Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Insulate Britain are an absolute menace…

288 replies

Flawedperfection · 20/09/2021 08:24

Just that really. Currently listening to LBC radio.
And they should be held to account for the death of the woman last week who couldn’t reach an hospital for 6 hours, following what would normally have been a much shorter journey. An oncologist also couldn’t get to work, where she was surely urgently needed.
I understand they have a message, but what if they do more help than good?
What do you think?

OP posts:
AGreenerShadeofKale · 21/09/2021 09:35

Obstructive Wankers.
I'd love to meet one and pick apart their lifestyle.

Antsinyourpanta · 21/09/2021 09:34

In a similar way to how I am always confused by XR protesting about climate change in ways that are particularly un eco friendly, how does creating extra lengthy traffic jams on a road already known for traffic jams, help the environment?
And quite disgraceful that these actions led to an innocent persons death. It would be bad enough to deal with if the ambulance had simply been delayed by weight of traffic or an accident but this was totally preventable.

Just like pouring paint all over a building or stopping people using public transport is equally un eco.

sst1234 · 21/09/2021 09:28

A degree in radical campaign design? Wow this takes the concept of Mickey Mouse degrees to a whole new level.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 21/09/2021 09:22

@LeafOfTruth

As the risk of sounding like I support IB (I don't - I don't pay them a huge amount of attention), it occurs to me that every effective (and some non-effective) activist group since the dawn of time has been

a) disruptive
b) described negatively for it

The suffragettes were accused using similar language to that used here. Called terrorists, accused of causing millions of pounds worth of damage and risking/taking lives with their bombs.

Sometimes the current generation is not best placed to judge what is reasonable and what isn't - plus, progress is only made by unreasonable men and all that. So my distaste for IB may be right or may just be a product of my generation.

None of these ‘activists’ can ever answer the question - what is the point in this virtue signalling when UK has less than 1% of global carbon emissions? Really what difference does it make?

1% is too high no? There are 195 countries in the world and the UK is a small one compared to some. Using a crude measure 1/195 of the carbon emissions would be 0.5% so 1% would appear to be more than 'our fair share' iyswim.

Sigh. And as we have to discuss EVERY FUCKING TIME these numpties come up, the suffragettes didn’t get the vote for these tactics. In fact, they got no public support for them. It was only when WW1 happened and they changed tactics completely - they stopped protesting almost all together and used their organising to support the “homefront” and then, while we may not love it, they were given the vote as a kind of reward for this. Not for any protesting and definitely not for obstructionist protesting.

It would be like what would happen if all these arseholes went and actually helped at a single home that needs insulation. They’d be done in a day. People have DIY projects all the time, so it would be legal - maybe not insulating the whole house but perhaps they could be insulating people’s attics with just one tradesman to direct them on where to bend their backs, AND they could call out newspapers to cover them doing it. That would be a hell of a lot more like what won the suffragettes the vote. But as @LoislovesStewie points out, she’ll never see them at her house. Because the director of Insulate Britain, Roger Hallam, ex-Extinction Rebellion founder, has a university degree in “radical campaign design,” (not a joke, look it up) not in actually helping a single person.

SoloISland · 21/09/2021 08:18

[quote LoislovesStewie]@BlackCountryWench2; if they want to come around and do some work on my house (for free!) I won't stop them. But I don't think any of them would do anything practical, would they?[/quote]
lol You stole my thunder... And you are so right. They look young and fit and should be pleased to learn trade and show the world how much they care,,
and yes I am being sardonic but

how about that being the penalty for their obstruction?

