Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what age you think is too young to pass away

218 replies

Youcanbesweet · 19/09/2021 16:50

I say under 80

OP posts:
hellcatspangle · 20/09/2021 06:59

I think it depends how someone lived their life and how they died - someone I know recently passed away at 70 from lung cancer after being a smoker all their life, so not entirely unexpected. If they'd been healthy all their lives and died suddenly I'd have considered that too soon.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 20/09/2021 06:40

“Sounds strange to say but I think people that know they are dying/terminal illness are lucky. They can prepare for their death and their loved ones.”

In my experience I’d say not. I spent 3.5 years knowing my wonderful husband was going to die of cancer. The pressure to live well - make the most of our time together - with our young family, knowing we were going to lose him, was immense. The grief started early and it was one I had to put a brave face on because many people didn’t realise, and you can’t keep pointing it out, plus I was trying to give DH a good rest of life. So much guilt for the times I failed. We’d rather not have known, for sure. You can’t prepare a 5 and 7 year old for losing their hero. It’s just barbaric that it should happen at all.

Maybe you are right for much older people. I don’t know. But not ‘out of order’ deaths.

Phonelightmidnight · 20/09/2021 04:44

I was annoyed that my grandmother died at 70. Thinking it was way too young and had at least 10 years in her. She had a stroke and died the next day. I was still a teenager and my cousins son born a month after she died and never got to meet him. I think 80s is a good age to die. My other grandmother died in her mid 80s and I thought that it’s expected, we can’t live forever. The uk life expectancy is currently 81. When an old person dies you’re sad because you miss them, when a young person dies you’re sad for their future they never had.

My feelings changed somewhat when my cousin in their early 30s died. That was too young but worse as they did not have any children (no part of them left, just gone forever) Their death was sudden, no warning at all. Death seems to happen young in my family and quickly. My dads father was in his early 40s, mums father was early 30s, mums brother late 40s and dads brother mid to late 50s.

Sounds strange to say but I think people that know they are dying/terminal illness are lucky. They can prepare for their death and their loved ones. When it is sudden, it’s a shock and brings up feelings that you would have never felt. For example, did I spend enough time with them, I never told them this or that, or we didn’t get to do this.

It’s sad when a person dies leaving behind young children but I don’t have that much empathy. Because I now in a heartbeat if people had a choice they would choose to die rather than their child. My cousin died leaving behind his mother and very ill father. They live in another country (parents home country). My cousins sibling lives here in the uk. My uncle passed this year (mid/late 60s) leaving behind my aunt on her own. No grandchildren to keep her occupied.

I don’t have much sympathy for old people dying because it’s expected. We all have to go someday but also because everyone around me dies so young. So I guess it just depends on your personal experience. I also find it hard when people talk about pets death. Realistically dogs have a life expectancy of 10-13yrs so it’s highly likely they will die before you. When people compare it to a family member I just think you clearly haven’t had a young person in your life die young. When a pet dies you don’t think about all the things your pet missed out on. A human, the grief is more complex. Such as they could’ve got married, had a family, etc.

I do feel awfully sad and angry when parents have lost their only child. Especially when the parents are too old or unable to have any more children after the death. I am by no means saying that having other children is replaceable but it does ease the pain. There was a couple who lost all three of their young kids on a plane crash. They were not flying with them. They had another child later on and even said they wouldn’t have had a child if it wasn’t for their deaths.

Losing a young person can make you really bitter but it’s not our fault. I regularly hear and see people on social media go on about their elderly parents or grandparents die. I’m left thinking their 83 why are you so bereft that you can’t cope. I saw a girl on tiktok mention she hasn’t showered in a few days because her cat died.

I think that if you can get through life only experiencing the loss of an elderly person die then you’re winning. Because the grief of a young person is like no other.

BreadInCaptivity · 20/09/2021 01:11

I think it's a very hard question to answer.

As pp's have already said, quality of life is a big issue.

That's not something you can always put an age on.

In general terms though, I think people who die before enjoying retirement are "too young".

Obviously the younger someone is the greater the loss of years and sense of injustice at the loss.

Personally the hardest losses IME are people in their 30's with small children.

The impact on their children and spouses is awful.

UrbanRambler · 20/09/2021 00:49

@DOINGOURBIT

Under pensionable age - without getting a chance to enjoy retirement with family.

Obviously the younger, the more sad it is. Lost family members at 24, 37 and 51, but also 91 and 99.

Yes, it's sad when people work hard and look forward to enjoying their retirement, then die before they have chance to enjoy a few golden years.

So, considering state pension age is now 66 or 67 for most people, 70 would seem too young to pass away. OTOH, I am not keen on living into my 80s, after what I witnessed my parents go through in their 80s.

The death of someone very young is truly tragic, but at the other end of the scale, there are people living to be very elderly, who have no quality of life due to dementia and/or other severe health problems, and that is a tragedy of a different kind.

TableFlowerss · 20/09/2021 00:22

I lost my mam in her 50’s (I was barely an adult) and my dad is nearby 80 now.

I would be sadder and more affected by a strangers child dying than my own dad dying. I was having this radon (albeit) conversion with my friend recently and she was quite shocked. It’s the tragedy of a child’s death that breaks my heart.

Miseryl · 20/09/2021 00:19

So many errors in my post! Terrible! Should say tragic not fragile!

