Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No wonder why people get annoyed with those on furlough

106 replies

Whatnotwhat · 21/09/2021 18:08

I work in a social club in the evening. I do have a day time job.
Before covid I worked Tuesday, Friday and Saturday.
I have been very grateful that I was paid furlough during lockdown.
At the beginning of September the club finally opened fully.
Glad to be back working missed the company.

This is now my aibu the girl who works on a Monday, Thursday and Saturday
who was paid furlough for those hours has come back and will only work
on the Monday as she doesn't want to work the other days.
Her words 'furlough was money for nothing'. She also has a job during the day.
Our employer isn't allowed to hire anyone else yet until she puts it in writing
that she will only work Mon

W

OP posts:
LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:59

This topic honestly just makes me think "fucking grow up" every time I see people moan about it.

It's like children whining because they had to work and someone else didn't and it's not fair.

No one chose to be furloughed and I'm fairly sure all of the people complaining would feel differently if it were them who had been.

I worked throughout. It was hard. It was stressful and it was busy. But furlough helped some of my friends and family keep themselves above water through a global pandemic and I for one am not going to start throwing my toys out the pram like a whinging child now because of it. So what that some people take the piss, that's life, you will never get a system that people don't exploit in some way, you have to get over that. I'm just grateful that it was there to help the people I care about who needed it.

MatildaIThink · 21/09/2021 20:55

@seaandsandcastles

What’s the problem? She’s decided she values her time more and wants to reduce her days.
I would imagine the issue is that she was hapoy to keep taking taxpayers money on furlough, but when it can to actually working again said no.
LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:50

@AICM

First post in is a NAFWALT.

Yes we now but far too many are!

What's your magic solution then? How much better for your taxes do you think all of those people on furlough losing their jobs instead would have been?

Honest to God I'm sick of this topic now. Always the same "well my friends, dog walkers aunty knows someone on FB who had a ball on furlough". AND?

There are people who take the piss out of the benefit system so shall we all just stomp our feet and say IM NOT PAYING FOR IT?

People don't like benefit shaming (rightly so). What's the difference?

Is it only acceptable if the people on furlough have a sufficiently shit time to make you all feel better?

HalzTangz · 21/09/2021 20:47

@WhenISnappedAndFarted

A lot of people I know who was furloughed is now in heavy debt because despite being paid 80% it wasn't enough to cover the bills etc
Then they were covering there bills before furlough. The 20% they didn't get was there tax and NI contribution (or the equivalent too) so they would have been taking home roughly the same. I was furloughed for 6 weeks and noticed no change in my take home pay. I actually saved loads as wasn't buying coffee and lunch daily and wasn't paying my commute (£100 a week average I saved during furlough), I'm now hybrid, 1 day in office 4 at home and still saving 80 odd a week. Over the 18 months I've saved just shy of 9k
LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:45

all of us who worked should be given an additional 80% of our pay or a massive tax rebate

I've never called 999 or used the emergency services, never claimed UC, rarely use the NHS and didn't have kids in schools for years either... Can I have my massive tax rebate now please?

As someone who also worked throughout, maybe just consider yourself fortunate enough to still have a job.

Do you think huge swathes of unemployed people would have been better for your taxes?

AICM · 21/09/2021 20:42

First post in is a NAFWALT.

Yes we now but far too many are!

Doingtheboxerbeat · 21/09/2021 20:41

Also people who are only being paid 80% in an already badly paid job may have had to work tons of overtime just to get by and furlough would have prevented that.

MagnoliaXYZ · 21/09/2021 20:40

@BrendaBubbles

Of course people will take advantage. The problem was keeping the scamscheme going so long, there has been zero excuse for it since at least June. If you can milk it then fill your boots, your taxes will be going up to pay for it eventually anyway.
But my taxes will go up too and I never received furlough (worked all through it). I agree that it went on much too long and should have been a loan, alternatively, all of us who worked should be given an additional 80% of our pay or a massive tax rebate.
HalzTangz · 21/09/2021 20:39

Maybe whilst on furlough she valued her free time more therefore has worked out she can drop two nights and have more of a family/social life

MajorCarolDanvers · 21/09/2021 20:33

It is not unreasonable for anyone to wish to renegotiate their hours.

Obviouspretzel · 21/09/2021 20:31

@LaLaJ

What has this got to go with "the furloughed"?