CMZ2018 · 21/09/2021 07:38

Of course it’s not unreasonable, the public who they’re holding up should be left to deal with them

LoislovesStewie · 21/09/2021 07:35

@BlackCountryWench2; if they want to come around and do some work on my house (for free!) I won't stop them. But I don't think any of them would do anything practical, would they?

wonkylegs · 21/09/2021 07:18

@MercyBooth @RedToothBrush
Those issues aren't with being over insulated but poorly design and poor detailing executed badly.
Insulation can't just be whacked in with no thought but it often is. New build housing by mass house builders isn't designed by people who have the right skill set to actually design low energy housing and it is a skill set. There is no requirement to be qualified to do any of this kind of thing and it shows.
There are well insulated well designed low energy houses and house retrofits that don't overheat in summer but they generally aren't built by mass house builders

WhatTheFlap · 21/09/2021 06:45

I was in one of the cars stuck on the M25 last Monday. We had a 9 week old baby in the back who (legally) I couldn’t get out to feed or change for 2 hours (but obviously I did as we were at a standstill and he was screaming).

Our dog was also sitting at home on her own for 6 hours because of the massive delays we had. Probably not a huge deal to some people but unnecessary stress caused to her.

I don’t see how targeting people like us who may usually support their cause is going to help - now we just think they’re dickheads.

itsgettingwierd · 21/09/2021 06:41

They want support for their cause.

They're getting the attention they want it to have.

But they won't get support by doing something that's resulting in deaths of others.

And they refuse to answer questions around this and if they think their cause is worth this.

I fully support the right to peaceful protests as it has its place. But this isn't that.

BlackCountryWench2 · 21/09/2021 06:36

@LoislovesStewie

I read somewhere that one of these idiots lives in a house that has single glazed windows and no insulation. So why hasn't he done something about that?
Because it’s probably a grade II* listed property. I have never seen a more entitled, middle class, hand-wringing liberal “do as I say” bunch than these lot. When they say insulate Britain, they mean poor people’s houses. Theirs wouldn’t get past the heritage planning officer.
BlackCountryWench2 · 21/09/2021 06:26

I think that you’ll find that the extreme end of the suffragette movement had very little to do with the granting of female suffrage in this country. It mainly just pissed people off and seriously put lives at risk - their own and those of society. Terrorism never brings about positive change. It was lobbying, the example set by other countries and most importantly, women’s contribution to the war effort which brought about votes for women.

And yes, we might be a small country in terms of landmass and population, but as the world’s fifth biggest economy I think we should be proud that we do not contribute anywhere near to other economies in terms of emissions. There’s still more to do, of course. We own an old house (1903) and as we’ve slowly been restoring it to its former glory we’ve added all of the insulation we can (reinstated sash windows but double-glazed; insulated ceilings, floors etc). This was more about keeping our eye on the ball with energy bills in such a large house to heat but if it’s also helping the planet - win-win. It’s still not going to do bugger all when the US, China, India, Brazil et al don’t give a shit when they’re chasing dollars. My DH and I are on a drive to not buy plastic tat made in the Far East as much as we possibly can - Insulate Britain/XR would gain my respect if they encouraged Brits to do the same and hit them where it hurts but no, let’s block roads, cause greater pollution and risk lives in the UK while factories and power stations in the rest of the world are blissfully pumping away…

MercyBooth · 21/09/2021 02:28

Because its not trendy enough @Tealightsandd

Tealightsandd · 21/09/2021 02:00

Meanwhile, why don't these people ever protest about issues we can more easily do something about? If they cared that much about suffering, why aren't they campaigning (in a non aggressive manner) about the public health housing emergency and the UC cut.

(I care passionately about the environment btw. I know, however, that attacking people - stopping them getting to work or hospital - isn't the solution.)

Tealightsandd · 21/09/2021 01:58

I assumed they were XR, or part of the group.

What I don't get, is what exactly they want. They say they're concerned about climate change/the environment. Why?

It can't be because they care about the impact on humans - because their own actions have impacted heavily on humans. XR have delayed ambulances and stopped a man getting to the hospital in time to say goodbye to a dying parent. This Insulate lot have killed someone.

So is it that they care about non humans and the rest of the environment? If so, they're kidding themselves if they think much will change. We're a destructive species. And there's too many of us. We're building all over animal habitat, cutting down rainforests, taking their space and food.

