Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they handled this really badly and be really annoyed

58 replies

NcButBeenHereAges · 21/09/2021 09:10

WARNING talk of children and porn/sex

I'm not sure if I am being unreasonable and should just stay out of it or whether I should say something to DH about this.

I have a DSS who is 11 (nearly 12 actually). Basically my husband's ex rang him yesterday absolutely horrified that she'd found him watching porn on his phone, she was fuming so was DH who went over there and told him off.

When he came back and told me about it I just felt really angry for DSS and like they both handled it fucking appallingly.

DH (and his ex, I saw the messages as they were talking again about it later she was sending DH copies of what he'd been watching to show how awful it was (I know lots of people don't agree with porn but it wasn't anything "out there" but I appreciate seeing your child watching it can be upsetting) was going on about how sick it made him feel because he was far too young, how does he even know what it is, must be his friends who encouraged it, maybe he shouldn't hang out with them anymore, DSS isn't allowed his phone anymore, is grounded and so on...

Basically just going on as if the poor kid had committed some awful sin.

I tried to say to DH that he's getting older and he will start to want to explore this and maybe he needs to actually speak to him about sex but he thinks this is ridiculous and disgusting and far too young.

I've come away from the conversation actually really upset for DSS who was apparently mortified that his Mum had told his Dad who'd turned up and was crying. I think they've really fucked this up and missed a perfectly good opportunity to have "the talk" in a positive way with him.

I appreciate it's probably none of my business but I'm really annoyed with DH and thinks he needs to deal with the fact his son is not a baby anymore and will start to grow up in this way and not take that out on him.

I think he needs to fix this and try again. AIBU to tell him I think he handled this so wrong and stand up for DSS?

I've been here a while so I know this subject may cause people to question this situation but this is 100% true and I'm really, really annoyed about it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CityMumma78 · 23/09/2021 10:45

That poor kid, his parents handled this terribly!!

Lady1576 · 22/09/2021 19:14

@Lasttimeneveragain

I don't agree with the way they handled it either. This was very much the window of opportunity to talk about lots of things here, sex, consent and the negative impact of porn.

I think too many people are letting their negative feelings towards porn get in the way. This is a child who is being to develop a curiosity into sex. It happens at this age whether people like it or not. A child does not instinctively know porn the problems with porn unless someone takes the time to explain it is to them.

Yes absolutely. I don’t anyone thinks it’s a great idea for an 11 year old to look at porn. The point is that it is relatively common, if you prefer that word to ‘normal’. I don’t think exH has permanently ruined the relationship, everyone can mess up and react instinctively. If he wanted to repair the situation he could apologise for his strong reaction and for shaming him, and then explain why he had such a strong reaction. Ie ‘You’re my boy and it takes some getting used to, realising you’re growing up. Also I don’t like porn, can you imagine why? Here’s what I think…. However I really regret my first reaction and now I know you’re starting to be curious about these things I really want to be able to talk openly about this. Sometimes it might take me a moment to understand how things are different nowadays to when I was growing up. Or we might have different ideas on things, but I’ll never be disgusted by you or anything you tell me and it’s my responsibility to deal with my feelings about these topics, so please don’t worry that I can’t handle what you tell me. I definitely can and will.
Lasttimeneveragain · 21/09/2021 22:02

I don't agree with the way they handled it either. This was very much the window of opportunity to talk about lots of things here, sex, consent and the negative impact of porn.

I think too many people are letting their negative feelings towards porn get in the way. This is a child who is being to develop a curiosity into sex. It happens at this age whether people like it or not. A child does not instinctively know porn the problems with porn unless someone takes the time to explain it is to them.

Mammyloveswine · 21/09/2021 21:51

I suspect they acted instinctively and panicked.. he is an 11 year old child... I would be horrified too!

You have the benefit of not being the parent.. so can look at it with less emotion.

Have you said to your husband about positive next steps? How has he reacted?

felulageller · 21/09/2021 18:49

I dont think any of you handled it well.

Porn is the worst way to deal with curiosity.

Cam2020 · 21/09/2021 18:41

Their reaction explains why your DSS might have gone straight to watching porn in the first place! As you said, it was an opportunity to talk and they blew it. Your SS won't trust them enough to talk about anything in the future.

