Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are an adult and was homeschooled..

121 replies

SchoolNoMore · 19/09/2021 16:11

… i would be keen to hear your experiences and pros/cons such an approach has had on your life.

We have made the decision to deregister our 12 year old son from school due to skyrocketing anxiety and friendship issues. It got to the point where he was breaking down in the mornings and just refusing point blank to acknowledge us talking to him or get dressed, he is a smart kid, sensitive and we decided to home school. Naturally, i am scared and worried about what that means for his future and future prospects.
If you have been through this yourself, i’d be greatful to hear your experiences and how this impacted your life, career, mental health, social life/skills. Is a good outcome possible in such situation?

OP posts:
Mombie2021 · 19/09/2021 17:57

@Orangejuicemarathoner Never said she was doing 3 GCSEs this year. Does Women’s History GCSE exist? No, it does not.

Doing 26 GCSE exams for 13 subjects total is not representative of A Levels, University or work life in general.

DD would have no issue gaining 9s across the board should she stay at school, however I’m more interested in her mental health and emotional well-being then forcing her to stay in school and “achieve”, at the cost of everything else.

JustPloddingAlong123 · 19/09/2021 17:53

I was home educated for years 5-9, my mother walked full time but was in a fortunate position my grandmother could watch me. It was the best thing for me. She didn't have time to teach me, I had a combination of tutors and using BBC Bitesize. I hear Khan Academy is good too. An online school like you've suggested above could work too.
Definitely a local club for socialisation, given his age he can take himself like he would for school if you're still working. I'd start off with 1 club given the bullying to build his confidence and then add in a few more one at a time. He'll make friendships through those and eventually meet with others at weekends etc

MathsRocksMathsRocks · 19/09/2021 17:50

@SchoolNoMore I tutor GCSE students, both those at school and have tutored a couple of homeschooled students too.

My subject is (obviously!) one of the core subjects. Your son will need to pass this subject, as well as English Language as a minimum if he's to compete with other young adults for jobs when the time comes. Ideally, he will need the sciences as well.

I would say it's worth investing in private tutors (1:1 or in small groups) for the core subjects at GCSE level. These are subjects that matter most in terms of having good grades at this stage. Everything else in terms of subjects is optional.

It will cost you money though. Tutors charge anything from £20 p/h upwards for an hour for GCSE (depends where you are - I charge more, but I'm in an expensive part of the country). And you'd need at least an hour each week for the equivalent of Year 11, if not starting in the equivalent of Year 10 (depending on where your son's starting point is). That will add up over time.

I have to be honest, OP, the fact you work full time and can't really 'Home Ed' your son in groups/socially is an issue. Just de-registering him without plans in place won't do him any favours. Please look into this more closely before you commit to what you're proposing. Could he change school in the short-term? A different school and different teachers might make all the difference. It's worth a try while you look into Home Education a bit more.

toconclude · 19/09/2021 17:43

ad damn autocorrect

Wannakisstheteacher · 19/09/2021 17:41

It would be horribly neglectful to take your DC out of school unless you plan on paying for a tutor or enrolling them in online school. You cannot simply work full time and expect a 12 year old to self study.

toconclude · 19/09/2021 17:41

[quote JayAlfredPrufrock]@toconclude

That we are all different. What suits one person doesn’t suit another.

You sound quite confrontational.[/quote]
Translation: if I swing in with an ad hominen (or as mulierem in this case), people won't notice I just contradicted myself and agreed with toconclude.

Ashitaka · 19/09/2021 17:36

@SchoolNoMore

We are looking at options as there are online schools but they cost money. I work full time and am divorced so cannot quit or reduce work as there is mortgage amd usual living costs to cover. We’d be sharing homeschooling with ex as split was amicable but it’s little consolation to me at the moment. Btw, i know it’s not aibu, i have posted here for traffic.
I work full time and am divorced so cannot quit or reduce work as there is mortgage amd usual living costs to cover. so how will you home school if you are at work?
toocold54 · 19/09/2021 17:35

How did you find homeschooling and WFH in the lockdown?

I’m a teacher and don’t feel I could homeschool my own child and I definitely couldn’t if I had to juggle working FT too.
My DD has terrible social anxiety and really struggles at her school but as an only child I think it’s important for her to be around other children.

If I was you I would look into other strategies before committing to homeschooling completely.
Have you spoken to the school?
Could he have a reduced timetable and do the rest at home? Or could he move to a different school even?
Some people homeschool very effectively but I can imagine if it doesn’t work out it would be very hard to go back into the school environment. So if definitely have it as a last resort.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/09/2021 17:34

@toconclude

That we are all different. What suits one person doesn’t suit another.

You sound quite confrontational.

MumofSpud · 19/09/2021 17:34

@murasaki

If you didn't realise that it should be 'were' homeschooled, I'd suggest you don't inflict it on your child.
Came on to say this as well as great duo and i. I would say that your DS needs help with his issues and withdrawing him from society will not help but.... I realise getting MH help for teens is difficult (Whilst trying time book a Camhs appt for my DD I couldn't believe that they only work 10-3!)
toconclude · 19/09/2021 17:30

@JayAlfredPrufrock

I know two homeschooled girls.

I always feel desperately sorry for them.

