Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which is harder, being a stay at home parent or working full time?

292 replies

guac · 21/09/2021 11:12

I know this will probably vary dependent on the number of children and the type of job. Let's assume the hours of the job and SAHP are Mon to Fri 9-5. Not trying to bash either role by the way, just interested in peoples opinions

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 22/09/2021 16:45

@TheKeatingFive

I don’t know anyone where all the household adults work that have a cleaner or eat out regularly to not have to cook.

Me neither. I see this assumption on here quite a bit, but it’s not my experience at all.

This with bells on!

I think a good proportion of mn are much higher earners than I am, though.

TheKeatingFive · 22/09/2021 16:41

I don’t know anyone where all the household adults work that have a cleaner or eat out regularly to not have to cook.

Me neither. I see this assumption on here quite a bit, but it’s not my experience at all.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 22/09/2021 16:36

Most families I know with two earners buy in all the help they need and can afford meals out at weekends/ takeaways holidays etc so no not all working parents have to come home and then do all the chores

I don’t know anyone where all the household adults work that have a cleaner or eat out regularly to not have to cook.
The only person I know with a cleaner doesn’t work and has no children.

Tal45 · 22/09/2021 16:03

I think the harder one is whichever one you don't want to do!

marykitty · 22/09/2021 15:54

@nyktipolos

Most families I know with two earners buy in all the help they need and can afford meals out at weekends/ takeaways holidays etc so no not all working parents have to come home and then do all the chores.

Not sure where you live, but tons of families have 2 people working and can not afford outside help, take aways and meals out all weekend. Or infact want to. I am actually going to say most do not do this.

We could afford a cleaner. Would not like someone coming in the house while we were out. Would also probably clean for the cleaner coming round Grin

And also, most single parents can't afford outside help either with sahp support.

Absolutely agree! We both work but definitely cannot afford a cleaner, a gardener, take outs etc!
nyktipolos · 22/09/2021 15:28

Most families I know with two earners buy in all the help they need and can afford meals out at weekends/ takeaways holidays etc so no not all working parents have to come home and then do all the chores.

Not sure where you live, but tons of families have 2 people working and can not afford outside help, take aways and meals out all weekend. Or infact want to. I am actually going to say most do not do this.

We could afford a cleaner. Would not like someone coming in the house while we were out. Would also probably clean for the cleaner coming round Grin

And also, most single parents can't afford outside help either with sahp support.

OhGiveUp · 22/09/2021 15:22

@MarshaBradyo Even as pre schoolers, I found it a doddle. I went back to full time employment when they were six.
Semi retired now and running around after the grandkids.

Eustaciavile · 22/09/2021 15:22

Neither.
Having done FT/PT work and SAHP with 4 children over a period of 25 plus years, I can honestly say FTW and caring for elderly parents with dementia is the hardest job of all.

Summerbreeze4 · 22/09/2021 15:16

@Mirrorxx

Surely full time working mothers have much more to do. They still have to do housework and look after their children, but with much less time to do it
Most families I know with two earners buy in all the help they need and can afford meals out at weekends/ takeaways holidays etc so no not all working parents have to come home and then do all the chores.

When .I stopped work to be a SAHM my exH immediately did no house stuff at all ever as that was my area, so at weekends while he could sit on his arse my job was 24/7 365 days a year with 4 children, no family nearby and no money for even a babysitter and an occasional night out.

That said .I wouldn’t swop my time with the children for the world, although am now in a financial mess with no career/pension now that I am single, so I would y advise this.

Summerbreeze4 · 22/09/2021 15:11

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

It all depends on what the circumstances are!

Generally speaking

When children are babies or preschoolers - SAHP is harder

When children are at school - working is harder

However a lot depends on whether there’s another parent at home and whether they pull their weight with the “out of hours” work.

This.

It also depends on family help and finances. If you both earn enough to have a cleaner/ironed/gardener/ sitter/ au pair etc then working can be much easier but if you have to do all the housework and ferrying children around as well as work then working full time is very hard.

LastToBePicked · 22/09/2021 13:32

If money were no object, I think being SAHM to school age children but volunteering 2-3?days a week (charity work etc) would be the optimal balance.

SafeMove · 22/09/2021 10:50

So many typos, thanks to new phone.

*employee

SafeMove · 22/09/2021 10:49

I have never been a SAHM, I guess the closest I have had was Mat Leave. Loved mat leave. Pretty much despised my 22 years of FT work. I have had loads of jobs - lecturer, social worker, researcher, bar work, support worker, shop work, call centre work. They have all been crap tbh. Wpuld much rather have bern able to focus on being a mum. Have had more fun being a mum than an employer, that is for sure.