Summerbubbles · 21/09/2021 18:21

@DeepaBeesKit

1) not your kid 2) not harmless 3) 11/12 is way too fucking young. I'm sorry but it is.
Absolutely agree with points 2 and 3 (1 not so much). Porn can be incredibly harmful, especially to young people who have not actually experienced any sort of relationship before, they think what they watch is normal and anything short of extreme sexual practices are just not worth it. At 11/12 of course they will be curious, most of us would have grown up in the times where pre teens looked at the underwear section of a mail order catalogue or a glimpse of page 3, a far cry from today's porn, which is just depressing on every level.
Twobirdsinatree · 21/09/2021 18:16

Yanbu at all they have handled that dreadfully!
This was an opportunity to sit down and have an open discussion about sex and porn
Instead its been a shaming excercise which will mean he wont ever be open about his sexuality in the future as a teen. All that will happen is that he will now view his natural interest in sex as something dirty and wrong and take pains ti cover it up.. leaving both him at risk and his future partners.
I had an ex who was addicted to porn and one of his most vivid childhood memories was of his mum finding a porn magasine his friend had given him and hed hidden under his mattress. His mother had cried in front of him when he found it. He had a really messed up attitude towards sex as an adult.. a mixture of hatred and resentment towards women and an obsession with pornography whilst also hating himself for having an obsession with pornography. As you can imagine this did not lead to healthy relationships.

There are ways to discuss why pornography might be harmful to women with your child....and i do think its good to have that discussion with your children
But massively overreacting and acting like its some disgusting unnatural thing that needs punishment is just really psychologically damaging and not helpful in the slightest

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/09/2021 18:03

@Lady1576

If you are a parent, time to get prepared/practising for the moment you find out your 11 year old has accessed or come across porn, because it will happen, so think now how you want to handle it. Don’t be flustered about it, because you’ve had fair warning (for those saying they’d have acted like exH) If you think it’s shocking/unlikely, you are out of touch unfortunately. It is absolutely developmentally appropriate to be interested and curious about sex at this age, and in the times we live in, that means young people may access porn themselves or have another child show it to them.
This ^

If your daft Oh won't use this as a useful teaching opportunity... Let the older teens teach him (the wrong) stuff about sex...

Every kid asks at the age they need to start having these conversations... I was asking about sex at 10/11....and most likely would have accessed porn had the Internet been around.

Awful that your daft OH has now shamed his son, thus making it much less likely for your DSS to speak to him.

LaLaJ · 21/09/2021 17:09

@DeepaBeesKit

1) not your kid 2) not harmless 3) 11/12 is way too fucking young. I'm sorry but it is.
11/12 is way too fucking young. I'm sorry but it is

You are kidding yourself or being incredibly naive if you think its way too young for a 12 year old boy to be curious about sex.

I'm not sure if it's wishful thinking because you don't want your kids to grow up but it is entirely normal for that age to be starting to get curious about this stuff and sticking your fingers in your ears and pretending it's not doesn't help them.

Lady1576 · 21/09/2021 14:34

If you are a parent, time to get prepared/practising for the moment you find out your 11 year old has accessed or come across porn, because it will happen, so think now how you want to handle it. Don’t be flustered about it, because you’ve had fair warning (for those saying they’d have acted like exH) If you think it’s shocking/unlikely, you are out of touch unfortunately. It is absolutely developmentally appropriate to be interested and curious about sex at this age, and in the times we live in, that means young people may access porn themselves or have another child show it to them.

billy1966 · 21/09/2021 14:24

I don't believe punishment was in any way appropriate.

He has a phone, no doubt paid for by his parents and via that, accessed sites that are not appropriate.

Punishment is completely inappropriate.

Sitting down and having a chat and expressing your concerns for him and explaining how damaging porn is, is the way to go.

Not humiliating a child, causing him to cry and punishing him.

OP, keep this stupid man away from YOUR child.

DeepaBeesKit · 21/09/2021 14:24

Clearly if his son is searching for it and watching it he’s not too young.

Not true.

Children are curious and easily led by older influences. It only takes a popular child with an older sibling to boast about enjoying this for children to go along with things they are not comfortable with.

DeepaBeesKit · 21/09/2021 14:23
  1. not your kid
  2. not harmless
  3. 11/12 is way too fucking young. I'm sorry but it is.
bluegreygreen · 21/09/2021 14:18

The son is no longer a toddler but it does seem a bit unrealistic to be equating an 11 yr old with a 'young teen'

Etonmessisyum · 21/09/2021 11:27

Clearly if his son is searching for it and watching it he’s not too young. Here they get sex education via personal and social education in p5 at 9 then in p7 but I think it’s ongoing in the health topic anyway. So they do know stuff. My 11 year old (12 in March) is p7 so of course you need to speak to them and educate them. Their friends tell them stuff, those friends have older siblings who they hear things from (my son has a 20 yo and 16 yo ds) so to prevent to much ‘curiosity’ parental controls are on devices. And I talk to them about things. It’s open and honest and they can ask me things - ds 11 asked me about wanking last week. He’d heard someone talking about it apparently. We were in the car so I just said we’ll have a chat at home as my younger son was in the car so then gives me a chance to think about what to say and how to say it. (I can be quite tongue tied sometimes) his dad has never discussed anything with him and I think he’d go off his head and text me whinging about it so I prefer if they speak to me)

Your dh needs to grow up and realise his son isn’t a toddler and speaking to him about these things will help him and his son and stop the bloody hysteria. No porn is not ok but sex is and it’s part of life, making sex all bad and dirty isn’t healthy

Hont1986 · 21/09/2021 11:27

Then what part of how they handled it do you disagree with? You don't think they should have been angry? Watching porn at home is not a harmless act. I'm not rabidly anti-porn but an 11 year old doesn't know what they are doing - they could download viruses, they could access child porn, they could leave it on the computer for a younger sibling to see, etc. Not to mention the harm they do to themselves and their own sexuality - even 'normal' porn would teach an impressionable youth that 'facials', choking, some light slapping, etc are all part of normal sex.

NcButBeenHereAges · 21/09/2021 11:19

@Hont1986

I actually don't think it's wrong that his ex called him round. Their son did something that needed to be punished/addressed, it is a significant enough event that both his parents should be there and be on the same page about it.

Of course he was crying, he's 11 and his mum and dad caught him watching porn. Anyone would feel mortified. That doesn't mean they should have ignored it.

I don't think there's is anything wrong with that either. I never said there was. And I don't think it should have been ignored.
OP posts:
BrendaBubbles · 21/09/2021 11:19

I don't think they should have humiliated him like that, but at the same time they did have to do something as if you know your child is viewing porn and you do nothing about it, you are breaking the law (essentially it is the equivalent of you showing them it).

Hont1986 · 21/09/2021 11:15

I actually don't think it's wrong that his ex called him round. Their son did something that needed to be punished/addressed, it is a significant enough event that both his parents should be there and be on the same page about it.

Of course he was crying, he's 11 and his mum and dad caught him watching porn. Anyone would feel mortified. That doesn't mean they should have ignored it.

earthyfire · 21/09/2021 11:08

I've got a settings on my Wifi so my kids can't access or stumble upon porn, I remember my youngest coming home from school after being taught RSE and googling sex and other words discussed that day and up popped porn. I didn't know until my eldest told me so I quickly discovered how to put a block/parental restrictions on the Wifi. I just had a chat with her, explained about it not being a true reflection of real sex etc, all while trying not to make her feel embarrassed about it.

Hortibunda · 21/09/2021 11:04

[quote gailplattshairbrush]@Hortibunda why on earth would the poor kid want to ask his dad any questions now? He has been told off and punished rather than spoken to openly. All that will do is shame him and make him feel unable to ask these 'questions'. It can be daunting and embarrassing to speak to your parents about things like this. The absolute worst thing you can do if you want to keep communication open is freak out and over react like the parents did in this case.

I suspect the son will be too nervous and scared to speak to them frankly again [/quote]
If you read my post I was quite clearly talking about how I would have handled this situation gailplattshairbrush. Of course you need to keep the lines of communication open; it's one of the most important things you can do as a parent. And if a child is embarrassed; it's your job to approach it in a way that reassures them that it's a normal and OK subject to talk about.

In this instance I would encourage the dad to take his son out for a drive and a burger and apologise to him for over-reacting and explain calmly why he reacted in that way (being protective etc) and encourage him to ask any questions he needs to.

Hoppinggreen · 21/09/2021 10:57

I have a 12 year old boy and yes it has been handled very very badly
They have humiliated and frightened this boy rather than use it as a teaching opportunity
I understand it’s hard to accept that your baby boy is or is becoming a hormone fuelled teen but it happens and you can help them on that journey in an appropriate way or give them some serous hang ups about sex
Unfortunately OP it’s not your child but hopefully you can help your partner see sense

gailplattshairbrush · 21/09/2021 10:57

@Hortibunda why on earth would the poor kid want to ask his dad any questions now? He has been told off and punished rather than spoken to openly. All that will do is shame him and make him feel unable to ask these 'questions'. It can be daunting and embarrassing to speak to your parents about things like this. The absolute worst thing you can do if you want to keep communication open is freak out and over react like the parents did in this case.

I suspect the son will be too nervous and scared to speak to them frankly again

purpleboy · 21/09/2021 10:56

I think you need to try and speak to your dh again, I guess he has time to calm down and process, so he may now be open to a reasonable discussion.
Maybe ask him the questions like what age does he feel it appropriate to discuss with ds? What does he think will be gained by waiting until then? Is he aware ds has covered sex education at school? Does he think it's better for ds to get info (potentially damaging) from his friends rather than from his parents?
Try and get him to think and explore his reasoning and feelings a bit more.
Good luck it sounds a mess.