Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alex Monroe is ridiculous

114 replies

buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 15:42

I really loved their hidden bee locket but wanted it 50% bigger. (1.5cm tall instead of 1cm)

After several attempts and mis-communications with them going back to April, I finally managed to get a quote from them today! The original is £775, they want between £3500 and £5000!

Is it me, or does anyone else think they've lost the plot? They really don't want to make this necklace for me, do they?

Anyone recommend a similar jeweller who can make something similar at a more reasonable price?

OP posts:
TheWoleb · 20/09/2021 18:03

@garlicandsapphires

He's a man.

LemonSwan · 20/09/2021 18:03

Well I very much like their work so thanks for sharing OP.

I have an entirely separate gold jewellery problem in that I cant find anyone who works in 18ct Red Gold.

Not only does it always have to be custom if I want this metal, but I also cannot get plated options.

So count your blessings OP. Count your blessings!!!

EastWestWhosBest · 20/09/2021 18:01

Or just don’t buy anything.

OverTheRubicon · 20/09/2021 18:00

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!
But if you had a customer who wanted a cake in a specific shape that required you to design, cast and create an entirely new cake tin, not only requiring new skills but also time you could have used to create many other cakes, you might well increase it that much.
OneTC · 20/09/2021 17:59

I didn’t know Alex Monroe was female

He isn't

garlicandsapphires · 20/09/2021 17:55

I didn’t know Alex Monroe was female!

WoozySnoozy · 20/09/2021 17:52

@buzzoffbee

I have already accepted IABU!

Please can anyone recommend British Jewellers who are more reasonably priced and work in solid gold not just gold plate?

For example I really like Lily and Roo

Anyone know others which are similar?

That doesn't look particularly unique. It looks nice though.
Abigail12345654321 · 20/09/2021 17:50

@buzzoffbee

I bake cakes- if someone wanted a 12oz cake instead of a standard 8oz cake I wouldn't increase the price from £50 to £325- it doesn't make any sense!
But in both cases you use standard cake tins that you can easily buy cheaply.

With the pendants even if the work is partly by hand I expect they are made using some sort of mould. In which case they would need to pay for the tooling to scale up by 50%. Seems reasonable that would cost a lot.

Henio · 20/09/2021 17:47

Their products are very expensive for what they are in the first place

MichelleScarn · 20/09/2021 17:39

@Lotusmonster

The increase will be more than just the scaled up material and labour cost….you are massively over simplifying it as is the poster who talked about a bigger cake. The locket probably has a mould for the standard size. For your bespoke size they’d have to create and make a new mould. That mould and any other specific tools for the design may only ever be used for you and you alone.
Exactly, would it not be more like you were asked for cake that would be too big for your current oven, so to make it youd need to buy a new one?
Zilla1 · 20/09/2021 17:39

I certainly don't think they are ridiculous for making a commercial decision. I don't think you should ask for a recommendation for a brand name designer maker, OP, rather a trade jeweller, ideally in the Birmingham Jewellery Quarter or Hatton Garden. I could PM a recommendation if you want.

It would depend on the weight of the gold but for such a small pendant that has a hollow-ish design, the gold might be (low) hundreds. There would be one off work for the moulds if cast - I don't know where on the spectrum of manufacturing Alex Monroe is from machine made, 'slave' trade volumehand made in Asia made to hand-made or casting and hand finished in the UK. There would be different ways to make this from either needing probably a mould for each half that could then be cast to using 3d printing for wax to direct cast. If they CAD the original master then it would be straightforward to scale this up.

TheWoleb · 20/09/2021 17:31

It's made to order from a cast. They use a mould and cast it. The molds are already made. The "made to order" part is just the pouring the metal, putting it together and finishing it. Usually for casting, you would have 50 to 100 poured in one go and then you put the pieces together and finish for each order. Its cheaper the more castings you order in one go.

If you want it mar largertthen that requires making a new blank (usually carved from wax) in the correct size, having that wax then turned into a new mould and then casting one piece. A single casting comes with surcharges from the casters.

Your quote is because you're paying for them to carve a new wax blank, paying for a new mould to be created, paying for a single casting and then putting that together. You're also paying a premium for a one of a kind piece which they dont make.

iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 20/09/2021 17:28

People like you are why I stopped doing custom designs in my shop. I got tired of politely explaining what should be really basic concepts to people who thought they could get original work for high street prices.

buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 17:26

Can people not read the thread?

I have accepted I am unreasonable- people don't need to keep repeating the same things that others have already said.

OP posts:
borntobequiet · 20/09/2021 17:24

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

50% bigger doesn't mean 50% more gold. I don't know what shape the piece of jewellery is, but to simplify it I'll pretend it's a sphere, which will overestimate somewhat but perhaps not much. The formula for the volume of a sphere is V = (4/3)πr3, so increasing the diameter of a sphere by 50% increases the volume by 237.5%. So unless I've fucked up the maths somewhere, a sphere of gold that's 50% taller actually has nearly 3½ times as much gold in it.
This
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 20/09/2021 17:18

@Lotusmonster

The increase will be more than just the scaled up material and labour cost….you are massively over simplifying it as is the poster who talked about a bigger cake. The locket probably has a mould for the standard size. For your bespoke size they’d have to create and make a new mould. That mould and any other specific tools for the design may only ever be used for you and you alone.
I realise the increased materials costs are pretty much nugatory when we're talking about custom one-off versions of something already so vastly overpriced. It just bugged me to see someone confidently state that scaling up a piece of jewellery so it's 50% bigger by length will require only 50% more gold. It's the mathematical equivalent of confidently stating that the plural of sheep is sheepses.
buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 17:15

@Jumpjumpjumper

It still looks like it should have "Elizabeth Duke" across the top of the page.
What does?
OP posts:
Jumpjumpjumper · 20/09/2021 17:12

It still looks like it should have "Elizabeth Duke" across the top of the page.

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 20/09/2021 17:12

@buzzoffbee

I have already accepted IABU!

Please can anyone recommend British Jewellers who are more reasonably priced and work in solid gold not just gold plate?

For example I really like Lily and Roo

Anyone know others which are similar?

Dinny Hall does very nice things.
buzzoffbee · 20/09/2021 17:11

www.joyeverley.co.uk/collections/yellow-gold-necklaces This lady seems reasonably priced- I like the oak leaf and acorn!

OP posts:
Lobelian · 20/09/2021 17:08

Stephen Einhorn?

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 20/09/2021 17:08

@buzzoffbee

The necklace is 18ct gold and is made to order anyway, they do a bespoke service and I just want it 50% bigger than their standard offering in this design. Of course I expected it to be more- 50% more gold and scaling up but they are asking for not 50% more cost but a cost increase of around 700%
Do you know how jewelery is made op?

It is not just a question of stretching it.

ThatSunnyCorner · 20/09/2021 17:06

Why not just go to a reputable goldsmith rather than an online shop? That way you can get exactly what you want and it will be unique (as long as it isn't someone else's design!).

Lotusmonster · 20/09/2021 17:05

The increase will be more than just the scaled up material and labour cost….you are massively over simplifying it as is the poster who talked about a bigger cake. The locket probably has a mould for the standard size. For your bespoke size they’d have to create and make a new mould. That mould and any other specific tools for the design may only ever be used for you and you alone.

LynetteScavo · 20/09/2021 17:03

I'm glad you've agreed you are BU.

Because I really think you are Grin