Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not *that* weird to only have one car?

184 replies

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 20/09/2021 17:21

At lunchtime today I was chatting to a colleague who asked if I was going to an (optional) event in the office on Wednesday. For context, we’re currently hybrid working, 2 office days/3 WFH days each week and as one of the managers (albeit not too high up the seniority tree) I get to manage which days are which myself, with sensitivity to the needs of the business of course.

I said I would have quite liked to have been there but my car is booked in for a repair on Wednesday so I’ve had to make it a WFH day. She immediately said “can you not just use your husband’s car that day?” I said we only have one car and she said “oh” and looked quite nonplussed, as if I’d suddenly started speaking in tongues, and there was a long pause where it looked like she genuinely didn’t know how to respond to my shocking revelation Grin I asked her if she was going and the conversation moved on, so I thought. But then as she was about to go back to her desk she hesitated, and then said “so what does your husband do if he needs to go somewhere while you’re at work?” so it was obviously playing on her mind. I just said, we manage (as it happens he’s disabled so no longer drives but she doesn’t need to know the ins and outs of his medical history, and even if he were still driving we couldn’t afford to run two cars) but it got me thinking…is it so unusual to only have one car between a couple these days?

OP posts:
MacSmirving · 20/09/2021 20:53

We live rurally and have managed quite well for years with just one car. Admittedly we're not very outgoing, so probably easier for us than it would be for others

I'm really hoping, with more people working from home, that more households will be able to move to having only one car.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 20/09/2021 20:49

I think it all depends on where you live and where you work.

When I read about the wonderful peace and quiet of living in the country, but then the average family needs at least 2 cars to even function it fills me with horror.

NotImpossible · 20/09/2021 20:48

One here. But neither of us use it loads - everything local is walkable - so it's fine. We do need the one though as public transport isn't great and family members live rurally.

jessnoah · 20/09/2021 20:46

We don't have one, my MIL lives a five minute walk away and we just borrow hers from time to time and give her about £80 a month towards it. I work from home and my husband does too but occasionally goes in on the train, kids' nursery and town/aldi/parks/river is all walkable for us

ISeeTheLight · 20/09/2021 20:45

We have one car and most of our friend couples only have one car - bar one pair but the husband has a company car.
Various reasons - some medical (2 friends with epilepsy), one of my friends has a license but hates to drive, my DP can't drive (although he's promised he's finally going to learn).
We both work from home permanently (since pre covid); before that we worked in central London so no need for a car.

mommybear1 · 20/09/2021 20:42

We have always had two cars but with lockdown DH's work has now been completely made WFH so we got rid of his car. It's only been a few weeks for us but makes massive financial sense. We have had some very odd reactions from family members etc who seem to think it's very odd Grin.

PeonyTime · 20/09/2021 20:40

No, its not weird if it works for you.
However, I've just looked up the public transport route to get to work. It starts off with "drive a car 8 minutes"....

KingdomScrolls · 20/09/2021 20:38

We only had one for any six months this year, DHs needed more money spent on it than we were willing to so we sold it and the second hand car market was a bit ridiculous. He cycles to work so that was ok, but there were a number of occasions it made logistics around DS difficult

CosmicComfort · 20/09/2021 20:37

We are a one car family, always have been.

DH used to use the train to work, now WFH. Never been an issue and we have never wanted the additional cost.

We are unusual in our street and within our family as well. We plant to get a camper van next year when DH retires, I guess we will be 2 vehicles then!

Freetodowhatiwant · 20/09/2021 20:37

No car here! I love having no car. I choose to live centrally and love walking. Will take a cab if I need to.

Cakecrumbsinmybra · 20/09/2021 20:36

@Hopdathelf
I had no idea I've been using nonplussed incorrectly!

TheRebelle · 20/09/2021 20:36

A friend and her DH only have one VERY expensive car between them but actually they need two and they’re forever have to inconvenience themselves and others (including me) because of it. I’m sure it’s because she wanted to have the “status car” and looks down on me and DH for having two cheaper cars but actually I don’t think it’s that impressive when you have to beg me for a lift because your DH has been called into work at the last minute and taken the car.

monkeysox · 20/09/2021 20:35

I think it depends on where you live and work. Not possible for us to use trains for work as childcare does not open early enough so have a car each.
40 min drive vs 2 hours of trains

EdgeOfTheSky · 20/09/2021 20:34

In my road, and family, each household has one, or none. And more and more people are getting rid.

It is London, though.

DeepaBeesKit · 20/09/2021 20:34

It depends where you live.DH and I live rurally where there are few facilities and no public transport to speak of.

If we didnt have a car each it would eliminate (for example) being able the kids to swimming & tennis lessons, me going to the shops/doctors/anywhere when DH is at work.

grafittiartist · 20/09/2021 20:32

One car here- and people do think it's a bit odd. As if it's a hardship rather than a choice.

BiddyPop · 20/09/2021 20:30

Sorry, I meant to say that my car did those things, DH's car sat at home all week even when he was here, and just shared the weekend trips on his few weekends at home (although that did tend to be the one doing the long trips "home" most of the time).

EvilRingahBitch · 20/09/2021 20:28

I don't drive myself but I wouldn't necessarily have a go at your colleague. Assuming that your workplace is only really accessible by car, it would be a natural human response for her to project the "doesn't that leave her DH stranded at home?" which would be appropriate to her own circumstances. A failure of imagination, but a common one.

BiddyPop · 20/09/2021 20:28

DH and I shared a car from the time we got married (he added me to the insurance on his) until DD was 3 months old (almost 6 years later). We then dropped 1 car when he was working away 50% of the time (6 years later) and even when he was back 100%, didn't go back to 2 cars for another couple of years. We only got the 2nd one again at that stage as DFIL got cancer and DH needed to spend a lot of time with ILs 2.5 hours away, while DD and I needed one here for daily use and to go up and down to ILs at weekends.

When we had only 1 car in the middle part of that, for about 6 years, we had some juggling to do about who had it certain times. But we were using public transport, cycling and walking as well so mostly it was fine. Occasionally, I would get a call that I needed to get home to collect a sick DD from school - which meant a taxi to get there in reasonable time. We also agreed that taxis on occasion were necessary, and that there may well be times when we would need to rent a car for a weekend or few days on occasion (there is a rental place near enough to us) - so perfectly do-able.

Yes, you get used to the convenience of always having your own vehicle (or DH's if he has "borrowed" mine) outside the door.

But when there is decent public transport and other options available, you get used to it very quickly. You share the car more often for journeys, and consolidate your journeys (so do 4 jobs at once rather than 4 separate outings). It is cheaper, even with public transport and some taxis and rentals included.

I know lots of people thought we were daft dropping 1 at the time - but DH was literally away from Sunday morning 1 weekend to Saturday afternoon 2 weeks later, commuted by bike to the office when he was here (2 weeks), so the car mainly drove me to the train station locally (for the commuter train), home again via school (to collect DD from afterschool), and doing the weekly shopping and going to weekend clubs, with a trip to DPs/DPILs (2.5 hours away) about once every 2 months (on the 1 weekend/month that DH was home for the whole weekend).

PartyPotato · 20/09/2021 20:27

Been with DH 7 years and we only had one car until last year.

Betsyboo87 · 20/09/2021 20:24

We didn’t have a car for a few years but bought one last year that we share. We live in a city with great public transport and so mainly only use it at weekends. We definitely don’t need two.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 20/09/2021 20:22

We also only have one car now too as we now work in the same town so drive in together. The odd times we would have benefitted from having a second car are not worth the extra expense. It also helps we also live near a very convenient train lindz

DroopyClematis · 20/09/2021 20:20

We've only had one car for about twenty years, even with very young children.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 20/09/2021 20:20

We have one. Until recently we had none. We’ve never had an issue.

MrsMariaReynolds · 20/09/2021 20:19

We're a car-less family, which really gets a lot of 🤔 from people.