Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Insulate Britain are an absolute menace…

288 replies

Flawedperfection · 20/09/2021 08:24

Just that really. Currently listening to LBC radio.
And they should be held to account for the death of the woman last week who couldn’t reach an hospital for 6 hours, following what would normally have been a much shorter journey. An oncologist also couldn’t get to work, where she was surely urgently needed.
I understand they have a message, but what if they do more help than good?
What do you think?

OP posts:
LoislovesStewie · 22/09/2021 12:53

The man with the degree in radical campaign design who is running Insulate Britain just won’t stop being awful. He OWNS and is renting out (to people with a hell of a lot less money than him) a horrible uninsulated farm building with the worst energy rating possible and he won’t even fix that. He could insulate it tomorrow! It’s just more proof they don’t really care about insulating a single building.
Bloody hell ! I so did not know that, what an absolute disgrace!

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 22/09/2021 12:46

As @AGreenerShadeofKale has pointed out it’s irrelevant, so I won’t let myself get drawn in further or further derail the thread.

It’s absolutely right to “judge them on their own idiocy.” And the idiocy is tremendous.

The man with the degree in radical campaign design who is running Insulate Britain just won’t stop being awful. He OWNS and is renting out (to people with a hell of a lot less money than him) a horrible uninsulated farm building with the worst energy rating possible and he won’t even fix that. He could insulate it tomorrow! It’s just more proof they don’t really care about insulating a single building.

The fact is that doesn’t matter if there were working class suffragettes (for this argument); it has nothing to do with the current people clogging the motorways, as the head of the current protests is shitting on working class people he rents to (who will be freezing come winter) and CURRENT protestors ARE mostly middle class and we have proof. Facts about the “working class” being largely absent from these current selfish arsehats - Extinction Britain and their offshoots:
85% hold a university degree (twice the national average)
Most are self-employed or not “traditionally employed”
2/3rds identify as middle class
3/4ths of those arrested live below the Severn Wash line
1/3rd of those arrested were from the West Country with emphasis “in Stroud, Frome, and Totnes”

First-hand source for that info:
cusp.ac.uk/themes/p/xr-study/
Source about Roger Hallam and his farm insulation:
www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1492186/extinction-rebellion-co-founder-rents-old-building-farm-employees/amp

ArcheryAnnie · 22/09/2021 12:21

"but cannot for a second imagine my great-grandmother being able to leave her children uncared for, her husband not fed and the household being short of an income while she chained herself to some railings for a few days to make a political point, no matter how much she wanted the vote or believed in the movement"

All that means is that your imagination isn't very good. Almost everything we as women have gained in the last century (including the radical notion that maybe, just maybe, husbands can feed themselves without having their wives to serve them) has resulted from action taken by women who didn't have the money, didn't have the time, didn't have the energy, didn't have the support, and who had kids to feed - but who did it anyway.

BlackCountryWench2 · 22/09/2021 11:59

I didn’t say that there were no working class suffragettes. What I was pointing out was that - much like XR and IB today - the extreme end of political activity was led or mainly perpetrated by the upper and middle class sections of the movement, who had the economic means to do so. Walking to Westminster and back on your day off is not the same as going on hunger strike when you would normally never be hungry, trying to give a leaflet to a jockey or chaining yourself to railings. I would never ever denigrate the contribution of working class women, but cannot for a second imagine my great-grandmother being able to leave her children uncared for, her husband not fed and the household being short of an income while she chained herself to some railings for a few days to make a political point, no matter how much she wanted the vote or believed in the movement. She was a munitions worker during the Great War, by the way.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 22/09/2021 11:09

Judge these folk on their own idiocy.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 22/09/2021 11:08

Anyway as mentioned by a pp it's rather an irrelevant point imo.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 22/09/2021 11:07

You have over interpreted my post of support for Wench's position archery Annie. I do know there were many working class suffragettes.
As to would we have had widening if suffrage without them. Imo yes.

ArcheryAnnie · 22/09/2021 11:02

SudokuWillNotSaveYou don't be so disingenuous - the links I set out were in reply to the ludicrous "first hand sources" post. And you didn't read what I linked to, did you?

