Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I say sth to the football coach about this sub arrangement

56 replies

midnightOK · 19/09/2021 22:20

DS joined a football club since May. He likes football though I have to say his performance is just ok, not great. Everytime he went for a training or match, he would like me to watch him. I rarely got time to watch it. However in these few times I did watch him, he was rarely in the field, was often in the subs. This morning the match started at 12:00, by the time I had to leave, which was 12:30, he was still sitting aside and waiting for his turn to go in the match. Later on when I picked him up, I asked him how long he had been playing, he said probably 10 mins. He might not be accurate about the time he was in the match, however it is clear that some kids were in the match from start to the end and my son was only in it for a very short time. Should I talk about it with the football coach? I don't think this is fair. It's supposed to be roughly equal time for every kid to be in the match, is that right?

OP posts:
McT123 · 20/09/2021 07:47

I have three children who have all played football and have also managed and coached a team. I am an FA qualified coach.

My first son was very enthusiastic but not very good and used to be played for only a few minutes at the end of the game or not at all. I asked him if he wanted to move to a different club but he wanted to stay with his friends. I didn't say anything to the manager but wish that I had - I would now. At the age of 11, he was told that he was no longer wanted for the team as they had recruited some new, better players.

He moved to another, less victory-focused club and played much more, partly because he was no longer the least accomplished player and partly because the coaches were much more aware of giving each player a fair amount of game time.

I eventually took over the team as manager and coach and told all parents and coaches that it would be my aim to give each player at least half a game of playing time. I often had 5 substitutes and was also trying to win games so I had to try not to let the team become too weak or unbalanced - it was more difficult to do than I had expected. We had rolling substitutes so I literally made a chart for each game to make sure that each player got a fair amount of game time. This was not universally liked by the parents - the parents of some of the better players didn't like that their children didn't play more and that we sometimes lost games that we could have won if I had not played the weaker players (the kids were perfectly happy with the system) - but over all it worked well and I was proud to have given boys who loved football but were not great players an opportunity. Ironically, by this point, my son had grown, got faster and stronger and would have played a full game every game if he had stayed with his previous team.

My second son joined a team that stated at the start of each season: "we are trying to win every game and we will pick the team accordingly." My son was one of the fringe players and didn't get to play much but he enjoyed the training and so was content to stay, particularly as he knew at the start of each season what the situation was.

Personally I believe that outside of professional clubs' academies (and that is a whole different world) all sports teams should encourage all players to reach their full potential whatever their ability; unfortunately there are too many parents involved who focus solely on their child and can make the lives of the coaches very uncomfortable, there are too many coaches who don't realise that their main purpose is to allow and encourage their players to benefit from exercise and being part of a team and that winning, whilst an important goal, is secondary to that.

My advice to the OP is to talk to the coach. If the coach says that winning is the priority and the needs of each individual have to cede to that: find another team or sport.

My advice to all other parents is to ask the coach or manager before the start of the season whether they intend to give each player a decent amount of playing time (it doesn't have to be equal for everyone, just more than a token 5 minutes) and then decide whether to join a team based on that information.

Mermaidpool · 20/09/2021 07:21

I would ask some other parents what the rule is regarding subs. Ds plays rugby and the rfu have the half game rule for all players up to u16. I have no idea if football has similar but I would fund out before approaching the coach about it

Roseshavethorns · 20/09/2021 07:18

It depends on the type of club they are playing for. If the club are very serious and play lots of competitive tournaments then the coach will have a core team of the strongest players and the rest will be subs and will have to break through to become part of the core. This happens naturally as the older players move up an age grade.
At 11 the more serious players that are hoping to be "spotted" take it incredibly seriously and spend all their time practising skills outside of training. If this is the type of club your ds plays for then I would not approach the coach to ask that he get more playing time.
If it is playing for fun and not really competitive then there is no harm in approaching the coach although I would perhaps say that I could only stay for the part of the match and ask him to put ds on earlier in the match. That way you are gently bringing ds to his attention without questioning his judgement (coaches don't like that).
In my experience the "everyone gets a chance" ethos dies out by the age of 8 as that is when professional clubs start watching players (my ds was approached at age 7).

isitweds9thseptyet · 20/09/2021 07:16

My DS team get equal time to the minute. And fair rotation around attack and defence. They also only get play minutes if they turn up to training.

