Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not *that* weird to only have one car?

184 replies

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 20/09/2021 17:21

At lunchtime today I was chatting to a colleague who asked if I was going to an (optional) event in the office on Wednesday. For context, we’re currently hybrid working, 2 office days/3 WFH days each week and as one of the managers (albeit not too high up the seniority tree) I get to manage which days are which myself, with sensitivity to the needs of the business of course.

I said I would have quite liked to have been there but my car is booked in for a repair on Wednesday so I’ve had to make it a WFH day. She immediately said “can you not just use your husband’s car that day?” I said we only have one car and she said “oh” and looked quite nonplussed, as if I’d suddenly started speaking in tongues, and there was a long pause where it looked like she genuinely didn’t know how to respond to my shocking revelation Grin I asked her if she was going and the conversation moved on, so I thought. But then as she was about to go back to her desk she hesitated, and then said “so what does your husband do if he needs to go somewhere while you’re at work?” so it was obviously playing on her mind. I just said, we manage (as it happens he’s disabled so no longer drives but she doesn’t need to know the ins and outs of his medical history, and even if he were still driving we couldn’t afford to run two cars) but it got me thinking…is it so unusual to only have one car between a couple these days?

OP posts:
RumHoney · 20/09/2021 19:22

We only have one. We live in a city and both used to cycle to work so it only got used at weekends when we tend to go out together. There is also public transport into the city centre.

I've since got a new job which is more rural/further away and I drive there a couple of days a week (others are a mix of WFH and cycling) but he doesn't really need the car while I'm out so we're still fine with one.

RobinPenguins · 20/09/2021 19:20

We have one and manage fine. We can walk 25 mins to post office, doctor, dentist, shops, cafes and train station and 5 mins walk to bus stop. We do a combination of walking, public transport and car.

Most families could manage perfectly fine with one car, they just don’t want to. My in laws are horrified at the idea of walking 15-20 minutes to the shops, or taking a bus.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 20/09/2021 19:20

Blimey, she must have had a sheltered life if she is shocked by a couple having one car!
We have always had 2, but to be fair could manage with one now, but that's pretty recent.

han2020 · 20/09/2021 19:19

It’s perfectly okay to have as few or as many cars as you need/want/can afford. We’d only had one car for years and only bought our other, bigger car this year because we’re expecting twins imminently. We were going to sell our other car originally, but then realised that my little old Picanto was probably worth more to us as a second car than the rather pitiful amount we would have been able to sell it for.

TellerTuesday · 20/09/2021 19:18

We have two cars but in the same scenario as you've described wouldn't make an ounce of difference as DH would be at work with it.

ClareBlue · 20/09/2021 19:16

@ShanghaiDiva

We have one and manage fine. We can walk 25 mins to post office, doctor, dentist, shops, cafes and train station and 5 mins walk to bus stop. We do a combination of walking, public transport and car.
And this is surely the model we should be embracing. We live rural and do this. Teenage children, two full time working, lots of community involvement and have never had more than one car. Sharing lifts, bus (2 a day in our area), taxi if essential, community give each other children lifts home (no probs going out of your way if it is your turn), even staying over after late nights out, organized mini buses for local matches, train from nearest town (13 miles), on call for each other if need a car quickly and car being used (very very rare to really need a car), all have bikes, lift WhatsApp group, etc etc It takes more organizing but at what stage does it become a priority to do this against the convenience of having dedicated personal transport. The vast majority of people in this planet do not have their own personal transport yet in rich societies we see it as a necessity whilst we destroy the planet to ensure we don't have to wait for a bus.
worrybutterfly · 20/09/2021 19:15

We only have 1 car, but most couples I know have at least 2.

It's an issues maybe 2-3 times a year, which is not enough to justify the extra cost of another car. Worst case scenario one of us uses a hire care or gets taxi.

Once the DC are a bit older and have different clubs, parties, etc on the weekends I may become an issue.

Lincslady53 · 20/09/2021 19:15

We cut back to one car 20 years ago when both kids had left home. We have also gone for a small engined, fuel efficient car that gets 60 to the gallon. It has been awkward maybe 3 or 4 times in 20 years. We try to use it as little as possible as our but to help towards reducing our carbon footprint, but when we read of billionaires going onto space just because they can. Or that bloody train that ran empty from London to Glasgow to try to win a speed record, and using over 3,000 gallons of diesel in the attempt, I do wonder why we bother.

drpaddington · 20/09/2021 19:13

We only have one but OH does have a van through work, which he can use outside of work if needed. If his van had to be left at work each day we would need two cars, as neither of us work within reasonable working distance. Actually OH would probably get a motorbike.

