Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bias at school in selection of teams and positions

38 replies

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 09:15

At our child's Primary school, there has always been a tendancy for roles in sports teams and positions held in school to be allocated to the same children, often the children of teaching staff or friends of.
Has anyone else encountered this and if so, did you do anything about it?
My sister lives in a different part of the country and says there was none of this at their primary school and it's weird then there were no children with parents on the teaching staff at the school.
AIBU to think this is unfair on other kids who don't get a look in or is it a fact of life, it's who you know, get over it?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 20:15

Don'tAskIDon'tKnow,

Precisely!

A failing of education and society!

Favour and promote Middle England who already have access to betterment and fail the less privileged who don't.

We have a high ratio of pupil premium families at our school for whom clubs are not an option.

Would it be that great a hardship to assess the kids on merit rather than their connections to the school? And what message does this send out to the kids? Yet their policy spouts inclusion, equality, fairness. Bulls**t bingo at its best!

That such thinking and practices are forming the foundation of our future society is disconcerting!

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 19:37

Myyearmytime,

Glad I wasn't privy to that conversation! Angry

How times have changed...I represented both my school and district at athletics. Not once did my parents take me to the venues, we would go on the school minibus...had it relied on parent transportation, I wouldn't have either.

Reading such comments sadden me...
the 'haves' who are already participating in extra-curricular activities both in and out of school have it all and the 'have nots' are shut out in the cold. Sums it up really! So much for social inclusion and equality!

OP posts:
DontAskIDontKnow · 21/09/2021 18:12

I see this as a failing of education, in a way. For some children, their only opportunity to be taught how to be consistent with practise and committed to a team is through school. If the school just picks the ones that already have those life skills, then that’s a missed opportunity to improve a child’s life skills.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 17:31

ColumboOnTheCase,

Reading some of the posts, this behaviour is not so unusual after all!

I'm surprised there isn't any embarrassment on the teachers' or their kids' parts, however this sadly appears to be the norm where we are too. The times I've seen awards going to coaches'/teachers' kids! Suppose there has to be a perk to what they're doing...!
They must take parents for stupid not to notice or too polite to challenge, I am neither! Of course when you do, opens the door to sour grapes rather than the lacking meritocracy and nepotism!

OP posts:
Myyearmytime · 21/09/2021 17:01

When a secondary school sport teacher was challenged about this by another teacher in my hearing ( as parent on a school trip) the answer was children of teacher turn up for sporting events other children don't always . So teacher children and other child that are so as reliable get picked .

Which sadly is true as children only have transport to sport events if their parents take them . If parents can't or won't take them then children can't do them .
School sport and plays take up lots of time outside school so need a massive commitment from the parents if this does not happen kids don't get pick.

ColumboOnTheCase · 21/09/2021 16:35

Sadly this happens at our school, same children chosen for all the important roles. In this case regardless of whether they are the best child for the role.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 13:08

aretheareanyleftatall

Sour grapes about the 5 out of 6 teaching staff kids awarded a role? Totally!Angry

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 21/09/2021 13:00

@mrsm43s

In my experience, the children chosen to do things are usually the ones who are capable, show commitment, and often are confident. They also have parents who support bringing them along to practises/rehearsals etc.

It's not nepotism or favouritism, its choosing the best child for the job.

I am not a teacher or PTA member or in anyway linked to the school and have two children. One is hard working, determined, committed, turned up to every practise, always learnt her lines/practised her music/did any prep work required, was well behaved, always volunteered. She got picked for things all the time, she also put effort into doing the best job she could do. My other child, whilst perfectly capable is inclined to be lazy, puts in little effort, is scatty and will miss practises (or prioritise a more fun activity), will leave things like learning lines til the last minute, can be prone to mucking about - he often (but not always) volunteered, but would be picked far less often that my other child. Rightly so, simply not as committed.

If your child really wants to be picked, then they have to make sure that they consistently show the behaviours that make them the best child for the job.

This continues in Secondary BTW, and is even more pronounced. Prizes at prize giving will go to either the best or the one who has consistently made the most effort. Sports teams are picked by the best player. Choir/orchestra are usually filled on talent. Form captain/sports captain/house captain/Head boy/girl are picked based on how a child behaves. There's no more "everyone gets a turn to be Star of the Week". If you don't put the effort in, you won't get the reward.

This is spot on. I read posts like the ops and just think 'sour grapes.'
edwinbear · 21/09/2021 12:46

I think schools should be playing B,C teams etc. DC's school play all the way down to E teams because they make a point of ensuring every child will represent the school in sport at least once a term.

I do see the flip side though, primarily in athletics and XC as DS's primary sports. It's not confidence building for a child who isn't quite so fast to run against children so much faster. I've seen many a child who runs the 800m in 3 mins, competing against children who run it in 2.20 - 2.30. Likewise children who run the 100m in over 15 secs competing against children who run sub 13. Being the child who still has 200m of an 800m to go, when everyone else has finished isn't a nice experience for them and is more likely to put them off. I officiated at a county high jump competition once, where one child couldn't clear the bar at the starting height of 110cms, whereas many cleared over 130cms. That child went off in tears and it was heart breaking to watch.

mdh2020 · 21/09/2021 12:33

We were discussing this a few days ago. In Primary School my partner and I were always the reserves for the country dancing show At secondary school I was very good at tennis but not selected for the team because I wasn’t in the netball team. Everyone in the room had similar stories. My GD has missed out on being selected for the swimming team because she hasn’t been able to practice during the pandemic while other girls were swimming at home.

coldwarenigma · 21/09/2021 12:21

This just seems to carry on and on. I argued this when my DC were young and pointed out it is no achievement for the school to pick kids who play for outside teams. Pick the kids who don't play outside school and you get the true reflection of the school teaching/ coaching... play 2nds/3rds matches etc..imagine if school only entered outside tutored kids for exams because they are 'the best for the role' and most likely to achieve.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 12:13

LizzieBet14,
That's what you'd expect right...?
So blatant and obvious when it's the same 5/6 kids whose parents just so happen to work at the school or best friends with the head's kids!
This is not isolated year groups either, this has been going on for years! Same faces in the newsletters! No embarrassment whatsoever. Nauseating!
Send them over to our school, they'll soon be picked first...for everything!

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 11:59

edwinbear,

I would welcome some trialling...
similarly at our school, it is only cross country...other sports based on participation in pe which does not always necessarily encompass the school team sports, ie, ten pin bowling.
Most of the kids in the competitive sports teams are already playing for outside clubs. There are kids we know who are perfectly good enough for the team who don't get a look in and whose parents can't afford to send them to clubs and activities outside school who miss out because the school lacks creativity and inclusion when it comes to selection!

OP posts:
Jangle33 · 21/09/2021 11:59

This has been going on since the dawn of time. I’m amazed that there is actually a school where it doesn’t!

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 11:48

AngelWithSilverWings,

Really glad your daughter's running ability was eventually picked up at secondary schoolStar. I'm hoping the same will be true for us at secondary school.

You're right, it is laughable really. Before they were announced, I predicted the results with remarkable accuracy. Only one outside runner, a sporty role for a non-sporty kid!

OP posts:
Wotwhywhen · 21/09/2021 11:43

I have a daughter that is in the middle...

She's not a high attainer, she's not a bottom of the class and she's not a child of a friend of the teachers. She's the kid in the class that does the work to a decent standard, rarely.needs help, rarely makes fuss and just.gets on with it.

I've noticed, though she is only 8, that she gets overlooked a lot.
The naughty kid that behaves well for a day, gets rewarded... My kid behaves well every day but there's no reward.
The children of the friends of the teachers get picked as winners of 'homework of the week' or 'book in a box' etc even if they don't put much effort in, my.kid always puts enough effort in but never gets picked.

There's been a few times it's happened, but one that sticks out:
There was a "send a photo of you reading" competition.
My kid and me traveled all over the place and took several pictures reading several books in several situations, most of which rhymed. So we went to a marina and she read a book about Goats near the boats. Went to a forest and read about Frogs whilst sat on logs. We took Hairy Mclairy to an actual dairy...etc
6 of these types of days out, she learned how to edit them into one photo and put borders around etc. Took several hours of days out, picking books, photographing, editing etc. Lots of effort really.
Kid that won lives on a farm, picture was him just sat near some cows with a book open, zero effort entry. The kid is the son of the head teachers bestie and the head teacher picked the winner..

Affected my daughter quite a bit tbh, she's reluctant now to put any extra effort in and won't enter similar activities.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 11:37

MissyB1,
Good point. Our eldest went to an independent school for his first 2 years. Donations were 'voluntary' yet the biggest donors got a nice little plaque outside the school office! One particular kid was always in trouble and got himself excluded one time, the family donations safeguarded his place. Money talks!

OP posts:
Peanutsandchilli · 21/09/2021 11:34

It's been going on for decades. I remember when I was a school, it was always the same kids picked for certain activities. Fair enough if it's sports or similar, and there are only a few genuinely talented kids, but it was so bloody obvious that there were favourites. Usually the popular kids who could shout the loudest.

In my kids' primary it'd be the same children that won annual competitions, the same ones that got picked to go on special trips out etc. You knew who was going to be the head girl and boy before anyone had voted. You knew who was going to win the competition before anyone had submitted their entry. It just became farcical.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 11:28

BananaPB,

I agree with your point about personality... our two are chalk and cheese!
Our eldest got picked for all the competitive sports and roles and wasn't really that fussed! Was not a natural student, youngest is.
Funny thing is they've picked kids for sports roles that aren't even sportyConfused.

OP posts:
LizzieBet14 · 21/09/2021 11:21

In my experience kids whose parents are teachers/coaches are considered last for things so it doesn't look like 'favouritism' - I often feel sorry for them as they just want to be treated like everyone else.

Also, you don't see what goes on inside the classroom. My DS would be picked for all the sports teams (on show for school events - parents invited) but very much overlooked within the classroom where he was very much middle of the road. The complete opposite for my DD. All children deserve a chance to shine.

edwinbear · 21/09/2021 11:20

@AngelsWithSilverWings I don't think it's right at all that they trial children, but selection is then made on different criteria, I agree. For cross country at DC's school, trials are open to everyone, it's explained very clearly that they will select the 4 fastest finishers for the squad so everyone is clear.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 21/09/2021 11:08

At my DS's Y6 leavers assembly there were 6 Head Teacher awards handed out for various achievements. All 6 were handed to a child of a member of staff or the child of a parent governor. It was laughable really.

There was a definite bias when it came to picking teams for sporting events. My daughter used to tell me that she couldn't understand why she was never picked for the cross country team when she always did really well in the trials. Kids who didn't do as well were given a place over her.

When she started secondary school she was immediately marked out as one of the 10 best cross country runners in her year and this was at a very sporty school.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 21/09/2021 11:05

There's no more "everyone gets a turn to be Star of the Week

I think the OP's point is that not everyone does get a turn to be Star of the Week. I know what you mean, OP, I used to think hell would freeze over before my son got chosen to do anything.

On the other hand, it's not odd that the kids who are best at sport are chosen for the school teams; or that the kids who are most articulate are chosen to be narrator at the school play. However, there needs to be some creativity employed to ensure that those who would like a chance get a chance. As was pointed out on the football thread, if you never get to play, you never get better.

GiftOfGob · 21/09/2021 11:03

edwinbear,

Our two both play for clubs outside school which gives them an entirely different perspective. Not all kids at our school have that luxury.

Funnily enough, our eldest did get picked for the competitive sports team and given one of the roles, did not get chosen for performing roles, not into that.
He then got selected for everything going...badminton, cross country, tag rugby, bowling! I said to the school just because he performs well at one sport does not necessarily make him good at everything. When we declined participation in one team and to give someone else a chance, it came with a caution that he may not be selected next time!!!

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 21/09/2021 10:54

I'm an ex teacher (secondary) and my first thought in these issues is always to defend the teachers.

But then I remembered how, in the L6th, I was believed by everyone in my circle to be a shoe-in for the post of house captain (which was almost entirely a sports role) as we moved into the U6th. I had consistently played not only in a wide range of house teams but also in school sports, all through school, including the best first 11 hockey team in the county.

I was given vice captain - the captain's role went to a girl who was pretty and more popular and hadn't played school sport since Y8.

They came back to me and asked me to be captain when, a few months into the U6th, she discovered she was pregnant and left...