This means his team is not the most competitive but is very inclusive and my son is learning about more then just football by watching this work:

However, i notice massive variation when you watch the matches of how the other teams work. Many kids come to my sons team after being treat badly at other teams.

So do a little digging and find out whats going on elsewhere too.

Some teams are so competitive the not so good ones get put on 'training only'.

Lucyccfc68 · 20/09/2021 07:08

@Kite22

It is FA Guidelines that players should get equal game time at that age. It is non competitive up to U12s

Can you link to that please @Lucyccfc68 as that hasn't been my experience so I tried searching but couldn't find anything that said that.

www.thefa.com/-/media/thefacom-new/files/get-involved/youth-football/youth-football-the-fa-position-statements.ashx
Paq · 20/09/2021 06:24

Unfortunately football is one of the worst sports for inclusion. Talk to the coach by all means but be prepared for disappointment.

backtolifebacktoreality · 20/09/2021 06:19

@midnightOK

"They are 11 years old.*"
*
My son was in a team prior to this age. Realistically he wasn't the best but he enjoyed playing and their manager brought all kids on for a reasonable amount of time.

However. around this age the matches start to be taken more seriously and he was literally brought on for a few minutes at the end.

It started upsetting him and became humiliating to be sat on the bench all match, so we pulled him from the team.
We explained the reason to the manager, who didn't deny what was happening!

Kite22 · 19/09/2021 23:46

It is FA Guidelines that players should get equal game time at that age. It is non competitive up to U12s

Can you link to that please @Lucyccfc68 as that hasn't been my experience so I tried searching but couldn't find anything that said that.

Kite22 · 19/09/2021 23:39

My experience has generally been that kids of ‘pushy’ parents get treated better and get more opportunities than kids of parents who ‘put up and shut up’. I’ve learned to push and advocate for my child as otherwise she’s often overlooked, due to being quiet and well behaved and not demanding etc.

Not my experience in any of the multitude of things any of my dc have been involved in over the last 20+ years.

is it basically a lesson with opportunities for everyone to play and improve, or is it a competitive match with only the best being played

I presume it won't be either of these. It is likely to be a competitive match, each week, with opportunities for substitutions, and some matches against stronger teams and some against teams known to be weaker, when there will be more opportunities for the weaker players to play more. The matches will be across 9 months or so, and there will be chances for all to play. There will no doubt be lessons learned from playing in matches, but most of the learning will be during the training sessions.

Lucyccfc68 · 19/09/2021 23:19

It is FA guidelines that players should get equal game time at that age. It is non competitive up to U12’s.

It should not be about winning or who is the best player or the (perceived) best player being annoyed at other players getting equal time.

A good coach will have an ethos of developing all players, instilling a positive attitude and ensuring everyone is having fun. It’s grassroots football and to be fair, no matter how much ‘practise’ a player puts in, in their back garden, it’s still grassroots and not a professional academy.

I would move your son to a club with a coach with a better attitude.

Skysblue · 19/09/2021 23:12

I’d ask the coach what the deal is: is it basically a lesson with opportunities for everyone to play and improve, or is it a competitive match with only the best being played. Just say you’re trying to work out if it’s a fit. Doesn’t have to sound like a complaint but if your son is on the bench the whole time, so the stars of the team can guarantee a win, not much point in his being there is there, and it sounds really bad for his self esteem.

My experience has generally been that kids of ‘pushy’ parents get treated better and get more opportunities than kids of parents who ‘put up and shut up’. I’ve learned to push and advocate for my child as otherwise she’s often overlooked, due to being quiet and well behaved and not demanding etc.

Restlessinthenorth · 19/09/2021 23:06

Honestly, there really is no turn taking at this age, and it sets the wrong example to your son. Simply turning up in life doesn't guarantee you opportunity. You get a place on the team by earning it at that age.

My son is out in the garden every night practicing and as a result has developed his skills and has a place in his team. Him and other kids like him wold be mortified if other kids were given equal time. Like everything in life, places in competitive teams are given by merit. The other kids would soon get sick of your son if the team starts losing because he's on the pitch when betters players are sat on a subs bench too.

It's really good he wants to keep going though, so I would be absolutely encouraging lots of practice outside of the match day and affirming his effort etc.

Invisimamma · 19/09/2021 23:05

My son is nearly 11 and has been playing with his club since he was 8. New and inexpierneced players will get less time on the pitch than the boys who have been training and playing together for years.

It also depends on the league and level that they are playing at. We are only allowed to make 2 subs per match according to league rules, so weaker player won't be subbed on until last quarter. Also different teams have different ethos, some are more nurturing and spread game time evenly and others are 'in it to win it.' Maybe this club isn't the best match for him?

Piggy42 · 19/09/2021 23:02

Maybe your son needs to find a lower division club to play for, so he gets more game time. I think it’s quite normal. My dd gets played a lot in football but found she was often on the subs bench at another sport.

Kite22 · 19/09/2021 22:59

By 11, they are playing competitively, so no, it isn't about 'turn taking' at that age. The best coaches will roll subs on and off in response to how the game is evolving, but no, I wouldn't expect players to get equal time by aged 11.

I had assumed you must have been talking about 6 yr olds.

RobertaFirmino · 19/09/2021 22:58

This is going to sound harsh but there is a reason your son is on the subs bench and not the starting XI. You admit yourself that his performance is just ok, not great.

If DS has a look on You Tube, he'll find plenty of skills videos from the top clubs.

m00rfarm · 19/09/2021 22:55

THe players know who are best and at that age will start being a bit pissy with the less good players if they are given games and cause the team to lose. THat is not good either. Hopefully there will be some tournaments soon which mean that all the boys can get a few games.

MerryMarigold · 19/09/2021 22:49

My husband is a coach and would play his under 11s like this. The issue is that you can give everyone equal time and lose matches or play your best players and hope to win. The team gets discouraged if they lose match after match. The practice sessions are there to improve, but some kids have been playing longer or are just more talented so it's hard to take a decent player off and replace with someone not so good, especially if you are losing or drawing. Of course if you're winning 5-0 after 10 mins, you can afford to swap in all the worse players!

AmyDeirdre · 19/09/2021 22:49

They split our team into 2 so the children would get more game time, but this meant they needed more parent volunteers to help with the teams. Have you offered to help out, OP? Here, anyway, the coaches are all volunteers giving up (a lot) of their own time and doing their best.

Hellocatshome · 19/09/2021 22:42

At that age they are supposed to get equal playing time but that is not equal in each match it is equal across the season so some games they might get littlentimr, other games they get the whole match. I think without you watching the matches or training regularly you are going to find it hard to query this with the coach as you haven't really got much evidence to go on, for example a child that messes around at training will often not get to start the next match etc. Could you or another adult watch some full training sessions and matches and get a proper understanding of what is going on?

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 19/09/2021 22:42

This is where football is so different to rugby-everyone gets 50% off match time and that’s the RFU rules-this really encourages everyone to have a go and they get better as a result. You can’t improve if you’re never played🤷‍♀️

ilovesooty · 19/09/2021 22:39

Does he know what he needs to do to develop and improve?

midnightOK · 19/09/2021 22:38

@gabsdot45

My son had the same experience. He was small for his age plus a December birthday made him one of the youngest too. He was a decent player but there were other boys bigger and stronger so they got the play much more than he did. I ended up hating the whole thing, the competitiveness, swearing, abusing the refferee and the other team, making kids cry and I'm talking about the coaches!! I think you should talk to the coach, I wish I'd spoken up more.
I am thinking of talking to the coach, but really can't figure out a better way of saying the whole thing without sounding like complaining. The coach seems a nice person, I am just wondering if this is common practice in football
OP posts:
midnightOK · 19/09/2021 22:36

@SnarkyBag

Depends on the coach. DS’s coach gives everyone pitch time but the better players stay on the whole match. Football is pretty ruthless in that respect especially as they get older. Friend’s son was told by his coach he was welcome to come to training but he should be prepared to spend most matches on the side line.
Thanks. I suggested DS to stop the football club, but he is still keen on going there. It just feels bad when you know they are eager to play but they can only sit and wait for their turn.
OP posts:
gabsdot45 · 19/09/2021 22:32

My son had the same experience. He was small for his age plus a December birthday made him one of the youngest too.
He was a decent player but there were other boys bigger and stronger so they got the play much more than he did.
I ended up hating the whole thing, the competitiveness, swearing, abusing the refferee and the other team, making kids cry and I'm talking about the coaches!!
I think you should talk to the coach, I wish I'd spoken up more.