Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to say my pronouns

267 replies

Bamechage · 21/09/2021 13:45

Completely happy to get roasted here and for people to tell me I’m wrong but I’m a woman and my name is always mistaken for a man as I shorten it to unisex. I enjoy the ambiguity of it and that in written correspondence people don’t know. Where I work have made it mandatory and I understand it’s to be more inclusive but I liked people not knowing. Have I completely missed the point here and aibu?

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:25

@merrymouse

The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

I don’t think you read my question. I’m referring to anyone who doesn’t identify with societal gender expectations whether they would describe that as being trans or something else.

To put it bluntly, the policy you support forces people to out themselves publically and professionally or lie.

I'm not sure you've read my answer either! I actually don't support a policy of forcing people to declare their pronouns, and I haven't said I do.

What I oppose is privileged people not considering doing so for the good of others.

Most trans people I know, and most trans groups as far as I'm aware, do support people declaring pronounces in order to normalise when trans people do this, and it is no huge deal for me to do as asked, so I do.

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 18:20

So I am less worried about discrimination against men than I am about discrimination against women.

Apparently not or you wouldn’t be suggesting that women invite discrimination in their email signature.

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 18:14

The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

I don’t think you read my question. I’m referring to anyone who doesn’t identify with societal gender expectations whether they would describe that as being trans or something else.

To put it bluntly, the policy you support forces people to out themselves publically and professionally or lie.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/09/2021 18:13

The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

Which is not a helpful way to think when you are dealing with two different oppressed groups, one of whom can only benefit from a measure at the expense of the other. Listing pronouns calls attention to sex or gender, and calling attention to sex or gender has known oppressive effects on (for example) women who work in male-dominated environments.

There's no way round it except to start playing more-oppressed-than-thou and that never ends well.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:03

@merrymouse

Stompythedinosaur, You seem to be returning to the thread so perhaps you could explain why putting somebody in a position where they may feel forced to declare a gender with which they don’t identify is inclusive.
It's an issue of privilege. The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

So I am less worried about discrimination against men than I am about discrimination against women.

And I'm less worried about discrimination against white people than I am about discrimination against people of colour.

And I'm less worried about discrimination against people who feel they are the gender they were allocated at birth than I am against discrimination against trans people.

When you are already in a stronger position, the onus is on you to give a little to the oppressed group.

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 17:58

Stompythedinosaur, You seem to be returning to the thread so perhaps you could explain why putting somebody in a position where they may feel forced to declare a gender with which they don’t identify is inclusive.

VelvetChairGirl · 22/09/2021 13:06

Pronouns are BS and anyone with an obsession with them is a self centered bore who has clearly had nothing to worry about in their life if they focus on that bollocks and needs to get over themselves, I want absolutely nothing to do with anyone who has a hissy fit over pronouns its a massive red flag.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 22/09/2021 13:04

My name is always a woman's name, but In your shoes, OP, I'd refuse to provide pronouns as I'd prefer people not knowing if I were male or female and treating me differently on account of my sex.

Wroxie · 22/09/2021 13:00

@Macncheeseballs Mr. and Mrs. are titles, not pronouns... pronouns are words like he, she, they, them.

Titles come with their own problems (why do they indicate marital status for women and not men? Why are male teachers traditionally called Sir while female teachers are called Miss?) ... anyway it doesn't matter if they're on bank cards, I can't remember the last time a cashier looked at mine because I'm tapping it or putting it in the machine myself (or just using apple pay 90% of the time).

itsgrand · 22/09/2021 11:17

I would say that "I do not disclose personal information such as health, gender or disability other than officially & confidentiality to HR".

CecilyP · 22/09/2021 11:15

I would put a sentence that says I have no preference for my pronoun and people are welcome to use whatever they choose.

True, and people may say much worse when talking about you, rather than too you, than using the wrong pronoun!

itsgrand · 22/09/2021 11:13

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Say you don't identify as having any pronouns.
100%

I would say that "I do not disclose personal information such as my health, gender or disability other than officially & confidentiality to HR".

TheElementsSong · 22/09/2021 11:01

If I refused to put my favourite Saint in my email signature, would I be erasing Christians/denying the existence of Christians/ opposing religious rights?

Scarby9 · 22/09/2021 10:56

Maybe put he/her or go French with elle/ lui, or keep it simple - it.

BelleOfTheProvince · 22/09/2021 10:54

And what rights specifically are being 'opposed'?

Wrongsideofhistorymyarse · 22/09/2021 10:54

But put that way it doesn't equate to opposing trans rights.

What rights don't trans people have? And which of their rights are impacted by people adding pronouns to their emails?

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 10:51

@Bombaloorina

Disabled people's rights aren't being respected, so transgender people shouldn't be respected either.

Try a more affirmative take on it:

If only people gave as much of a shit about disabled people’s rights as they did about transgender rights.

I fully agree with this statement! But put that way it doesn't equate to opposing trans rights.
ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 22/09/2021 10:49

Don’t think they can legally force you. Just give your name as your pronoun if you feel you must give something.

Yours sincerely
Morrison’s ( Morrison’s)

Instead of

Yours sincerely
Morrison’s ( they/them).
That’s what I would do. Can’t be doing with all this tripe.

annacondom · 22/09/2021 10:49

This is brilliant. Only a few seconds long: pronouns cat

Bombaloorina · 22/09/2021 10:49

Disabled people's rights aren't being respected, so transgender people shouldn't be respected either.

Try a more affirmative take on it:

If only people gave as much of a shit about disabled people’s rights as they did about transgender rights.

CecilyP · 22/09/2021 10:38

Say you don't identify as having any pronouns.

Exactly, something like, 'Cecily does not wish to be referred to by any pronouns. Cecily insists that you refer to Cecily as Cecily at all times!'

Waitwhat23 · 22/09/2021 10:35

Putting pronouns on emails gets support as a policy because it doesn't cost anything.

Well yes. Because companies can then say that they are 'inclusive' without actually having to do anything to materially change their employees lives and make their workplaces inclusive. Why bother putting money into improving access for employees with sight loss, or accommodations for those who need more support accessing the workplace due to mental health barriers, or improving support for pregnant women who have a pregnancy related health issue, or providing support to women going through the menopause, or addressing institutional racism within recruitment practices, or tackling poor support in terms of wages and training for young people coming into the workforce, or tackling homophobic bullying at work?

Just ignore all the other protected groups who could do with support in the workplace, make everyone change their email signature and hey presto! The company can pat themselves on the back for being 'inclusive'.

BelleOfTheProvince · 22/09/2021 10:16

don't mean that transgender people can't campaign for their own rights

What rights don't trans people have?

annacondom · 22/09/2021 10:09

@KingsleyShacklebolt

I have a friend called Lee. She is a woman. Her point of view is that people should treat you the same whether you are a man called Lee or a woman called Lee so why should she have to put Lee Smith she/her?

Piece of nonsense.

The thing about this is that when people reply they'll either have to say "Dear Lee", or if they need to be more formal you can bet it'll be "Dear Mr Smith". Or they could do the time-honoured Dear Sir or Madam or Dear M/Ms Smith. So that's the only benefit I can see from all this. But doubtless this isn't why it's happening so universally..Why have so many companies been taken in? A small group of vocal people?
Jellycatspyjamas · 22/09/2021 10:07

Transgender people don’t have the right to impose their ideology on me, or to change my identity or impose labels that I don’t ascribe to. Which insisting everyone labels themselves with their pronouns does.