So one person you know has decided that she wants to cut her working hours?

Yes you're absolutely right everyone should be absolutely fuming at every single person who received furlough pay because of this one woman wanting to do a completely reasonable thing like change her working hours.

Weird.

Spot on. Lunatic thread.
LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:27

I didn't tell work I was quitting after maternity leave until my SMP had finished even though I knew I would be leaving beforehand. Do you hate all "those on maternity" now?

tttigress · 21/09/2021 20:24

I think furlough was initially needed, but it should have stopped a lot sooner than it did.

RE: your colleague, even without Covid things could change dramatically for a person over 18 months, so it shouldn't be a complete shock that she has different priorities after 18 months, you can't exactly expect someone to do the same job, with the same hours for the rest of their lives.

Simonjt · 21/09/2021 20:19

@flippertyop

Those people earning 80 percent also had no transport costs to get to work. Didn't need to drop children off at school saving costs. Couldn't eat out etc etc I can't understand how they can be in debt
The furlough payment didn’t even cover my mortgage, I luckily had savings, thats a luxury a lot of people don’t have.
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/09/2021 20:16

If she’s refusing to work but hasn’t written in then it’s work’s fault for not using disciplinary.
Otherwise taking furlough money for a job she wanted to quit while ‘morally wrong’ isn’t illegal. You don’t even know if she reassessed or did it deliberately.

LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:07

@flippertyop

Those people earning 80 percent also had no transport costs to get to work. Didn't need to drop children off at school saving costs. Couldn't eat out etc etc I can't understand how they can be in debt
I can't understand how anyone could possibly think that EVERYONE uses 20% of their wage on transport and eating out. Are you really that sheltered?

What a nice life you must lead if you could get by on 80% of your wage by pocketing all the cash you spend at restaurants throughout the month.

Fucking hell 🤦‍♀️

LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 20:04

What has this got to go with "the furloughed"?

So one person you know has decided that she wants to cut her working hours?

Yes you're absolutely right everyone should be absolutely fuming at every single person who received furlough pay because of this one woman wanting to do a completely reasonable thing like change her working hours.

Weird.

Blankiefan · 21/09/2021 19:51

As much as people are full of moral outrage about this pattern of behaviour, I think its a rare person that would have turned down the furlough cash and resigned if they weren't planning on returning, rather than shut up and take it.

ImNotDancing · 21/09/2021 19:46

@flippertyop

Those people earning 80 percent also had no transport costs to get to work. Didn't need to drop children off at school saving costs. Couldn't eat out etc etc I can't understand how they can be in debt
This might surprise you but some people walk to work and school and already can’t afford to eat out!
FourTeaFallOut · 21/09/2021 19:34

That wasn't just a side effect, that was built in. Otherwise all affected businesses could have lost all their experienced and trained staff in one fell swoop. That would be pretty catastrophic to the economy.

But yes, you are right, as an individual she has taken the piss.

user1497207191 · 21/09/2021 19:26

@FourTeaFallOut

The point being that someone was always going to be paid to do nothing to keep the job active. Whether it was her or someone else isn't relative to anything to do with the mechanism of furlough.
Furlough is to benefit the worker and to stop them having to claim benefits had they been made redundant. A side effect was that the employer would have a "ready to go" workforce when they were allowed to re-open. On the last point, the system fails because a lot of staff have gone off and got alternative work, so they're not available when called back to work, like the case here.
user1497207191 · 21/09/2021 19:23

@FourTeaFallOut The role was furloughed. The furlough payments to the business kept the role viable. Now it can be filled by someone who wants the role

Furlough doesn't benefit the business, it benefits the worker. In fact, the business will be out of pocket because it was liable for employers NIC, holiday pay etc., so a net cost. The business would have saved money had the worker simply given notice and left instead of continuing to cost the govt and employer.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 21/09/2021 19:19

Good for her. There's more to life than working all day and half the nights in the week.

She has been used to living on less and having more time, so wants to continue with that.

Your work should be able to find a replacement as soon as she puts it in writing for them.

user1487194234 · 21/09/2021 19:13

The furlough system was totally open to abuse
By employers and employees

Pendingname · 21/09/2021 19:12

If they are still using the furlough scheme currently in place which is flexible furlough if she isn't working what were her normal hours and her contract hours haven't officially been changed she could still be receiving 80% of pay for the shifts she isn't doing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread