Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appropriate punishment?

234 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 14:14

Caught my 7 year old last night up watching her iPad at gone 11. She had snuck downstairs and got it out of the cabinet and took it upstairs to her bedroom. This, ontop of losing her camera she got for a birthday a month ago and not being remotely remourseful about it plus her attitude in general at the minute, we’ve decided no more screen time for the next week until her bedroom has been tidied and her camera has been found. It’s definitely in there somewhere, it hasnt left the house.

She just seems to have no respect for her stuff at all. We told her if she carries on like this then we won’t bother getTing her anything nice for Christmas as she will just lose it. She just shrugged and said ok.

She never used to be like this! We’ve said from now on she can go to bed and it’s lights straight off until she can show us sue can behave. Is this effective for her age?

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 20/09/2021 16:07

Jesus, sneaking a biscuit is hardly a the type of thing to label a kid deceitful. Don't you ever wander in to the kitchen and fancy a biscuit? They aren't rustling through your handbag to feed a drug habit.

GinIronic · 20/09/2021 16:06

Poor kid. Punishment. Punishment.

Glittertwins · 20/09/2021 16:05

Password protect the iPad so even if she does get it, she can't use it.

girlmom21 · 20/09/2021 16:05

@SheABitSpicyToday

She can earn it back by finding her camera and she’s agreed to that.
She'll conveniently find that pretty quickly.
Gonnagetgoing · 20/09/2021 16:05

@Lweji

At 7 & 9, my two decided to delete my parental controls app on my phone as they blamed it for limiting their tech time.

I would be quite impressed. (but not let them know)

Impressive of the kids!
Gonnagetgoing · 20/09/2021 16:04

@Lweji

She knows this is naughty and she should be sleeping.

Does she?
She probably woke up, or couldn't sleep and simply wanted to watch it. Or she wanted to watch the next episode of a series.

Naughty would be kicking a dog for no reason, for example.
She was just being a young child. As others suggested, I'd prefer to talk to her about why she should not be awake at that time, and find other strategies to get to sleep.

With DS I used to tell him a story about myself, or a boy surprisingly similar to him, to show the consequences of whatever action. For a first time, I'd let him know what would happen next time.

I don’t think she’s broken the camera because she was trying to find it to take to my dads at the weekend but couldn’t find it.

That was her punishment, then. You won't give her a new camera, which is a natural consequence. She needs to find it. And she needs to place it where she can find it next time.

Personally at age 7 I do think she knows she's being naughty sneaking downstairs to find and watch the iPad etc and she must know how late it was because it means she is not sleeping when she should be!

Yes, other strategies to help her get to sleep would be useful though. Yes good idea re story re consequences and letting her know what will happen next time this happens.

itsgettingwierd · 20/09/2021 16:02

I don't think it's harsh removing for a week.

She deliberately did something she knew she couldn't and it's a natural consequence that if you can't stop using something at the right time you need time off it to break that "need".

I do wonder though if the attitude change could be hormones? Girls start puberty at this age in some cases and it can cause some quite confrontational and don't careish outbursts.

The important thing is not to let her see her behaviour is bothering you so she gets no reward for it. Be non chalent and make breaking the rules boring for her!

cherrytreecottage · 20/09/2021 15:58

@BasementIdeas

Has no one read the OP? Why are you all so fixated on the camera?

A 7 year old sneaked and iPad out of the cabinet and was playing on it well after bedtime. No screen time for a week is definitely appropriate

Agree!
Lweji · 20/09/2021 15:57

At 7 & 9, my two decided to delete my parental controls app on my phone as they blamed it for limiting their tech time.

I would be quite impressed. (but not let them know)

BogRollBOGOF · 20/09/2021 15:55

At 7 & 9, my two decided to delete my parental controls app on my phone as they blamed it for limiting their tech time.
They were rumbled pretty quickly as I also use it to extend their time Grin

They were banned from tech for a week with a caveat (for every one's sanity, especially as it was summer 2020) that they could earn a modest tech allowence by doing chores.

They knew they were wrong and after an initial upset at being found out, took the consequences in good grace.

I wouldn't make a thing about Christmas presents, but if she isn't looking after expensive items and is exceeding reasonable boundaries, then it is reasonable to consider what presents are appropriate.

Atalune · 20/09/2021 15:53

Sneaking is bad whether it was an iPad or a biscuit. It’s deceitful!

Punishment seems tough compared to the crime- so 2 days on NO screen time with new limits and codes in place going forward.

I know yoy DONT want a lecture on screen limits and so on. But she is still quite little to have so many techs gadgets and with your lack of knowledge and expertise around setting limits, family link and so on. Perhaps it is time to reassess all round?

Lweji · 20/09/2021 15:53

Blimey the attitudes on punishment on this thread is why there are so many naughty kids at my dcs school!

My DS is definitely not naughty (not a word I'd use anyway) with anyone, and he was given appropriate punishments when necessary. He has also always known that I follow through when I threaten anything. My nephews know too.
But I don't over do punishments, nor threaten things in a distant time, nor threaten things that I don't intend to do.

OP's attitude is more likely to produce said naughty kids, IMO.

