Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which is harder, being a stay at home parent or working full time?

292 replies

guac · 21/09/2021 11:12

I know this will probably vary dependent on the number of children and the type of job. Let's assume the hours of the job and SAHP are Mon to Fri 9-5. Not trying to bash either role by the way, just interested in peoples opinions

OP posts:
Pinkyxx · 21/09/2021 22:23

I was a SAHM for 8 months of maternity leave, been back at work full time since. For the last 8 years I've also been a single parent working full time, child lives with me full time. Ex about as much use as a chocolate teapot as he isn't interested in ''parenting''.

SAHM was definitely a lot easier than working full time, and working full time with a partner was heaps easier than single mum working full time & parenting full time. Once I've finished my 'day job' I do my 2nd job.. and that's before I consider all the cooking, cleaning, admin, medical appts, school stuff, night waking, activities after school etc.

I love it when I take time off in the school holidays as I get to catch my breath instead of running around like a mad woman non-stop 7 days a week..

TracyLords · 21/09/2021 22:20

So many variables. Depends on your job, commute, work environment, and of course, your kids and temperament. I found maternity leave an absolute doddle and loved every minute. But, my son was a nightmare toddler and I would have found being a SAHM at that point very stressful

JoborPlay · 21/09/2021 22:13

@sst1234

SAHP is easier than parents who work full time. Because it’s like having two jobs, even with childcare. Anyone who says otherwise is being disingenuous.
I'm not being disingenuous at all. I just don't think you can grasp how hard some people find parenting. I find full time work much, much easier. I don't feel it's two jobs at all.
KeyboardWorriers · 21/09/2021 20:10

Depends on the child (ren), depends on the job, depends on the parent, depends on their spouse /other support network, depends on their finances....

MarshaBradyo · 21/09/2021 20:01

@sst1234

SAHP is easier than parents who work full time. Because it’s like having two jobs, even with childcare. Anyone who says otherwise is being disingenuous.
Many are talking about their own experience though not just assuming it’s easier
Hobbitfeet32 · 21/09/2021 19:58

I think that working full time is harder than being a SAHM however harder doesn’t necessarily mean less enjoyable. I like my job and would always choose to work than be at home because I don’t particularly enjoy looking after children all day.

When I have time off in school holidays it’s a pleasure. No routines and stressing about trying to fit everything in.

Genuinely intrigued at those SAHM parents who claim that it is a 24 hour job…who do you think looks after the children when a working parent clocks off? You still have to do the night wakings, washing, bedtimes, cooking, mad rush for after school activities etc.
SAHM parent of school age children must be a doddle.

Ragwort · 21/09/2021 19:06

Impossible to answer as it depends on so many circumstances.

I was a SAHM for 12 years ... the easiest 12 years of my life;

I only had one DC (who was very, very 'easy').
I had a fully supportive DH who loved spending time with his own DC so I had plenty of 'me time'. There was no attitude from my DH that I needed to contribute financially (I ensured my NI was paid etc to secure my pension).
I had no financial worries - fully shared joint finances and I never had to 'ask' when I spent money.
Plenty of interests, hobbies, friends etc to fill my time.
Nice, comfortable home ... near the beach Smile.

But if I'd had more then one DC, perhaps with special needs, a dick head of a partner, no access to money, poor living conditions then of course life would have been much, much harder.

sst1234 · 21/09/2021 18:54

SAHP is easier than parents who work full time. Because it’s like having two jobs, even with childcare. Anyone who says otherwise is being disingenuous.

lazylinguist · 21/09/2021 18:42

Depends entirely on the type of job and what the children are like (additional needs, medical problems etc). My dc were pretty easy as young kids. I found being a SAHM (for a couple of years) an absolute piece of piss compared with my full time job (teacher). No comparison whatsoever.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 21/09/2021 18:38

Work without a doubt.

Parenting has no deadlines, no boss, can do what you like, no actual work etc.

MattyGroves · 21/09/2021 18:26

@Mirrorxx

Surely full time working mothers have much more to do. They still have to do housework and look after their children, but with much less time to do it
There is a lot less housework to do if you're out all day. And I never get anything done with two under 5s around anyway. I have a day off with my kids and I get less housework done that day than any other as they mess up the house and I am too knackered by the evening to do anything
MattyGroves · 21/09/2021 17:44

SAHM of under 5s very hard
SAHM of one under 5 who naps, not that bad
SAHM of school age children piece of piss

Tumbleweed101 · 21/09/2021 17:23

Done both. I enjoyed being a SAHP but it was more lonely but I struggle to keep on top of all the conflicting demands working full time. I enjoy the money and adult company though. Pros and cons to both and both can be hard going without outside company and support.

Itsnotdeep · 21/09/2021 17:16

I had 4 under 6 at one stage. Working full time is still harder both during the day and when you're at home - you don't stop being a parent just because you're working.

But it doesn't matter, because everyone does what's right for them.

Goldbar · 21/09/2021 17:14

It depends on whether the choice is:

  • SAHP 24/7
  • SAHP 9-5 and then the other parent comes home and you split things 50/50.
  • Working parent 9-5 + you do 100% of the house/childcare stuff
  • Working parent 9-5 + the other parent does 100% of the house/childcare stuff.
  • Working parent 9-5 + you and the other parent split stuff 50/50 whe you're not at work.

Clearly being a SAHP whose OH comes home and splits things 50/50 is going to be easier than being a working parent who also does 100% of the domestic drudge.

JoborPlay · 21/09/2021 17:11

@FindingMeno

Depends on how much outside help you get. Working, whether full or part time, is definitely harder when you have to do everything at home yourself on top of work hours, and plan childcare.
I think it depends how hard you find parenting.

We have some help (cleaner etc) but haven't always, and I still found working full-time miles easier.

Plantstrees · 21/09/2021 17:11

I have done both and working full-time was much more stressful but probably less tiring.

I had a desk job so it was great to be able to escape the house and I was able to pay for help at home so didn't have to come home and do everything. It was very stressful trying to keep the balance though and the guilt of working made it more worse for me. I much preferred being a stay at home mum.

Comedycook · 21/09/2021 17:08

@Nonicknamesforcatapillars

This is one goady thread. But as it’s already here I’ll play.

Brings SAHM is by no stretch of the imagination harder than working full time and still being a full time parent. Yes it can be relentless and thankless when they are very small, but once they’re at school you have all day to yourself. Even before they go to school you have time. You can do things in your own time. You can stay in your pjs and potter about doing bit of house work here and there as you choose. You can watch this morning on the sofa with some toast and a cuppa. Yes you may crave more adult interaction and your brain may be under stimulated, but that isn’t hard work IMO.

If you’re at work full time. The morning is a rush, kids to be clothed, fed etc. Out the door for drop offs. Whole day at work, home, yea, bath bed. Try to fit in home work and a bit of house work to keep things ticking over. At weekends you have all the jobs you couldn’t get done in the week because you were at work to sort as well as trying to spend some quality time with your DC. It’s so much harder.

The best woods probably be working 2-3 days a week. That way you get adult interaction time, but also more time for life stuff and quality time with your DC.

I totally disagree...it's depends on so many factors...number and age of kids, financial situation, family help, supportive husband, sen etc

A sahm with three kids under 5 at home all day will have a much tougher time than a wohm who has one child and lots of family help.

A sahm of school age children will have a much easier life than a wohm with several kids who relies on wrap around care and holiday clubs.

Just so many variables really.

The hardest part I found of working when I had DC was the commute and worrying about whether I'd be able to pick up my DC at the end of the day.

FindingMeno · 21/09/2021 17:01

Depends on how much outside help you get.
Working, whether full or part time, is definitely harder when you have to do everything at home yourself on top of work hours, and plan childcare.

JoborPlay · 21/09/2021 17:00

I would find being a SAHP harder. I find parenting generally very hard and labourious. I enjoy my job, I'm good at it and it gives me a sense of self worth and to be 'me' that parenting doesn't.

Additionally, I find the house much easier to keep on top of when we aren't all in it all day!

Vargas · 21/09/2021 17:00

For me: before school age SAHP was very hard and I would love to have been at work at least part time. But I couldn't bear to leave my kids with someone else, and DH works ridiculous hours and is scarcely home before 8pm M-F so I would have had to do work + most of the parenting.

After school age, actually probably after about Y2 (mine seemed to be constantly ill in Reception and Y1) then I would say SAHP was easier. Although of course there are the holidays....

Now I work part-time and have teenagers, and life is very good!

AllieTM · 21/09/2021 16:58

I’ve done both.

Being a stay at home parent to a baby and a two year old - incredibly hard work.

Being a stay at home parent to two school age children - much much easier than working full time.

And that is only based on my experience. There are two many nuances (health of children/parent, additional needs, financial situation etc).

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 21/09/2021 16:55

Sorry for all the typos!!

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 21/09/2021 16:54

This is one goady thread. But as it’s already here I’ll play.

Brings SAHM is by no stretch of the imagination harder than working full time and still being a full time parent. Yes it can be relentless and thankless when they are very small, but once they’re at school you have all day to yourself. Even before they go to school you have time. You can do things in your own time. You can stay in your pjs and potter about doing bit of house work here and there as you choose. You can watch this morning on the sofa with some toast and a cuppa. Yes you may crave more adult interaction and your brain may be under stimulated, but that isn’t hard work IMO.

If you’re at work full time. The morning is a rush, kids to be clothed, fed etc. Out the door for drop offs. Whole day at work, home, yea, bath bed. Try to fit in home work and a bit of house work to keep things ticking over. At weekends you have all the jobs you couldn’t get done in the week because you were at work to sort as well as trying to spend some quality time with your DC. It’s so much harder.

The best woods probably be working 2-3 days a week. That way you get adult interaction time, but also more time for life stuff and quality time with your DC.

doadeer · 21/09/2021 16:46

Stay at home parent much harder I think. The work day flies by for me it's so much more varied.

Swipe left for the next trending thread