Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alex Monroe is ridiculous

114 replies

buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 15:42

I really loved their hidden bee locket but wanted it 50% bigger. (1.5cm tall instead of 1cm)

After several attempts and mis-communications with them going back to April, I finally managed to get a quote from them today! The original is £775, they want between £3500 and £5000!

Is it me, or does anyone else think they've lost the plot? They really don't want to make this necklace for me, do they?

Anyone recommend a similar jeweller who can make something similar at a more reasonable price?

OP posts:
Genegenieee · 20/09/2021 16:23

Really surprised you don't get the difference between buying it in a mass produced size, and one that is made to order in a different size - in gold.

We really need to teach more business skills and commercial thinking in schools

buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 16:22

OK, I accept i am being unreasonable to think it should be cheaper, but I think I can find something much better for that amount of money....

OP posts:
DominicRaabsTravelAgent · 20/09/2021 16:20

I think you're doing a great job of advertising Alex Monroe's jewellery OP. Bet most people who've read your thread have had a look at their website today Smile

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 20/09/2021 16:20

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

Say your standard cake is circular, 6cm deep and 20cm in diameter. The total volume of the cake would be 1885cm³. Someone asks for a cake that's 50% bigger — 30cm in diameter. The total volume of that cake would be 4241cm³. It's 2¼ times the volume of the smaller cake. If you'd only charged 50% extra for ingredients you'd be out of pocket because you've used 2½ times the quantity, to make a cake that's "only" 50% bigger. When you also take into account the fact that you've had to buy a new, bigger cake tin, put it in the oven longer, spend time working out the new cooking times and troubleshooting any issues that arise because of the change in the properties of the cake you're making, you'll be seriously short-changing yourself by charging only 50% more.
Typo — 2¼, not 2½. Sorry. Not that it makes much difference.
suspiria777 · 20/09/2021 16:19

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

50% bigger doesn't mean 50% more gold. I don't know what shape the piece of jewellery is, but to simplify it I'll pretend it's a sphere, which will overestimate somewhat but perhaps not much. The formula for the volume of a sphere is V = (4/3)πr3, so increasing the diameter of a sphere by 50% increases the volume by 237.5%. So unless I've fucked up the maths somewhere, a sphere of gold that's 50% taller actually has nearly 3½ times as much gold in it.
+

*They might make the standard one 'to order', but they will have a pre-made mould that they use to make each one, with one mould making a large number of pieces. The cost to them of making the standard size are therefoee significantly lower than making a bespoke piece.

A 50% increase in size will require them to make a fresh design and mould etc. that they will only be able to use once.*

These two points have nailed it.
Things you don't know:

How many hours of labour does it take to design a new die (or several, depending on the structure of the piece)?
How much does it /cost/ to make that die? (What is it made from? I know nothing about jewellery but a custom bronze die for making a pasta shape (e.g. conchiglie) would normally be several thousand pounds, and there is currently something of a shortage of bronze worldwide).
Does the new die/dies need to be outsourced (almost certainly)?
What is the lead time? What is the shipping time? What are the import costs?
How much is a skilled jeweller's labour worth?
How much does gold cost?
How much does it cost to reply to your queries and run a website and research the possibility of making a bespoke piece that you're ultimately turning your nose up to?

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 20/09/2021 16:18

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

Not just buy a new cake tin - hand carve it from scratch!
Fair point Grin

OP you're asking for a one-off, custom-made version of a mass-produced product, which contains significantly more of the expensive materials. I'm surprised you're surprised at the price jump.

Cocomarine · 20/09/2021 16:15

[quote buzzoffbee]@gorl, yes I thought that and I wouldn't really want to copy the design- it feels tainted now, what a shame![/quote]
That’s pretty shitty. You don’t want to rip off a designer’s ideas because it’s “tainted” - so because it’s unethical?

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 16:15

Xpost

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 16:14

Not just buy a new cake tin - hand carve it from scratch!

Cocomarine · 20/09/2021 16:14

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!
Well take your example.

If you own an 12oz tin and needed to buy a 10oz tin, and that tin was £20 in Lakeland, you’d possibly add £20 to the quotation.

