Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what are the rules re rape victims handing over phones to police and if the invasion of doing that is worth going through pursuing a case if mental health already fragile?

37 replies

C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 07:26

Just that. I’m asking for my child who has spoken to police but been warned phone will be taken for evidence. It’s having a big impact on mental health that is already fragile. I know it’s not my decision but not sure what to do re encouraging either way. Does going through with a prosecution help with recovery in the long run? Does not going though with it make mental health worse?Can police drop a case if there is a refusal to hand over phone? Has anybody had to do this and how did it impact mental health?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MatildaIThink · 19/09/2021 11:14

There is supposed to be a system allowing them to clone the phone onto their servers then hand it back, but I am not sure if it has been brought online yet.

MatildaIThink · 19/09/2021 11:13

@C0t0n3ast3r

Why does the whole phone need to be sent in? Why can’t those representing the raped send in all material relevant to case if there is any. The accused would have the same messages and be able to do the same. A rose victim having phoned checked does send a message of disbelief and is an invasion of privacy.
Evidential chain of custody. The laws around evidence are complicated and very prescriptive.

They are also looking for communications between other parties about the incident.

NootNoop · 19/09/2021 11:11

@C0t0n3ast3r I can't talk for all police forces, but the ones round here will let you keep your phone if you download all the messages off of it that they want and send those to them

knittingaddict · 19/09/2021 10:49

@Tinpotspectator

Ah I see. In case she's elsewhere talking about setting him up, for example. Still, it seems very unnecessary to remove it permanently. Just snapshot what they need.
Remove what permanently? They don't remove the data on the phone or remove the phone permanently.

The police need to use special software to download deleted information as well as what's still on there. It takes time to do this. There are real issues these days with the volume of digital data available as evidence and policing is suffering as a result.

I'm not on the side of the police here. They seriously messed up my relatives case and didn't go looking for evidence until months later, by which time it was long gone. Something desperately needs to be done about domestic abuse and sexual assault prosecutions, but it's going to involve time and money. Above all that the will to treat these crimes seriously needs to be there and it just isn't.

Tinpotspectator · 19/09/2021 10:12

Ah I see. In case she's elsewhere talking about setting him up, for example. Still, it seems very unnecessary to remove it permanently. Just snapshot what they need.

Ayeayeayeaye · 19/09/2021 10:02

“I don't understand why they can't just do a search for the accused's name on your phone right in front of you, capture what's relevant, and hand it straight back?”

It’s not just as simple as that. All conversations at the proximate time need to be analysed as they could hold evidence. Forensic recovery for anything deleted. Pictures, voicemails, social media conversations.

Ayeayeayeaye · 19/09/2021 10:00

“Why does the whole phone need to be sent in? Why can’t those representing the raped send in all material relevant to case if there is any.”

Shockingly (assuming you’re in England) no one represents the victim of a crime. If it proceeds to trial then it is the crown’s case, and the victim becomes a witness for the prosecution. Victims have zero legal representation while accused do. The prosecution will support her as a witness but not as a client.

Is there any type of victim support agency where you live or free legal services agency that could give her a bit more advise re disclosure of her phone?

If it’s going to cause her more harm than good then unfortunately going ahead may not be the best thing to do. Chances of conviction are low and the process is mentally taxing.

Tinpotspectator · 19/09/2021 09:57

I don't understand why they can't just do a search for the accused's name on your phone right in front of you, capture what's relevant, and hand it straight back?

Thelnebriati · 19/09/2021 09:50

Its odd that people can't see the issue with the victim having to hand over their phone.
Aside from the fact its investigating the victim there are practical problems; for benefit claimants it causes trouble as its linked to their claim, plus if you are tied into a contract you have to keep paying even if the police have your phone for months.

NeedToKnow101 · 19/09/2021 09:39

@HeAteItWithASpoon

As a rape victim who reported it to the police my recommendation would be to never report rape to the police. I was actually mentally ok after being raped. It was the way I was treated by the police that traumatised me. My rapist left me with physical injuries that required hospital treatment, left dna inside my body and apologised in writing for raping me. It didn’t even get to court due to insufficient evidence. He was interviewed once for less than half an hour. I had my phone taken for 3 months, was interviewed 6 separate times and constantly asked if what my sexual tastes were, did I enjoy bondage, have I ever asked a partner to hit me during sex, asked why I met with a man that I’d previously considered a friend and gone to his house if I wasn’t planning to have sex with him. It was just awful.

I consider myself fairly robust, mentally, but I do not know how anyone has the strength to actually go through a rape trial as a victim.

