Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Insulate Britain are an absolute menace…

288 replies

Flawedperfection · 20/09/2021 08:24

Just that really. Currently listening to LBC radio.
And they should be held to account for the death of the woman last week who couldn’t reach an hospital for 6 hours, following what would normally have been a much shorter journey. An oncologist also couldn’t get to work, where she was surely urgently needed.
I understand they have a message, but what if they do more help than good?
What do you think?

OP posts:
PaperhouseLegs · 20/09/2021 13:04

It's just ridiculously counterproductive and I don't know how they can't see it. Instead of garnering support from the general public with well informed campaigns actually spelling out what they want to achieve, they carry out these stupid stunts. Yes, it enables them to get a headline news appearance, but not in a good way. None of their actual cause objectives are being featured, just photos of them chucking paint, gluing themselves to roads and getting into fights with the public. Oh, and articles on the members personal life and how they don't actually practise what they preach!

Moonmelodies · 20/09/2021 13:03

It's difficult to insulate more houses when you can't get the materials delivered.

Bythemillpond · 20/09/2021 12:56

Their founder says stopping people getting to work will get the attention they need

I am sure they will get attention but probably it will just be turning people off doing anything. I wonder how many vehicles didn’t turn their engine off whilst waiting for the blockage to be cleared.
Why do all these protests about climate change involve more pollution being added to the atmosphere.
These type of “protests” could have done so much if they had gone at it with the attitude to show people different ways they can help and get on board with changing the world.

People respond more to pleasantness.
Putting peoples backs up is going to get you no where.

I saw an article about a guy in the recent XR protests who had chained himself to a lorry wheel. He said he did it because he wanted people to think why had he chained himself to a lorry wheel and then ask him why.

I think most people just thought a**ehole and stepped over him.

Mickarooni · 20/09/2021 12:50

@2point7degrees

Fair point, my apologies. Most people are not old, they’re commuting people. I do care about the environment. I more care that I sat in my car polluting it further while these people glued themselves to rails, waiting precious police resources. I do a job driving to attend to people who are vulnerable. I wasn’t delighted that I was prevented from that.

LeafOfTruth · 20/09/2021 12:43

As the risk of sounding like I support IB (I don't - I don't pay them a huge amount of attention), it occurs to me that every effective (and some non-effective) activist group since the dawn of time has been

a) disruptive
b) described negatively for it

The suffragettes were accused using similar language to that used here. Called terrorists, accused of causing millions of pounds worth of damage and risking/taking lives with their bombs.

Sometimes the current generation is not best placed to judge what is reasonable and what isn't - plus, progress is only made by unreasonable men and all that. So my distaste for IB may be right or may just be a product of my generation.

None of these ‘activists’ can ever answer the question - what is the point in this virtue signalling when UK has less than 1% of global carbon emissions? Really what difference does it make?

1% is too high no? There are 195 countries in the world and the UK is a small one compared to some. Using a crude measure 1/195 of the carbon emissions would be 0.5% so 1% would appear to be more than 'our fair share' iyswim.

lonelyapple · 20/09/2021 12:39

Why aren't the police arresting them and heavily fining them? If these were lockdown protestors the police wouldn't be treating them with kid gloves. Why is there seemingly a two-tier policing system for the middle class wokesters vs working class protestors?

D0gg0G00d · 20/09/2021 12:39

Lots of schemes already exist for free or subsidised insulation & for installation of central heating

Better ways to protest than closing the M25 surely ?

SoupDragon · 20/09/2021 12:35

I mean, they're all older than 16 but that's not what you meant I assume

purpleboy · 20/09/2021 12:34

I didn't hear the interview Is the women who died the same one that had the stroke and couldn't get to hospital in time? They should be prosecuted for manslaughter. Bastards

SoupDragon · 20/09/2021 12:34

@2point7degrees

Umm what?!! Only older people commute on the M25? What on earth makes you say that?