And of course I know that Sylvia Pankhurst and Dora Montefiore were upper class (ah, yes, Montefiore, that traditional working class surname) - I named Sylvia's bloody sister as one of the ones who behaved very badly towards working-class suffragettes. But there presence doesn't magically disappear all the working-class suffragettes that the para - cd&pd from one of the links - describes. It's not a mystery why resources from the time are more likely to talk about (and name) the upper-class women involved. It's the same now, ffs!

None of your post changes that what BlackCountryWench and AGreenerShadeOfKale said about the suffragettes - that they were a movement of upper-class women, while working class women were too busy making nails in their back gardens, or whatever - isn't accurate or true.

Xenia · 22/09/2021 10:46

Comparisons to other groups is not relevant. These people are causing deaths and huge damage to lives and if the injunction does not work may be direct action from drivers to remove the people from the roads is another alternative - what is sauce for the goose etc.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 22/09/2021 10:43

Sigh. archeryannie posted her “you have to be kidding” comment before @BlackCountryWench2 said ANYTHING about classes in the suffragettes so this was 100% in response to not knowing history re: how women got the vote, that is the suffragettes changing tactic and the vote being granted after WW1, not due to militant demonstrations. @ArcheryAnnie You cannot now pretend your comment was after, and responding to her comment about upper class suffragettes.

The real question is: you throw out four names. Minnie Baldock “broke contact with the increasingly militant WSPU” years before women got the vote AND before WW1, so BlackCountryWrench2 isn’t wrong yet. During WW1, she was actually doing exactly what BCW2 mentioned so this was a TERRIBLE argument on your side. It’s on a “quick Google search” of her.

And it says right under Annie Kenney’s history:
“ At the outbreak of World War I in 1914, Emmeline Pankhurst called an end to suffragette militancy and urged the women to become actively involved in war work by taking on jobs that had traditionally been regarded as in the male preserve,[16] as most of those men were now absent at the front. This was set in train through the pages of The Suffragette, relaunched on 16 April 1915 with the slogan that it was 'a thousand times more the duty of the militant Suffragettes to fight the Kaiser for the sake of liberty than it was to fight anti-Suffrage Governments'. In autumn 1915 Kenney accompanied Emmeline Pankhurst, Flora Drummond, Norah Dacre Fox and Grace Roe to South Wales, the Midlands and Clydeside on a recruiting and lecture tour to encourage trade unions to support war work.[17] Kenney took her message as far afield as France and the United States.” So she supported exactly what BlackCountryWrench said. That a working class suffragette wasn’t out militantly demonstrating from 1914-1918.

The other two names you provided were upper class: Sylvia, daughter of Emmeline Pankhurst, and Dora Montefiore. Did you just not check?

So again, honestly, did you just decide to pick up on the working class bit when you were wrong about the WW1 part or what? And you picked two examples that don’t disprove your opponent’s point and then tell her she needs to educate herself more? Bad look.

ArcheryAnnie · 22/09/2021 10:11

"The first London branch of the WSPU was formed by the docks in Canning Town by Annie Kenney and local activist Minnie Baldock, along with Sylvia Pankhurst and Dora Montefiore. More branches soon opened in Poplar, Bow, Stepney and Limehouse. Most of the huge marches and demonstrations in London which put the WSPU in the headlines over the next few years were populated by working-class women from the East End, many of whom routinely gave up their only free day in the week to walk to Westminster and back."

Even the most cursory google will give you a ton of detail, including names, of working-class suffragettes. They formed the bulk of the WSPU. Yes, there were serious rifts with upper-class women leaders, some of whom behaved incredibly badly (looking at you, Christabel Pankhurst), but that doesn't diminish the work of these working-class suffragettes, just makes it even more remarkable what they achieved. Why are you so determined to erase these women from their own history?

eastendwomensmuseum.org/the-womens-hall

www.bl.uk/votes-for-women/articles/women-quite-unknown-working-class-women-in-the-suffrage-movement

AGreenerShadeofKale · 22/09/2021 09:54

I agree with what black country wench has written regarding suffrage.
In addition to reading historians I listened to my working class family growing up: first hand sources.

mum2jakie · 22/09/2021 09:50

Good news about the injunction!

