Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Insulate Britain are an absolute menace…

288 replies

Flawedperfection · 20/09/2021 08:24

Just that really. Currently listening to LBC radio.
And they should be held to account for the death of the woman last week who couldn’t reach an hospital for 6 hours, following what would normally have been a much shorter journey. An oncologist also couldn’t get to work, where she was surely urgently needed.
I understand they have a message, but what if they do more help than good?
What do you think?

OP posts:
LoislovesStewie · 24/09/2021 09:25

I shouldn't worry about cars causing pollution; at this rate we won't have any petrol in a short while. Then we will have food shortages, and we will starve to death.(After the riots etc that will inevitably break out)

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 07:58

If clean air is so essential why are your lot causing cars to idle on the M25?

I didn't realise that lying on the M25 caused clean air. I must redo my science GCSE.

Knobs.

As I said. You and the virtue signalling idiots are irrelevant. You are like children who have been given an important 'job' by a parent who's had enough of you.

LOOK at ME. I'm HELPING.

The real work is being done by others. You just want to take the credit when people more proactive than you find the practical solutions to the problems.

ArcheryAnnie · 24/09/2021 01:35

Cars are essential in the current world we live in

Breathable air is essential in the current world we live in.

A temperature that isn't too high to support agricultural and mammalian life is essential in the current world we live in.

If you are OK with death and destruction being caused by things you think are "essential" (even though many people disagree with you), then why shouldn't others think the same way about defending what they think is essential?

user1471447863 · 23/09/2021 21:04

@MercyBooth thanks for posting that GMB interview, that guy is a rip roaring bell end. He definitely gets this year's award for worst campaign spokesperson. He did them no favours what so ever. He had zero credibility what so ever, completely unable to think on his feet and reverted to is couple of prepared rant points. He wasn't even dressed to convey any credibility. He looked and behaved like someone who should have been loitering around a university campus selling copies of the socialist worker.
As much as I don't care for Richard Madley I was quite impressed with how he stuck into him and tore him apart. All 3 of them did in fact. I think if he hadn't walked off Richard would have have told him to get off in the end

AGreenerShadeofKale · 23/09/2021 19:13

Well said Belle.

lioncitygirl · 23/09/2021 19:13

They are absolutely bloody stupid idiots. I wish they would put them all in jail or something. That poor woman.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 19:10

If the planet is to be saved it will be by scientists, driving to work everyday to come up with energy efficient solutions.

By farmers adapting their practice.

By the government financially rewarding the above methods.

Idiots causing pile ups don't figure. That's just your ego talking.
You are insignificant.
People are working on it. They'll do it without you, but they'll probably get in done quicker without money and resources being used up on pointless, dangerous stunts.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 19:01

Cars are essential in the current world we live in.
Feel free to build infrastructure to support people not to use one.
At the moment that's not the world we live in, nor do this terrorist groups actions bring us closer to that world.
Currently lying on the motorway like a cunt doesn't put food on the table.
Driving to work does.
Therefore it's not equivalent.

But yeah, I'm the hypocrite.
Enjoy your bacon sandwich in your 4x4 though, won't you.

nottoday3000 · 23/09/2021 18:57

I surprised the people haven't got out of their cars and moved them or tried to, I know my partner would....he would be arrested while they sit on the m25 ...it's terrifying watching them imagine your children in the car while everyone stops suddenly it's murderous

LemonSwan · 23/09/2021 18:55

A doctor that smokes, that tells you to give up because it’s going to kill you, is still right

Its not like that though is it.

Its like a partner being physically, financially and emotionally abusive to you because you smoke and they want you to stop, but they haven't bothered quitting themselves.

ArcheryAnnie · 23/09/2021 18:45

until they endanger people's lives with their hypocrisy

Belle you've already said, in essence, that you don't care that people die because of car use (either die directly, or because of illnesses caused, or because of contributing to climate change, which is already killing people now), because in your view car use is "essential".

Glass houses / stones.

sst1234 · 23/09/2021 18:06

@Lostmarbles2021

Where is your 1% figure from?

