Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to just be sick of men..

189 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 21/09/2021 14:01

Caught by accident two family men known to me discussing how they'd 'got their own pictures' of a dance teacher who was teaching their 6 year old daughters. They were with their wives and children, both supposedly Christian - both in their early 30s so not a generational thing as is often trotted out. It occured to me that when they were dating their wives they would have been MORTIFIED for these new shiny women to hear them being so gross yet now the wives have committed, given them children, become part of the furniture they are supposed to listen to any old shit.
And yes, I know that there are loads of you who will say 'my DH /DP would never dream of doing this' so obviously I am not talking about them- is anyone else just fed up of continually being disappointed even by men you previously liked or trusted?
I know I am being ranty but i'm going with it!

OP posts:
AICM · 22/09/2021 06:32

@IWantT0BreakFree

Comparing this with terrorism is a massive reach and just demonstrates a complete inability (or unwillingness) to understand the point that countless PPs have taken the time to explain now.

No it’s not OK to generalise an entire group of people because the majority of terrorism is committed by that group. It would be OK to take issue with that group in a more general sense if a significant proportion (probably majority) of the group were either involved in terrorist attacks or in less severe but still related activities.

"Majority of terrorism committed by X group" is not the same as "majority of X group are terrorists".

It's not only the fact that almost all violent crime and sexual crime is committed by men, it's the fact that such a massive proportion of men engage in misogynistic behaviour to one degree or another. And that all men benefit from patriarchy.

The fact that men are the oppressor group in this scenario, and that all men benefit from patriarchy, and that men (in general) possess greater social currency and power than women, is the reason that men have a responsibility to challenge sexism and male on female violence. It's not enough to be the "good guy" standing on the sidelines. It is OK to hold men to account.

Some really intelligent and thoughtful comments. Thank you. You have given me reason to stop and think.

Would be true to a similar situation exists with racism?

Racism is widespread and oppresses people of colour, therefore it follows that all white people benefit from racism.

SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 22:54

Unless you mean the other version of "Did you report it?" that some people say when someone comes out months or years later, in a way to tell them they've missed their chance.

Then, yes that can be similar.

IWantT0BreakFree · 21/09/2021 22:53

Comparing this with terrorism is a massive reach and just demonstrates a complete inability (or unwillingness) to understand the point that countless PPs have taken the time to explain now.

No it’s not OK to generalise an entire group of people because the majority of terrorism is committed by that group. It would be OK to take issue with that group in a more general sense if a significant proportion (probably majority) of the group were either involved in terrorist attacks or in less severe but still related activities.

"Majority of terrorism committed by X group" is not the same as "majority of X group are terrorists".

It's not only the fact that almost all violent crime and sexual crime is committed by men, it's the fact that such a massive proportion of men engage in misogynistic behaviour to one degree or another. And that all men benefit from patriarchy.

The fact that men are the oppressor group in this scenario, and that all men benefit from patriarchy, and that men (in general) possess greater social currency and power than women, is the reason that men have a responsibility to challenge sexism and male on female violence. It's not enough to be the "good guy" standing on the sidelines. It is OK to hold men to account.

SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 22:42

No it isn't.

Comments like "why was she there?" Is the same as what you just said "It shouldn't have happened in the first place".

But it HAS happened. There's no changing it or need to blame.

Comments like "did you report it or challenge it" is asking now that it's happened, what could/did you do? By all means, challenge it. (Assuming it's safe to do so). That's how it starts being clear that it's unacceptable.

What else do you prefer? Don't do anything about it after it's happened? Just come on mn and talk about it? How does that help (if changing it is what you want)?

OuiOuiBonjour · 21/09/2021 22:18

@crochetmonkey74

It's annoying when women keep being asked 'did you report it? Did you challenge it?' As if the responsibility lies with us to sort it out. Why isn't the anger with those that did the thing?
I mean, I had a duty of care to report concerns so obviously I reported it. But you are right...I shouldn't have had to report it because it shouldn't have happened in the first place.

"Did you report it?" is just another stock phrase...

"Why was she walking alone after dark?"

"What were you wearing?"

"She was asking for it."

"What did she expect dressed like that?"

"Why didn't you get a taxi instead of walking?"

"You did accept a drink from him."

"Maybe you led him on"

or, my favourite.

"What was her mother thinking letting her out dressed like that in the first place?"

