Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I say sth to the football coach about this sub arrangement

56 replies

midnightOK · 19/09/2021 22:20

DS joined a football club since May. He likes football though I have to say his performance is just ok, not great. Everytime he went for a training or match, he would like me to watch him. I rarely got time to watch it. However in these few times I did watch him, he was rarely in the field, was often in the subs. This morning the match started at 12:00, by the time I had to leave, which was 12:30, he was still sitting aside and waiting for his turn to go in the match. Later on when I picked him up, I asked him how long he had been playing, he said probably 10 mins. He might not be accurate about the time he was in the match, however it is clear that some kids were in the match from start to the end and my son was only in it for a very short time. Should I talk about it with the football coach? I don't think this is fair. It's supposed to be roughly equal time for every kid to be in the match, is that right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lockdownmadnessdotcom · 21/09/2021 10:54

I don't think football is a very inclusive sport, unfortunately. However, there should be teams in different divisions which allow for different ability levels, as others have suggested.

Otherwise I would suggest athletics. It's much more inclusive, there are plenty of track events and junior and 5k parkruns happen every weekend.

In my admittedly limited experience the FA is completely rubbish at making sure that the rules are followed. My son played football and had a much nicer time when he switched to athletics.

ThatSunnyCorner · 21/09/2021 10:38

@Kite22

No longer being allowed to publish league tables doesn't mean it is non competitive. It is a sport - ergo - you are competing against the opposing team (in this case - obviously might be opposing player).

^In the Foundation phase the focus should be on developing the individual players rather than results of the team. In relation to the management of a team this should mean that in a game or over a course of games that a squad of youth players should experience a range of situations –starting, starting as a substitute, coming on as a substitute, being substituted. There should be an aim to offer all squad players comparable game time. However, we believe
this approach should be based on a developmental ethos rather than regulation imposed by a stop watch.^

So if you read the last sentence, it specifically says "based on developmental ethos rather than regulations imposed by a stopwatch " which I interpret as the Team Manager / Coach using their common sense and skill, and does not mean saying everyone has to be on the pitch for the same number of minutes every single game.

I have no expectation in my mind that my dd was going to be the next Harry Kane or Phil Foden, and she had a whole season when she knew she would get half a game at the most because of the make up of the squad that season, and she was fine about that. She is fully aware of her abilities and skills and where others are better than her, but that she brought her own qualities to the squad and she enjoyed the training and being part of the squad. So I think you are over generalising there. Oh, and I have never "screeched instructions from the side-lines nor abused referees".
I am 100% for rotating squads and giving everyone time to play and practice their skills. I love rolling subs an no limit on the number of subs, but sometimes there is also a place for developing skills with some stability of knowing (for example) where the winger will be when you make that pass. As I say, it depends on the game, not, (as indeed the FA agree with me), on a stopwatch of equal minutes.

Yes I agree with this. Of course competitive football is allowed with under 12s, even if league tables arent published, you'll find competitive matches all over the country every weekend. And tournaments. And cup competitions with finals.

It's clear from the FA guidelines that coaches can also use their discretion regarding equality of time on the pitch.

Kite22 · 20/09/2021 21:05

No longer being allowed to publish league tables doesn't mean it is non competitive. It is a sport - ergo - you are competing against the opposing team (in this case - obviously might be opposing player).

^In the Foundation phase the focus should be on developing the individual players rather than results of the team. In relation to the management of a team this should mean that in a game or over a course of games that a squad of youth players should experience a range of situations –starting, starting as a substitute, coming on as a substitute, being substituted. There should be an aim to offer all squad players comparable game time. However, we believe
this approach should be based on a developmental ethos rather than regulation imposed by a stop watch.^

So if you read the last sentence, it specifically says "based on developmental ethos rather than regulations imposed by a stopwatch " which I interpret as the Team Manager / Coach using their common sense and skill, and does not mean saying everyone has to be on the pitch for the same number of minutes every single game.