I could pretend I thought this was an honest attempt to understand the point and give a response to elaborate, but given you've immediately resorted to changing the word "most" to "only" to create a strawman it is far too evident that you have no genuine interest in understand any point of view other than your own.

It's still ridiculous to say that "most" people on the M25 are older.
FanFckingTastic · 20/09/2021 12:28

It's disgusting. I actually think it's counterproductive too - people are more interested in the horrible things that they are doing rather than the message behind it which is sad. I don't want to hear a word that they have to say about insulation, climate change or whatever else, not because of the subject matter but because of the way that they are going about it. Why are they not protesting outside the Chinese or US embassies? That wouldn't have resulted in the the death of the poor women who couldn't reach the hospital in time, the four way pile up that resulted in at least one person having to be airlifted to hospital with serious injuries or the hardship for the countless hardworking people that they delayed. I'm presuming that the Co2 emissions are actually worse as a result of all the cars idling on the motorway too.

OrangutanLibrarian · 20/09/2021 12:26

@RedToothBrush

I have a friend who is a supporter. His posts on FB are getting more ridiculous.

This week he has posted about people having their freedoms removed for being unvaccinated. Then about these numpties.

Now I generally support the right not to be vaccinated, but his attitude made me think 'oh for god sake'. And I couldn't help but think about the insulate guys and how new build properties have issues with lack of ventilation and over heating because they are almost over insulated. And again its his attitude.

Basically he is an anti-establishmentarian rather than particularly having beliefs. He is a 40 something year old rebel. And his attitude is hostile and alienating and is liable to damage the causes he supports rather than encourage awareness.

I've known him years and he's really well meaning but totally clueless about how to encourage people to get on board with his causes.

Ironically I broadly support what he thinks, but he has this ability to make it annoying and want to say the opposite!!!

They would do better by learning how to better communicate with people. But then I suspect it wouldn't get them the attention or drama they seek as part of the lifestyle and being able to say they hate the state.

Cos thats what I really think its about - and if they weren't protesting about this, they'd simply be on a different bandwagon.

Nice guy, just looking for a purpose and cause in life.

Do you mean he’s complaining about people having their freedoms removed and doesn’t think that should happen?
seaandsandcastles · 20/09/2021 12:24

Ridiculous. Chuck them all in prison, the same as they should with Extinction Rebellion.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 20/09/2021 12:22

@HarrietsChariot

They're scum, there's no other word. Well, there are lots of less polite ones I suppose.

When XR were on the rampage a few years back I made a committment not to recycle anything for a year and largely managed it for a long while, though I've gradually slipped back into doing it because of the convenience factor. I also used to leave the taps running as much as possible.

I don't really want to start that nonsense again but this road-blocking bullshit has angered me every bit as much as the XR twats disrupting public transport, so I think I will have to.

I know wasting water and not recycling aren't exactly what "Insulate Britain" are protesting about but it feels like the only action I can reasonably take. At least it's sticking two fingers up to the environmentalist thugs in a general sense.

Some things are easier, I try to buy things that have a lot of "food miles" and processed stuff because often they're cheaper than buying local/organic stuff.

Sorry..... what? Like actually, WTF?

Are people really as childish and ridiculous as this?

You can disagree with XR and IB's methods - I totally get that, but how exactly do you think your actions are helping?

I can only conclude that a lot of people are idiotic shits, if they think this is acceptable behaviour for an adult

Porridgeislife · 20/09/2021 12:14

In isolation, they’ve got a point. UK homes are poorly insulated relative to other equally cold, wet countries and properly insulating homes would not only decrease carbon emissions, it would decrease housing poverty as those least able to afford it would see their bills come down/quality of life improve in dry, warm homes.

However, stopping traffic on the M25 and causing anything from delay to death for ordinary working people is the most perplexing way I can think of to make an environmental point.

2point7degrees · 20/09/2021 12:12

Umm what?!! Only older people commute on the
M25? What on earth makes you say that?