TableFlowerss · 20/09/2021 00:16

@Miseryl

To me it's not about people wanting to die or not having a good life at an old age age, it's about the fact that we do all die and that the longer you go on, the less unjust it is. Someone in their 70s or 80s in very good health is extremely lucky and should be thankful they've had so long in good health. II'm only 41 but even I can see the difference in someone my age passing to a child. It's curious that people almost feeL entitled to ever lasting life for them and their relatives or that you have to be very ill for death to seem warranted. There are many gravely ill babies out there but you can't tell me their parents feel more at peace when they pass, whereas the death of a "fit and well" 70 year old is so much more fragile because they were enjoying life?
Another post I completely agree with.
Miseryl · 20/09/2021 00:13

To me it's not about people wanting to die or not having a good life at an old age age, it's about the fact that we do all die and that the longer you go on, the less unjust it is. Someone in their 70s or 80s in very good health is extremely lucky and should be thankful they've had so long in good health. II'm only 41 but even I can see the difference in someone my age passing to a child. It's curious that people almost feeL entitled to ever lasting life for them and their relatives or that you have to be very ill for death to seem warranted. There are many gravely ill babies out there but you can't tell me their parents feel more at peace when they pass, whereas the death of a "fit and well" 70 year old is so much more fragile because they were enjoying life?

TableFlowerss · 20/09/2021 00:09

not unlucky

TableFlowerss · 20/09/2021 00:08

@ParkheadParadise

I remember a lady in the queue outside Tesco asking me what I thought about Prince Philip dying( believe me she asked the wrong person) she seemed shocked that I thought at 99 he was well past his sell-by date. My dd was brutally Murdered at 23 and found by a stranger. I don't have time for people upset about 99-year-olds dying peacefully in their beds with their families beside them.
Aww that’s absolutely horrific. What a cross to bare that must be for you. I’m so sorry. I completely understand why you feel the way you do.

I feel exactly the same. At 99 you’ve lived about 17 years more than the average person. A very lucky person I would, but unlucky.

Crankley · 20/09/2021 00:04

I think those suggesting under 70 may quickly change their minds when they reach that age. I'm 76 and despite being physically disabled, have no intention of popping off for a while.

TableFlowerss · 20/09/2021 00:03

@Ginger1982

I don't think anything above 70 is 'too young to die.' Yes, it's sad these people didn't live longer but 70 is a good life innings. My dad was 43, my friend's little boy was 6 months. Both far too young
Exactly. This is how I see it. I’m sorry but if I died at 75 Ive still had a good innings. These poor souls haven’t.

I think people should think of it as what the person has had, in terms of years, rather than what they haven’t, when it comes to 70+

TableFlowerss · 19/09/2021 23:58

Lost

TableFlowerss · 19/09/2021 23:58

@NuffSaidSam

I think it's a sliding scale rather than a specific cut-off. The younger the person, the sadder it is generally.
This in absolute buckets. That’s why when children die it’s so much more tragic than someone of say 83.

It’s the years list that they never had the opportunity to live, what they could have done, the families that will spend a lifetime grieving. It’s not the natural order so it’s so so sad

I would say 70

WolfKnuckle · 19/09/2021 23:56

Also agree with the younger the more painful. I lost my boyfriend at 20 and that still hurts more than any other family loss in 40s, 50s.

WolfKnuckle · 19/09/2021 23:52

Under 65 / whenever children are set up

My parents are both still alive at 75 and 78 with various health ailments, nothing serious but all part of ageing. The past 10+ years ive seen how they are, put bluntly, wasting away time without the quality of life that they enjoyed in their 50s and 60s (luckily they retired early and and a happy 2 decades of a '2nd childhood', travelled, welcomed grandkids etc). They are at a stage where they are degenerating quickly health wise and not contributing much to their community. One is going senile.

I don't really want to live past 70 for this reason.

Esspee · 19/09/2021 23:48

Depends what age you are. When I was young I thought people in their 60s were old.

Spidey66 · 19/09/2021 23:47

My parents died young, i think.....my dad was 56 and my mum 67.

I'm 55 now and it's scary how close I am to the age my dad was when he died. (Ps I don't wish to offend anyone but while I'm ok to say my mum died of cancer, the cause of my dad's death is painful even 25 years later and I don't like talking about it so please don't ask.)

HSHorror · 19/09/2021 23:42

Also a friend died at 12 and that was devastating for her mum.

HSHorror · 19/09/2021 23:41

My mum had heart attack around 55 when 1 was early 20s. That was very young. She survived and had a stent. Now 70s.
I do think we need a uk dignitas though for people who want to go or go when they get dementia

Rinkytinkpanther · 19/09/2021 23:40
  1. My cousin had terminal lung cancer recently diagnosed and was sent home. She died a week later the day before her 60th birthday.
KeyboardWorriers · 19/09/2021 23:39

My first boyfriend died age 19, my best friend when I was 23. And a few other school friends had died by time I was 25. I have never taken reaching middle age for granted, let alone old age. I every yea ttyat passes feels like an unexpected gift.

vdbfamily · 19/09/2021 23:38

My parents are late 70's and in pretty good health but feel they have had a good run and happy to go whenever their time comes. However, our family have lost a few members too young, including my brother a couple of years ago, which puts it into perspective for them. They also have a strong faith and think that their life here is just the start of greater things so no fear of the end.

Honeyroar · 19/09/2021 23:37

@DOINGOURBIT

Under pensionable age - without getting a chance to enjoy retirement with family.

Obviously the younger, the more sad it is. Lost family members at 24, 37 and 51, but also 91 and 99.

Yes I think you’re right - under pension age. Or under 70.