Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what are the rules re rape victims handing over phones to police and if the invasion of doing that is worth going through pursuing a case if mental health already fragile?

37 replies

C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 07:26

Just that. I’m asking for my child who has spoken to police but been warned phone will be taken for evidence. It’s having a big impact on mental health that is already fragile. I know it’s not my decision but not sure what to do re encouraging either way. Does going through with a prosecution help with recovery in the long run? Does not going though with it make mental health worse?Can police drop a case if there is a refusal to hand over phone? Has anybody had to do this and how did it impact mental health?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 19/09/2021 07:53

Here’s the guidance from the CPS about handing over phones. Please ask your dd to read it carefully. I hope she is getting support via the police for this crime - sending her big hugs.

www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/handing-over-mobile-phone-data-rape-prosecutions

RocketPanda · 19/09/2021 07:52

In my personal experience I was fragile mentally and the reporting alone had a massively negative impact. This was pre phone era and I think the added stress of my privacy being picked through would be a lot.
On one hand yes it's vital to punish rapists but on the other rape and sexual assault is not like other crimes, its in a whole other realm of violation and should be treated with the utmost care ad compassion but seldom is.

HeAteItWithASpoon · 19/09/2021 07:52

As a rape victim who reported it to the police my recommendation would be to never report rape to the police. I was actually mentally ok after being raped. It was the way I was treated by the police that traumatised me. My rapist left me with physical injuries that required hospital treatment, left dna inside my body and apologised in writing for raping me. It didn’t even get to court due to insufficient evidence. He was interviewed once for less than half an hour. I had my phone taken for 3 months, was interviewed 6 separate times and constantly asked if what my sexual tastes were, did I enjoy bondage, have I ever asked a partner to hit me during sex, asked why I met with a man that I’d previously considered a friend and gone to his house if I wasn’t planning to have sex with him. It was just awful.

I consider myself fairly robust, mentally, but I do not know how anyone has the strength to actually go through a rape trial as a victim.

NashvilleQueen · 19/09/2021 07:51

Hi OP. You have said the word invasion so I assume you're concerned about the privacy aspect more than her not having a phone.

The police have to carry out all reasonable lines of enquiry when an allegation has been made. In some sexual offences (say where the parties are not known to each other before the incident) then the evidence on a phone is unlikely ever to be reasonable. However in cases where the parties are known and where the suspect may be saying the victim consented then the police need to look at material on the phone because there is a duty to disclose to the defence any material that might help the defence or damage the prosecution case.

Without proper management of disclosure a case will fail.

A prosecutor won't hand over general personal information on the phone (for example intimate conversations with others etc) and disclosure will only be where the content meets a certain test for this particular case.

I know how frightening it is for a victim and how they can feel that they are being judged after such a traumatic event. I am so sorry that you and your DD are having to go through such an ordeal and for what happened to her. The police and cps want to successfully prosecute more rape cases but in order to do that they need to ensure that they have carried out the investigation properly and then handled disclosure correctly.

You have asked about the consequences for not handing it over. In some cases that happens and the impact depends on the particular issues arising. If the suspect were to say something in his defence that brings material on the phone directly into issue then it makes it difficult for the prosecution. Not having it can in some situations make prosecution difficult.

The police use specialist investigators and the cps have a bespoke unit to handle rape and sexual offences.

Your daughter should be provided with support via an Independent Sexual Violence Advisor who can help explain the process.

AriadnesWeb · 19/09/2021 07:46

I can only comment on England/Wales - Scotland might be different.

Unfortunately it's not the police insisting on this - it's the CPS. They are hugely reluctant to charge a suspect without a phone download from both suspect and victim especially if they are known to each other. It's to do with R v Allen and the collapse of the case.

Realistically, unless the suspect is on remand, it won't be a quick investigation and is unlikely to make it to trial in less then 2 years - probably longer due to the backlog at court. Rape investigations can be long and complex and the charging threshold from CPS is very high and can be difficult to get across. Your daughter will be supported by a specially trained officer throughout but it may still take it's toll. They are likely to need her phone for several months.

Awalkintime · 19/09/2021 07:44

This was meant to be stopped as victims do not need investigating as if they were the accused.

Is there something on there that could help her - a text that the perpetrator has sent that could support her case? If not then do not hand it over. Support her in asking why this is necessary if there is no need for it.

The police took data without consent and it really affected me. I felt powerless at the time as a victim and unable to stand up to them. I have no idea what data they took. Your daughter will also feel powerless. You have that power to stand up to the police and say no.

knittingaddict · 19/09/2021 07:43

Every thing was downloaded on to a new phone and she got the old one back eventually.

I think it's worth it, but that's just my personal opinion.

knittingaddict · 19/09/2021 07:41

My relative handed over her phone willingly. Yes it is an invasion of privacy, but it needs to be done. Sadly this was done far, far too late and the perpetrator's phone was long gone.

C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 07:40

No police have said phone will need to be handed in. Do you have to or can they proceed without? I wasn’t there with conversations as 17.

OP posts:
C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 07:39

It’s not as easy as that.My child already had fragile mental health and is extremely anxious. It’s not as easy as just handing it over. Also aside from the invasion of privacy I’m also concerned re the messages it sends out. Want to be sure it will be worth the trauma. At the end of the day it won’t be my decision but not sure how to support or advise.

OP posts:
Mybalconyiscracking · 19/09/2021 07:35

Surely they will let you copy contacts etc to your PC first, then download onto new phone?

Justreadingtheforum3 · 19/09/2021 07:31

Sorry to hear about your daughter.

The perpetrator needs bringing to justice. It's just a phone!

Get another. I buy second hand phones when I break or lose one from Ebay for less than 100. You cant not prosecute for fear of losing a phone.