Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Partner violent when sugars are low.

390 replies

Badlytornfrube · 20/09/2021 16:19

My good friend has recently had a baby with her partner. He is a type 1 diabetic and has had trouble stabilising his sugars since a recent injury.

He has very verbally aggressive and has pushed her. Two weeks ago he bit her on the arm. Each time he has blamed it on a sugar low and has gone to the GP to ask for help with this. My friend thinks this is not a reason to leave and not his fault because of the sugars. He has never been violent towards his kids from a previous relationship or the new baby.

I think the blood sugar excuse is bollocks and she should run for the hills. The fact he has never hurt the kids proves he can control himself. She is financially fine and has a flat to go to.
Has anyone had any experience of low sugar causing violence? Is he responsible? Should she leave?

YABU not his fault
YANBU she should leave

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 21/09/2021 12:15

Does it really need to be spelt out that if a man pushes or bites a woman with a baby in her arms, harm could result to the baby.

Sirzy · 21/09/2021 12:14

From the Ops post it seems to violence is coming when his wife is trying to help him during a hypo, and others experiences would suggest that is a likely case too. In that case thankfully it doesn’t sound like it poses a massive risk to the baby just to those who are trying to help him at the time.

Hopefully he and his wife can get the support they need to resolve the problem

TatianaBis · 21/09/2021 12:14

It's also about a man who has taken all the steps possible to ensure this doesn't happen again.

Except that it’s not necessarily that easy to control and so he can’t guarantee it won’t happen again.

Porcupineintherough · 21/09/2021 12:11

Well this is a lovely thread. Such big opinions, so little knowledge.

TintinIsBack · 21/09/2021 11:58

@TatianaBis

Curzon - this thread isn’t about you and your DH. It’s about a man who’s lashing out in a house with a small baby.

A small baby has protected status as much as a disability and the scant regard for the safety of the baby in your post is strange.

If a reaction to a hypo involves behaviour that could endanger a baby then the partner must consider the baby’s safety. Full stop.

It's also about a man who has taken all the steps possible to ensure this doesn't happen again.

A man who never had that sort of reaction before and has a known medical condition that can be made stable again.

What you are saying is that, that man, who is doing all the right things and is in an unusual situation for him shouldn't be allowed to be with his dc or his dw.
Despite the fact his dw is happy with the way things are handled.....

Hmm
TooBigForMyBoots · 21/09/2021 11:54

Some people really get annoyed when their ignorance is exposed.🙄

Oblomov21 · 21/09/2021 11:52

Where was the OP statement that baby was in danger?

Oblomov21 · 21/09/2021 11:49

We are not asking for it to be pulled. We've reported it asking for MNHQ to comment on the thread.

TatianaBis · 21/09/2021 11:46

[quote Cadent]@CurzonDax doesn’t sound like you’ve attacked your husband though.

A pp says ‘they’re not rational, they’re not in a state of control, they absolutely cannot think and act with purpose’. What happens if he kills her next time?

Should we just say the marriage vows say till death do us part?[/quote]
Quite. When he has a small baby.

Marriage vows are irrelevant not least as the couple may not be married.

Cadent · 21/09/2021 11:44

@CurzonDax doesn’t sound like you’ve attacked your husband though.

A pp says ‘they’re not rational, they’re not in a state of control, they absolutely cannot think and act with purpose’. What happens if he kills her next time?

Should we just say the marriage vows say till death do us part?

TatianaBis · 21/09/2021 11:42

Curzon - this thread isn’t about you and your DH. It’s about a man who’s lashing out in a house with a small baby.

A small baby has protected status as much as a disability and the scant regard for the safety of the baby in your post is strange.

If a reaction to a hypo involves behaviour that could endanger a baby then the partner must consider the baby’s safety. Full stop.

CurzonDax · 21/09/2021 11:37

@Cadent

What are people reporting the thread going to achieve?