CraftyGin · 20/09/2021 19:12

When one of our cars goes, we won't be replacing it. I am happy to bus/uber, or even walk.

KnobblyWand · 20/09/2021 19:11

We don't drive and have three children and two jobs between us. We'd probably blow her mind.

BoreiPuriHagafen · 20/09/2021 19:10

@MatildaIThink

I don't know any couples (apart from the odd ones who do not drive) who live outside of Central London who do not have two cars as pretty much everywhere else public transport is awful.
We don't have any cars and it's not because we can't drive. We do not live in central London.
TheGrumpyGoat · 20/09/2021 19:09

@MatildaIThink

I don't know any couples (apart from the odd ones who do not drive) who live outside of Central London who do not have two cars as pretty much everywhere else public transport is awful.
We both drive, live a long way from London and only have one car because the public transport is good 🤷🏻‍♀️
BoreiPuriHagafen · 20/09/2021 19:09

We have zero cars. Luckily we are all able-bodied and public transport exists.

SciFiScream · 20/09/2021 19:08

We only have one car. Not unusual here. I know lots of families that only have one car.

We could do with a second car once a week but are resisting as long as possible because even on a busy day the car is parked/stationary for 22 hours a day!

What a waste eh? It's either parked at home or parked at work.

Catra · 20/09/2021 19:07

We don't have any cars car - we can get to everywhere essential on foot or by public transport so can't justify the expense. Occasionally we'll hire a car for a few days if we want to go somewhere further afield.

ClareBlue · 20/09/2021 19:02

@MatildaIThink

I don't know any couples (apart from the odd ones who do not drive) who live outside of Central London who do not have two cars as pretty much everywhere else public transport is awful.
This is just not true. Public transport is not aweful outside central London. You might have to organize your travel and maybe sometimes wait and be inconvenienced, but you can move between all centers of population in England by public transport. There are very few population settlements of over 1000 people you can not connect to using public transport and people continually saying it is aweful is part of the problem.
ClareBlue · 20/09/2021 18:57

Personal transport is a privaledge of rich societies that is destroying the planet, so it should be weird that people think households should even have more that one car, if even that. What is weird is how much we except climate disasters across the world to make sure we don't have to be inconvenienced by sharing transport systems or organizing our days and prioritising our options to reduce our impacts.
Everyone always has valid reasons why it shouldn't be them, why their time is so important not to use public transport, why they have the job that needs personal transport, etc etc.
How many households actually need two cars or is it just not convenient to not have them.
The answer to your question is it is not weird and hopefully one day soon the exact opposite will be the case

dworky · 20/09/2021 18:47

Wait till she finds out some people manage without any cars, particularly in cities.

ShanghaiDiva · 20/09/2021 18:44

We have one and manage fine. We can walk 25 mins to post office, doctor, dentist, shops, cafes and train station and 5 mins walk to bus stop. We do a combination of walking, public transport and car.

MatildaIThink · 20/09/2021 18:42

@PhoboPhobia

I wonder what she’d think of my adult DD who has no intention of learning to drive?!
Most people tend to think of that as a bit odd. Someone might not need to drive now, but it will almost certainly be useful qt some point, at least for the next 10-20 years until fully driverless cars are implemented.
Theriband · 20/09/2021 18:42

She's a twat. Give her an uppercut next time you see her.

elbea · 20/09/2021 18:42

If you lived in a city I can’t see it would matter. I’ve lived very rurally (i.e 25 minute drive to the nearest shop, mile long dirt track drive), I’d be completely marooned without a car.

Minionbums · 20/09/2021 18:41

We’ve got one car, for money and environmental reasons. But we also have access to my FIL’s car and borrow that when we need 2 cars, which is happening more often now. But I’d do anything to avoid buying a second. I can think of plenty of things I’d rather spend the money on. But to echo a PP - it’s a status thing for a lot of people, and that isn’t my thing really.

MatildaIThink · 20/09/2021 18:40

I don't know any couples (apart from the odd ones who do not drive) who live outside of Central London who do not have two cars as pretty much everywhere else public transport is awful.