Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think becoming a first time mother in your 60s is the height of selfishness?

495 replies

CounsellorTroi · 19/09/2021 09:33

www.vogue.co.uk/arts-and-lifestyle/article/julia-peyton-jones

Had a baby alone at 64. She’ll be 80 years old when her daughter is 16. There’s a good chance she’ll be dead by the time the child is 30. She could well die before the child reaches 25. So very selfish.

OP posts:
MitheringMytryl · 19/09/2021 23:47

@milkyaqua

I hope this thread gets pulled. It's really ugly to judge and condemn a woman like this, who may well be reading here.
Totally agree.
HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:47

@IceLace100

As with anything, if exploitation is involved, it isn't right.

However, I don't think surrogacy is inherently exploitative. It can be done well, with all parties aware of the risks and consenting freely.

I also think poor women can make the best decisions for them.

Yes women can make any choice they want right. Sell their body, their womb for the gain of someone else. Like genuinely risk their life just so some selfish rich woman can have a baby.

What about a kidney? Shouldn’t she have the right to sell that too to some rich person who needs one.

Except then why is it illegal to sell organs 🤔 Because it’s fucking exploitative that’s why

EmeraldShamrock · 19/09/2021 23:46

Well, given we don't actually know the circumstances of this child's gestation - maybe it was a relative, or a good friend who acted as surrogate
At 64 no I'd have only offer surrogacy to a loved one who was responsible, this lady is not.
Only a desperately poor woman would do that for a near pensioner.
I hope the Ukraine has good counselling.

milkyaqua · 19/09/2021 23:45

I hope this thread gets pulled. It's really ugly to judge and condemn a woman like this, who may well be reading here.

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:44

Exactly. You should only remove babies from their mothers as a last resort. There have been years of research and studies that have shown how damaging it is to take babies away from their mothers.

Actually choosing to do this with no thought for the child and even worse to do it in your 60s when you realistically won’t be able to care for the child properly or for long absolutely beggars belief.

IceLace100 · 19/09/2021 23:43

As with anything, if exploitation is involved, it isn't right.

However, I don't think surrogacy is inherently exploitative. It can be done well, with all parties aware of the risks and consenting freely.

I also think poor women can make the best decisions for them.

EmeraldShamrock · 19/09/2021 23:42

Old parents v. v. bad. Grandparents same age who by necessity take in junior offspring of their own drug-addicted, etc, offspring, also bad?
Completely different situation but a very sad one for the DC of a drug addict.
It's great grandparents will foster but its still a horrible situation.

Antsinyourpanta · 19/09/2021 23:42

Do you see many wealthy white women doing it out of the goodness of their hearts?

Or even :

Do you see many wealthy white women doing it out of the goodness of their hearts? for money because it's a good career choice?

milkyaqua · 19/09/2021 23:42

Doing it out of love is different I'd have seriously considered it if my sisters needed it.

Well, given we don't actually know the circumstances of this child's gestation - maybe it was a relative, or a good friend who acted as surrogate - it really does seem unkind to condemn JVJ on this basis.

TheNatureOfTheCatastrophe · 19/09/2021 23:41

I don't think that any of the posters who disapprove of this particular parenting choice have said "I am only allowed to disapprove of one parenting choice, and have decided to go for this one - addicted/sociopathic/negligent/abusive parents are therefore absolutely fine by me"

Elderly kinship carers are the least worst option in many cases. For the same reason, people who disapprove of surrogacy because of the damage done by removing a baby from its mother don't necessarily disapprove of a newborn baby being removed from a mother with a long and apparently incurable history of child abuse.

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:40

@milkyaqua

Right, monetary involvement bad. Sociopathic parents, cool.

Old parents v. v. bad. Grandparents same age who by necessity take in junior offspring of their own drug-addicted, etc, offspring, also bad?

How can you compare grandparents looking after their own grandchildren out of necessity with a woman in her 60s actually choosing to have a baby?! It’s in no way at all the same thing.

As you’ve put in your own post, it’s out of necessity. No one in their right mind would choose this or say it’s a good idea.

Just because things can be done doesn’t mean they should be

EmeraldShamrock · 19/09/2021 23:39

Yeah I actually don't think surrogacy is exploitative. Adults can make commercial decisions about their bodies.
Why do only poor women do it?
Desperation? Giving birth isn't easy, neither is egg stimulation, then there is the child, how will it impact on their mh.
Doing it out of love is different I'd have seriously considered it if my sisters needed it.

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:38

Surrogacy doesn’t exploit women? Just like prostitution doesn’t I suppose?

Do you see many wealthy white women doing it out of the goodness of their hearts?

Pregnancy and birth is one of the most dangerous things a woman can do. I myself have been left with life altering injuries as a result, that I’ll have for life, lost over 3 litres of blood during the birth of my twins and required a transfusion. Name me any wealthy, educated woman that would do this for a non family member without payment. I highly doubt you’d be able to.

The practices of the surrogacy industry in India and some parts of Eastern Europe are despicable. And if you think that doesn’t filter over to countries like the UK then you’re either extremely naive or an idiot

milkyaqua · 19/09/2021 23:33

Right, monetary involvement bad. Sociopathic parents, cool.

Old parents v. v. bad. Grandparents same age who by necessity take in junior offspring of their own drug-addicted, etc, offspring, also bad?

IceLace100 · 19/09/2021 23:33

Yeah I actually don't think surrogacy is exploitative. Adults can make commercial decisions about their bodies.

Clearly going to be flamed on here but just wanted to put forward an alternative opinion that is also probably widely held by the majority of people.

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:28

@IceLace100

Oh do keep up. She used someone else’s body.

Alright love no need to be snippy Grin

Why can't we stop judging women's choices then? Live and let live.

Women’s choices? Exploiting some other woman for her own gains. Yeah go right ahead
HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:27

@milkyaqua

Well, people also pay for IVF babies. Does that disgust you?
No. As the mother grows the baby in her own womb and doesn’t have to give it up the minute it’s born. And likely isn’t in her 60s
IceLace100 · 19/09/2021 23:27

Oh do keep up. She used someone else’s body.

Alright love no need to be snippy Grin

Why can't we stop judging women's choices then? Live and let live.

RowanAlong · 19/09/2021 23:26

Yes of course we are all right to be concerned with children’s welfare. But it’s one woman, and one child, not a societal ‘trend’ for 60+ motherhood, and she did, by all accounts, give a great deal of thought to it. Child is loved and wanted.

milkyaqua · 19/09/2021 23:23

Well, people also pay for IVF babies. Does that disgust you?

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 23:19

@milkyaqua

And the welfare of children is something we should all be concerned with, no?

I would be more concerned about the welfare of all the children born to and raised by the many rampant covid deniers, and those who consider the elderly and unwell collateral damage, and all those who have expressed blatant sociopathic tendencies in response to this pandemic, myself.

A surrogate arrangement is hardly "ripping a child from its mothers arms"; it is a commercial arrangement involving a willing participant with a degree of choice.

I can’t say I’m horrendously upset about covid deniers - don’t give them much thought. I am concerned about children being brought into the world without a single thought for their welfare though.

Doesn’t stop me being concerned with other morally repugnant issues.

A commercial arrangement? You could say the same for prostitution. Is it really a choice if a woman is trying to feed her family or pay off debts but feels the need to sell her body to achieve this? And it does rip a newborn from its mothers arms. Into someone’s arms who’s paid for the baby. Disgusting

milkyaqua · 19/09/2021 23:14

And the welfare of children is something we should all be concerned with, no?

I would be more concerned about the welfare of all the children born to and raised by the many rampant covid deniers, and those who consider the elderly and unwell collateral damage, and all those who have expressed blatant sociopathic tendencies in response to this pandemic, myself.

A surrogate arrangement is hardly "ripping a child from its mothers arms"; it is a commercial arrangement involving a willing participant with a degree of choice.

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2021 23:12

@IceLace100

Why can't we stop judging what women do with their bodies?
Oh do keep up. She used someone else’s body.
IceLace100 · 19/09/2021 23:10

Why can't we stop judging what women do with their bodies?

HermioneKipper · 19/09/2021 22:59

@RowanAlong

I’m really surprised at the vitriol on this thread. Not at all surprised that people are raising eyebrows, but amazed that people are getting actually het up about one woman’s decision as if it’s a personal slight somehow. Each to their own?
How dare we care about an issue where women are being exploited into selling their bodies for financial gain and a newborn is ripped from its mothers arms to provide an elderly lady with a hobby in her retirement. It’s morally repugnant.

And the welfare of children is something we should all be concerned with, no?