Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it must have been so humiliating and depressing for Shelley Long

244 replies

Suetully · 19/09/2021 12:47

I caught Cheers reruns flicking through tv last night. Having not seen or thought of it in well over 25 years, I forgot how good Shelley Long was in it as Diane and her brilliant chemistry with Ted Danson.

I did some research after and she'd after 5 years left for a movie career but her career tanked and within 3 years of leaving, she was another jobbing tv actress whilst the show went strong for another 6 years and that was the show she'd deserted as the main star.

Like I can't imagine her anguish and humiliation that Danson went on to become the biggest tv star of that time, the show went to number 1 and her co-stars who were support to her reign like Kelsey Grammar and Woody Harrison became much bigger stars than she did.
She even returned to be a guest star on Frasier and he became the highest tv star in the world whilst at a time he was only brought into Cheers as her love interest.

That and her replacement Kirstie Alley became even bigger than Long was both in her carer and in general fame. It seems her name now is synonymous with a bad career move if you google her. AIBU to think that would be a pretty hard pill to swallow?

OP posts:
LukeEvansWife · 20/09/2021 09:29

If that was to me, then I did read it. Women on TV etc were able to be pregnant and still work. Confused

confessionsOfa · 20/09/2021 09:22

And read my posts properly before ripping them apart. Look at the actual wording of my sentences.

confessionsOfa · 20/09/2021 09:19

I have no interest in checking out Dans Wikipedia page and I've never heard of Legion I'm afraid so as far as I'm aware he's not been on my radar for a while. He was great in the Eurovision film though.

Obviously some pregnant women have had storylines written around them but many had to leave roles, take time out etc last century. Blimey that makes me sound ancient. But I guess I am. Anyway that's a fact so there we go.

Times have moved on and improved and sometimes we forget how crap things were for women in the workplace. Be thankful to be in a position not to remember you are lucky

LukeEvansWife · 20/09/2021 08:54

@confessionsOfa

We mustn't forget that in those days having a child and being pregnant were not as accepted as now. It's only the last 15-20 years a TV / news / weather could carry on in her job pregnant. That never used to happen. Filming would not have been flexible around her childcare needs etc.
Don’t be silly - being pregnant or having a child was perfectly acceptable. It was the 1980s, not the 1880s!

Loving the idea that it is only since 2000 that it’s been acceptable to have pregnant women on TV Hmm

Alison Steadman was heavily pregnant in Abigail’s Party and that was the 1970s.

And why would filming have to be flexible around childcare needs anyway? Most people seem to make it work.

longwayoff · 20/09/2021 08:29

Actors are allowed to have lives outside the telly box. You are very unreasonable to trash her achievements. It's not all about mega fame and success with a fickle audience.

DroopyClematis · 20/09/2021 08:24

@confessionsOfa

I always think of Dan who played Mathew in Downton in these threads as he left far to early and apart from Beauty and the Beast and a couple of other things he just faded into obscurity. Plus he really pissed us all off leaving the show so served him right really.
You might want to check out his Wikipedia page.
DriveMeCrazy1974 · 20/09/2021 08:21

@confessionsOfa

We mustn't forget that in those days having a child and being pregnant were not as accepted as now. It's only the last 15-20 years a TV / news / weather could carry on in her job pregnant. That never used to happen. Filming would not have been flexible around her childcare needs etc.
In season 3 of Cheers, both Shelley Long and Rhea Perlman we pregnant. Rhea's pregnancy was written into the show for her character, Carla and Shelley's was covered up because it wouldn't have been in keeping with the character. Shelley was in 2 more seasons and Rhea was in it until the end. I wouldn't have though that either suffered because their childcare needs were not being met.
DriveMeCrazy1974 · 20/09/2021 08:14

We've recently re-watched the entire 11 seasons of Cheers (and are now watching Frasier) and I have to say the series lost a lot of its appeal once Shelley Long left.
Those who are saying that Sam was the main character, are, in my opinion, wrong. The reason I say this is because as soon as Shelley left, the series pretty much became very much an ensemble show rather than a show with a lead actor.

I just don't think, at that point in the series, Sam's character was strong enough to be the most important part of the show. His exploits with women became a bit monotonous to be honest.

I also think there would have been a real issue having a character today who is as much of a bully as Carla was. There were times when the character was just plain nasty.

I don't know if Shelley Long regrets leaving the series when she did, but the show wasn't the same without her in it. None of us could ever know her true feelings about that. But, I don't think she should feel humiliated and depressed - that's a very weird thing to say. The Money Pit was a great film, as were other things she's starred in.
She's a great comedy actor.

I loved the Coach and when the actor who played him (Nicholas Colasanto) died, it was a real loss to the show. They did well in replacing him with Woody Harrelson, but it wasn't really the same.

Surely, for most actors, they want to be trying different roles. Isn't that the whole point of being an actor? I would have assumed that's why she chose to leave.

EvilRingahBitch · 20/09/2021 07:56

I think we think of Dan Stevens as being out of work because Legion never came to the UK, so we didn't see him for three years, but it was a solid starring role. And of course leading in one of the highest grossing romantic movies of all time is going to mean that your profile or bank balance will be well stocked for a decade so he doesn't need to be desperate.