The only way to save the environment is to let the human race die out. Naturally, of course - no need for mass murder Covid style. Less extreme but still much more helpful than aggressive 'protest' would be encouraging (through education and access to contraception) smaller families.

Raising awareness? Everyone knows about the need to take action, in what small ways we can. Aggressive selfish action isn't even needed. People already know. For the majority, it's not lack of awareness. It's lack of funds. A lot of climate friendly action is expensive.

Aquafizzle · 21/09/2021 01:21

Almost missed my flights due to these fools. First flight in 24 months. If I had, I would have rescheduled another certainly were not influencing my plans the way they hoped. Completely selfish, virtue signalling dicks.

SkiingIsHeaven · 21/09/2021 01:13

These people are what water cannons were invented for. People should start using them on them. Absolutely arseholes.

Snugglybuggly · 21/09/2021 01:11

Agreed they are a bunch of idiots

MercyBooth · 21/09/2021 00:49

And I couldn't help but think about the insulate guys and how new build properties have issues with lack of ventilation and over heating because they are almost over insulated. And again its his attitude

YY @RedToothBrush I live in a social housing flat that was built in the "70s. They have been over insulated. Because work has been done since including repeat cavity wall insulation. In summer it is like a furnace. I cant take it anymore. It affects everything including eating habits because of the need to cool down. Cant store perishable yet non fridge food for long. Fed up with it. Over insulation also causes mould. On top of the over insulation they also put in new windows (in Jan 2004) which open by inches. Previously we had slidey up windows which were much better for letting air in.

IMO the reason there has been a concerted effort to shift the blame to tenants for mould issues is to cover up their mistakes.

Driftingblue · 21/09/2021 00:15

I don’t care what cause someone is supporting, they should not be preventing people from normal access to right of ways and places they have the right to enter. It could be a motorway, it could be a picket line in front of a factory. Once I saw striking students physically blocking other students from trying to attend class.

I don’t have to follow a cause to believe in someone’s right to advocate, loudly, but I do believe they must do it in such a way that other people can choose to ignore them if they wish.

rosamacrose · 21/09/2021 00:14

@2point7degrees

Yep annoying ordinary people will get them attention, but also massively turn people off their cause which seems exceptionally counter productive

Turn who off their case? Most likely most people on the M25 are older people with a majority view that they'll probably be dead or near the end by the time the worst consequences of climate change really set in - massive frequent natural disasters, widescale food and resource shortages and wars to name a few. Older generations have shown for long enough that collectively they don't give a shit and will happily leave younger generations to a horrific fate, why should anyone who cares about climate change care if these people are inconvenienced?

More beneficial for climate change than the single issue of isolating British homes is the contribution and added momentum to increasingly disruptive activism amongst younger groups across the world to actually take climate change seriously, because asking nicely and increasingly bleak scientific reports are making bugger all difference.

So to sum up: Old people dont care. Young people do care.

What outstanding insight.
Summed it up right there.
Clever you.
Biscuit

Pazuzu · 21/09/2021 00:02

Look at me! Look at me! I'm an activist and I'm better than you!

Attention seeking prats. It's all it is.

sst1234 · 20/09/2021 23:59

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

Pathetic bunch of (mainly) baby boomers who rinsed this country of fossil fuels, never recycled, living off a life pension and homes that have appreciated 16 x since they bought them - holding up the struggling to survive working masses who are more acutely aware of climate change than ever before! I would run one over for sure!
Ha ha
sst1234 · 20/09/2021 23:57

@LoislovesStewie

I read somewhere that one of these idiots lives in a house that has single glazed windows and no insulation. So why hasn't he done something about that?
It’s their leader. Honestly you couldn’t make it up.
sst1234 · 20/09/2021 23:56

Imagine what happens when these dense middle class arseholes cross the wrong kind of guy on one these protests.
On a side note, their leader comes across as thick as mince on tv. Honestly, every idiot calls themselves a climate activist nowadays without a single brain cell in their possession.