At the end of the day, a woman is getting pushed around and bitten by her partner. It’s irrelevant why he does it, she should be safe in her own home and posters are free to say she should dump him.

No one is owed a relationship.

Whilst I agree that her partner needs help, and it sounds like he has taken the steps to get it - seeing his GP, been given technology to help notify him when he goes low. The reason why he acted in this way is VERY relevant.

What would you say to someone who said, 'My partner's wheelchair is taking up space in my hallway, should I dump him? I need the space for a coat stand/a pushchair."

As has already been mentioned T1 diabetes is a chronic illness, and therefore is protected under discrimination laws. So yes, in the eyes of the law, the reason is very relevant.

Fortunately for me, my husband takes his marriage vows seriously, and promised to love me in sickness and in health. He is understanding of my diabetes, and that it comes as part if the deal with being with me. He will openly admit that sometimes he finds it hard - I've seen him in tears as he has had to give me an emergency glucagon jab and call out paramedics - the thought of knowing that I could die at any time, without intervention, or suffer long term illness as a result of my diabetes, is something that we have to accept on a daily basis. My specialist asked me what I worried about the most - this was just after my husband and I got engaged, I said, "I'm afraid of leaving him a widow in a few years."

He might not owe me a relationship, but he definitely loves and supports me. Seems like the OP's friend also does her own partner.

Badlytornfrube · 21/09/2021 11:23

@Oblomov21 @TSSDNCOP it would be a real shame to have this thread pulled. I have found it really helpful. I was very ignorant about T1 and the advice on here has been invaluable.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 21/09/2021 10:55

It actually can be a side effect of low sugars. It's not necessarily bollocks. What's his sugars after these episodes?

Cadent · 21/09/2021 10:49

What are people reporting the thread going to achieve?

At the end of the day, a woman is getting pushed around and bitten by her partner. It’s irrelevant why he does it, she should be safe in her own home and posters are free to say she should dump him.

No one is owed a relationship.

Oblomov21 · 21/09/2021 10:44

I too have reported to MNHQ.

TSSDNCOP · 21/09/2021 10:26

I reported this thread to MNHQ at 8pm last night. I'm surprised and disappointed they have not at least posted to remind posters that T1 Diabetes is a disability many MN members and their family and children suffer from.

Ninkanink · 21/09/2021 10:11

That is a different discussion entirely.

It’s simply not true that it’s ‘bollocks’ (which OP has already acknowledged, to her credit), nor that it’s ‘abusive’, nor that there’s anything he can do to just control it.

Of course I understand OPs initial concern and her lack of understanding wasn’t her fault. But her friend has already said that she doesn’t blame him, that it’s due to unstable glucose control and hypos. She capable of understanding his condition and can make that decision. This is what life is like at times for family and partners of diabetics who take insulin.

If it becomes too much for her then perhaps it will be necessary for them to address living arrangements. But OP’s opening premise was wholly inaccurate from a medical perspective and many comments on the thread show a staggering lack of understanding. That is what I’m addressing.

timeisnotaline · 21/09/2021 10:01

@Ninkanink

And just to make it really, really clear to people:

When an individual is having a severe hypo their whole system is in the process of completely shutting down. As pp has said, the brain is in mortal danger. If there is no intervention, THEY WILL DIE. So no, they’re not rational, they’re not in a state of control, they absolutely cannot think and act with purpose.

I personally know two people whose loved one died from an accidental overdose of insulin. My daughter could one day fall into a coma and die simply from taking the meds that keep her alive.

It is no joke, and no, it is not easy nor straightforward for every individual to monitor/control it.

A relative of mine died from it too, early 30s. I do understand it’s hard to control even after having managed it all your life. However this doesn’t mean the outcome here is that the op has to feel unsafe in her home with her partner the threat, while she’s looking after a tiny baby. That is unacceptable, whatever the justifiable reason. Posters say the op is being targeted because she’s the one telling him his glucose levels are out. I still think he needs to go somewhere else and have someone else be this person for him for a while, it shouldn’t be someone vulnerable and a woman and new mum is.
FirewomanSam · 21/09/2021 09:32

It’s very worrying and I’m glad you are looking out for your friend but it is technically possible that his blood sugar is playing a part here. Definitely doesn’t make it OK though and it’s up to him to get this under control immediately.

I said this earlier and I’d like to apologise because this was insensitively worded. I was sympathetic and understood that hypos can cause aggression but I hadn’t fully understood the realities of living with this. I now completely appreciate that getting it ‘under control’ is far easier said than done. He’s remorseful and he’s gone to his GP for help which is the most he can do right now.

I’m so sorry to everyone who has found this thread so upsetting and I hope one positive is that many people have been educated about the realities of living with T1 through reading it.

Lavender24 · 21/09/2021 09:19

I've, had type one diabetes for 22 years and hypos can make me irritable not not aggressive.

I agree with the PP who said that even given the benefit of the doubt he needs to leave until this is sorted.

Ninkanink · 21/09/2021 08:58

And just to make it really, really clear to people:

When an individual is having a severe hypo their whole system is in the process of completely shutting down. As pp has said, the brain is in mortal danger. If there is no intervention, THEY WILL DIE. So no, they’re not rational, they’re not in a state of control, they absolutely cannot think and act with purpose.

I personally know two people whose loved one died from an accidental overdose of insulin. My daughter could one day fall into a coma and die simply from taking the meds that keep her alive.

It is no joke, and no, it is not easy nor straightforward for every individual to monitor/control it.

CurzonDax · 21/09/2021 08:44

*room, not toom

CurzonDax · 21/09/2021 08:43

@Oblomov21

Hello Simon. We see eachother from time to time on diabetic threads.

I have found this thread very very upsetting. SadSadSad

I've had T1 since almost birth, and have been on a pump for 20 years. It still doesn't control it. Mine is very brittle, hard to manage. I work at it, try and control it, it's still hard. Invasive. I've had the pump, the sensor, the libre. I'm under the top London hospital and have been pre dc. I've still go low. The more Dh insists I'm low the more I insist I'm not.

The brain is deprived of enough glucose to function properly. Can you imagine how incredibly embarrassing it is, when you recover, and people tell you how you've been? It's humiliating. Degrading.

Walk a mile in my shoes. See how you like it.

This.

I was also just going to post the image that you did. Think the solution is simple, in order to be in 'control' us T1s just need to:

  • Never eat again.
  • Never get stressed, or have any other human emotions
  • Never move
  • Don't have periods each month, or suffer from any hormones full stop.
  • Don't go outside. Ever. Stay in, inside one toom that is able to maintain a constant temperature.
  • Don't get allergies/any other non-diabetic illness - ever. Although, we should be safe from common colds anyway as we only ever stay inside one room.
  • Don't ever interact with other people.

Whilst also having to manually do the job of a vital internal organ. Every single minute, of every single day. Forever.

We got this!

LoislovesStewie · 21/09/2021 08:23

@BreatheAndFocus

*However, there are a few things that are concerning, -he has never hit or bit his children, this is said like he has some control. Does he have control? If he has enough control that his children aren't in danger, then why is it different with his partner? This issue wouldn't really allow for the differentiation to be with him at that moment*

FFS! How many times does it have to be explained? The man is lashing out at his partner because she’s the one trying to intervene and get the glucose into him! Read the bloody thread! If it was a paramedic, a neighbour, a colleague or whoever the man could do the same. It is a primitive, fear response because the brain feels it’s in mortal danger - and it is. It is NOT a conscious thought-process or response, or a choice.

Exactly, my AC would shout 'no! quite clearly and hit my hands when I was trying to get some sugar/glucose into their mouth. It probably looked like I was trying to harm him from his point of view.
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread