Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents insisting my DS mask?

137 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 20/09/2021 08:32

My parents can be very neurotic and are suddenly insisting DS (13) wears a mask when visiting them with us. He is doubly vaccinated and wears a mask in school (Ireland). I pointed out yesterday to my irate Father that he took train across the country recently, they use buses and taxis, my DH is in work, and my son is no likelier to carry Covid than they do.
They've been watching the jump in primary school children being sent home when one child tests positive, and are obsessing about this.
Yesterday I told my son not to mask and my Father was furious and left the room (which had an open window and we were all sitting at a long distance from each other) in a rage. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Topseyt · 22/09/2021 09:54

I think you are doing very well standing up for your DS now and starting to protect him in a way that nobody protected you when you were his age.

Stay strong. Keep protecting him (I'm sure you will anyway).

I'd agree with others that low contact is probably the best way to be going forward. If your parents ask at some point in the future why they are hardly seeing you or DS then that might be your cue to tell them bluntly.

billy1966 · 22/09/2021 08:52

I honestly have no wish to shame you at all, but I must admit that that it is hard to understand when parents are so dreadful that the were violently abusive to someone, to the extent you write, that you would want them to be a part of your childrens life at all.

Well done for standing up for your son, but I do think stepping away would be better all round.

This is not a kind, decent man, who will add value to your son's life.

He can't care a whit about him to behave in such a nasty, humiliating way to a child.

So your father by his behaviour is carrying his abuse on to the next generation.

You don't sound like you want that, so what is the point of him in your life, or your mother who aids him?

Try fading them out as much as possible. Low contact can be very successful.

I'm so sorry this man had such power over you as to ruin your your career early on.

I do really sympathise.Flowers

L0stinCyberspace · 21/09/2021 22:10

Thank you so much @saraclara you do indeed get it. My Father is similar...able to pretend to be nice for short periods and I've always carefully managed DSs exposure to him. Only in the last year is he seeing that his GF has a horrible side to him.

OP posts:
saraclara · 21/09/2021 22:05

I get it @L0stinCyberspace

When I had my own children, I wanted them to have the calm and happy family life that I didn't. My abusive parent managed to put an entirely different face on for short periods in front of other people, and lived a distance away, so our contact with her was infrequent, brief, and always under our control. I knew she'd behave because she wanted my DH to like her. So my DDs knew nothing of who she could be, and even my late DH didn't know most of it. My DDs had happy times there as they grew up, and were fond of their GM

My DB spilled the beans to one of my DDs when she was a young adult (he didn't know it was something that I'd locked away) and she was really shocked. Now both of my DDs know more than even my DH did, but they're old enough to process it and talk with me about it. And they understand the effect my mum's behaviour had/has on me and are a great and calm support.

It will be harder for you as obviously your father lives more locally, so you can't protect you DS in the same way. But well done for sticking up for DS and challenging your dad. I know it's really hard.

L0stinCyberspace · 21/09/2021 21:17

@billy1966

I genuinely cannot understand OP, why people like you who were clearly abused by your parents offer up your children to these people?

I really can't.

Your father is a nasty abusive thug who has been now given the opportunity to bully a 13 year old.

I mean it kindly, but step the hell up and don't allow this.

Explain the awful truth to your children if you have to.

Your father is not a good man and you are staying the hell away.

This is so damaging to your son.

Step far away from these awful people that would treat your poor child like this.
Flowers

It sounds illogical to a person who hasn't grown up with abusive parents.

As illogical as women who stay with abusers.

"Step far away" sounds easily done if you haven't ties of obligation and concern. I'm not offering my son up to my Father at all - I took him on, challenged him, and sent him a message (after he'd tried to manipulate the situation in a nasty follow up message to me) to calmly explain why his actions were unfair on my DS and not something I was going to tolerate.

DS will have no time alone with my parents from now on. I have told DS some of what went on for me.

Your message certainly does not come across as "kindly" but rather shaming. I've been through hell in my upbringing in a way that scuppered my career early on due to the impact of my Father. Count yourself very lucky that you don't understand.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 21/09/2021 20:19

I genuinely cannot understand OP, why people like you who were clearly abused by your parents offer up your children to these people?

I really can't.

Your father is a nasty abusive thug who has been now given the opportunity to bully a 13 year old.

I mean it kindly, but step the hell up and don't allow this.

Explain the awful truth to your children if you have to.

Your father is not a good man and you are staying the hell away.

This is so damaging to your son.

Step far away from these awful people that would treat your poor child like this.
Flowers

NotMaryWhitehouse · 21/09/2021 19:58

Thats fair @L0stinCyberspace , I can imagine you feel a lot of resentment towards her.

Cheekyandfreaky · 21/09/2021 19:07

Follow your gut OP, I think you know what to do. I don’t know your Dad but I do know bullies and they don’t back off when they see a vulnerable target.

LukeEvansWife · 21/09/2021 18:57

Yes, I am very aggressive and I have long fangs

What are you talking about? Seriously, it’s really not worth getting so angry

Topseyt · 21/09/2021 18:56

@LukeEvansWife

Yes. It is and always has been.

For example, in medicine one set of symptoms might "mask" something else if a diagnosis is possibly open to question.

What about a masked ball? Those who go to the ball are "masked."

Now during the pandemic people have often been masked.

What pathetic point are you trying to make?

Wow - ‘pathetic point’? Grin

Of course I know it’s a verb in that context. But i only hear people say ‘wear a mask’ not ‘mask’ meaning to put one on.

Are you always this aggressive? Hmm

Yes, I am very aggressive and I have long fangs. 🙄

Round here people often talked about being masked to go into shops. Thankfully a thing of the past - for now. It's a verb when you want it to be.

L0stinCyberspace · 21/09/2021 14:22

@NotMaryWhitehouse

Ah. I read your updates. Your father sound, I'm sorry to say, like a bit of a twat. Now I also feel sorry for your mum, and you! Thanks
Thanks @NotMaryWhitehouse

My DM is so complicit in all this too. DF has given her a horrible life but she never stood up for me as a child. This time, I'm as annoyed with her as with him.

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 20/09/2021 19:32

@LukeEvansWife

Yes. It is and always has been.

For example, in medicine one set of symptoms might "mask" something else if a diagnosis is possibly open to question.

What about a masked ball? Those who go to the ball are "masked."

Now during the pandemic people have often been masked.

What pathetic point are you trying to make?

Wow - ‘pathetic point’? Grin

Of course I know it’s a verb in that context. But i only hear people say ‘wear a mask’ not ‘mask’ meaning to put one on.

Are you always this aggressive? Hmm

Yeah, you’re right - this is a new usage of the verb ‘to mask’, intransitively.

English is very accepting of this kind of shift in usage. Often, we don’t even notice that something new has happened - as might be demonstrated by the unnecessarily bolshie reply you got.

LukeEvansWife · 20/09/2021 18:53

Yes. It is and always has been.

For example, in medicine one set of symptoms might "mask" something else if a diagnosis is possibly open to question.

What about a masked ball? Those who go to the ball are "masked."

Now during the pandemic people have often been masked.

What pathetic point are you trying to make?

Wow - ‘pathetic point’? Grin

Of course I know it’s a verb in that context. But i only hear people say ‘wear a mask’ not ‘mask’ meaning to put one on.

Are you always this aggressive? Hmm

Topseyt · 20/09/2021 18:40

@LukeEvansWife

Is ‘to mask’ a verb now? Confused
Yes. It is and always has been.

For example, in medicine one set of symptoms might "mask" something else if a diagnosis is possibly open to question.

What about a masked ball? Those who go to the ball are "masked."

Now during the pandemic people have often been masked.

What pathetic point are you trying to make?

BogRollBOGOF · 20/09/2021 15:41

Keep your son away from this foul, irrational, bullying bastard.

My line on visiting June 2020 Ireland was that my paranoid in-laws were not going to treat my children as lesser than me (UK u12s so entered untested covered by mine and DH's double vaccines... we kept life very low risk for 10 days before and made low-risk travel arrangements by ferry). If my ILs were being funny about letting our pestilence-ridden-plague-spreaders indoors, then DH and I also refused to go indoors, so we all sucked up "sociallising" in 15⁰C downpours.

The irony is that because we'd isolated from indoor spaces, my children were "safer" than their vaccinated adult/ teenage cousins.

I will not tolerate my children being treated as outcasts based on their age.

waybill · 20/09/2021 15:15

What a nasty cantankerous old bastard. He doesn't deserve to have a relationship with his grandchild. Don't let him bully you or your dc.

Rainbowsew · 20/09/2021 15:14

Definitely a power play going on here can't believe people think this is about covid fear and his house/his rules that would only be the case if all visitors are asked to wear masks and he never went out.

The fact that isn't so shows he is a vile bully. Time to empower your son not to take it. Your father is a fool he's the one sabotaging his relationship with you and his grandson.

Rainbowsew · 20/09/2021 15:08

@L0stinCyberspace

My Father has form for being very controlling and bullying. DM never challenges him and is obedient to his every whim and demand.

When DS went for the meal we weren't there, as my parents said they "wanted to spend time with him b4 he went back to school" but DS was very hurt at being asked to eat separately from them. I raised it with DM but she was as delightfully vague as always. "Oh that's awful he feels that way..." "Hmm, I can't remember WHY your Father didn't want to each lunch outside..."

@TheGrumpyGoat we are all vaccinated, including DS.

@WeAllHaveWings because of the history of my DFs bullying towards me I suppose I didn't react in the most measured way, but I was horrified he was insisting DS was some kind of Typhoid Mary when he's out on trains buses and taxis.

My DH suggested "right, why don't we all sit outside so?" last night to my DF, but DF said furiously "because we're not going to".

That's the point we'd have left. I don't understand why they're singling him out? Because he's a teen at school?

That's weird bullying behaviour and even if my DS was happy to wear the mask I wouldn't be happy with him being treated that way!

If they're out and and about in the community they have no reason to insist your ds is no greater risk to them than anyone else.

I'm furious on your/his behalf and would be ceasing any visits at theirs.

LookItsMeAgain · 20/09/2021 14:58

I'm Irish and I feel sorry for your DS (and you too @L0stinCyberspace) because I think Irish women (and yes, this will be a sweeping generalisation here) have been so conditioned over the years (thanks to the almighty Catholic Church) to cowtow to their husbands and what they say goes.
Your mum didn't step in on behalf of either you her daughter or her grandson in taking her husband to task over what he was saying/doing.

I 100% agree with the others who have suggested that you don't visit as much in their house and if they ask why you're not visiting them as much, tell them.
Start enforcing those boundaries.

ChristmasPlannier · 20/09/2021 14:55

[quote L0stinCyberspace]@MajorCarolDanvers no, they are just singling out DS fora mask!

They invited him for lunch b4 school started up, but then made him eat his meal in a separate room. They could have eaten outside as I bought them a sturdy garden set, but Father "didn't want to". Angry[/quote]
I hope you left when they treated him like this?

BoredZelda · 20/09/2021 14:46

Children don't pass it on as much as adults so you may well be wrong about that.

I understood that was thought to be the case prior to Delta, but it was a game changer in that regard? In any event, what I meant was, if anyone has it in our household it is DD. I’ve seen two adults other than my husband in the past two weeks, he’s seen about the same.

SpnBaby1967 · 20/09/2021 14:43

@LukeEvansWife

Is ‘to mask’ a verb now? Confused
I hope not ! It should always be "to wear a mask", its just laziness to try to turn it into a verb.

OP, if my family were making my son eat in a separate room and singling him out in that way I'd be ensuring they didn't catch Covid from him by not going there ever again. Treating a child with such disdain is appalling.

Notaroadrunner · 20/09/2021 14:38

[quote L0stinCyberspace]@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons no, agreed there's no problem with him wearing a mask. It's the seeing him as some kind of contagion that I have the issue with- despite him being doubly vaccinated and wearing masks at school. If he was in primary where there's no vaccination or masking I'd absolutely see my DPs POV.

@TintinIsBack thanks re 1. 2 - I'm dutiful and also love to see DS with his GP's. I dreaded the day when my DF might start going for DS the way he did for me as a young teen. I suppose this is the beginning. Will reduce contact and not let DS go alone anymore. 3. Outbursts have been my life. I'm constantly attacked by DF.[/quote]
You're constantly being attacked and yet you still go back for more and now he's started on Ds. I think you should seriously think about cutting back on contact with this horrible bully of a man. Meet your mother out for coffee if you want to see her. If you can't go LC then at the very least look into ways to stand up to him, call him out on his bully behaviour and teach your Ds to do the same. And tell Dh to stand up for you all if, on occasion, you find yourself stuck for words. Your father doesn't deserve to have you visit and spend time in his company.

NotMaryWhitehouse · 20/09/2021 14:34

Ah. I read your updates. Your father sound, I'm sorry to say, like a bit of a twat. Now I also feel sorry for your mum, and you! Thanks

NotMaryWhitehouse · 20/09/2021 14:32

[quote L0stinCyberspace]@MajorCarolDanvers no, they are just singling out DS fora mask!

They invited him for lunch b4 school started up, but then made him eat his meal in a separate room. They could have eaten outside as I bought them a sturdy garden set, but Father "didn't want to". Angry[/quote]
Gosh my mouth actually dropped open at this! How AWFUL of them. I'd certainly not be hurrying back there any time soon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread