Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to say my pronouns

267 replies

Bamechage · 21/09/2021 13:45

Completely happy to get roasted here and for people to tell me I’m wrong but I’m a woman and my name is always mistaken for a man as I shorten it to unisex. I enjoy the ambiguity of it and that in written correspondence people don’t know. Where I work have made it mandatory and I understand it’s to be more inclusive but I liked people not knowing. Have I completely missed the point here and aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shelllendyouhertoothbrush · 28/09/2021 14:23

Why would the person sending you emails need to know your pronouns? Are they going to address the emails, Dear Her? Or maybe if referring to your emails when talking to someone else they'll want to say, "Her email stated". Very useful.

DrSbaitso · 27/09/2021 14:01

My point is that it won't be seen that way. It'll be seen as OP asserting a masculine gender identity.

SpindleWorld · 27/09/2021 13:43

I think SnackQueen is suggesting taking the piss out of an illogical, damaging system.

Personally though I'd rather challenge it on legal grounds: privacy and sexism.

DrSbaitso · 27/09/2021 13:32

@SnackQueen

Duh that’s the point.
What are you talking about? It's not the point at all. It won't come across as an act of defiance, it'll just look like OP is buying into the system. If anything it'll help validate it by suggesting OP is using it to assert herself as trans or NB when she isn't.
SnackQueen · 25/09/2021 17:02

Duh that’s the point.

DrSbaitso · 24/09/2021 23:03

@SnackQueen

This is absolutely not okay. If you are guilted into complying with this ridiculous policy, put in "he/him". If anyone queries you about it, tell them you'll be reporting them to HR and contacting your lawyers.
People will take that to mean OP is either male (she says her name is unisex as she uses it) or a transman.
SnackQueen · 24/09/2021 21:13

This is absolutely not okay. If you are guilted into complying with this ridiculous policy, put in "he/him". If anyone queries you about it, tell them you'll be reporting them to HR and contacting your lawyers.

334bu · 24/09/2021 20:36

I was referencing female sex offenders who are housed in the female estate not male sex offenders who should be in the male prison estate.

DrSbaitso · 24/09/2021 18:45

I am sure that this can be managed just as it is in the male estate with male sex offenders who sexually offend against other males.

Why should it have to be? Why must women be locked up with dangerous males at all? To whose benefit, for what reason, and to whose cost?

Why not just make prisons completely unisex if sex segregation can be overridden by anyone with a penis claiming they feel female?

334bu · 24/09/2021 18:24

It's similar to the tricky placement problem of placing women who sexually offend against women, though, surely? A group that is very small, but needs careful managent to protect the rest of the prison population

I am sure that this can be managed just as it is in the male estate with male sex offenders who sexually offend against other males

BubbleCoffee · 23/09/2021 16:18

Nearly right. Most trans people aren't trying to harm women but harming women is collateral damage of some of these proposals.

Well said. It seems that many of the trans lobby 1. don't understand why women need to defend their hard-won sex-based rights, 2. don't really care whether women's rights are upheld or not 3. think their own self-assumed 'right' to do whatever they like (and male privilege) is more important than whether this tramples on women's rights.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 23/09/2021 12:07

It is dangerous to assume yourself to always be the victim as a member of one oppressed group.

I didn't make that assumption. You don't seem to understand that there could be a conflict of interest between opporessed groups.

I know it is a popular opinion on mn that trans people are somehow trying to harm women

Nearly right. Most trans people aren't trying to harm women but harming women is collateral damage of some of these proposals. You haven't explained how harm to women is to be avoided. Just decided it doesn't matter because trans people are oppressed too, or oppressed more, or something,

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 22:30

It's similar to the tricky placement problem of placing women who sexually offend against women, though, surely? A group that is very small, but needs careful managent to protect the rest of the prison population.

I think you have misunderstood the relative percentages.

The male prison population is 19 times bigger than the female prison population.

Just the number of men in prison for sex offences is roughly 4 times the size of the entire female prison population.

Only a relatively small number of men need to decide they would prefer a woman’s prison before services are overwhelmed, but self ID gives them that right.

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 21:58

I have as much right to be here as you do.

Nobody has said you aren't allowed to be here. But "I'm allowed to say it" is a very very poor substitute for an actual argument. Especially coming from someone whose ideology silences women in their spaces, from prisons to competitive sports, except for when it's trying to pressure them to say things in their email footers when they don't want to.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 22/09/2021 21:55

It's similar to the tricky placement problem of placing women who sexually offend against women, though, surely? A group that is very small, but needs careful management to protect the rest of the prison population.

Well no, because if we allow everyone to self-ID using their idiosyncratic definition of gender then we can expect many, many, many more XY humans in a 'women's' prison. Hiding behind 'small numbers' does not address the issue. Neither does is address the way that women feel when they are locked up with an XY human - even if notionally they are 'protected'.

