Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to say my pronouns

267 replies

Bamechage · 21/09/2021 13:45

Completely happy to get roasted here and for people to tell me I’m wrong but I’m a woman and my name is always mistaken for a man as I shorten it to unisex. I enjoy the ambiguity of it and that in written correspondence people don’t know. Where I work have made it mandatory and I understand it’s to be more inclusive but I liked people not knowing. Have I completely missed the point here and aibu?

OP posts:
merrymouse · 22/09/2021 19:58

For starters there are so many other ways to find out someone's gender e.g. title, images on a website, calling them, the subtle differences in language used by different genders (e.g. all the "softening" words women feel they have to use).

No. You can find out their sex but you can only make stereotypical assumptions about gender. If they announce pronouns they are endorsing your assumptions.

I certainly disagree with your beliefs about feminism if your arguments are poor.

Bombaloorina · 22/09/2021 19:44

Surely if someone has changed their gender, they have changed their name.

My perception is that gender ideology is nothing more than a set of recessive stereotypes, so if someone has decided they no longer identify as a man and are now Shelia instead, it’s kind of obvious that they’re she/her, and I don’t need it spelt out for me.

If someone needs everyone to refer to them as they/them when they’re not around, because they don’t identify as either male or female, then knock yourself out with your email signature.

The banal self-absorption of it all is next level.

grey12 · 22/09/2021 19:43

@GeorgiaMcGraw

It really shouldn't be mandatory. There is nothing inclusive about forcing people to declare their gender identity in every email they make at work.
True

And I personally hate calling people Mr, Mrs, Ms....... Envy Dear also doesn't make it any better

We should come up with a way to AVOID these things, not make them ever more present

HeronLanyon · 22/09/2021 19:35

whatiswrong agree strongly.

Thorgod · 22/09/2021 19:34

@Thorgod

Amazing answer! Best laugh I've had all day!
Ffs. To the pp who said pronouns should be fark/off Grin
Thorgod · 22/09/2021 19:32

Amazing answer! Best laugh I've had all day!

spongedog · 22/09/2021 19:28

@Wrongsideofhistorymyarse

YANBU.

When asked to give my pronouns at work:

  1. I pointed out sexism www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066?ri18n=true
  2. I mentioned Stereotype threat en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat
  3. I said that I am gender critical, that I don't believe in gender and stated that it is a protected belief

I don't think they'll ask me again.

No I don't think they will. Excellent. Well done.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 22/09/2021 19:20

*It's an issue of privilege. The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

So I am less worried about discrimination against men than I am about discrimination against women.

And I'm less worried about discrimination against white people than I am about discrimination against people of colour.

And I'm less worried about discrimination against people who feel they are the gender they were allocated at birth than I am against discrimination against trans people.

When you are already in a stronger position, the onus is on you to give a little to the oppressed group.*

I agree with this. Which means we need to give women the same level of protection as trans men and women. Gender ideology is removing protections for women - hence our concerns about it.

*We are all part of multiple groups, I can be both oppressed as a woman and privileged as a white person.

It is dangerous to assume yourself to always be the victim as a member of one oppressed group.*

Also agree - hence we also need to bear in mind that trans people do sometimes victimise others (inc women).

With regards to transwomen in female prisons - do you not care whether the women feel safe? or whether this triggers them? Does care for people feelings only extend to people who've grown up with male privilege?

Theoldprospector · 22/09/2021 19:14

Here:

It's an issue of privilege. The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

‘So I am less worried about discrimination against men than I am about discrimination against women.’

That is in contradiction to what you describe as reasonable about the Equality Act.

nocoolnamesleft · 22/09/2021 19:14

Tell them sharing your pronouns is triggering for you.

Theoldprospector · 22/09/2021 19:12

‘The equalities act puts all the protected characteristics on equal footing, which seems reasonable to me.’

But this entirely contradicts what you just said about being less concerned about the rights of men.

Men’s rights are no less important under the equality act than women’s.

GrumpyPanda · 22/09/2021 19:06

(hee/haw)

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 19:05

There were clearly massive failing in this case and she was very obviously put into the wrong environment. There is no way I would try to support that choice. But I don't think she was dangerous because she was transgender, I would so no sexual offender should have access to further potential victims in prison.