That is horrific, and not unusual, from what I have read about rape cases. So sorry you were put through that. It's disgusting how women are treated by the police and CPS.
C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 09:36

Why does the whole phone need to be sent in? Why can’t those representing the raped send in all material relevant to case if there is any. The accused would have the same messages and be able to do the same. A rose victim having phoned checked does send a message of disbelief and is an invasion of privacy.

OP posts:
Clocktopus · 19/09/2021 09:34

Read the room @MatildaIThink, that wasn't the time or place for that post (as an FYI, only around 2-4% of accusations are false, a tiny amount).

Awalkintime · 19/09/2021 09:26

At no point did I say that we should convict on an accusation. However it takes a lot to get an arrest for rape and men will always deny it of course.

I said women changing their mind is a myth. Women text their rapists often following rape because of the 5 fs - fight, flight, friend, foe and flop. Lots do not realise they were raped - like me. The police told me it was rape. For a year I did not know. Many are groomed and do not respond in the text book way. Many carry on being friends as they as keeping friends keeps them safe. So texting thank you for a nice night is not confessing they consented at all. The complexities of how people react to rape is poorly understood clearly.

Naunet · 19/09/2021 09:24

For fuck sake @MatildaIThink, read Awalkintimes post properly, he had confessed. This really isn’t the right place for your stories of evil lying women.

MatildaIThink · 19/09/2021 09:09

@Awalkintime

MatildaIThink I had a confession and the police didn't even put it to CPS because of victim blaming attitudes like that. Women don't change their mind. These are rape myths. Peddled by men to cast doubt on the accusers and clearly it works on some women too.
One of my husband's friends was falsely accused of rape by a woman, I know it was false because the friend was on a golfing holiday in Portugal with seven other people including my husband on the weekend when the woman claimed it occurred. My husband's friend is a lovely man but was broken by this for months, he was arrested at his place of work because the police had been unable to locate him elsewhere (he had not been at home as he was in Portugal). It took nearly right months for it to be dropped despite records showing he was not even in the country when it happened.

Some women are horrible, just as rapists are horrible people, the cases might be a minority but for justice to be done we have to uphold the law and validity of convictions, we cannot convict based purely an accusation.

Naunet · 19/09/2021 08:55

The police will continue to investigate, but with a refusal to hand the phone over the CPS will be more likely to not prosecute. Rape is almost always a "he said, she said" situation unless violence was involved which makes it very difficult to prosecute anyway

Sorry but this is bullshit. The CPS don’t prosecute when there has been violence, or he’s confessed, or it’s been recorded etc, it happens all the time. The idea that they don’t prosecute because it’s “he said, she said” is almost a rape myth itself at this point.

I agree with HeAteItWithASpoon, I would never report again, it only adds to the trauma and prosecutions are as rare as unicorns, never mind getting a guilty verdict in court.

I’m so sorry this happened to your daughter OP, some therapy might help if she’s not already having any? I’d also make her aware of how unlikely it is that he will end up in prison, she needs to be prepared for what she will go through if she wants to continue.

HolaAmigoz · 19/09/2021 08:53

@HeAteItWithASpoon and @RocketPanda

I have no words. I’m so sorry you had to go through that. As a mother of a daughter, I fear for her every day.

Op, I’m sorry I don’t have any advice just wanted to offer some Flowers. I’m sorry for what your dd is going through and I hope he get what he deserves.

C152 · 19/09/2021 08:48

@Justreadingtheforum3

Sorry to hear about your daughter.

The perpetrator needs bringing to justice. It's just a phone!

Get another. I buy second hand phones when I break or lose one from Ebay for less than 100. You cant not prosecute for fear of losing a phone.

It's not about the phone. If the OP is in the UK, there have been multiple stories in recent years about how wrong this demand for victim's phones is, as they trawl through it looking for anything the defence may use to suggest the victim was 'asking for it', then the CPS refuses to prosecute the case. (It's just another way of saying women are asking for it if they dress a certain way.)

OP, I am so sorry to hear about your daughter, and for what you must be going through to. As much as I am in favour of reporting crimes, I would be thinking twice about it in your daughter's case. Are the two of you able to talk about what she feels about reporting it and whether she would cope with police questioning? If she's not sure, would a therapist be able to help her figure out whether reporting it is right for her at the moment?

MuffinsAreJustCakesAtBreakfast · 19/09/2021 08:41

@HeAteItWithASpoon and @RocketPanda

Your stories are absolutely shocking and not at all what you would expect from an otherwise civilised country like ours.