My point is there is still a huge amount we could do. And we aren’t. And we won’t until it is enshrined in policy and legislation. The government haven’t done that. They haven’t listened for years. My point is. Direct action and civil disobedience is the only option left. Which is why I support it.

Look it up, that is UK contribution to global emissions.

Still not answered the question (not that you are obliged to), what difference does it make whatever we do in this country. Yes it might make people feel better, but what difference does it make to global emissions.

Lostmarbles2021 · 23/09/2021 17:57

Where is your 1% figure from?

My point is there is still a huge amount we could do. And we aren’t. And we won’t until it is enshrined in policy and legislation. The government haven’t done that. They haven’t listened for years. My point is. Direct action and civil disobedience is the only option left. Which is why I support it.

sst1234 · 23/09/2021 17:47

@Lostmarbles2021

You use a lot of words and I am sure you mean well, but what’s your point? This do something rhetoric means what exactly? We could get to 0 emissions, it still wouldn’t change anything, we account for less than 1% of global emissions.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 17:32

@Bythemillpond

Lostmarbles2021

So tell me why if Insulate Britain and XR are so worried about climate change do all their protests involve making things worse.

Why do their protests seem to always add to the problem of climate change rather than help it.

Oh I got this one

It is spool bad you plebs don't understand. The environmental damage of stopping the motorway traffic is a drop in the ocean if we don't act now. No we don't know what needs to be done. That's for someone else to work out. But something needs to be done. Just not by me. And yesterday is not soon enough. No, we know people are working on the solutions, but it's not soon enough so everything we do is justified and not wankerish. Sigh. Holds children.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 17:24

I don't judge anyone for the choices they make- until they endanger people's lives with their hypocrisy.
Nice to know you are committing to the lifestyle, however, in my mind this just puts you in the naive rather than self serving catagory. We have solar panels by the way and they do come with their own environmental problems by the way. Hopefully the technology is improving. This will be down to people working on them in the industry though and not idiots super glueing themselves to lorries.
I've suggested several times what could be done. Personally I would be thrilled to vote for a party that centres the environment. Yet if I'm asked to give up women's safety and dignity to do so it's a hard no from me. If the greens had stuck to their remit they wouldn't be haemorrhaging their traditional voters like me. It's really not that hard.

Or funding alternatives. Again, something people could do.

Dress it up all you want but it's terrorist tactics. Fine if you want to support it, but don't be fooled. It's not the moral high ground you think it is.

Bythemillpond · 23/09/2021 17:17

Lostmarbles2021

So tell me why if Insulate Britain and XR are so worried about climate change do all their protests involve making things worse.

Why do their protests seem to always add to the problem of climate change rather than help it.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 17:13

Ok let's say the spirit of eco future visits Boris Johnson in a dream.
He vows to commit to zero emissions by tomorrow.
Bans cars. Pulls planes. Bans meat. Bans uninsulated houses.
What then? Do any of these lobby groups have a plan. An infrastructure?
No. They have nothing.
See the cole mines above. They need steel for our eco alternative. They're calling for changes to be made but have no alternative.
That's busy work for someone else to do. Grunt work is far too important for these ideological protesters.

As an above poster says, there's no substance to anything they demand or advocate for.

Lostmarbles2021 · 23/09/2021 17:12

Obviously this needs to be a global effort but it’s no use sticking as we are and pointing the finger at countries with worse emissions. We only have control over our own actions, individually and as a country. We can, and must, lead by example.

Belle, ok, you’ve sucked me into a tit for tat...we personally are plant based, don’t fly, drive electric etc. Etc. Everything we can do, we are doing. Not everyone can do all that we do and I don’t judge those who can’t. I don’t even judge those that can and don’t because that’s just being human. As a family, we are also constantly working towards doing more - eg solar panels. One of our core values is to reduce our carbon footprint so we strive to do that. We are most definitely not perfect though. But that’s not the point. The point is that decades of doing it ‘the right way’ have failed, so what choice is left?

