren't shackled by 50 years of tradition or social convention, are choosing to do things differently, making a different choice which suits people better. It has nothing to do with looking like a young person

But many are still following trends. This time filers and botox.

arield · 22/09/2021 09:39

[quote postingfortraffichere]@Rubyflint I think fir summer months wedges are still quite popular for evenings holidays etc [/quote]
Yeah I'm sure these neck pieces are coming back reeeeal soon!

To think high heels look a bit silly?
JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 22/09/2021 09:38

[quote WaterBottle123]@JasonMomoasgirlfriend

Shoes don't need to offer support. Our feet are perfectly evolved to walk without support. Shoes are a pretty recent invention you know Grin[/quote]
Ok well I didn't think it needed pointed out but since we actually wear shoes and don't go around walking to work in bare feet...the shoes you wear should offer support...

arield · 22/09/2021 09:37

@Libraryghost

I am surprised by some of the strong reactions. If women want to wear heels and they will again once fashions change - then it’s their choice. All this patriarchy shit makes me laugh. Women dress for themselves and to outshine other women. Nobody forces young women to put fillers in their lips, men actively say they hate it but girls still do it!
And why do women want to outshine other women?
Dancingonmoonlight · 22/09/2021 09:36

but take a look at the feet of someone who hasn't had decent shoes before you decide good support isn't necessary

This is very true. I know an eighty something year old whose feet are deformed from wearing badly fitting shoes.
They are shocking to see.

Beefcurtains79 · 22/09/2021 09:33

These threads always turn sneery and nasty, posters who prefer flat shoes always seem to get jibes in about what try hard, unfashionable losers women who wear heels are.
Meanwhile Amina Muaddi shoes are selling out like hotcakes.

arield · 22/09/2021 09:33

Men do nothing from a fashion perspective or rarely do that's uncomfortable or risks their health.

A lot of men take steroids for bigger muscles etc, so they do do risky things for trends

arield · 22/09/2021 09:32

@Downton57

Why do high heels need to be part of 'formal wear' though? Why do we need to damage our feet to look smart? Men wouldn't. It certainly doesn't make sense from a safety or comfort angle .
Exactly.

A few women have come on here to say they like heels because they're 'senior' and need the height. Well, why?

Another poster said she didn't like heels because they are 'sexy' but liked them because they lengthen her legs. Why do you want your legs to look lengthened if not to look 'sexy'?

arield · 22/09/2021 09:30

@PyongyangKipperbang

If they give you blisters and aching feet then you have the wrong size or fit. I have bought flats that I have worn a handful of times because of the horrible blisters, I think that they were too narrow. However I have pairs of heels that I know I can wear to walk to my local and back (about 3 miles total) and still feel fine.

And yes it is judgemental to say "They are aging/dated/secretarial (wtf?!) silly" instead of "I dont like them, I dont wear them but dont give a thought to anyone else who chooses to wear them".

Heels make your feet ache because of the awful positioning of the foot. Don't try and say otherwise
JustLyra · 22/09/2021 09:26

@Macncheeseballs

Justlyra - how can a ballet pump be just as bad for you as a high heel, I've only ever had blisters or pain from the latter
Because most of them are completely lacking in arch support.

Especially cheap ones - they are a one way street to plantar fasciitis and posture issues

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/09/2021 09:25

Shoes don't need to offer support. Our feet are perfectly evolved to walk without support. Shoes are a pretty recent invention you know grin
This is what I don’t understand. I hear it often that the best support for our feet and back are slight heels but surely walking barefoot is fine, with it being how we’ve evolved and all.

I think if we are going to wear shoes we need support as we’re carrying the shoe on our feet. Having to grip a shoe in by tensing your feet - like a court shoe or ballet slipper - is a problem.

BoredZelda · 22/09/2021 09:23

As an aside from the issue of heels, why are some people stating no younger people would be seen dead in them as if its something we must all aspire to? To look like a younger person?

It says that young people, who aren't shackled by 50 years of tradition or social convention, are choosing to do things differently, making a different choice which suits people better. It has nothing to do with looking like a young person.

Shoes don't need to offer support. Our feet are perfectly evolved to walk without support. Shoes are a pretty recent invention you know

Other things that are pretty recent inventions, sanitation, indoor plumbing, central heating, anti-biotics. Just because we didn't have them for a very long time, doesn't mean we don't need them now.

Sure, when we died forty years younger and our only concern was not being eaten by predators, shoes were the least of our worries, but take a look at the feet of someone who hasn't had decent shoes before you decide good support isn't necessary.

sansucre · 22/09/2021 09:23

@Sommernacht89

High heels ruin your feet and look naff and old fashionend.it is usually women with horrid lipfiller,fake tan and caked on make up,who wears high heels.yuk!!
WOW. That's a sweeping statement and a half.

I don't wear make-up and am free from filler, Botox and fake tan and I like to wear heels. I most certainly do not look naff of old-fashioned and neither are my feet ruined.

sansucre · 22/09/2021 09:17

When worn with a short, tight body con dress, then yes, high heels do look dated, but then to my mind, that whole mode of dressing has been dated for a long time.

While I don't wear heels all the time, I do like to wear them, often with a midi-skirt or midi-dress. I particularly like high heeled ankle boots and jeans too. I think it's more what you're wearing them with that stops them from looking silly. Most pertinently, if you don't like or enjoy wearing heels, don't wear them - it's a personal choice, not something mandatory.

I tend to wear them I want to feel more put together, or to steal a revolting fashion term 'to elevate my look'. Heels add a certain je ne sais quoi to an outfit that flats do not.

brokenbiscuitsx · 22/09/2021 09:14

[quote WaterBottle123]@JasonMomoasgirlfriend

Shoes don't need to offer support. Our feet are perfectly evolved to walk without support. Shoes are a pretty recent invention you know Grin[/quote]
This is what I don’t understand. I hear it often that the best support for our feet and back are slight heels but surely walking barefoot is fine, with it being how we’ve evolved and all.

Cryalot2 · 22/09/2021 09:14

In saying that i must add I never wear flats, I was told they are bad for you. My slippers are a pair of fitflop slip on mules/loafers bought specially for the purpose of slippers.
I suppose I am one of those people who mostly only wear fitflops. I bought my first pair to tone my legs ( they promised that when they first came out) and yes I have great legs . Shame about the rest of me. I just found the brand so comfortable that over the years thats all I wear most of the time.

TheKeatingFive · 22/09/2021 09:11

Shoes don't need to offer support. Our feet are perfectly evolved to walk without support. Shoes are a pretty recent invention you know

Our feet aren’t perfectly evolved to walk in shoes and ballet pumps offer no support to the arch. They’re not great for feet at all. I thought that was common knowledge?

WingingItSince1973 · 22/09/2021 09:09

I am 48 and have always worn chunky style shoes and boots. I just can't get on with high heels. My sis in law has gorgeous slim feet and looks fab and a midi heel. But for me nope. Never. I love dresses etc but have always worn chunky flats. I do like to be comfy too x