Pinkbonbon · 21/09/2021 22:13

@crochetmonkey74

It's annoying when women keep being asked 'did you report it? Did you challenge it?' As if the responsibility lies with us to sort it out. Why isn't the anger with those that did the thing?
Anyone who overhears these behaviours, br they male or female has a responsibility to challenge it. You also said you knew these men? So presumably, you'll be choosing to remove the from your life and (assuming it is safe to do so) making damn sure they and any other relevant parties, know why.

But yes, sometimes it is tough to do the right thing. That's why it's called bravery.

RickySpanishhh · 21/09/2021 21:56

Middle aged ones are often remarkably stroppy

Careful, you get screeched at if you say anything mildly ageist on Mumsnet

SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 21:51

Those who did it are arseholes but do you want them to report themselves or challenge themselves? Obviously, that's the problem - that they're either too blind to see what they're doing or too arrogant to care.

If you're going to complain about them not being challenged, then challenge them. Someone has to and the sooner women start doing so openly and directly, the better.

crochetmonkey74 · 21/09/2021 21:46

It's annoying when women keep being asked 'did you report it? Did you challenge it?' As if the responsibility lies with us to sort it out. Why isn't the anger with those that did the thing?

OP posts:
SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 21:40

@PickUpAPepper

Ooh, the pic posted! Sorry, the pic wasn't actually aimed at you SJ, although I expect you'll struggle to believe that. It's one that I used to see on here once upon a time and the damn thing wasn't posting separately.
That's fine. I did wonder at first but it didn't make sense to me how it would be aimed at me, given your post. Also, since you mentioned a meme, I took it as you showing the image of the meme.
HotPenguin · 21/09/2021 21:37

I'm with you OP this week I've had to do an unusual bit of work that involves being on the roadside. Men yelling at me from vehicles - this isnt in the evening, it's like 7 and 8 am on their way to work, wtf?

SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 21:35

Hmm. Okay well that says something different then.

I know the "Man here" routine on MN all too well.

PickUpAPepper · 21/09/2021 21:34

Oh go away. Do you have any idea how often we hear the same old crap everyday? Go and get a bloody life.

OuiOuiBonjour · 21/09/2021 21:34

Did you report his behaviour to your boss at school

Of course. He agreed it was weird and uncomfortable. He agreed he was a bit of a creep. He said he would keep an eye and intervene if he witnessed anything inappropriate or if any more disturbing red flags appeared with his sons. However, he and the Safeguarding Lead were clear that he'd broke no law, the images of me were not explicit or of me under the age of consent and were publicly available and that they couldn't police people's thoughts.

AICM · 21/09/2021 21:32

and then blame the members of that group who are not involved for not policing those who are?

AICM · 21/09/2021 21:31

@PickUpAPepper

I was listening to some man say how fed up he was of women just yesterday, at work. Weirdly enough no other group is allowed to be spoken of in public like that, let alone in a work environment. You can't even say it about the group that commits 99% of all sexual crimes on a women's website, named for mothers, without getting jumped on.

And needless to say, the man who said that was not challenged, nor was he about to declare celibacy. His complaint, as usual, was that a woman had dared to say no.

What if the members of one particular group committed the majority of terrorist offences? Would it be OK to make a generalisation about the group?

As in starting a thread titled 'to be just sick.of...'

PickUpAPepper · 21/09/2021 21:28

Ooh, the pic posted! Sorry, the pic wasn't actually aimed at you SJ, although I expect you'll struggle to believe that. It's one that I used to see on here once upon a time and the damn thing wasn't posting separately.

PickUpAPepper · 21/09/2021 21:27

All right. I did challenge it, after a short delay. The men in the group did not. Sexism is quite common in this workplace. Needless to say there were then comments about my comment, most of which boiled down to women have to be nice and STFU.

Jumping on threads that complain about the violence men do on this website is so common that we have a meme about it, or did you not notice the comments about post no 1 on this thread??

to just be sick of men..
Theworldishard · 21/09/2021 21:26

@OuiOuiBonjour

It's the level of disgust really, that I felt at him, that was the worst rather than the scary aspect of it. I didn't encounter him through dance or as a teenager but he'd gone out of his way to have pictures of me in an old childhood hobby for "his personal use". And then knowing his boys were being raised by someone like him (they would make inappropriately flirty comments or "moves" like a wink or a "kerching! get in their lad!" which they'd clearly observed or been taught) and that his wife, instead of calling him out, was rude to me (and presumably any younger woman he tried it on with).