Karen White is not a she.

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 18:54

For starters there are so many other ways to find out someone's gender e.g. title, images on a website, calling them, the subtle differences in language used by different genders (e.g. all the "softening" words women feel they have to use).

Then why do we need to state them on our emails?

gogohm · 22/09/2021 18:52

When I'm asked my title I tell them just to use my name! Thankfully I design my own email signature so no issues there

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:51

@Siameasy

People who “don’t identify with the gender allocated to them at birth” - whatever that means - are not oppressed and shouldn’t feel entitled to claim the same or similar experiences to black or brown people. That is a huge liberty Stompy, to suggest that
It's tricky and divisive to try to have a hierarchy of oppression. I think it is unnecessary.

The equalities act puts all the protected characteristics on equal footing, which seems reasonable to me.

Waitwhat23 · 22/09/2021 18:49

There was a very recent judicial review, brought by a female prisoner sexually assaulted by a transwoman in the female prison system, in which the Ministry of Justice admitted that they do not know how many transgender prisoners are in the female estate and have also admitted there have been other rapes and sexual assaults on females by transwomen prisoners.

There is also the issue that a huge majority of transwoman prisoners in the female estate are there due having been convicted of sexual assault.

For anyone interested in further information, the website Keep Prisons Single Sex have very useful resources.

Siameasy · 22/09/2021 18:49

People who “don’t identify with the gender allocated to them at birth” - whatever that means - are not oppressed and shouldn’t feel entitled to claim the same or similar experiences to black or brown people. That is a huge liberty Stompy, to suggest that

TillyTopper · 22/09/2021 18:47

Exactly as @NavigatingAdolescence said - it isn't mandatory. We are supposed to add our pronouns too, I'm still waiting to be called out on it.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:42

@Norma27

Ever heard of Karen White for starters?
I hadn't, but I've read about her now. Thanks for the example.

There were clearly massive failing in this case and she was very obviously put into the wrong environment. There is no way I would try to support that choice. But I don't think she was dangerous because she was transgender, I would so no sexual offender should have access to further potential victims in prison.

Norma27 · 22/09/2021 18:38

Ever heard of Karen White for starters?

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:35

@EishetChayil

I am not harmed in any way by another person's gender identity.

You are when their gender identity takes precedence over biological sex and you find yourself in prison with a violent male-bodied sex offender.

Are there any examples you can give me of a "male bodied sex offender" being given free access to women in a prison environment?

I worked in a prison for 5 years, and my experience is that there was a fair amount of thought and consideration as to how to keep the prisoners safe.

I currently work with young offenders (including transgender teens) and I similarly find there is quite careful consideration about how to accommodate the children to meet everyone's needs.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:32

@merrymouse

So I am less worried about discrimination against men than I am about discrimination against women.

Apparently not or you wouldn’t be suggesting that women invite discrimination in their email signature.

I don't believe that omitting pronouns from an email signature will reduce the discrimination a women experiences.

For starters there are so many other ways to find out someone's gender e.g. title, images on a website, calling them, the subtle differences in language used by different genders (e.g. all the "softening" words women feel they have to use).

I think it is really tiresome to be called unfeminist because I disagree with you on this issue. There isn't only one correct way to be a feminist.

EishetChayil · 22/09/2021 18:31

I am not harmed in any way by another person's gender identity.

You are when their gender identity takes precedence over biological sex and you find yourself in prison with a violent male-bodied sex offender.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 18:28

@AmaryllisNightAndDay

The privileged group don't require, and aren't entitled to, the same level or protection, because they are not being oppressed.

Which is not a helpful way to think when you are dealing with two different oppressed groups, one of whom can only benefit from a measure at the expense of the other. Listing pronouns calls attention to sex or gender, and calling attention to sex or gender has known oppressive effects on (for example) women who work in male-dominated environments.

There's no way round it except to start playing more-oppressed-than-thou and that never ends well.

We are all part of multiple groups, I can be both oppressed as a woman and privileged as a white person.

It is dangerous to assume yourself to always be the victim as a member of one oppressed group.

I know it is a popular opinion on mn that trans people are somehow trying to harm women, but I don't believe that. I am not harmed in any way by another person's gender identity.