Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which is harder, being a stay at home parent or working full time?

292 replies

guac · 21/09/2021 11:12

I know this will probably vary dependent on the number of children and the type of job. Let's assume the hours of the job and SAHP are Mon to Fri 9-5. Not trying to bash either role by the way, just interested in peoples opinions

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 22/09/2021 06:47

@RobinPenguins

Mind numbingly, bone crushingly relentless and tiring - SAHP.

Having no spare time, feeling pulled in multiple directions, juggling competing priorities, stressful - working full time.

Which scenario is “harder” than the other depends on the person and the circumstances.

That didn't go away once you add in 30 hours of work though. Then you have to still do it all but at night
MattyGroves · 22/09/2021 06:46

@Iwonder08

People who find a full time job easier than being sahm (unless there is some sort of special needs involved) just never had a job with enough responsibilities. Being sahm is just parenting, being in FT job is a bloody hard work on top of parenting with some sprinkles of guilt for not being there for your child all the time.
I have a senior professional job. I haven't been a SAHM but I have been on mat leave and I find working easier. I just find being with two under 5s stressful and draining in a way that my job isn't.

With my job, I am senior enough that if I am a bit tired one day, I can take it slightly easier but my kids won't allow that. No taking a short break with a coffee or going for a quick walk to get my head in order.

But some of it is that I really love my job and am very well suited to it. I would not be well suited to looking after children full time.

liveforsummer · 22/09/2021 06:46

I definitely did it harder working, although I don't work full full time hours I work 5 days a week for longer hours than they are in school then once I get back to the dc I'm running around often til late in the evening getting them to their clubs. Finding the time to do housework washing etc is difficult and I'm often too exhausted to do it come 8.30/9pm when we are at all home and fed.

Simonjt · 22/09/2021 06:21

I personally found being a SAHD easier than being a working parent. I took 15 months off work, while my son was hard work for the first 6 or so months it was still less stressful etc than work.

I liked that I didn’t have to meet anyones deadlines, I didn’t have to have a daily plan or targets, we could just please ourselves. If he hadn’t slept well I could have a nap, or I could just do low key activities that day. It was easier to socialise as I wasn’t knackered come 5pm, even little things were easier like going to the dentist, as you didn’t have to either lose a days holiday or worry about having to stay late at work and missing your appointment.

I personally find being a working parent much harder, I’m more tired, I’m more stressed and I worry more. I only work four days a week, in September we have a large number of deadlines so all staff are contracted fulltime in September, having to work five days at the minute is a killer as theres no time for those extra jobs I would get done on my day off, but I also don’t have those few hours that are just for me to relax, do what I want etc.

If I had a different job, or a different child my answer would probably be totally different.

Pixxie7 · 22/09/2021 05:58

There are so many variants depends on your job, if you have kids at home, financial situation. I found being a SAHM quite boring, but working as a nurse 60 plus hrs a week more stressful.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 22/09/2021 05:54

One thing I've noticed - people only ever say being a SAHM is harder when it's a married woman. When it's a single mum being a SAHM on benefits (God forbid) she is lazy and should get a job.

2catsandhappy · 22/09/2021 05:37

My ex would inform me that I had it so much easier as I was a sahp. Apparantly paid work outside the home was so much harder. Poor exdh would come home to a clean house and laundry, home cooked meals with shopping all done and would refuse point blank to do night duties as he 'went to work and needed a full nights sleep' He was so well rested he went to the pub 6 nights a week.
I wonder if someone is informing op that she has it easier as a sahp? Maybe op is wondering if they are going mad from lack of sleep and is checking to see if they really have the cushy life they have been told they have.

Is someone trying to convince you @guac ?

nyktipolos · 22/09/2021 05:18

I have been a sahm, ft working parents and ft working single parent.

All have positive and negative sides. All have bits taht make it easier or harder. But again, I may have a different view of each situation has the situation being slightly different.

My kids are older now and I work a very senior role. Which would have been almost impossible when they were younger and would have made life harder.

It situation would have only need minute changes, to make them better or worse.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 22/09/2021 05:11

@Iwonder08

People who find a full time job easier than being sahm (unless there is some sort of special needs involved) just never had a job with enough responsibilities. Being sahm is just parenting, being in FT job is a bloody hard work on top of parenting with some sprinkles of guilt for not being there for your child all the time.

This will bells on.

I work FT and have 3 young children under 5 including a set of twins - being a SAHM is much much easier

My work is challenging and hard work involving lots of domestic travel and lots of responsibility - I make decisions all day every day involving millions of pounds and manage 100s of people.
I do this on lack of sleep with 3 children who don't sleep through the night. I then come home spend some time with them, make dinner, bath them put them to bed and then often have to log on for a few hours a night oh and home cook, do all the domestic housework- washing, ironing, cleaning etc

It's not a competition but honestly I find it quite insulting when family members who are SAHP go on about "hard" it is when all they need to decide of a day is which baby group to attend

Iwonder08 · 22/09/2021 04:46

People who find a full time job easier than being sahm (unless there is some sort of special needs involved) just never had a job with enough responsibilities. Being sahm is just parenting, being in FT job is a bloody hard work on top of parenting with some sprinkles of guilt for not being there for your child all the time.

NumberTheory · 22/09/2021 03:52

I think this depends on number and ages of children. Type of job and hours with commute. And what sort of support you get.

If you have a partner who really pulls their weight with the childcare, night wakings, mental load, the default parenting etc., good childcare in place and a job you like then working may be easier. Working full time with a partner who is a SAHP, for instance, and does the sorts of things most SAHMs do, is probably easier than being a SAHM in the pre-school years.

Most women don’t have that sort of support and in the early years a full time job might take them away from nonstop childcare (which lots of women find tiring and tedious, even though they love their kids) but they still have all the other bits to juggle too and so have so much else on their plate that it just ends up being very tiring and stressful.

I think the bigger issue with being a SAHM is the lack of agency, power and standing it gives you in society (and, often, in the family). And down the line that translates to a less happy life. It’s not that working is easier, it generally isn’t, but it ends up being better.

TrishM80 · 22/09/2021 01:03

You'll get a lot of replies saying "oh, being a SAHM is so much harder than working full time".

Absolute and utter bullshit!

Wineat5isfine · 22/09/2021 00:18

So many varying factor - but personally, for me right now is working FT. Keeping on top of housework and the mental load is off the scale.

When I was a SAHM (2 children), my house was a lot tidier, my children had my undivided attention when they for home and we would bake a lot!

I don’t have that right now sadly

Restingtiger · 22/09/2021 00:03

It's not a race to the bottom FFS

Newmumatlast · 21/09/2021 23:53

During maternity I found being SAHM physcially and mentally easier than my job before I had my child by far, even with the lack of sleep etc. Now I have returned to work my job is just as hard but I also have the house stuff to contend with and struggle to get it done - my life would be much more orderly if a SAHM.However it was not stimulating enough for me and I could imagine that if I had to do it long term I would end up finding it harder mentally definitely

BikeRunSki · 21/09/2021 23:38

(Last comment was lighthearted, kind of)

BikeRunSki · 21/09/2021 23:38

Well, I’ve just sat down with a spreadsheet and term dates for 2 different schools, 2 different sets of onset days and 48 days annual leave between dh& I, abd have decided it’s got to be easier for one of us to resign than to try and accommodate the 25 or so school holiday days we can’t cover between us.

TheKeatingFive · 21/09/2021 23:18

It’s a stupid question, there are so many individual factors

BreadInCaptivity · 21/09/2021 23:17

IME it depends.

I worked FT in a high pressure job that was very well paid. DH and I could afford to outsource lots of housework like cleaning/ironing/gardening/after school care etc. He was also equally hands on outside work as myself.

I think my life was much, much easier than my friend who was a SAHM who literally did everything (her DH was a dick who thought because he worked he didn't have to do anything but had enthusiastically backed her giving up her job). She worked her ass off daily.

I think there's definitely a happy balance to be struck in both scenarios depending on how much you earn and how supportive your partner is.

I think the biggest risk of being a SAHM is finding out your so called loving partner is anything but when the chips are down.

My friend carried the mental and physical load - from which she never got a holiday for the best part of 15 years until he (cliche alert) fucked off with a woman who he'd met at work.

Ironically he valued her work ethic Hmm.

Snog · 21/09/2021 23:14

I found being a SAHP to be a walk in the park compared to working.

wanderlove · 21/09/2021 23:01

Both are hard in different ways. I feel like there are some strange answers on here. Those saying SAHM because it’s not 9-5 hours or SAHM especially after a sleepless night, you do realise that parents that work out of thr house still have to look after their children overnight?!? Genuinely confused why being a SAHM after no sleep is worse then going to wirk after no sleep. When I get home after work I then sort out all by chores till about 9.30 then cross my fingers that thr baby sleeps! I’ve done maternity leave, part time abs full time. I chose to work full
Time as I prefer stress to the boredom of being a SAHM …but I wouldn’t particularly say one is easier than the other…just one maybe fits your personality better.

Ozberry · 21/09/2021 22:47

Working, because all the stuff at home still needs doing but you have 40 less hours a week to do it in

Miliao · 21/09/2021 22:44

You can’t compare apples and oranges. I don’t really see the point of this thread. Why have you only quantified hours? Surely it depends on the job and the child not the hours.

Bunnycat101 · 21/09/2021 22:42

For me there is no question that work is harder with my life and circumstances. I have no doubt there will be situations where someone is caring for multiple children or those with disabilities they can tip it into being much harder. Sahp to school aged children would be much, much easier than a job.

But… working does also provide a sense of self-worth and purpose as well as money, pension etc. For me the longer/term benefits of working outweigh the short-term benefits of staying at home but some days the juggle feels horrendous. We’ve both for high pressure, stressful jobs and really that isn’t sustainable.

3scape · 21/09/2021 22:29

I've done SAHP.

Part time job and parenting.

And full time and parenting.

Although I had to be very time organised, budget more AND no one at work liked it I definitely recommend part time work.

Other than that. I think it's all better with a partner who isn't a total.loss.

As a single parent I think full time job AND solo parenting and keeping house is the toughest with the workload and emotional impact.