And I know two homeschooled young women whom I admire and envy. Your point being?
JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/09/2021 17:29

@SignOnTheWindow. Like I said might just be me. What’s your contribution?

Orangejuicemarathoner · 19/09/2021 17:28

@Mombie2021

And the keyboard warriors are out in force today I see Hmm

OP, I’ve just removed my 13YO from school and will be home educating once she’s had a week to decompress. I have a lot of friends, mostly ex teachers/Uni Academics who also home educate.

Firstly, home education looks nothing like formal schooling. There’s no need to have them studying for 6/7 hours a day.

DD will be studying German, Women’s History and Computer Science (and will be doing the GCSE at the end of this year).

Look for local home ed groups on Facebook. They are far more knowledgeable than Mumsnet and much nicer. On here you’ll just get people ripping your decision apart or being dicks in general.

There is no point in your child doing GCSEs this year, they won't count for anything.

GCSEs are a set of exams taken together, to demonstrate that the candidate is able to manage the demands of many subject simultaneously.

Taking 3 a year won't mean anything, as that is easy, and demonstrates nothing about the volume of information your child is able to handle at once

KatieKat88 · 19/09/2021 17:28

OP have you engaged with his school to get the support he needs first? You don't seem in an ideal situation in terms of time to home school, and his pastoral team should (sadly) have lots of experience of supporting students with anxiety, school refusers etc and could at least sign post local support for you. This seems a drastic step and potentially could exacerbate any social issues unless handled very carefully.

JuneOsborne · 19/09/2021 17:26

There's a large community of home schoolers where I live and our neighbours home school.
The children are a delight. They are being taught all sorts of things. One child especially loves botany and vegetable growing.

However, the mother does not work, so she is there to home school them all of the time. And, like I said, there's an active community l, do they get to do things together, one of the parents does the maths side and others do other things as part of the group. They have a wide circle of friends. They go to museums on special home ed days, they go on holiday out of term time, and other things.

It looks idyllic.

I'm not sure what you're proposing is at all similar. Online school would be a good option in your shoes.

Willowowisp · 19/09/2021 17:26

Really sorry about the situation. However, given you aren't actually available to teach him ( most home educators I've met are ft Sahm), surely you would be better looking at alternative schools. The LA may be able to support alternative provision with tutoring.

girlmom21 · 19/09/2021 17:21

If you can't facilitate the social aspect of homeschooling he's going to end up really lonely and isolated.

SchoolNoMore · 19/09/2021 17:21

@littledrummergirl, thank you. Such an outcome is my biggest worry.

OP posts:
littledrummergirl · 19/09/2021 17:20

I have friends who were homeschooling. All their dc are now 16+ with no qualifications, no job, no further education, no friendship groups and no desire to do anything about any of the above. The parents both worked full time, one from home.

Their parents are now worrying about the future.

SchoolNoMore · 19/09/2021 17:20

@hedgehogger1, that is true, i cannot see how it can be done. Hence im looking into online schools as that would provide structure and materials. It seems a much better way as neither me nor my ex can fully dedicate our time to educate him.

OP posts:
Bagstolen · 19/09/2021 17:17

I think you’re being very thoughtful considering this as it can be devastating when school is a miserable place for a child. Life is too short for that. have you any other alternative like trying a different school? Though home education may well be brilliant for him as so many variables for each child. A new school workEd a miracle for our DS who had bad anxiety at his first school and didn’t settle fully and suddenly seemed incredibly happy In a school that is much busier with more things that interest him and a much clearer structure . I don’t know exactly what helped but sometimes you know there has to be a change and anything else is worth a go!
I know two lovely siblings being homeschooled but worry they aren’t nearly as stimulated and look quite on the fringe with only other home ed friends and quite small a circle. In some ways it’s lovely they are so protected but if a child can both be happy and with lots of peers I feel it can be healthier as ours develop and grow so much through their peer group interactions.

Namenic · 19/09/2021 17:14

At his age could weekly clubs after school - eg around 6pm - be an option to facilitate social interaction? Eg hockey or trampolining club? Scouts?

hedgehogger1 · 19/09/2021 17:12

You can't work full time and home school
properly. You need another option

2bazookas · 19/09/2021 17:12

@toocold54

Homeschooling is a full time job so you either need to hire a tutor or quit your job. If neither is possible then homeschooling isn’t an option.
This.

I have a friend who resigned her FT post teaching at university level to home-educate her children. It was a full time job using a wide range of resources online. All four kids are now stable independent adults with full time careers. One has a degree in ecology and a related job in a wildlife reserve, one is a qualified plumber, one has his own business as a "I can fix it" Man Friday. something to do with websites, home technology etc.

I have another friend, professional biologist whose sons had dyslexia; they were not getting enough support in primary school (this was long ago) so she took them out and home -educated them.
Organising homeschool became her full time job. She had lots of academic artistic musical adults on side to tutor. Those boys were the most delightful, social, confident, skilled and beautifully -mannered home-ed kids I ever encountered. At 13, they flew through Common Entrance to private school (small classes) because Mum wanted them to have wider social experience with their own peer group..

MyDcAreMarvel · 19/09/2021 17:09

@toocold54 Homeschooling is a full time job so you either need to hire a tutor or quit your job. If neither is possible then homeschooling isn’t an option. maybe that was your experience of homeschooling, home educating however, is not.