Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what age you think is too young to pass away

218 replies

Youcanbesweet · 19/09/2021 16:50

I say under 80

OP posts:
eurochick · 19/09/2021 22:00

I think 80 seems about right. I base this on my own grandparents. One died around that age and was in excellent health until about two months before he died - just enough time to say his goodbyes and get everything in order. That's how I want to do it when the time comes. My other grandad was in his sixties - that's far too young. My grandmothers were both in their nineties and their final years were spent existing rather than living. It was a horrible slow decline to watch. So 80ish seems like a good innings to me.

Downton57 · 19/09/2021 21:56

My death might not be a tragedy for any of you but I'll be utterly gutted if I'm told my time's up at 60. That's far too young to die.

ZednotZee · 19/09/2021 21:48

@BangLyricalBlowToTheJaw

I agree. Lost my beloved dad at fifty three.

I have a friend who lost a child and my loss pales in to insignificance. My Dad lived a good, full life. Saw the world, met his DGC.
Her son was a mere baby.

Seventy is a gift imo.

MondeoFan · 19/09/2021 21:46

I think under 75.
My grandparents were 50, 73, 86 and 92 when they all died. So very varied.
My parents are 70 and 72 and in good health.

I think 80+ is a good age to die

Briony123 · 19/09/2021 21:43

Depends how the person lives. If you drive like a maniac, drink loads, smoke loads, eat crap, take drugs, then living almost any time at all feels like you've been lucky. If you live healthily and sensibly then popping off before 75 seems unfortunate.

BangLyricalBlowToTheJaw · 19/09/2021 21:42

I remember thinking my mum was at an okay age to die in her late fifties. I was in my early twenties so didn’t really have much perspective I think. I got a bit older and realised that’s quite young. Then got older again and experienced (not personally but through reading and social circles) children dying and realised that to make it well into middle age is really, nothing to complain about.

My heart absolutely aches for people who’ve lost children.

Ultimately it depends on your perception of the person. If they’re sick and wasting away at any age you’ll feel like it was an appropriate time to go, I know I felt like my mum had lasted as long as she could manage (alcoholism). Whereas my dad in his seventies now, if he died tomorrow I’d be shocked and heartbroken. But it wouldn’t mean seventies isn’t a good age to reach.

ZednotZee · 19/09/2021 21:40

@NuffSaidSam

The vaccine isn't safe for everybody.

My mother suffered a prerenal AKI and neurological symptoms following her second dose.
Had she been a care worker and had the vaccine under mandation or else lose her job there would have been no company sick pay, private medical insurance or liability admitted from the pharma company.

This shouldn't be mandated. Much less to 'save' a person who would die from any respiratory virus due to age and comorbidity.

NuffSaidSam · 19/09/2021 21:39

'As for the hypothesis that somehow we'd be fucked if people stopped dying is bizarre.'

I think that's true actually. If people continued to age, but never died we'd have a care crisis much bigger than the one we have now. We'd have to start killing people, then the what age is reasonable question would really come into sharp focus!

Hopefully the person who said anything over 30 is good isn't in charge at that point!

Comedycook · 19/09/2021 21:38

As for the hypothesis that somehow we'd be fucked if people stopped dying is bizarre

Well we would be.

Of course, it objectively sadder when someone very young dies.

echt · 19/09/2021 21:37

[quote ZednotZee]@echt

No, it just means that the hypothetical health of the elderly supercedes that of the care workers.[/quote]
No it doesn't.

ZednotZee · 19/09/2021 21:36

@echt

No, it just means that the hypothetical health of the elderly supercedes that of the care workers.

NuffSaidSam · 19/09/2021 21:35

@ZednotZee

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?

No. I think you'll find its rather 'fuck the minimum wage arsewipers' actually.

Surely, the vaccine also protects the minimum wage arsewipers and their families? They might not die of covid, but could be ill with it/need hospital treatment. It's a win-win. Not a sacrifice that the staff are making to save the residents.
echt · 19/09/2021 21:35

@Comedycook

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?

I don't think anyone thinks that but death is the only certain thing we have. We will all die. Death is sad on a personal level....but in terms of society, we'd be screwed if people stopped dying

But that's not what I said.

As for the hypothesis that somehow we'd be fucked if people stopped dying is bizarre.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 19/09/2021 21:34

My mum being diagnosed with a terminal illness in her 60s has focused my mind though.

I feel like I may only have 20 or so good years left and I am not going to waste them all at work. I am actively planning to retire early and travel the world whilst I still can.

My dad is really fit and well in his 70s but I don't take him for granted at all either. I make sure we see him a lot and spend quality time. I am acutely aware we may only have a few years left that he could still come on a foreign holiday or drive down to see us here.

echt · 19/09/2021 21:34

@ZednotZee

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?

No. I think you'll find its rather 'fuck the minimum wage arsewipers' actually.

Not quite getting my point, which was the utter callousness of the poster.

And no having concern about the elderly does not mean not having concern about their carers.

Comedycook · 19/09/2021 21:29

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?

I don't think anyone thinks that but death is the only certain thing we have. We will all die. Death is sad on a personal level....but in terms of society, we'd be screwed if people stopped dying

ZednotZee · 19/09/2021 21:29

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?

No. I think you'll find its rather 'fuck the minimum wage arsewipers' actually.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 19/09/2021 21:27

It's an interesting thread

My nana died aged 87 which surely is objectively a good innings but for a brief while I did emotionally feel that it was too soon even though quite clearly it wasn't.

She had all her marbles, didn't need any care, a bit slowed up walking and she didn't travel anywhere far anymore but she still baked delicious cakes and to most intents and purposes she seemed very well. She'd just moved into a lovely sheltered flat that she had really enjoyed choosing things for. That made me think couldn't we have had a few more years with her?

When I thought about it a bit more though it was exactly the right time. She would have hated to need care or be in a home. She had seen her grandchildren grow up and have kids of their own. My mum had already been diagnosed with the cancer that later killed her and I know she would not have wanted to bury her own daughter. She died peacefully at home in her own bed.

Basically by the time it seems like the right time it's probably already too late. We have to accept people dying whilst they are still 'good' or accept that they will suffer in the last years of their lives.

I hope I have a death like nana's.
My mum was barely 70 when she died of cancer but she had a good death too in many ways. She was still active and well to the last few weeks/ months of her life.
I miss her every day but that's selfishness really. I would not have wanted her to carry on but to suffer.
My other granny was in a care home with dementia for a number of years and her death was long drawn out and very hard.

echt · 19/09/2021 21:24

@ZednotZee

I agree from seventy onwards is a good innings.

Which makes me wonder why care home staff are having vaccines mandated, in order to hypothetically save people who are overwhelmingly in their eighties and nineties, from maybe dying from a virus.

I'm 67 soon, and no 70 + is not a good innings. Doctors don't think so either.

You're right about the crumblies in care homes. Fuck 'em, who cares?
Hmm

ZednotZee · 19/09/2021 21:20

I agree from seventy onwards is a good innings.

Which makes me wonder why care home staff are having vaccines mandated, in order to hypothetically save people who are overwhelmingly in their eighties and nineties, from maybe dying from a virus.

JaceLancs · 19/09/2021 21:15

Under 70 but that’s probably because I’m a long way off 70!
Ask me again when I’m 71 😂

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 19/09/2021 21:12

I think it depends on the person — I still have two DGM's, both 90.

If one died tomorrow I'd feel it was too soon — she still does a lot, and looks forward to things like seeing us all at Christmas, weddings, she'd like to see a great-grandchild etc. She makes plans for things like birthday presents, and what flowers she wants in her garden next summer etc. The other has dementia and doesn't really know us any more and spend a lot of time upset and scared. For her I'd still be sad she'd gone and miss her, but realistically she isn't enjoying her life or looking forward to things.

In general probably under 75 sounds quite young to me (although I've been lucky I suppose — most of the family I can remember have made 85, and a few have been over 100).

lilyfire · 19/09/2021 21:01

Miseryl - my dad died 20 years younger but had dementia and it was absolutely time for him to go. I guess my point is that it will feel too soon to people who love them if someone has a good quality of life and still has a zest for living. She still had a lot to give as a grandmother and great grandmother. She didn’t feel ‘worn out’. Of course objectively it wasn’t unjust like someone dying in their 30s or 40s or younger feels unfair.

Ozanj · 19/09/2021 20:59

Under 89

NuffSaidSam · 19/09/2021 20:58

[quote Miseryl]@lilyfire too soon? At over 100? When death is 100% certain for everyone? To me I would absolutely take comfort in a long life lived, with no sense of injustice. [/quote]
It can still feel to soon though, even though we all know it's coming. If someone is well and enjoying their life any age can feel too soon. It's like coming home from holiday.