Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appropriate punishment?

234 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 20/09/2021 14:14

Caught my 7 year old last night up watching her iPad at gone 11. She had snuck downstairs and got it out of the cabinet and took it upstairs to her bedroom. This, ontop of losing her camera she got for a birthday a month ago and not being remotely remourseful about it plus her attitude in general at the minute, we’ve decided no more screen time for the next week until her bedroom has been tidied and her camera has been found. It’s definitely in there somewhere, it hasnt left the house.

She just seems to have no respect for her stuff at all. We told her if she carries on like this then we won’t bother getTing her anything nice for Christmas as she will just lose it. She just shrugged and said ok.

She never used to be like this! We’ve said from now on she can go to bed and it’s lights straight off until she can show us sue can behave. Is this effective for her age?

OP posts:
SheABitSpicyToday · 22/09/2021 22:44

Sorry @StinkingCold but she’s 7 not 4….

OP posts:
StinkingCold · 22/09/2021 20:45

Flip the typos!! ...If it's in the house somewhere, can you look for it together tomorrow and help her with tidying her room....

Mrstamborineman · 22/09/2021 20:45

I take away for a week. It’s clearly not long enough because it happens quite regularly. They decide the consequences are worth the risk imo.

StinkingCold · 22/09/2021 20:44

And losing things?...even I do that and I'm 42! If it's on the house somewhere, can you for it together tomorrow and help her with tidying her room, and maybe make something together to hang on the windows to decorate the finished, clean and tidy new room?

StinkingCold · 22/09/2021 20:42

!! I think it's quite funny and normalish 7 yr old behaviour!! If mine had done that, I'd have known about it before 11 as I tend to check on them 20 mins after bed to see if they r ok, turn off the music which they often fall asleep to, and put the covers back on that have normally been kicked off! I then have a quick peek in again after another 20 mins to check all well.

However, if for some reason I'd not checked them til 11 and I saw this I think I'd give a little 'my my my!!....and what are you doing at this time young man?..' promptly followed by a visit from the tickle monster! and an explanation of why what he did was wrong (at this age you need sleep etc .. so you can get up for school in the morning, you should ask mummy before taking things etc...) and then maybe a warning that if it happens again it will be no screens the next day.

Kids are kids! They push boundaries, but ultimately I don't really see this as any major event!!

Theworldishard · 22/09/2021 20:04

@Lweji

There’s nothing wrong with labeling a behaviour as naughty which is what it was.

Yes, there is. Because if you can't see past how you feel about the behaviour, then you cannot go to the root of that behaviour.
All you see is that she broke your rules, not why.
Again, very surprising from a psychologist.

You are really overthinking this. I wonder why. Strange.
Theworldishard · 22/09/2021 20:02

@GinIronic

Poor kid. Punishment. Punishment.
What would you suggest then, parent of the year?
Theworldishard · 22/09/2021 20:00

@Goldenbear

She's 7 way too young to dishing out week long punishments and effectively telling her she is not good enough to you as no Christmas presents either as you are anticipating she is going to disappoint you again.
What she would you deem appropriate. I work with primary age children and believe me seven year olds are not too young for punishments. Our headteacher rang home parents of a group of children who were being unkind age 6-7. When would you suggest discipline begins?
Theworldishard · 22/09/2021 19:59

@SheABitSpicyToday

No I just don’t agree with your pandering approach. There’s nothing wrong with labeling a behaviour as naughty which is what it was. She snuck out of bed, went downstairs and climbed up to a cabinet to get the iPad that she knows she’s not allowed on after bed or during the week anyway. I’m not just going to be “awww darling” about it. She’s been punished and knowing MY child and her personality type, she won’t be doing it again in a hurry.
Agree. Not sure why everyone is getting so irate? I don't understand.
Theworldishard · 22/09/2021 19:56

@MaskingForIt

It just sounds like you’re a lot more materialistic than she is. Good for her.
Don't understand your comment?

The child has lost something expensive and isn't remotely bothered and you're praising her? Hmm

Block · 22/09/2021 19:54

@SheABitSpicyToday

I have the camera now, she can have it when she asks for it but it’s not to be kept in her room any longer.
I think this is the first sensible thing you have said.

I was thinking about all of this earlier (in the way that one does), and my conclusions were:

When my DC were younger, "everyone" had a Nintendo DS. I bought one - but made it clear that it was mine. They could use it, for a limited amount of time, and I would then re-possess it. It would live with me. This might have been easier because there was no way I was buying multiples of any of this stuff. So keeping custody of the camera and allowing your DD access to it when she asks seems sensible, OP.

I do think you need to consider some of the questions you have been asked a bit more, as your DD is about to go through a massive upheaval. It does make a difference if she and the baby are full siblings, even though I need to don a hard hat to say this. It only make a difference because if they aren't, she will still be processing her parents' split and the fact that her mum has moved on. There's no reason why anyone shouldn't move on (I'm a lone parent with a partner, so would be the last to preach) - but my children have all said they are glad that DP and I are too old to have children. I think it does make a difference to younger ones.

LST · 22/09/2021 16:52

People calling the op unhinged? Wow.

girlmom21 · 22/09/2021 14:40

@SheABitSpicyToday

I have the camera now, she can have it when she asks for it but it’s not to be kept in her room any longer.
I'm glad you have the camera. She must be relieved!
SheABitSpicyToday · 22/09/2021 14:24

I have the camera now, she can have it when she asks for it but it’s not to be kept in her room any longer.

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/09/2021 14:09

Not buying her any Christmas presents is extreme.

The OP said later that she meant she wouldn't be buying another big expensive item like a camera. Which I think is pretty sensible.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/09/2021 14:05

You don’t think a 7 year old has the ability to tidy her room?

Depends what you mean by "tidy her room". Chuck everything into drawers, yes. Sort most things into more or less the right place, some kid yes, some no. Carefully put an expensive SLR camera into its case and make sure it was put back in its proper place every time? Quite a big ask.

BoredZelda · 22/09/2021 10:59

I’m impressed if she has the ability, but you still run a risk of cutting her motivation to do it.

You don’t think a 7 year old has the ability to tidy her room?

BoredZelda · 22/09/2021 10:58

I won’t be turning off the wifi because why should the rest of us have to go without? Her iPad is in my room now and she wouldn’t dare go in my room to get it. I’ve said she can read but that’s it. The switch has been out away too.

Put parental controls on the iPad, change the password on the WIfI and set up a separate kids WiFi with a different password and turn it on and off as required.

Not buying her any Christmas presents is extreme.

Block · 21/09/2021 22:18

@SheABitSpicyToday

She wanted a Poleroid camera for her scrap booking.

I don’t need advice on my parenting there is nothing wrong with it thanks. I asked if a week was too long to remove the iPad and I’m now sure of my decision.

Um... you're sure of your decision because so many people have questioned your strategy and have asked some very sensible questions which you have chosen not to answer?

Ok, then.

Confused
SheABitSpicyToday · 21/09/2021 19:46

She wanted a Poleroid camera for her scrap booking.

I don’t need advice on my parenting there is nothing wrong with it thanks. I asked if a week was too long to remove the iPad and I’m now sure of my decision.

OP posts:
Miseryl · 21/09/2021 19:05

Why does a 7 year old need a camera AND an iPad? Surely the iPad can double as both, unless she's some sort of photography genius? If she's not arsed about the camera, just sell it.
And the sneaking down thing isn't that bad surely? Seems an extreme over reaction on your part. You sound like you're talking about a much older child, in the way I may talk about my teenager. She is still very little really.

Rivermonsters · 21/09/2021 18:54

I’m going to against the grain and say YABU. You seem unhinged

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 21/09/2021 18:16

I’m not worried about her ability to tidy her room at the age of 7.

I'm impressed if she has the ability, but you still run a risk of cutting her motivation to do it. Judging by the the way you described her and her behaviour here, your DD must be learning she can get a strong emotional reaction out of you by some fairly minor misbehaviour - taking the iPad, attitude, untidiness, mislaying her own camera. That's not something you want her to learn with a new baby on the way. You might find that her willingness to (e.g) tidy her room vanishes overnight and the more frustrated and enraged you become the less willing she is.

As a psychology graduate you'll know that's basic motivation theory - leaving your room in a mess and getting the attention of an angry punishing mum is better than keeping it tidy for a mum who takes your tidying for granted and ignores you while she's busy with a baby. Of course getting a positive reaction is best, but a negative reaction is more motivating than none at all.

So think strategy - better to spend a pleasant time with her helping her tidy up than get angry with her for not tidying.

Lweji · 21/09/2021 17:56

Don't bother. The OP was only asking for validation.

Block · 21/09/2021 17:24

@SheABitSpicyToday

Any decent parent would not be ok with their 7 year old staying up till nearly midnight in secret watching tv. If you’d be ok with that then perhaps look at your own parenting before judging someone else’s.
OP, I don't think you're listening to the vast majority of posters on here, none of whom is saying they would adopt a "there, there, darling, oh it's so clever of you to sneak onto your ipad" approach.

My youngest child is 17 (we have five), and my experience is that the teenagers who have grown up being scared of punishment are the most likely to become involved in risky behaviours and not to be able to tell you.

I have had some pretty tricky moments with mine, and am not out of the woods yet. However, it is really important that they know that they can come to you with something, however dire, without being afraid of being punished by you on top of whatever they've already done. Your job, really, is to help children and, in due course, teenagers and young adults be able to own up to their mistakes and thoughtless behaviour (and teenagers can be masters of this) and to try to find ways to put them right. This is emphatically not the same as letting do whatever they like and getting away with it.