Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appropriate punishment?

234 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 14:14

Caught my 7 year old last night up watching her iPad at gone 11. She had snuck downstairs and got it out of the cabinet and took it upstairs to her bedroom. This, ontop of losing her camera she got for a birthday a month ago and not being remotely remourseful about it plus her attitude in general at the minute, we’ve decided no more screen time for the next week until her bedroom has been tidied and her camera has been found. It’s definitely in there somewhere, it hasnt left the house.

She just seems to have no respect for her stuff at all. We told her if she carries on like this then we won’t bother getTing her anything nice for Christmas as she will just lose it. She just shrugged and said ok.

She never used to be like this! We’ve said from now on she can go to bed and it’s lights straight off until she can show us sue can behave. Is this effective for her age?

OP posts:
SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 17:21

@QforCucumber I went to bed the same time as she did as I’m 32 weeks pregnant and exhausted and ill. My husband heard her giggling when he got home from work and found her on the iPad.

OP posts:
HitMeWithYourRhythmicPrick · 20/09/2021 17:06

@ProfSprout is spot on with behaviour is communication

HitMeWithYourRhythmicPrick · 20/09/2021 17:03

OP, you sound very wound up about this. I can see why - but you're in for a very, very bumpy ride when your daughter as a teenager if you are already going down this route with her when she's 7.

Explain why you are cross/disappointed, and explain the consequence. Then don't bang on about it or start ramping up the consequences when your daughter professes not to care. Just follow through, and move on.

On a slightly different note, she does sound a bit spoilt (having to sort out her bedroom before her birthday to make room for the new stuff coming her way? Really?) It will be a big leap for her to go from being a rather spoilt only child for seven years to being a 'big sister'. Could some of her behaviour be related to this? And what's the context? Is the baby a full sibling or a half sibling? These things can all have an effect on children's behaviour.

The camera will turn up somewhere in the house, in a weird place. I would leave it at that, and change the password on her ipad. She shouldn't have unrestricted access to it anyway.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 20/09/2021 16:58

She's 7. 7 year olds don't have a huge sense of what's expensive or valuable to adults. If the camera is so important to you then there should be a special place for it and she should always put it back in that special place, and until it becomes a habit you'll need to check that it gets put there after she uses it. But really you need to ask yourself, is it her toy or yours? And think about whether she wouldn't really prefer cheaper presents that aren't such a source of contention.

I can't imagine leaving a 7 year old to tody their own bedroom once it gets in a state. If you want it tidied then get a cup of tea and sit there with her while she goes through it and puts things away, and talk to her about where things go. Having your attention and company is a huge motivator to do something.

"Stuff" is probably a lot less valuable to her than your time and attention. And that's how it should be.

She never used to be like this! We’ve said from now on she can go to bed and it’s lights straight off until she can show us sue can behave. Is this effective for her age?

No, it's not effective for any age. Apart from the things other poeple have said, it's too vague. You know what "show us you can behave" and "carry on like this" means to you, but she doesn't. You know what "attitude" is, she doesn't. Instead you need to plan specific consequences for specific bits of good and bad behaviour, small rewards that she can earn easilty along with praise and compliments for getting it right, and small punishments that you can repeat easily. And a lot of annoying behaviours that come under the heading of "attitude" mainly need to be ignored. Spend your energy instead on noticing and making a fuss over any odd bits of good behaviour.

As for the iPad, I would just remove temptation. Put it somewhere at night where she can't get at it and be sympathetic but firm that she can't have it.

ProfSprout · 20/09/2021 16:44

I find the majority attitude on this thread that a week of no screen time is some barbaric punishment absolutely baffling. Clearly I am a horrible parent because my dc get zero screen time in the week (and are much happier and nicer to be around for it).

To me sneaking the iPad late at night is something I would be very cross about and disappointed in dc for doing (as they know that would not be allowed) so restricting access to the iPad with a new code etc seems a sensible strategy as she has shown, for whatever reason, she isn’t able to regulate iPad use herself. Therefore as a parent you can put strategies in place to help her with this.