Goldbar · 20/09/2021 15:52

OP, I think you need to be clear about what you want from her. She sounds quite strong-willed (and that's not necessarily a bad thing!) so you need to give her a way to climb down gracefully without feeling like she's conceding defeat in a battle between you and her. As the adult, I'm afraid you're going to have to make the first move on this as it's too much to expect from her.

Bebabelouba · 20/09/2021 15:51

Lots of change at yours then OP with a new baby on the way Flowers
Has Dd just started a new school? Just asking as local to me children move to upper primary or junior school.

I wonder if any of that counts for a change in her, if she sees herself as being older?
It will be nice if she can find her camera for baby pics etc.

I personally wouldn't sweat the consequence too much. A night or two of lights out straight away would give her a chance to catch up on sleep. If you think she will go to sleep.
I wouldn't worry too much though. It's not the most heinous crime Smile.

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 15:50

She can earn it back by finding her camera and she’s agreed to that.

OP posts:
Coulddowithanap · 20/09/2021 15:49

We would say no tablet for a week (hide it away somewhere) then give her the chance to earn it back with good behaviour.

Lweji · 20/09/2021 15:49

She knows this is naughty and she should be sleeping.

Does she?
She probably woke up, or couldn't sleep and simply wanted to watch it. Or she wanted to watch the next episode of a series.

Naughty would be kicking a dog for no reason, for example.
She was just being a young child. As others suggested, I'd prefer to talk to her about why she should not be awake at that time, and find other strategies to get to sleep.

With DS I used to tell him a story about myself, or a boy surprisingly similar to him, to show the consequences of whatever action. For a first time, I'd let him know what would happen next time.

I don’t think she’s broken the camera because she was trying to find it to take to my dads at the weekend but couldn’t find it.

That was her punishment, then. You won't give her a new camera, which is a natural consequence. She needs to find it. And she needs to place it where she can find it next time.

BlueMoons90 · 20/09/2021 15:48

Have you asked her why she got up and got her iPad instead of going to sleep? I always try and ask my DC why they did something so I can understand their actions more. E.g. DS who is 3, bit his DB the other day. I asked why and he explained (as well as a 3 year old can).

I think a week without an iPad is excessive, I would probably just say until Friday.

ProcrastinationIsMySuperPower · 20/09/2021 15:48

I'd limit screen time for a few days in these circumstances.

We use the Family Link app which sets screen time limits, and we set a bedtime after which she can't use her devices, which negates this issue entirely - I'm not certain, but guessing there must be a similar app available for Apple devices?

Driftingblue · 20/09/2021 15:48

Taking away Christmas is never an appropriate punishment.

Neither is lights out. Bedtime reading time only gets lost if it has simply gotten too late and will interfere with sleep.

Totally fine to remove screen time during the day. It’s basically the go-to modern punishment.

But also don’t set your kids up to fail. Use parental controls and block them out of devices during inappropriate hours. Even adults have trouble resisting picking them up when we shouldn’t. Every electronic device, like the camera, should have an assigned spot in the house and a time once a day that it must be in that spot. . You have to teach some kids to take care of their things, it doesn’t come naturally for all.

Our check-in is part of the now unsupervised bedtime routine, though occasionally devices can be taken back out now that DD is older and she has earned some trust and some later evening use of certain things. It took several years for us to get to the point where we could
trust her to say, “mom i need an extra hour of internet time because I feel like drawing before bed and want to look up examples” and be able to trust that she would shut everything off on time and put it away properly and charging.

LST · 20/09/2021 15:44

No idea where the angry faces have come from. I didn't add those!

LST · 20/09/2021 15:43

@fallfallfall

You sound so angry and your adding and adding reasons why you should be punishing her and more. Getting and sneaking an iPad is not a big deal, just make sure it’s tucked away higher/more discretely. And what a conscientious little one to use headphones, that’s a very kind gesture.
The head phones were blatantly so she wasn't clocked not doing as she was told

Blimey the attitudes on punishment on this thread is why there are so many naughty kids at my dcs school!

DameAlyson · 20/09/2021 15:43

Also I remember at that age I loved reading, still do. I used to read under the bed covers with a torch. Don't think I ever got caught either!

I did. The punishment was the book being taken away. Since it was a library book, that meant I didn't get to finish it until I was able to take it out of the library again. It was a Famous Five, as I recall.

Obviously I was annoyed at not being able to finish the book, but I knew I shouldn't have been reading at that time, in a poor light, and I didn't think it was unfair. I didn't, as pp have suggested, 'learn to fear'.

WildFlowerBees · 20/09/2021 15:42

When you've spent good money on something you expect it to be kept nicely and not to be lost so I can see why op is irritated that she can't find it, it makes you not want to buy them anything nice again. At 7 she should know that belongings need to be looked after.

fallfallfall · 20/09/2021 15:41

You sound so angry and your adding and adding reasons why you should be punishing her and more.
Getting and sneaking an iPad is not a big deal, just make sure it’s tucked away higher/more discretely.
And what a conscientious little one to use headphones, that’s a very kind gesture.

Swipe left for the next trending thread