Apart from anything else - why do you think we even need segregation according to identity? Identity is as individual as a people, so it is very hard to group people according to something as nebulous as that. Why do we need sports, prisons - anything - to be segregated according to identity? What would be the rationale for that? If we do segregate according to identity then why are we picking 'gender identity' as a categorisation? Why not pick something more universal? (by which I mean that most people don't have a gender identity).

Jellycatspyjamas · 22/09/2021 21:54

I'm aware that there's a body of mners who'd prefer to silence those of us who support trans rights, but I have as much right to be here as you do.

I have no wish to silence you or anyone else who support trans rights. I would be interested in you explaining what it means to identify as a woman - without referring to sex based gender stereotypes. I’d be interested in hearing how you support trans rights to, for example, access to single sex space, or children being socially transitioned at primary school without their parents knowledge, or the right of a trans woman to compete in women’s sport (beating a woman unconscious in an MMA bout, for example. I’d be interested in hearing how those issues don’t undermine women’s rights/parental rights and responsibilities. I’d be interested in hearing how it’s possible to change your biological sex.

I’d be interested in hearing how compelling people to write their pronouns at the end of an email promotes trans rights?

In my mind it’s forcing me to change my behaviour to support an ideology that I don’t subscribe to - whereby my views and beliefs matter less than those of trans women.

Wrongsideofhistorymyarse · 22/09/2021 21:47

Stompy what rights do trans people lack in the UK? And how does compelling the use of pronouns help?

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 21:38

It's similar to the tricky placement problem of placing women who sexually offend against women, though, surely? A group that is very small, but needs careful managent to protect the rest of the prison population.

No, it is not similar at all, for the rather basic reason that male people aren't female people, and there is a particular risk dynamic and offending pattern that is highly relevant here. A female sex offender also isn't physically capable of rape, as defined by penile penetration and all the associated risks of that. There's also the issue of how women feel about being banged up with a man calling himself Karen, and why their feelings - indeed their safety - matter less than Karen's wish to have his feminine identity (hardy har har) validated in a female space as equivalent to actually being female.

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 21:31

I am, just following a slightly different ideology to you.

A form of feminism that reduces womanhood to a "feeling" and makes a woman out of a male sex offender who wasn't even legally female when he insisted on being incarcerated with women so he could attack them.

Good job.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 21:28

@merrymouse

For starters there are so many other ways to find out someone's gender e.g. title, images on a website, calling them, the subtle differences in language used by different genders (e.g. all the "softening" words women feel they have to use).

No. You can find out their sex but you can only make stereotypical assumptions about gender. If they announce pronouns they are endorsing your assumptions.

I certainly disagree with your beliefs about feminism if your arguments are poor.

Sure, of course. No problem with disagreement at all (I find your arguments similarly poor btw). It was the comment about saying I was not a feminist that I objected to. I am, just following a slightly different ideology to you.
Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 21:27

@merrymouse

But I don't think she was dangerous because she was transgender, I would so no sexual offender should have access to further potential victims in prison.

Only 5% of the prison population is female and of this about 3% are in prison for sexual offences.

About 20% of the male prison population is in prison for sexual offences. Under self ID they all have the right to be housed in the female estate, should they choose.

Where are they going to go?

If you really knew what people think on Mumsnet, you would be familiar with Karen White and you would know that women are not worried about trans people, they are worried about men. Self ID does not make a distinction.

It's similar to the tricky placement problem of placing women who sexually offend against women, though, surely? A group that is very small, but needs careful managent to protect the rest of the prison population.
DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 21:26

Thanks for sharing that - were you expecting me to be devastated?

Believe me, I am expecting very very little.

Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 21:25

@DrSbaitso

I'm afraid that I can't respect anything being said on this issue by someone who had never heard of Karen White and, when they do, insists that he is a woman.
Thanks for sharing that - were you expecting me to be devastated?

I'm aware that there's a body of mners who'd prefer to silence those of us who support trans rights, but I have as much right to be here as you do.

merrymouse · 22/09/2021 20:08

But I don't think she was dangerous because she was transgender, I would so no sexual offender should have access to further potential victims in prison.

Only 5% of the prison population is female and of this about 3% are in prison for sexual offences.

About 20% of the male prison population is in prison for sexual offences. Under self ID they all have the right to be housed in the female estate, should they choose.

Where are they going to go?

If you really knew what people think on Mumsnet, you would be familiar with Karen White and you would know that women are not worried about trans people, they are worried about men. Self ID does not make a distinction.

DrSbaitso · 22/09/2021 20:02

I'm afraid that I can't respect anything being said on this issue by someone who had never heard of Karen White and, when they do, insists that he is a woman.

Swipe left for the next trending thread