When drivers for speeding, bad parking etc are gone after more harshly than rape perpetrators you just despair don’t you. Utterly appalling.

Thank you for sharing your stories, even if they make the blood boil!

And society wonders why women can be nervous around men…and we get called hysterical for it. I have no words!

BenjiMcSchmenzie · 19/09/2021 08:19

@C0t0n3ast3r

That’s really helpful, thank you. Does anybody know if proceeding can helpful in the long run. The experience below is my concern ie my child will end up feeling even more crap. As selfish as it sounds preservation of mental health means more to me than getting a conviction.
It doesn't sound selfish at all, and having read the accounts of survivors on this thread I don't think I would encourage my children to report a rape either. All the very best to you x
Awalkintime · 19/09/2021 08:17

MatildaIThink
I had a confession and the police didn't even put it to CPS because of victim blaming attitudes like that. Women don't change their mind. These are rape myths. Peddled by men to cast doubt on the accusers and clearly it works on some women too.

Sickoffamilydrama · 19/09/2021 08:15

As she's already fragile mentally please keep in mind I know someone who wasn't allowed to access support until after the trail of her rapist in case it was used against her or "changed her memory of the event". They used it against her anyway and he got off.

He'd done it to other women but they all refused to go to court.

MatildaIThink · 19/09/2021 08:05

@C0t0n3ast3r

Just that. I’m asking for my child who has spoken to police but been warned phone will be taken for evidence. It’s having a big impact on mental health that is already fragile. I know it’s not my decision but not sure what to do re encouraging either way. Does going through with a prosecution help with recovery in the long run? Does not going though with it make mental health worse?Can police drop a case if there is a refusal to hand over phone? Has anybody had to do this and how did it impact mental health?
The police will continue to investigate, but with a refusal to hand the phone over the CPS will be more likely to not prosecute. Rape is almost always a "he said, she said" situation unless violence was involved which makes it very difficult to prosecute anyway, the police and CPS will want to know the background and look for all possible evidence either way. There have been cases where rapists have apologised for the rape the next day via messaging, that obviously gives compelling evidence of guilt. There have also been cases where a "victim" has messaged saying "thank you for a lovely night etc. only to change their mind in the morning and claim rape when the sex was entirely consensual.

I am not in any way saying your child's case is not entirely valid, but the police and CPS need to be sure of that. The measure for guilt is "beyond a reasonable doubt", they will not want to be blindsided by some evidence presented by the defence.

I don't know on mental health as it is always different for everyone, with different people having different reactions to every part of then process, let alone the rape itself. One of my close friends was raped when we were at uni, it was Nokias back in those days and the police asked to see text messages, which she showed them and it did not bother her, but I know some people react differently. He was found guilty and was jailed, that made her feel better, although she was one of the lucky people who did not get traumatised by the whole experience. She was and still is a very pragmatic person, went to see a therapist as a precaution, was open in talking to her friends about it etc. she made the decision not to feel shamed by it as she had done nothing wrong. She took us friends down the pub to celebrate the rapist going to prison.

C0t0n3ast3r · 19/09/2021 08:00

That’s really helpful, thank you. Does anybody know if proceeding can helpful in the long run. The experience below is my concern ie my child will end up feeling even more crap. As selfish as it sounds preservation of mental health means more to me than getting a conviction.

OP posts:
Awalkintime · 19/09/2021 07:57

@HeAteItWithASpoon

As a rape victim who reported it to the police my recommendation would be to never report rape to the police. I was actually mentally ok after being raped. It was the way I was treated by the police that traumatised me. My rapist left me with physical injuries that required hospital treatment, left dna inside my body and apologised in writing for raping me. It didn’t even get to court due to insufficient evidence. He was interviewed once for less than half an hour. I had my phone taken for 3 months, was interviewed 6 separate times and constantly asked if what my sexual tastes were, did I enjoy bondage, have I ever asked a partner to hit me during sex, asked why I met with a man that I’d previously considered a friend and gone to his house if I wasn’t planning to have sex with him. It was just awful.

I consider myself fairly robust, mentally, but I do not know how anyone has the strength to actually go through a rape trial as a victim.

I wholeheartedly agree with this. My rapist also admitted it and mine didn't get to court either. The police said I should accept it now with the introduction of 50 shades and that he stopped eventually so there is no issues. They even answered their own questions they put to me when I was too distressed to answer. I was then threatened never to say that he raped me because I would get arrested for that as it wasn't proven in court. Never again would I report.
Swipe left for the next trending thread