I have no expectation in my mind that my dd was going to be the next Harry Kane or Phil Foden, and she had a whole season when she knew she would get half a game at the most because of the make up of the squad that season, and she was fine about that. She is fully aware of her abilities and skills and where others are better than her, but that she brought her own qualities to the squad and she enjoyed the training and being part of the squad. So I think you are over generalising there. Oh, and I have never "screeched instructions from the side-lines nor abused referees".
I am 100% for rotating squads and giving everyone time to play and practice their skills. I love rolling subs an no limit on the number of subs, but sometimes there is also a place for developing skills with some stability of knowing (for example) where the winger will be when you make that pass. As I say, it depends on the game, not, (as indeed the FA agree with me), on a stopwatch of equal minutes.

Lucyccfc68 · 20/09/2021 19:03

@Kite22

I agree *@ThatSunnyCorner*

Thanks for linking @Lucyccfc68. I had found and read that link, but it doesn't say that at all.

I think little children (whatever sport) should very much be about learning and having the opportunity to practice . I love kwik cricket in particular for this, in that the players 'stay in' when they are 'out', just lose points. It is great. However there comes a time when those who have been learning and 'practising' for years, who need the next challenge of playing competitively. Yes, part of this is that better players get more time - in the same way that musicians or actors audition for a role or a place in a competitive orchestra. Some people are better than others. That is part of life. the lovely things about something like football, is that you can play at all sorts of different levels - that is how leagues work. You just have to find a club that plays in a league with other players of your ability.

It absolutely says:

Foundation phase (age 5-12). Developing the individual players rather than the results of the team. Should be an aim to offer all squad players comparable game time.

Also states:

SCORY does not permit the publication of tables for those age groups U7 to U11. This MEANS it’s non competitive I.e. no league tables.

This guidance is in place so that Football is for ALL (FA’s mantra) from age 5-12. It doesn’t matter how much a child of that age practises (gets 1-2-1 expensive coaching via their pushy parent) foundation phase is about developing individual players and not results - which doesn’t mean giving the best players more time on the pitch at the expense of those who are not as good at that age.

Some players, given the opportunity, blossom as they get older. Without game time, this just won’t happen.

The FA produced these guidelines as best practise in the hope that all children at foundation stage get a chance to play, develop and shine. The ones who don’t buy into this ethos are generally the ones who think little Tommy is going to be the next Harry Kane or Phil Foden and send their kids to some team with the name ‘elite’ or ‘academy’ in the title and spend their time screeching instructions from the side-lines and abusing referees when they don’t like a decision.

Plenty of time when they reach U12’s for competitive football. That’s when you potentially find a club or league that is the right level for your child.

Jangle33 · 20/09/2021 18:43

I think at age 10 the sport is very competitive and the best children get chosen to play. If he’s not getting match play soon then I’d look for a lower division team for him to play. Even by 6 it’s pretty ruthless!

Kite22 · 20/09/2021 18:18

I agree @ThatSunnyCorner

Thanks for linking @Lucyccfc68. I had found and read that link, but it doesn't say that at all.

I think little children (whatever sport) should very much be about learning and having the opportunity to practice . I love kwik cricket in particular for this, in that the players 'stay in' when they are 'out', just lose points. It is great. However there comes a time when those who have been learning and 'practising' for years, who need the next challenge of playing competitively. Yes, part of this is that better players get more time - in the same way that musicians or actors audition for a role or a place in a competitive orchestra. Some people are better than others. That is part of life. the lovely things about something like football, is that you can play at all sorts of different levels - that is how leagues work. You just have to find a club that plays in a league with other players of your ability.

wingardium8 · 20/09/2021 12:50

If your DS is turning up to all training, has a good attitude and is sufficiently physically fit but still not getting match time, then speak to the coach about whether he is realistically likely to improve enough to make the team. If not, find a club with a team playing in a lower division.

It’s all about finding the right fit. Matches are competitive at that age and coaches run the risk of their better players leaving if results are poor due to playing a weaker team, however much they might want to be fair and inclusive.