Anonymouseposter · 22/09/2021 09:20

Good, National Highways have been granted an injunction against them and they could face imprisonment.
They are indeed a menace and are putting people off what are valid issues.
Interesting to read that middle class baby boomers are to blame on the one hand but that mainly old people use the M25 on the other hand and boomers don't care about the environment.
In any case it's counterproductive and stupid to protest by causing people massive inconvenience and sometimes severe harm.

ArcheryAnnie · 22/09/2021 08:54

BlackCountryWench you really do need to learn a bit more history, especially working class history.

mum2jakie · 22/09/2021 08:54

That Liam bloke they had on GMB this morning hasn't done much to promote their cause! What an absolutely patronising hypocritical knob!! He needs be the first in jail for inciting terrorism

LoislovesStewie · 22/09/2021 06:51

@BlackCountryWench2

Sorry, had to add: upper class and middle class women taking part in hunger strikes, bombs and throwing themselves at racehorses. Working class women were too busy making chains and nails in their back yards, raising children, running households and then (1914-18) working in munitions factories. In war time, the government had to rely on women to keep the country running. That’s what gave us the vote. Not middle class suffragettes.
You are absolutely correct. World War 1 got all adults the vote, not hunger strikes etc. BTW I think it is also important to acknowledge that not all men had the vote at this time, and they were the ones who were more likely to be cannon fodder.
BlackCountryWench2 · 21/09/2021 23:14

Sorry, had to add: upper class and middle class women taking part in hunger strikes, bombs and throwing themselves at racehorses. Working class women were too busy making chains and nails in their back yards, raising children, running households and then (1914-18) working in munitions factories. In war time, the government had to rely on women to keep the country running. That’s what gave us the vote. Not middle class suffragettes.

BlackCountryWench2 · 21/09/2021 23:05

Yes. You don’t seriously believe that hunger strikes, bombs and running at racehorses got women the vote, do you?

LobsterNapkin · 21/09/2021 22:49

What really seems crazy is that this is the kind of thing that in the bigger picture, makes people support limits on protests. If they carry on with these bad decisions all they are going to find is that soon they will be much more restricted in what they can do.

user1471447863 · 21/09/2021 22:45

There was a good video online of a burly chap helping a couple of protestors to move to a position of safety at the side of the road so they wouldn't get knocked down and the police were stopping him!
Blocking a motorway like the M25 is a hugely dangerous thing to do - not for the twats sitting at the front but for the people caught in the hours of delays. People unable to get to hospital. Infants stuck in car seats far exceeding recommend safe time guidance. Knock on delays and accidents on diversion routes.
Those entitled twats should have been told to move then arrested and forcibly moved upon refusal and the road reopened. The kind of delays and disruption they caused cost real lives today whereas their campaign surrounds hypothetical lives at some indeterminate time in the future.
If they have real conviction in their message I suggest they block access to a football stadium on a match day and see how well they get on.

ArcheryAnnie · 21/09/2021 22:27

You've got to be kidding, BlackCountryWench? You can't seriously believe that?

BlackCountryWench2 · 21/09/2021 19:23

@StorageIngredients

This particular situation is tragic and of course can't be condoned, but protest is supposed to be disruptive, inconveniencing the public the only way we've ever manged to force government to act. Teacher's strikes, for example, are effective when the public requires that government "do something".

Would women have the vote if the Suffragettes had played nice?

Yes. Suffragettes gained votes for women exactly for this, playing nice and supporting the war effort. They never would have achieved it had they stuck to their terrorism tactics. It turned many of the most sympathetic in society and politics completely against them.
BlackberrySky · 21/09/2021 17:20

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

If you watch how they get onto the motorway it’s a joke- the police practically escort them onto it- if they actually had to run infront of 70mph cars and lorries no way would they do it.
Oh wow, I had no idea. Makes me hate them even more.
mogsrus · 21/09/2021 17:10

Whatever these idiots do,nothing is going to change by next week,if at all

Swipe left for the next trending thread