Now imagine that Lakeland doesn’t make that size tin, in fact nobody does. You’re going to have to make it yourself. It’s going to take you 3 days to do that, 3 days you could have spent on some other income generating work. And the materials are really expensive for it. They were for the 8oz too, but you estimated you could sell 1000 cakes so it was worth it. You think you’ll get a 12oz order again… never.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 20/09/2021 16:13

Say your standard cake is circular, 6cm deep and 20cm in diameter. The total volume of the cake would be 1885cm³. Someone asks for a cake that's 50% bigger — 30cm in diameter. The total volume of that cake would be 4241cm³. It's 2¼ times the volume of the smaller cake. If you'd only charged 50% extra for ingredients you'd be out of pocket because you've used 2½ times the quantity, to make a cake that's "only" 50% bigger. When you also take into account the fact that you've had to buy a new, bigger cake tin, put it in the oven longer, spend time working out the new cooking times and troubleshooting any issues that arise because of the change in the properties of the cake you're making, you'll be seriously short-changing yourself by charging only 50% more.

SusieBob · 20/09/2021 16:12

And also, no reputable jeweller will accept a commision to rip off someone else's work, and it's a dick move to even ask.

OneTC · 20/09/2021 16:12

Well it's similar if you think you're only ever gonna make 1 x 12oz and you need to recover the cost for new tins from that customer

purplecorkheart · 20/09/2021 16:10

I would imagine you are playing for them to create do extra drawings, creating an new mould. The extra gold, taking in the price of gold at the current rate.

ChequerBoard · 20/09/2021 16:10

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!

That's a terrible comparison though. A bigger cake just needs a bigger tin and more ingredients.

Scaling up a necklace requires new moulding and hand carving on the individual elements. If there is a hidden bee for example they have to scale up the bee they can't just photocopy the existing bee 50% larger.

You're not thinking this through.

SusieBob · 20/09/2021 16:10

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!
Yeah, that's not the same thing at all.
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 16:09

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!
Cakes are not a good comparator. You can't make hundreds of cakes using a single mould or pattern. But you can with jewellery.
SusieBob · 20/09/2021 16:08

Depending on how it's made it probably would cost a significant amount to resize an existing design - e.g. if it's cast from a mold they have to design and make an entirely new mold, create test pieces etc all of which takes time and money, and if they can't then use that mold for future works it's just you covering the cost of that + any profit margin.

Or it could be they just don't want the work and have pulled the trick of giving you a ridiculous quote.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 16:08

It's like if a retailer makes a dress in standard sizes 10, 12 & 14 etc.. They will have cut patterns that they use multiple times, whenever a certain size is ordered. So the cost of the time spent making each of those patterns is divided by the large number of sales.

If you say "Actually, I want the same dress, but made to my specific body measurements", the cost of making a new pattern is all attributable to just one dress - yours. So it's going to cost a lot more regardless of how much material is used.

OneTC · 20/09/2021 16:05

Presumably it's cast in some way? So they'd need to make a different mould. Adapting a design to the same specifications would allow them to reuse the existing mould

buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 16:04

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!

OP posts:
chesirecat99 · 20/09/2021 16:04

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

They might make the standard one 'to order', but they will have a pre-made mould that they use to make each one, with one mould making a large number of pieces. The cost to them of making the standard size are therefoee significantly lower than making a bespoke piece.

A 50% increase in size will require them to make a fresh design and mould etc. that they will only be able to use once. It was never going to be just a 50% increase in price, or even just a 100% increase.

This.
ChequerBoard · 20/09/2021 16:04

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

They might make the standard one 'to order', but they will have a pre-made mould that they use to make each one, with one mould making a large number of pieces. The cost to them of making the standard size are therefoee significantly lower than making a bespoke piece.

A 50% increase in size will require them to make a fresh design and mould etc. that they will only be able to use once. It was never going to be just a 50% increase in price, or even just a 100% increase.

Exactly this.

They have told you the price which sounds fair enough given all the work involved to create scaled up moulds etc.

You just don't want to pay what it costs so go and buy something within your means elsewhere.

No need to try and trash someone's reputation because the prices isn't within your budget.

Lockdowndramaqueen · 20/09/2021 16:03

Try Max Danger

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 16:02

They might make the standard one 'to order', but they will have a pre-made mould that they use to make each one, with one mould making a large number of pieces. The cost to them of making the standard size are therefoee significantly lower than making a bespoke piece.

A 50% increase in size will require them to make a fresh design and mould etc. that they will only be able to use once. It was never going to be just a 50% increase in price, or even just a 100% increase.