As already said, most coaches are volunteers and give up enormous amounts of time for these children. If you’re not happy, by all means raise the issue but if your DS can’t be accommodated at that club, find somewhere more at his level or set up a B team.

midnightOK · 20/09/2021 11:39

Thanks for all your valuable input, I do know more about football now. I used to think that most of kids sports would be about having fun and getting some exercises really, but obviously it's not as simple as that. There are a few clubs near us, which I think I might contact and let DS have a trial. I don't think football is sth really suitable for him, but he is keen to play and I don't want to discourage him to do that. I might just email the coach and ask what DS can do to improve his performance in these matches? That might sound not too bad. I certainly don't want to make the coach's life difficult, but on other hand, I would like DS to have at least more chances in the pitch. I won't expect a perfect equal pitch time, but at least not too short for these weak kids?

OP posts:
Catforaheadrest · 20/09/2021 11:24

You don’t have anything to lose by having a conversation with the coach. This happened to one of my SDSs, nearly ended his love of football and cumulated horribly in him being sub for an entire match. I burst into tears when the whistle went and had to take myself off to the car Sad The coaches were 100% for the win, which was completely in breach of the league (YEL) rules. But, we’d also ended up in a team in quite a high division, which pushed the coaches to be competitive.

We luckily found a new team (local club and the league social media have good routes to contacts to help find teams with spaces) in a lower division and they’ve been with the team (now u14s) for probably 3 years and tellingly the team has stayed the same for those years. The kids and parents are really happy with the equal time & rotating position approach the coaches take. The divisions are well matched, so they won’t lose every time. And the coaches have no division winning/division climbing ambitions.

And he’s now a much much stronger and happier player.

Brefugee · 20/09/2021 11:11

are there any less competitive and more "everyone gets a go" type of clubs he could join?

The problem is if they play in a league, or they lose week after week, regardless of what the coach says, the team will know who the weak members are and not want to pass the ball to them, will put pressure on the coach not to play them et etc.

I'm of the opinion that everyone should have access to playing sport if they want to, but i also believe that if there is competition involved and the team wants to do well, that isn't a "sport for all" situation that invites this.

Can you change the times you go to the matches? if your son is going to be on the bench for the foreseeable, you need to be there at the last 20isn minutes of the match which is usually when subs go on.

Atalune · 20/09/2021 11:06

have a turn

This is not how it works at this age, I think he might be better suited to a different team, maybe he should go and have some tries with other local teams.

Also it may not be his sport, at 11 it is OK to drop one thing and focus on another.

ThatSunnyCorner · 20/09/2021 10:56

Just going back to the FA guidance, I'm not aware that it says all under 12 matches must not be competitive, and have equal play time. I think it's under 7s, not under 12s. And I think clubs can make their own decision in terms of offering equal game time, although it's considered preferable to do so.

OP you might find another club with an ethos which better fits what you're after, best of luck

Knitwit101 · 20/09/2021 10:47

I am just wondering if this is common practice in football

Yes in our experience. The team wants to win so they choose their best players. Your ds needs to find a team playing in a lower league where he will be among the better players.
Unfortunately in our case there were so few teams around that only the very best kids got a chance to play. Teams are all run by volunteers, there are only so many to go round.
It's shit but I don't know what the answer is. Unless you can volunteer to set something up yourself at a lower level.

boon · 20/09/2021 10:44

I should say, this was the same last year when under 12s. But the coach has always made this clear so that if a parent isnt happy with this they can move their child to a less competitive team where they are guaranteed more time on the pitch.

boon · 20/09/2021 10:42

So in our team the best players get most time on the pitch every match, but those players who aren't as good if chosen will always get at least 20minutes on the pitch. This is Under 13s and it is a lot more competitive at this age.

Crazycrazylady · 20/09/2021 10:34

Very common in football where I am at this age, The better kids get more game time, Its way way more competitive than the other sports my kids are involved in.
I honestly wouldn't bother saying anything. This is the soccer ethos it seems, At 12, He probably will spend a lot of time of the sideline anyway if he's not that good and i think you'd embarrass him if you spoke to the coaches.
I'd use it as a life lesson if i could especially if he is better at other sports ie the benefit of enjoying something without having to be the best/you can't be the best at everything etc.
It is hard to watch though.

RedHelenB · 20/09/2021 10:29

It's a tricky one. My ds has worked and trained hard and now always starts matches.This wasn't the case when he started out. He has also moved to a better club each season, this year will be the first time he's stayed at the same one. Personally I think they social side is important and he's coming round to that idea but he just wants to get as good as he can and try new positions out. If your d's doesn't mind I wouldn't make a big deal of ut, although it's disappointing not to get to watch him play

HarrietsChariot · 20/09/2021 10:28

Coaches can't win really. If they take good players off and replace them with poor ones, it demotivates the whole team. The people who were playing well complain, their parents complain. The subs who replace them feel bad for ruining their team's chances.

Guidelines like all players getting an equal time in the game only work if the matches themselves are non-competitive. An hour of play (or whatever they have at that age) but no score being kept, everyone gets equal playing time. If the score is being logged then the best team needs to play.

It's unfair on all the children if inadequate players replace good ones because it gives them false hope. If they spend all their time sitting on the bench it will either make them realise football isn't for them or decide to improve their fitness and their skills so that they can earn a place on the pitch.

stuckdownahole · 20/09/2021 10:21

My friend is a coach of a boys' team and although he tries hard to comply with the directive on equal playing time, it's difficult.

Putting the weaker players on for large portions of the match will cause the team to lose more than they win, which will de-motivate the boys, which means the better ones will move to another team, which makes losing more likely ... so it can become a downward spiral which ends in the team being disbanded due to lack of interest.

My friend didn't really want to be the coach but was begged to do it by the other parents. Those same parents are now sending him emails asking him to justify his selection decisions. He keeps a spreadsheet logging how much game time each boy gets.

He does it because his son is mad keen - the lad struggles with school and football builds his self confidence. Otherwise he'd give up.

Try to be gentle with the coach, OP.

Kanaloa · 20/09/2021 10:03

I also have an 11yo in football and this seems pretty common for newer boys not to get quite as much time as some of those who have been there longer and are more confident on the pitch. The better players do tend to play longer, but they do get every boy some time.

As he improves and practices more he’s likely to get more playing time.

billy1966 · 20/09/2021 09:46

When my sons played there were coaches that accepted all the subs for training but never played the boys at matches.

Disgusting behaviour.

Not my sons fortunately as we wouldn't have tolerated it, we would have simply left.

But so unfair for those boys week in, week out, not to get any game time.

There are some awful coaches out there that shouldn't be near children.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 20/09/2021 09:00

My son was subbed every home match (goalie) for I reckon 90% of games, and was always selected to play for away matches. Turned out the other goalie's parents refused to take him to away games so my son really got the short straw. Manager refused to see that it wasn't fair that my son sat out 50% of matches but the other kid played every game he went to. Really turned my ds off playing, at which point the manager begged him to rejoin.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 20/09/2021 08:22

Ide wait until next season. Hes only just started which means he will be fitting in with a team that has played together years.
I do understand how you feel though. It's hard always seeing them on the subs bench.
Ds2 started football about 3/4 years ago and it wasnt until he started his second season there that he started having more playing time in matches.

cptartapp · 20/09/2021 08:22

My boys have been involved in grass roots football since they were six, DS1 has now finished and DS2 is 16 and has two years to go.
Some teams will rotate players regardless of ability, some will not. I've seen players travel a fair distance to spend most of the match stood on sideline in the cold. The managers son was captain in one team, and another managers son always plays a full game despite his questionable ability.
As they get older this will only get worse. Even DS1 team which was pretty inclusive, by 13 or 14 the weaker players lost confidence massively as the better ones (and parents) got frustrated. By 15and 16 they'd all gone. By 17 the team consists solely of good skilful strong physical footballers.
Pick your team carefully and even then, be prepared as a weaker player for things to worsen regards game time as leagues become more competitive.

Greysofa · 20/09/2021 08:08

I would speak to the coach and club and find out what their take is on it.
My son has been playing for several years and is one of the more talented players in his squad, however, they all get pretty equal game time. Although it’s not meant to be competitive at their age, it’s now starting to become apparent that the other teams who give their best players more time are pushing on much further than my sons team who play everyone equally.