KimDeals · 22/09/2021 10:43

@Hobbitfeet32

I’m intrigued as to what all these jobs are that allow a long lunch or stroll into town or lots of coffee breaks. I’m in a very busy NHS job and barely have time to go to the loo!
Ha! I had the same thought! I am out working, and spinning plates in my head between work thoughts and house stuff - quiet strolls in working hours - no chance! More like lunch time run to the pharmacy pick up x y a post stuff / grab someone’s birthday present / endless jobs / organising …

Just basically being a SAHM but also working full time Grin

RainAndGreyClouds · 22/09/2021 09:17

I work. I'd absolutely love to be a sahm. I am very envious of those fortunate enough to have this option. If you don't like being a sahm, go to work.

MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2021 09:01

Also I’d done four year years ad hoc freelance and tricky to get ad hoc cc so Dh would walk in and I’d have to do my stuff. I was appreciating actually having at home cc and being out

MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2021 08:59

@OhGiveUp

I found being a SAHP an absolute doddle. Once I'd got the kids to school on a morning, I had until i collected them the rest of the day to do what I wanted, when I wanted.
I think most will agree that it’s far easier when they are at school.

Plus other things people mention making stuff hard won’t apply to all. Eg I had a nanny who did the bulk of stuff before I got home, a cleaner and I exercised by running home. Plus school age dc so lower feeling bad re leaving them

Sahm I didn’t have naughty dc particularly, or lots of them or any issues and still a cleaner it was just after a few years I was ready to work - and it felt interesting to be back

THisbackwithavengeance · 22/09/2021 08:56

When I was 18 I au-paired for a wealthy family in Germany. The women had been a management consultant somewhere like Price Waterhouse before giving it up to have 3 children.

She used to talk about how the 'real work' began when she gave up her job to be a SAHM

Given that she had an au pair (I worked 9 to 3 daily plus babysitting) a daily cleaner and someone who came in twice a week for laundry, I wasn't entirely convinced.

Antsinyourpanta · 22/09/2021 08:55

I was a SAHM to mine when they were babies/pre school age and I did find it hard (baby stage particularly) especially on days with no adult interaction. However once they were school age I went back to work pt and am now ft but it would be infinitely easier to be a SAHM to them now. (Especially as I know lots of other sahm) I'm even looking forward to wfh one day next week which I can very rarely do, because I can do things like put laundry on or start making dinner an hour earlier as u wont need to commute.

Katieandthekids · 22/09/2021 08:48

Done SAHM thing for my twins for 16 months and now working two days a week. I think mentally working a bit is easier but I couldn't work full time yet coz my mum guilt would eat me alive. About to go on Mat leave again for my third bambino and I think it will feel quite weird.

Confusedandshaken · 22/09/2021 08:47

I was mainly a SAHM, I just worked PT occasionally when money was tight. There is no question that combining parenting with working outside the home is harder. It's often more fun/stimulating but the sheer relentless pressure of it is so much harder. As a SAHM you can declare the occasional duvet day when you all lie in, no one gets dressed and you can build a fort and potter and mess around all day. There's no luxury like that when you have a workplace to get to.

KnuckleUp · 22/09/2021 08:46

Most mums have experienced both.
I have 2 DC close in age- for me working is harder.

whenwillthemadnessend · 22/09/2021 08:45

Definitely working.

I work part time but the days I work the washing piles up the house gets messier. Exercise and time For me is impossible.
Everything is harder to keep on top of.

Part time is definitely the right balance for me. I'd never go full time again.

MattyGroves · 22/09/2021 08:42

I don't understand why some people can't accept that not everyone is the same. I think many people would find my job harder and more stressful than being a SAHM. I don't - I find looking after two under 5s very hard work and any extra few mins to do housework more than outweighed by the work they create. And I don't think they are little terrors but if they are home, I have to make them more meals and clear up and get them to tidy their toys etc

JoborPlay · 22/09/2021 08:42

@vivainsomnia

I really don't get those who say that being a SAHM is harder than working FT. Unless you have 5 kids plus, or little terrors and don't know how to discipline, or you feel that you have to entertain them every second of the day, or your FT job is a piece in the cake, mainly involving socialising with your colleague, how can it be easier?

I was always FT mum, single too for many years since they were toddlers, worked in a quite demanding job, and the weeks I took off during the holidays, so both at home FT was an absolute breeze compared to our life whilst I worked.

I found being a SAHM mentally difficult. Touched out, like I had no value, no time for me or to be me. The housework was never done because we were always creating more mess.

Now I work full-time, the school holidays I take off are very very different to doing it full time and I enjoy it much more. It's the monotony that got me.