Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not *that* weird to only have one car?

184 replies

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 20/09/2021 17:21

At lunchtime today I was chatting to a colleague who asked if I was going to an (optional) event in the office on Wednesday. For context, we’re currently hybrid working, 2 office days/3 WFH days each week and as one of the managers (albeit not too high up the seniority tree) I get to manage which days are which myself, with sensitivity to the needs of the business of course.

I said I would have quite liked to have been there but my car is booked in for a repair on Wednesday so I’ve had to make it a WFH day. She immediately said “can you not just use your husband’s car that day?” I said we only have one car and she said “oh” and looked quite nonplussed, as if I’d suddenly started speaking in tongues, and there was a long pause where it looked like she genuinely didn’t know how to respond to my shocking revelation Grin I asked her if she was going and the conversation moved on, so I thought. But then as she was about to go back to her desk she hesitated, and then said “so what does your husband do if he needs to go somewhere while you’re at work?” so it was obviously playing on her mind. I just said, we manage (as it happens he’s disabled so no longer drives but she doesn’t need to know the ins and outs of his medical history, and even if he were still driving we couldn’t afford to run two cars) but it got me thinking…is it so unusual to only have one car between a couple these days?

OP posts:
arrangeyourface · 20/09/2021 18:40

DH and I have three cars but are about to go down to two. We’ve considered having one between us but it wouldn’t work due to conflicting demands of things we need to do/places we need to be.

For example, two nights a week, DH attends a thing in a different area not served well enough by public transport to get there in time. Those nights I have gym classes and there is no public transport to the gym. Walking or cycling isn’t an option because of the times I finish work versus start times of classes.

If you’re in a location well covered by public transport and you don’t have conflicting requirements then one car is perfectly normal. The reality is that many couples aren’t in that position.

Your colleague is weird for being weird about it though.

ABCDEF1234 · 20/09/2021 18:39

I can't think of anyone (family, friends, neighbours) that don't have 2 cars. I know I would really struggle if we were restricted to only one car (and I wfh 100% and hubby 80%).

PhoboPhobia · 20/09/2021 18:37

I wonder what she’d think of my adult DD who has no intention of learning to drive?!

irregularegular · 20/09/2021 18:36

We have one car, and try to use it as less as possible for environmental reasons. We are lucky in that we can both bike to work and the kids walk up a school. In this era of climate change, I thinks it’s everyone’s responsibility use their cars as least as they possibly can

It isn't necessarily less environmentally friendly to have two cars. We use less fuel since we bought the smaller more efficient car and use that most of the time. We'd struggle with just the small car. So the choice is big car, or big AND small. And I think the second is probably more environmentally friendly for us?

FastFood · 20/09/2021 18:36

I have a grand total of 0 car.
But I have a push bike, two train stations, a billion buses and DLR / overground not far.

I'd say its a bit surprising to have just one car when you're so reliant on it that you wouldn't be able to go to work without it, but with flexible working its less of an issue I guess

Happyface120 · 20/09/2021 18:35

Nope, not odd. We live rurally, 2DC about 8-9 miles from both mine and DH work, amd 6 miles from DCs school. We take it in turns to cycle to work whilst the other takes kids in, when weather is good we drop kids bikes in school and then the cycling adult collects them. Sometimes one of us will cycle in then run home, and the next day do it the other way around.. Works really well for fitting in exercise. Whoever has car is responsible for kids clubs in evenings

Mynameismargot · 20/09/2021 18:33

We only have one car. I work from home, dh works 5mins away so can walk. One kid gets the bus to school, the other kids school is 5 mins walk away. 99% of the time it isn't an issue and it isn't worth the expense of a 2nd car for the 1% of the time it would be handy.

yoyo1234 · 20/09/2021 18:32

@Sparklehead : We have one car, and try to use it as less as possible for environmental reasons. We are lucky in that we can both bike to work and the kids walk up a school. In this era of climate change, I thinks it’s everyone’s responsibility use their cars as least as they possibly can. Most of my friends are also one car families.

I agree with you

PhoboPhobia · 20/09/2021 18:31

We always had 2 cars when the DCs were younger but went down to one about 2 years ago. We manage fine.

DH rarely needs the car during the working day and I wfh a lot. If I think I’m going to need the car in the day I take him to work or he walks round to a colleague who lives 5 minutes away occasionally and gets a lift.

Lately I have had the car a lot as MIL is poorly so I visit during the day. Also DS started college and the trains can be hit and miss here sometimes so I am available if he gets stranded somewhere.

I dreaded only having one car but it has been a piece of cake. I can get the bus if I want to go into the office although it’s a bit expensive. Weird that your colleague can’t get her head round a fairly simple concept!

Anothermuddywalk · 20/09/2021 18:29

We only have one car, have done for years. DH cycles to work on days when I'm using the car. Its very rarely ever a problem, and certainly not enough for the expense of a second car. Thinking about it, several of our neighbours only have one car as well, so not uncommon here (reasonable public transport though, and a small town that can be cycled around easily).

yoyo1234 · 20/09/2021 18:28

I know of few of our friends with 2 cars. Often there is one car and the other uses public transport (if in a couple). I like to think concern for the environment plays a part, I also think with the people I know it is a generation thing (older generation more likely to have more than one in a couple).

Fink · 20/09/2021 18:26

I guess it depends where you live and what the public transport/cycling options are, as well as jobs and kids. My parents and all my siblings only have one car per family, but we all live in London so never use them for work anyway. When I lived more rurally it was a pain because dh and I would have to drive in to work together and hang around for each other to finish.

YoComoManzanas · 20/09/2021 18:25

It's bizarre that your colleague couldn't fathom using a taxi/ public transport/ walk or bike somewhere.

longestlurkerever · 20/09/2021 18:21

@FlowerArranger

So much to do with car ownership seems to be anchored in conveying an image of some sort. The 'right' car. Not older than, say, 4 years. I know people who take on so much debt they can't afford, thus depriving themselves of experiences that could enhance their lives. For a car - a means of getting from A to B!!

Obviously there are places where a car is virtually mandatory. Which is why we have one car. Which is 20 years old.... I fear one or two of our neighbours consider it a bit of a blot on the neighbourhood........ But do I care?

I do think this is true. I wonder how many people who cite terrible public transport would consider a certain level of inconvenience as acceptable. I visited dsis in Edinburgh recently by train and met up with quite a lot of people on various bits if the city who kept offering to drive to meet me or get me insured on their car. It's a city, it has buses and trains and I had my bike with me too. But I was made to feel a bit weird for being reliant on public transport, even for a week.
piglet81 · 20/09/2021 18:21

No cars here. London, though, so no need.

Sparklehead · 20/09/2021 18:20

We have one car, and try to use it as less as possible for environmental reasons. We are lucky in that we can both bike to work and the kids walk up a school. In this era of climate change, I thinks it’s everyone’s responsibility use their cars as least as they possibly can. Most of my friends are also one car families.

Lazypuppy · 20/09/2021 18:19

I personally wouldn't want to share only 1car with my DH but there are plenty of people who do so YANBU

Birdkin · 20/09/2021 18:18

Definitely think it’s location dependent.

I’ve always lived in cities and have never had a car in my life. People found it a bit weird in my childhood but as an adult I still don’t have one and neither do half my friends.

TheGrumpyGoat · 20/09/2021 18:18

We have one car. We had two, but when we took the second for it’s MOT last year and realised it had only done 350 miles in a year we sold it.
Now on the odd occasions it’s a problem one of us gets a taxi. Still cheaper over the course of a year.

Stovetopespresso · 20/09/2021 18:16

some people regard car ownership as some kind of personal statement of freedom or whatever!.its a mindset thing, also as public transport isn't always great in so many areas.

we have 2 but could possibly consider going down to one
I'd miss spontaneous trips on my day off though.
rubbish public transport where I live. so expensive.

DressBitch · 20/09/2021 18:15

We've got one car. My husband started his own business from home and the first year he did 1000 miles, most of which were done just to run his car for the sake of it. He had a BMW which was quite expensive to just keep as a lawn ornament.

Two weeks later, someone crashed into the other car and wrote it off, but apart from that, it's not been an issue!

Toolateplanting · 20/09/2021 18:15

This must be very location and income dependent! I am struggling to think of any families I know that live by us in similar circumstances who have 2 cars. Can think of plenty with none even where they could afford it but use car club instead. Yet im sure people living in suburbs or rurally would likely have 2 if they could.

FlowerArranger · 20/09/2021 18:15

So much to do with car ownership seems to be anchored in conveying an image of some sort. The 'right' car. Not older than, say, 4 years. I know people who take on so much debt they can't afford, thus depriving themselves of experiences that could enhance their lives. For a car - a means of getting from A to B!!

Obviously there are places where a car is virtually mandatory. Which is why we have one car. Which is 20 years old.... I fear one or two of our neighbours consider it a bit of a blot on the neighbourhood........ But do I care?

EllieSattler · 20/09/2021 18:12

I had to be in work at 7am today, and I work 40 miles away and live in a town with no train station. DH started work at 2pm, he will finish at 11pm. He also works about 40 miles away but in a different location. (Both emergency services). I needed to pick the DC up from school, and DD had an activity. We really couldn't manage with just one car. It was fine when we lived in a town that was walking distance (30 minutes) to a train station but no use now.

ChocChipPancake · 20/09/2021 18:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.