I’m not personally an activist (it’s something I’m not able to do at the moment but would if I was retired and DC grown up) but I am now (didn’t use to be in terms of climate change) pro direct action and civil disobedience, because, time has run out and we have no choice but to change. Until there is legislation and government action people will keep doing what they do. We can’t rely on individual change.

Lots of people refused to use energy saving light bulbs until they were legislated against. Just one example. Lots of people are queuing up to get back to their holidays abroad. People are still buying unnecessary SUVs. People are still eating factory farmed foods. People are still buying unnecessary clothes. Etc etc etc. And of course they are. Why would people change? Why would people voluntarily give up their creature comforts and lovely holidays. It’s bloody hard. I ache to go and lie on a beach somewhere hot. I’d love to see the parts of the world that excite me. It’s only because I speak regularly to people that know a lot more about climate change than I do that I’ve changed these behaviours and made difficult sacrifices.

The science is telling us, beyond doubt, that our current ways are creating climate change, which is already killing people and is worse even than predicted.

Inaction is not an option. Individual change is not enough. Governments need to legislate and build it in to policies that are likely to be unpopular. They haven’t. Not even in the face of incontrovertible evidence and public pressure. What campsigners have been doing hasn’t changed this. Everything else has been tried over decades.

So I ask again. What else can people do? ... What else can people do?

The choice now is - civil disobedience (everything else has been tried for decades, the government and current laws don’t protect us and don’t care for us as is needed and they are unjust - so this is now reasonable action to take) or nothing.

I fully support those that are choosing to do something. It’s a moral necessity now sadly. Sad

sst1234 · 23/09/2021 16:29

@Lostmarbles2021

Belle we could get into a tit for tat in terms of what each of us is doing but I fear I would win that battle. We have been steadily changing our habits for years. But that’s not the point.

Whatever your views of the Green Party, it has been tried.

Yes there are people working with the government and good on them if they are genuinely making a difference, but this needs to be a world wide, legislated effort.

Just recently the Government have been umming and erring on whether to open a new coal mine.

The pursuit of money has to stop trumping climate chaos. We can’t eat money. We can’t cool ourselves with money. We can’t re-establish extinct species with money.

Until governments listen, I can see no alternative to civil disobedience and direct action. Everything has been tried already and we don’t have time to waste now. This is urgent. Innocent people, many of them, are already dying.

What is your point? It’s all just abstract statements. What difference do these virtuous statements make if China and US are not on board. It’s just white noise, or it was until people started to be harmed by environmental extremists.
sst1234 · 23/09/2021 16:26

@ArcheryAnnie

A doctor that smokes, that tells you to give up because it’s going to kill you, is still right

You've absolutely nailed it.

Missing the point massively.

The smokers are largely based in China and US. The ‘doctor’ is telling us to hold our breath and stop breathing so we don’t passively smoke. The ‘doctor’ is stupid and should not be let loose to tell anyone anything.

Lostmarbles2021 · 23/09/2021 16:05

BelleOfTheProvince

Mystic Meg is wrong.

Stormsy · 23/09/2021 15:37

Whilst I don't necessarily agree with how they doing it, i do think good for them for having the balls and tenacity to try and get change. This country is so passive these days we'll be living under a dictatorship before we know it.

ArcheryAnnie · 23/09/2021 15:13

Well, if they are essential, then does that mean that the recklessness of too many people who drive them, or the lung damage of children growing up near main roads, or the environmental damage which affects us all, is just fine?

You seem to be saying that because a lot of people think (erroneously or not) that cars are absolutely necessary, then the collateral damage, because it wasn't the primary purpose of driving the cars, doesn't matter.

Well, whether we personally agree with the style of protests or not, it's very clear that the protesters think (erroneously or not) the protests are absolutely necessary, and the collateral damage, because it wasn't the primary purpose of the protests - well, does that matter, or not?

If you can think intent matters, and personal assessment of "essential" matters, then so can they.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/09/2021 15:06

No. Cars are an essential for the majority of people outside London.
And yes, if motorists were deliberately ramming pedestrians to make a point, then maybe you'd have a point. But they don't do they.
That protest was not essential.
The world will continue to find eco solutions without your virtue signalling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread