Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to say my pronouns

267 replies

Bamechage · 21/09/2021 13:45

Completely happy to get roasted here and for people to tell me I’m wrong but I’m a woman and my name is always mistaken for a man as I shorten it to unisex. I enjoy the ambiguity of it and that in written correspondence people don’t know. Where I work have made it mandatory and I understand it’s to be more inclusive but I liked people not knowing. Have I completely missed the point here and aibu?

OP posts:
mrsbitaly · 22/09/2021 06:40

I thought we were moving away from labelling people this to me is such a backward step.

lannistunut · 22/09/2021 06:32

Plenty of private sector businesses are doing this.

The world is not as simple as private sector good, public sector bad.

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 06:31

it's real people and who they are and it is horrible. Imagine people not thinking you had a right to exist?

Nobody’s right to exist is threatened if they fail to impose gender on others, i.e. force them to declare pronouns.

LizzieSiddal · 22/09/2021 06:30

My preferred pronouns: Fuck/Off

StealthPolarBear · 22/09/2021 06:21

And as a woman I am beyond irritated at being told that people with penises and beards are also women. That 'women' as a group made up of those who are female adults doesn't exist. But I don't extrapolate that to I as an individual not existing.

StealthPolarBear · 22/09/2021 06:18

The people exist and you know that's not what is meant
Gender as a belief system exists
I choose not to subscribe
I strongly resist any attempt to ascribe a gender to me.

Mostlylurkingiam · 22/09/2021 05:56

God I forgot how many truly nasty people on here "don't believe in gender" it's not a unicorn, it's real people and who they are and it is horrible. Imagine people not thinking you had a right to exist?

334bu · 22/09/2021 00:56

For what it's worth I think yabu not to be willing to endure a very slight inconvenience in order to support an oppressed minority.

Since when has having to work in a workplace where management impose a policy which is both misogynistic and transphobic , thereby creating a toxic working environment for some staff, "enduring a slight inconvenience" Forcing people to out themselves and others to put themselves in positions where they will suffer sex discrimination is bullying in the workplace.

thepinknecklace · 21/09/2021 22:43

We are not anti trans, we are pro women

CAN I GET AN AMEN.

Also how can you force people to call you by a particular pronoun? Great if John identifies as a woman or a she but if I don’t believe in this or I don’t want to call him she then why should i?

merrymouse · 21/09/2021 22:24

^I'm not sure I understand Warmdusher , are you saying that because disabled people aren't adequately supported (and I fully agree they aren't) we should make sure other groups don't receive support either? That doesn't make sense to me*

You haven’t explained why insisting that people declare a gender is supportive of anyone.

Waitwhat23 · 21/09/2021 22:16

I am assuming that Warmdusher is referencing the fact that there are 9 protected characteristics under the Equality Act and many organisations are doing lots to be inclusive of one protected group (gender re-assignment) while doing nothing at all to be inclusive of other protected groups, in her example - people with a disability. There's all sorts of 'pronoun promises' and the like to make workplaces more 'inclusive' for those who are questioning or have changed their gender but there's no corresponding focus on other protected characteristics.

merrymouse · 21/09/2021 22:04

@HollowTalk

Oh ffs just looked up Ed Davey on Twitter:

husband, father, carer, and MP for Kingston & Surbiton. Campaigning for a greener, fairer and more caring country. He/him

There has never been a female MP for Kingston & Surbiton, or the previous constituencies from which it was formed.
Stompythedinosaur · 21/09/2021 21:52

I'm not sure I understand Warmdusher , are you saying that because disabled people aren't adequately supported (and I fully agree they aren't) we should make sure other groups don't receive support either? That doesn't make sense to me.

Warmduscher · 21/09/2021 20:29

@Stompythedinosaur

You clearly know you won't be roasted on mn for this perspective so yabu to suggest you may be. There is a thread on this every couple of days.

For what it's worth I think yabu not to be willing to endure a very slight inconvenience in order to support an oppressed minority.

“Oppressed minority”?

If disabled people had half the support in the workplace that transactivists demand of everyone else, they would probably feel all their Christmases had come at once.

Congressdingo · 21/09/2021 19:45

@Macncheeseballs

Yanbu, although pronouns are useful on bank cards cos it cuts out 50% of the population as potential fraudsters
I've never had a pronoun on a bank card? Hows that work? A man states he is a woman today (see pips bunce for precedence) and ta da he is a woman, hows that help fraud?
Congressdingo · 21/09/2021 19:41

I am completely opposed to the anti-trans sentiment of Mumsnet and believe that TWAW

We are not anti trans, we are pro women.
I dont think any single one of us gives a shit what any mans wears/calls himself/does. So long as it's not in women only spaces.

ArnoldtheAngryTapir · 21/09/2021 19:16

Tell them you are gender free and find the concept of pronouns too narrow for how you like to express your being.

en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/gender-free

Thank God I'm self employed and don't have to deal with this pronouns shit!!!

Skysblue · 21/09/2021 19:02

Yanbu. This stating pronouns nonsense is Stonewall’s way of forcing people into one of two camps: those who say what Stonewall tell them to, and those who Stonewall hate and feel free to harrass. They think they’re at war, it’s very odd.

merrymouse · 21/09/2021 18:50

For what it's worth I think yabu not to be willing to endure a very slight inconvenience in order to support an oppressed minority.

Which trans people are you trying to support? If somebody has changed their name so that it’s obvious which pronouns they would rather you use, I don’t think it’s particularly supportive to suggest that you don’t know by ostentatiously announcing your pronouns.

Meanwhile if somebody is uncomfortable with gender, insisting that they choose and identify with a pronoun isn’t asking them to endure a slight convenience, it’s bullying.

KimWexlersPonyTail · 21/09/2021 18:28

i usually go with GC/AF

Tirediam · 21/09/2021 18:26

@Unfashionable I work in public sector where this kind of bollocks is starting to become rife. Because two of the blokiest men you can imagine have decided they are they/them and like to wear dresses. Makes me feel sick.

Stompythedinosaur · 21/09/2021 18:25

You clearly know you won't be roasted on mn for this perspective so yabu to suggest you may be. There is a thread on this every couple of days.

For what it's worth I think yabu not to be willing to endure a very slight inconvenience in order to support an oppressed minority.

thevassal · 21/09/2021 18:22

If it helps anyone - there was a letter recently on Ask a Manager - which is a ultra-woke-TWAW-death-to-JKR site but still manages to agree that mandating pronoun usage can actually be damaging to trans people by forcing them to either out or misgender themselves

www.askamanager.org/2021/06/my-office-wants-my-pronouns-but-im-still-figuring-it-out.html

Might be useful for those who don't want to stick their head too far above the parapet as it shows you don't necessarily have to be GC to oppose some of these ill-thought out ideas.

AlwaysLatte · 21/09/2021 18:14

It would find that intensely irritating. If they insist and you like the ambiguity though can you not just say They/Them?

C8H10N4O2 · 21/09/2021 18:03

@Wrongsideofhistorymyarse

YANBU.

When asked to give my pronouns at work:

  1. I pointed out sexism www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066?ri18n=true
  2. I mentioned Stereotype threat en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat
  3. I said that I am gender critical, that I don't believe in gender and stated that it is a protected belief

I don't think they'll ask me again.

and 4) it coerces and pressures people still considering their identity into a choice of revealing it publicly or publicly stating an identity they feel to be untrue.

It helps absolutely no-one but (IME) virtue signalers who are disproportionately white MC possessors of penises .