Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appropriate punishment?

234 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 14:14

Caught my 7 year old last night up watching her iPad at gone 11. She had snuck downstairs and got it out of the cabinet and took it upstairs to her bedroom. This, ontop of losing her camera she got for a birthday a month ago and not being remotely remourseful about it plus her attitude in general at the minute, we’ve decided no more screen time for the next week until her bedroom has been tidied and her camera has been found. It’s definitely in there somewhere, it hasnt left the house.

She just seems to have no respect for her stuff at all. We told her if she carries on like this then we won’t bother getTing her anything nice for Christmas as she will just lose it. She just shrugged and said ok.

She never used to be like this! We’ve said from now on she can go to bed and it’s lights straight off until she can show us sue can behave. Is this effective for her age?

OP posts:
Lweji · 21/09/2021 10:39

There’s nothing wrong with labeling a behaviour as naughty which is what it was.

Yes, there is. Because if you can't see past how you feel about the behaviour, then you cannot go to the root of that behaviour.
All you see is that she broke your rules, not why.
Again, very surprising from a psychologist.

SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 10:38

So exactly what I’ve done. Thanks.

OP posts:
Lweji · 21/09/2021 10:36

Some tips:

School-age children (six years to 12 years)
The child’s increasing independence may lead to conflicts. School-age children tend to act autonomously, choose their own activities and friends, and, to some extent, recognize other than parental authority. Parents should continue to supervise, provide good behavioural models, set rules consistently, but also allow the child to become increasingly autonomous. Parents should continue to make the important decisions because school-age children cannot always put reasoning and judgment into practice.

Praise and approval should be used liberally, although not excessively, to encourage good behaviour and growth into a more mature human being. The use of appropriate motivators should be encouraged; for example, buy a keen reader his or her favourite book.

Acceptable means of discipline include withdrawal or delay of privileges, consequences and time-out.

Example: The child destroys toys. Instead of replacing these toys, let the child learn the logical consequences. Destroying toys will result in no toys to play with.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2719514/

SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 10:34

No I just don’t agree with your pandering approach. There’s nothing wrong with labeling a behaviour as naughty which is what it was. She snuck out of bed, went downstairs and climbed up to a cabinet to get the iPad that she knows she’s not allowed on after bed or during the week anyway. I’m not just going to be “awww darling” about it. She’s been punished and knowing MY child and her personality type, she won’t be doing it again in a hurry.

OP posts:
Lweji · 21/09/2021 10:32

Forgot "dick". Nice.

Lweji · 21/09/2021 10:31

@SheABitSpicyToday

I'm very surprised that you are a psychologist (or at least have a degree in psychology) and keep using the word naughty and sneaky in relation to your daughter.

You also seem clueless in terms of appropriate discipline and how to deal with specific behaviours.
No attempt to understand where she is coming from and why she displays these behaviours, and how and why she is changing her behaviours.

I get that you're tired and pregnant, but quite frankly, you can do better.
Is this a case of doctor heal thyself? Or too much arrogance to learn more about dealing with children, rather than relying on some theoretical framework of development?

SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 10:29

This thread had really confirmed why there are so many horribly behaved, entitled children around who just allowed to do whatever the hell they like with no punishment.

OP posts:
SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 10:28

Part time? What about my degree was part time?

OP posts:
BrendaBubbles · 21/09/2021 10:26

She took the headphones sos that the noise wouldn’t wake me. It was very sneaky and there’s no way I’m letting that go without consequences.

So she couldn’t sleep, settled herself, and was considerate enough to not make a noise while doing so, and that should be punished. Great example there. It will bite you in the butt in the teenage years as the lesson has been “don’t get caught!”

But with your part time degree in psychology I am sure it will be okay although why you came to us lowly peons for advice when you’re the reincarnation of Sigmund Freud is anyone’s guess.

N4ish · 21/09/2021 10:11

Nice to describe your 7 year old daughter as a dick . . . .

SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 10:03

I did enough reading on cognitive development during my 4 year psychology degree thanks.

I don’t agree with your parenting and you don’t agree with mine. Leave it.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 21/09/2021 10:02

You need to read up on cognitive development and understand at a deeper level what motivates her to do the things she is doing. Disrespectful parenting is not the only way.

Goldenbear · 21/09/2021 09:57

AmaryllisNightAndDay are you joking? You do realise these are TV programmes with a set formula designed to pull in audience with its shock, horror and humiliation.

The autocratic way is not the only way to bring up children. Enforcement of the rules with punishmnets and acceptance of your child being contingent on their behaviouris not unconditional love and if you have a child that's what you should be providing. A child should be encouraged to reflect on their outlook and choices and not just take the right course of action because they are scared to do otherwise I.e with a punishment t awaiting them.

SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 09:49

Some of you have some wild imaginations.

My daughter is very happy. She was a dick, she’s been punished. Guess what? She’s still a loving happy little girl!

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 21/09/2021 09:10

She knows not to get out of bed unless she needs me or to go to the toilet or get a drink. She took the headphones sos that the noise wouldn’t wake me. It was very sneaky and there’s no way I’m letting that go without consequences.

As crimes go that seems pretty trivial, who hasn't crept downstairs to get a book and read under the covers (I used to sneak to the bathroom to read at night not to wake my sister) So it's not "very sneaky" it's just normal sneakiness for her age Smile. And one of the things you get from an iPad video in bed is comfort. Is it OK for her to need you just for comfort and company, or would that count as getting out of bed for no reason? Or are you disappointed that she didn't come to you for comfort?

Sadly for you and your like minded folk that want to believe this false nanny 911 narrative!

Eh? Which Nanny 911 narrative? Nanny 911 is usually about making sure the child's emotional needs are met and that expectations of behaviour are realistic for age and child's abilities, plus the usual stuff about routines, attention, positive and negative consequences and consistency. Which bit do you disapprove of?

OP it would be a good idea to rebuild a warm loving relationship with her now, before the new baby arrives. You are expecting her to behave like a reasonable careful and good tempered young lady who stays in bed when she's told and is grateful for expensive presents and doesn't lose her things or change her mind about what she wants. And you're getting annoyed and punishing her when she dosen't meet those expectations. But if you're so angry with her for not meeting your expectations now, how is that expectation going to play when the baby arrives? A seven year old with a new sibling often morphs into a 3 year old!

N4ish · 21/09/2021 09:07

Seems like an overreaction to me and you risk getting entrenched in a “you against DD’ mindset. You’ve put the iPad away safely at night so this can’t happen again, that would be enough for me. I’m not a believer in punishments, there’s always a root cause for sudden shifts in behaviour.

wingingit987 · 21/09/2021 08:49

@SheABitSpicyToday

I never said she’s not getting anything for Christmas. But she won’t be getting a big main present if she can’t look after her stuff. All she had to do was put the camera away where I asked her to and she hasn’t. 7 is more than old enough to do these things seeing as she’s always managed to do these thing up until this shift in attitude.
This I completely agree with why would you waste money on expensive things if she isn't going to look after then she will have to wait until she's older.
wingingit987 · 21/09/2021 08:47

Someone said you to materialistic is being ridiculous.

1, the sneaky ness of it I wound say at least 5 days screen ban.

2, the bedroom she may need assistance doing so while she's on the screen ban maybe you can help her.

Teaching children the value of money isn't a bad thing she's lost this camera which cost money if she wants nice things she needs to look after her stuff otherwise you won't buy her it as it's a waste of money.

BrendaBubbles · 21/09/2021 08:37

You’re a right bunch of miseries. Life is short, do you really want one of your child’s lasting memories to be some over the top performance punishment? I got a week of detention for throwing a paper airplane at school and I had a huge disdain for the institution after that.

bumblingbovine49 · 21/09/2021 08:12

You are mixing up all sorts of things . Punishing her for several things at once makes her feel hopeless to be able to change things and tells her she is a terrible person

She lost a camera and is in untidy child those are not things to punish her for they are things to help her with.

Telling her you will continue to punish her (sending her to bed early etc) until she can 'behave appropriately for her age' is a pretty poor parenting technique. That outcome is so non specific as to be useless.

She has lost a camera and she doesn't care that much, then don't buy her expensive things again until she is older and/or shows more responsibility and by all means and insist she helps look for it but this has nothing to do with the IPad. Mixing them together in a litany of complaints about her general behaviour does not help.

Sneaking the iPad out to watch it suggests problems with impulsivity. Perhaps explaining why you don't want her to have too much screen time along with a short and lightly applied punishment such as a few days of no.screens with a tone that shows you still love her if not what she did would be more appropriate

Your whole post seems to be very negative about her generally. You mention that this behaviour is fairly new , I'd be worried that means something has happened to cause it and would be trying to understand my child more than just punishing them

LST · 21/09/2021 08:01

@girlmom21 does everyone not expect their 7 year old to be able to tidy their own room? You act as though it's a weird idea

girlmom21 · 21/09/2021 07:47

[quote SheABitSpicyToday]@Goldenbear no I’m not offering more guidance at 11pm. I have no idea why she decided watch hours of Netflix instead of sleeping. I’d imagine because it’s more fun than sleeping. She still knows it naughty though, hence the secrecy.[/quote]
Why don't you just ask why she did it? You expect her to tidy her own room at 7 but won't have a conversation with her about why she chose to overstep boundaries?

HikingforScenery · 20/09/2021 20:39

Can you put time restrictions on the iPad?

HikingforScenery · 20/09/2021 20:37

A week with no screen time is adequate. You’ve to find a way to address the sneakiness. That would bother me a lot.

Block · 20/09/2021 20:32

And no it’s not my toy, what a ridiculous accusation. It’s very much gets in just annoyed that she so desperately wanted it and had been asking for It for almost a year and she’s managed to lose it in the space of a few weeks

Because asking for things when they have no clue about value or anything else is a thing that children do, OP. Losing these same things comes into the same category.

You are ignoring some experienced posters here who are saying very sensible things.