Threatening no Christmas presents etc, no that’s ridiculous and also Christmas is months away. Don’t do that.

Your dd’s life is about to change enormously with a new sibling, that is quite possibly the reason for some of her attitude / behaviour and she will need lots of reassurance that she is still your baby too. I would have a discussion with my 7yo (at a calm moment when we could spend proper time together) about the behaviour I’d noticed and whether dc could explain how they were feeling, where they thought it was coming from, what they needed etc (note what they need not what they want). Behaviour is communication after all and often our dc need our help to understand that and regulate the way they communicate their needs to us.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 20/09/2021 16:43

Why punish her for having the ipad "after hours" when you are partly to blame for not making sure it was out of reach?

slashlover · 20/09/2021 16:33

So her punishments are

Losing screen time for a week (including her switch)
Possibly no Christmas
Lights straight out

I wonder if she's pushing boundaries before the baby gets here to "prove" that you'll still love her.

HerrenaHarridan · 20/09/2021 16:32

Thw thing with punishments is that they engender this attitude of don’t give a fuck

Why care about anything if it’s just going to be used as leverage against you?

My best friends now adult kid used to be like this.

I remember her saying to me she was thinking of giving her pocket money again just so she would have something to take off her for being naughty

I remember thinking at the time something wasn’t right but I didn’t have the strategies I have now with my own to advise her

Positive reinforcement is more effective than punishment.

It’s your job to set them up to win

By all means hide the iPad after bedtime but taking her birthday presents away because your mad is about power and control not discipline

OnlySpam · 20/09/2021 16:32

What an overreaction. You'll end up ramping up punishments so much that you'll give her nowhere to go - and then you really will have problems.

She's 7. Just tell her if she does this again she'll be in trouble and will lose it. Just tell her off? Does nobody do this anymore?

I'd just remove the iPad in future at a time that I felt was right and keep it in my room. I don't get the camera thing either really. Just spend half an hour with her looking for it?

You seem to want to punish for what I'd consider very minor issues

BiBabbles · 20/09/2021 16:30

Whether the bedtime part is effective depends on the child, though more sleep might be useful to her moods. I don't think making any remarks about Christmas is useful though - it's too far out to have much meaning or really feel like a consequence to this action.

Putting the lock on the device so you have to unlock it is a good first step. I'd keep that for a while and discuss how such actions like sneaking stuff out result in a loss of trust. Changing the environment can make action changes easier.

As she's already agreed to look for the camera, I'd hold off, but if it takes more than another week, I'd support her by going through her room with her and reestablishing how to find places for things. Development isn't linear - it's normal for kids to sometimes have to relearn some skills, particularly at a time of big changes like a new sibling or the first flutters of adolescent hormones.

I'd pull up the rude remarks, mostly just by labeling them - that was rude, that was nasty. Possibly adding on that I'd doubt they'd like if someone talked to them like that/asking how she would feel if X person she admired said that to her, though that depends on personality - some will just bluster that they don't care. My general message with kids that age is don't do to other people what you don't want done to you. I really only get to punishment for remarks if they're being purposefully cruel particularly to another kid, and then it's usually being stuck with an adult to supervise because they can't be trusted to manage themselves and not hurt others.

Bingomangoes · 20/09/2021 16:29

I assumed the OP was still up but in a different room when her daughter snuck downstairs. Then discovered daughter with iPad when she went up to bed herself.

LST · 20/09/2021 16:27

@QforCucumber

It was 11:20 at night and she had been up for hours watching Netflix

if she had been put to bed at 8, what time did you then go to bed for her to then sneak downstairs and have been watching it for hours?

We sometimes go to bed at the same time as the DC. That's when mine has snuck down and got it
QforCucumber · 20/09/2021 16:20

It was 11:20 at night and she had been up for hours watching Netflix

if she had been put to bed at 8, what time did you then go to bed for her to then sneak downstairs and have been watching it for hours?

ScabbyHorse · 20/09/2021 16:20

You have to teach them how to tidy and clean. My DS can do it now but he is 15! It took years of teaching him...I tried to do it when I was in the mood and made it into a semi fun thing ie not in a rush. And he had to decide whether to keep stuff or donate or throw. He is still learning how to notice stuff that needs doing in the rest of the house though.

YouCantBeSadHoldingACupcake · 20/09/2021 16:19

Set up screen time on the iPad, really easy to do and locks it after a certain time. Yes loss of screen time is appropriate punishment for sneaking down and tidying her room to find the camera is just natural consequences isn't it.

Genegenieee · 20/09/2021 16:18

You can put restrictions on specific app usage on iPad, if she's been able to watch Netflix for hours it sounds like you aren't using those yet. Worth getting your head round - it's Netflix now but will be various social media apps / games in a few short years. Doesn't change need for consequences etc. But I don't think others have mentioned, apologies if they have.

I think I would be trying to get under the skin of why she is disregarding your rules and consequences / punishment though.

Seesawmummadaw · 20/09/2021 16:18

You said it’s unusual behaviour for her and you have a new baby coming soon. I expect this time is hard for both of you.
I wouldn’t be too hard on her.

Maybe help to look for the camera and change the settings on the iPad so she can use it but only for an hour a day.

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 20/09/2021 16:17

Password protect the ipad so she has to come to you to get time on it.

Also re wifi, you can cut individual devices, so you can cut kids off but not yourself. Google your router and how to identify and disable individual devices. Dh just used the threat of doing this and the children could see it could be done.

Sometimes children make out they are not bothered about something, for a 7 year old Christmas is a very long time away. I think maybe now there is a new rule of a tidy bedroom every day. Make it part of the routine. I have teenagers with very tidy rooms as we enforced this from an early age.

LST · 20/09/2021 16:16

@GoodForTheSoul

Taking an iPad away for a week is harsh? Why is OP using punishment for bad behaviour? Threads like this explain all the spoilt & entitled kids I come across. Your kids are going to have a tough time adjusting to the real world, having been raised with no discipline.
You've put it better than me.
Billybagpuss · 20/09/2021 16:16

Is it possible she’s distracted and acting up knowing that in 2 months time she won’t be an only child anymore.

As excited as she might be for a new baby, it’s going to be a time of big change for her, she’s had you to herself forever, now it will change.

Lweji · 20/09/2021 16:16

Perhaps spending too much time with my pre teen sister had had an effect.

I was going to say she sounded like a teen, yes. Grin

Honestly, if you get a raise out of it (or if you're triggered, as my teen would say), then you'll have some very difficult teen years. A sense of humour is your best friend.

GoodForTheSoul · 20/09/2021 16:15

Taking an iPad away for a week is harsh? Why is OP using punishment for bad behaviour? Threads like this explain all the spoilt & entitled kids I come across. Your kids are going to have a tough time adjusting to the real world, having been raised with no discipline.

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 16:13

I think there definitely could be some hormones involved as she really does the moody teenager thing now.

I told her about my weekend when I picked her up from my dads (after she refused to tell me about hers) and she said “that sounds boring and your food sounds disgusting.” Just really rude and mardy and nothing like how she’s always been. Perhaps spending too much time with my pre teen sister had had an effect.

OP posts:
Bingomangoes · 20/09/2021 16:13

Of course no screen time for a week is appropriate for a 7yr old, she snuck out of her room after bed time to do something she knew very well was not ok. It's not even a very harsh punishment it's just no screens for 1 week there are a million other things she can do instead and in fact when mine were banned from screens they suddenly remembered all their other toys existed, it was actually quite beneficial.

LST · 20/09/2021 16:11

@GinIronic

Poor kid. Punishment. Punishment.
So it's ok for children to just not do as they are told and not care about their things? Right ok. Obviously been doing it wrong HmmConfused