And then of course he became a pastor. With access to lots of, often quite vulnerable women and girls.

I encountered him at a wedding he concelebrated (he was invited to the reception) a couple of years ago and he was still perving after me and trying to listen in on conversations with other guests about my new workplace and hobbies no matter how I tried to avoid him like the plague.

I'm sure he'll never be on a register or actually physically do anything illegal. He'll just have a good wank in private to perfectly legal images and people will excuse his "risque" sense of humour. And he's not the only one out there. That's the actual scary part.

Did you report his behaviour to your boss at school
SJWsAtItAgain · 21/09/2021 21:21

Why wasn't he challenged? You were there, why didn't you say anything? Who else were you expecting to challenge him?

You can't even say it about the group that commits 99% of all sexual crimes on a women's website, named for mothers, without getting jumped on.
And this is another disingenuous post. I don't see posters descending on all the threads on MN about what men are doing, telling women to stop. No one has told women to stop talking about women's issues on this thread either. If you can't separate what's been said from that, then that's how you want to see it. It should be an easy concept to understand but it's been dragged longer than necessary.

PickUpAPepper · 21/09/2021 21:10

I was listening to some man say how fed up he was of women just yesterday, at work. Weirdly enough no other group is allowed to be spoken of in public like that, let alone in a work environment. You can't even say it about the group that commits 99% of all sexual crimes on a women's website, named for mothers, without getting jumped on.

And needless to say, the man who said that was not challenged, nor was he about to declare celibacy. His complaint, as usual, was that a woman had dared to say no.

Shelddd · 21/09/2021 20:33

@OneTC

Definitely not an ALM person

White people are racist - yes, the extent of which is debatable

White women oppress other women of ethnic minorities - yes, I believe that people, women and men are prone to abuse the power they have

In these conversations there are very few incidents in which people state the (all) part, yeah you can find them, but like violent incidents committed by women they are like hens teeth amongst the posts that simply and correctly refer to men as a class. "People" who rape have something particular in common, does that statement not bear out?

I wish more people would openly state their positions like this. Just be open about it, you hate white people, you support the genocide of white race. Just own it. That's who you are, don't hide behind some BLM narrative.
TheHouseIsOnFire · 21/09/2021 20:17

Nor is the coach likely to worry that one day he might find himself alone with one of them and that should they decide to assault him he couldn't fight them off.
Or that they might wait for him in the car park in the dark.
Or follow him home.
Or rape him.
Or murder him.
Because typically men don't need to worry that female attention, even when unwelcome, might place them in danger.

Absolutely spot on - this is why the whole “women do it too” shtick is so pointless - it’s nothing like the same thing.

When 3 men a week are murdered by women, and when women commit 85% if all violent crime and 98% of all sexual assaults - or let’s be generous here and settle for 50/50 - then we’ll have the discussion about how women are just as bad as men.

TheHouseIsOnFire · 21/09/2021 20:12

@Recessed

I've come to the conclusion that most men are creepy to varying degrees. I don't care for the NAMALT crowd at all as I think this discourse just shields the real issue - that men are to blame for most of the world's problems. More education targeted towards males is really needed, as women generally don't need lessons in how not to be a pervert.
Sadly I agree with you. I have sons and I reaaallllyyy hope that all my feministing hasn’t had the opposite effect and pushed them into the loving arms of the NAMALTers.

My DP is nothing but kind and respectful of me these days but I remember his boss at a work function said to me “you should hear how he talks about women when he’s at work” with a big guffaw. I would have taken it more seriously had the boss not been a well known shagger and probably covering his own arse as well, and my DP does have a questionable sense of humour. But it has made me uneasy about the different sides to men tbh.

So many women on here who work in male dominated industries and get to see what they’re like when they think there’s no women around. There’s something very wrong with men. Not every one of them, but too many of them for it to be a coincidence.

lottiegarbanzo · 21/09/2021 19:20

They don't need to be given the opportunity to say anything. Talk to the dance school owner. You don't have to name names. She can let her teachers know and send out a general message to parents if she wishes.

Yes, of course it would be better if no-one was ever bad. But they are and it is important that when they are, other people pick them up on it and/or deal with it.