I could pretend I thought this was an honest attempt to understand the point and give a response to elaborate, but given you've immediately resorted to changing the word "most" to "only" to create a strawman it is far too evident that you have no genuine interest in understand any point of view other than your own.

Mickarooni · 20/09/2021 12:07

@2point7degrees

“ Turn who off their case? Most likely most people on the M25 are older people with a majority view that they'll probably be dead or near the end by the time the worst consequences of climate change really set in.”

Umm what?!! Only older people commute on the
M25? What on earth makes you say that?

Imnotafemistbut · 20/09/2021 12:07

The Hollywood-level sense of entitlement they assume in believing that that have the moral right to disrupt the lives or ordinary people is utterly repugnant.

I really despise them

Mickarooni · 20/09/2021 12:05

They’re selfish shits and turning everyone off their important message. Stopping normal every day people getting to work is harming their cause. I think they enjoy attention seeking especially those who bloody commuted from other parts of England to waste police time and resources by glueing themselves to railings. I mean, that’s bizarre.

EvenRosesHaveThorns · 20/09/2021 12:04

@HarrietsChariot

They're scum, there's no other word. Well, there are lots of less polite ones I suppose.

When XR were on the rampage a few years back I made a committment not to recycle anything for a year and largely managed it for a long while, though I've gradually slipped back into doing it because of the convenience factor. I also used to leave the taps running as much as possible.

I don't really want to start that nonsense again but this road-blocking bullshit has angered me every bit as much as the XR twats disrupting public transport, so I think I will have to.

I know wasting water and not recycling aren't exactly what "Insulate Britain" are protesting about but it feels like the only action I can reasonably take. At least it's sticking two fingers up to the environmentalist thugs in a general sense.

Some things are easier, I try to buy things that have a lot of "food miles" and processed stuff because often they're cheaper than buying local/organic stuff.

You're as twisted in the head as they are... Why the fuck should the selfish actions of a tiny minority stop you recycling?
2point7degrees · 20/09/2021 12:04

Yep annoying ordinary people will get them attention, but also massively turn people off their cause which seems exceptionally counter productive

Turn who off their case? Most likely most people on the M25 are older people with a majority view that they'll probably be dead or near the end by the time the worst consequences of climate change really set in - massive frequent natural disasters, widescale food and resource shortages and wars to name a few. Older generations have shown for long enough that collectively they don't give a shit and will happily leave younger generations to a horrific fate, why should anyone who cares about climate change care if these people are inconvenienced?

More beneficial for climate change than the single issue of isolating British homes is the contribution and added momentum to increasingly disruptive activism amongst younger groups across the world to actually take climate change seriously, because asking nicely and increasingly bleak scientific reports are making bugger all difference.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 20/09/2021 12:03

Selfish fuckers. Perhaps if they put their efforts into coming up with a way to enable travel without the pollution I’d have some respect for them.

LemonFantaGin · 20/09/2021 11:53

Same with most protests and strikes, they target the wrong people and lose support,creating more pollution as they go.

NotSure94 · 20/09/2021 11:52

There's different ways to cause disruption though isn't there?

The cleverest protests hit those in power hard but don't harm those without. Like the rail strikes I read about once - not sure where but it was abroad - where the staff just opened the barriers and let the people travel for free in protest. Actually benefited those without the power and hit the company in the wallet.

Those poor delivery drivers stuck in that will have got their arses kicked for missing drops and like OP said, harm to health even death caused by disruption. But Jeff Bezos and Boris Johnson probably went about their day not even noticing!

It's a clumsy way to get a headline with a side order of pissing off thousands of people.

katemuff · 20/09/2021 11:51

I have a very old friend who has been swept into this movement. It is like a cult, no room for descent or individual thinking. There is usually a man at the top and he styles himself as 'the only person who knows the truth'. It is terrifying when someone you love is trapped in one of these groups. She has given up all her possessions including her phone and doesn't speak to her family or friends any more. The thinking is black and white, no room for any discussion. It's very dark.