The new Watergate thing he's in with Julia Roberts looks interesting - unfortunately I can't stand Sean Penn who's the other lead.

alittleprivacy · 20/09/2021 07:46

@confessionsOfa

I always think of Dan who played Mathew in Downton in these threads as he left far to early and apart from Beauty and the Beast and a couple of other things he just faded into obscurity. Plus he really pissed us all off leaving the show so served him right really.
Hardly. He played the titular role on the FX series Legion for 3 seasons and was critically lauded for the incredible range he showed on the show. And while Feige is denying they are bringing his Legion into the MCU, they are planning to bring Stevens in during phase 4.
BorderlineHappy · 20/09/2021 07:10

I suppose being an actor thats the risk you take.Its never been a steady line of work.

Also who would have thought it would have been Woody Harrelson who turned in to the Hollywood star.

UsedUpUsername · 20/09/2021 06:37

@Harford

No but her career going into the doldrums after leaving a hit show and her once high flying career fading into oblivion in such a short time might make me think it had some bad strain on the marriage. I would say Katherine Heigl had the same big regrets after leaving greys anatomy although she was younger and had time to recover more from it and I think she's doing ok on some Netflix show at the moment.
Heigl is actually supposed to be a nightmare to work with. Allegedly
confessionsOfa · 20/09/2021 02:42

I always think of Dan who played Mathew in Downton in these threads as he left far to early and apart from Beauty and the Beast and a couple of other things he just faded into obscurity. Plus he really pissed us all off leaving the show so served him right really.

confessionsOfa · 20/09/2021 02:39

We mustn't forget that in those days having a child and being pregnant were not as accepted as now. It's only the last 15-20 years a TV / news / weather could carry on in her job pregnant. That never used to happen. Filming would not have been flexible around her childcare needs etc.

Itsmeagainandagain · 20/09/2021 02:23

She was in the brady bunch remakes thats how i know of her

Snoozer11 · 20/09/2021 01:43

@Artonthefridge

Cheers had a heavily male writers room. The rumour goes that Shelley Long was not well liked. Sometimes a work environment is horrible and we look for a different job. I'm really glad people don't wonder why I left my retail position years after the fact. I left because it was a nightmare.

Thinking her time on the show was up (her storylines were getting repetitive) and wanting a bigger career in the movies...sorry, but what's wrong with that? What's wrong with ambition?

Has anyone seen The Comeback? It's great for highlighting the older female comic actors experience on a toxic show, and it's funny.

Valerie Cherish is supposedly based on Shelley Long.

Mickey is based on Shelley Long's hairdresser.

Trixabellecrowther · 20/09/2021 00:30

@Harford

This thread is amusing though. Penis or no penis

What do you find amusing? I don't mean that in a goady way, I am generally interested. Seems like a standard enough thread with interesting points made.

Not taken in a goady way, and thank you for the interest :)

I mean, it is a fairly standard and interesting topic, for those who have seen the programme and/or followed the actors in it.

People respond accordingly and appropriately.

Then people respond saying 'OMG why would anyone discuss this?!You're over invested, OP' (IMO, people's minds are made to wonder, scanning is fine, trivialities are as much a part of life as profound thoughts)...

Then people respond saying OP is wanting to do women down, why else would he post?

Then the thread turns into a soup of bits of all the above.

I does amuse me. And interests me. Thanks OP :)

Harford · 20/09/2021 00:08

No but her career going into the doldrums after leaving a hit show and her once high flying career fading into oblivion in such a short time might make me think it had some bad strain on the marriage. I would say Katherine Heigl had the same big regrets after leaving greys anatomy although she was younger and had time to recover more from it and I think she's doing ok on some Netflix show at the moment.

ChequerBoard · 19/09/2021 23:44

@Harford

It's hardly a tragic life, several well received and remembered movies and a long career as a working actor

I think I recall hearing she had a suicide attempt after the breakdown of her marriage.

OK then substitute 'career' for 'life'.

Not really sure why her personal
Life is relevant to this discussion. Are you saying her marriage wouldn't have broken up if she has remained in Cheers?!?

Harford · 19/09/2021 23:25

It's hardly a tragic life, several well received and remembered movies and a long career as a working actor

I think I recall hearing she had a suicide attempt after the breakdown of her marriage.

ChequerBoard · 19/09/2021 23:04

I think perhaps she thought that she had very few years left to crack the Hollywood movie market and so she took her shot.

In those days roles for women over 40 were really non existent so I think she knew it would be pretty short lived.

Maybe if she had stayed on Cheers for years doing the same old Sam and Diane schtick she would have been bored and really regretted not giving it a go.

It's hardly a tragic life, several well received and remembered movies and a long career as a working actor.

Harford · 19/09/2021 23:02

The Money Pit is one of my all time favourite films. My children have just discovered it. We've watched it twice this weekend

That was released when she was in Cheers though, the op was pointing out how her career floundered after Cheers in fairness.

MotherOfMonkeys0 · 19/09/2021 23:01

The Money Pit is one of my all time favourite films. My children have just discovered it. We've watched it twice this weekend

Harford · 19/09/2021 22:53

This thread is amusing though. Penis or no penis

What do you find amusing? I don't mean that in a goady way, I am generally interested. Seems like a standard enough thread with interesting points made.

Harford · 19/09/2021 22:48

People who are saying Shelley worked constantly or they liked her are missing the point. Yes getting work in the industry is good but it's the fact she went from being one of the award-winning biggest tv actresses in the world at the time to be another guest star tv actress in such a short time is what the op is getting at.
It would hurt more when the show was still playing and successful and her ex-costars were making big money and getting fame she wasn't anymore. She was the leading female star of the show too.
Of course, that would be a bitter pill to swallow.