Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending 43k savings on a wedding.

364 replies

Cosmos123 · 19/09/2021 06:59

I know a couple who are spending 43k (all savings) on a wedding yet have no where to live.
He is a 1st year nursing student on a bursary she is looking for work as a nursery nurse.
They are currently looking for 1 bed flat with a budget of £500pcm as that is all they can afford on his bursary. For which they have asked myself to be a guarantor.
Yet they are have an expensive wedding in 6 weeks.

I did discuss to them about spending less and perhaps the money as a deposit on a property further down the line. They seem to agree then bang this is what they decided.

OP posts:
MrsBobDylan · 19/09/2021 11:56

They can't afford that wedding, not when they also need to find money for a honeymoon and rent to live.

They will have to stay living at home for another few years. Lucky them!

Ellmau · 19/09/2021 11:54

Maybe it was wrong for me to be judgemental in their decisions to spend so much on one day as it is their money and their choice after all

Rubbish, everyone's being judgmental about that and quite rightly so.

You obviously care about them, OP, but you're right not to bail them out.

RealBecca · 19/09/2021 11:42

Dont be their guarantor then.

They probably think they will only get married once and can earn more money.

Spending anything over £500 on a wedding makes me uncomfortable but everyone is different- leave them to it.

DominicRaabsTravelAgent · 19/09/2021 11:39

Just make sure they don't ask your DPs, their DGPs, to be guarantors.

Some people will do this without a regard for their DGPs financial security

.Afterall there are 43,000 reasons not to be a guarantor for their rent.

Just realised you probably are the DGM OP.

In which case I'm glad you've said no to the loan for the Honeymoon and being guarantor.

I would offer her help to search for a job though. It's a shame she's not more worried about what people would think of her not having a job.

cakewench · 19/09/2021 11:33

"It's their money" well yes, it is, but it's a shame no one has taught them the value of it. They've been living at home and saving for years to manage to get to this total and it's going to be chucked away in one day.

If this is the type of financial decision they're comfortable making, I'm glad you've decided not to be their guarantor.

JinglingHellsBells · 19/09/2021 11:32

Why is the 'bride' unemployed? (Or is she working but wants to be a nursery nurse?)

Nursery nurses don't earn much anyway - a bit more than a TA but far less than a teacher. She's likely to hit a ceiling of around £20K unless she gets a snr role in a nursery (and it's not clear if she even has any qualifications as a nursery nurse or is just hoping to get a job in a nursery.)

Long term, a newly qualified nurse (him) and her (whatever she does) they are not going to earn shed loads.

Have they any realism about a mortgage application further down the line?

DoubleTweenQueen · 19/09/2021 11:30

@Cosmos123 Completely ridiculous to spend everything saved under very easy circumstances over the last 8/9 years on one day. Madness even. They could still have a really nice day on half that amount, surely?
Or a fraction of it for that matter. Then have a decent chunk to get themselves on the housing ladder for their future?

It is their choice, but it’s a bizarre one. Very odd values.

I wouldn’t be guarantor either for this couple.

k1233 · 19/09/2021 11:28

Agree @ejhhhhh. Not only will they get a reality check they will also then bang on about how unfair it is that they can't buy a property. Conveniently forgetting the obscene amount they blew on their "dream" wedding. Unfortunately life is about choices.

DominicRaabsTravelAgent · 19/09/2021 11:27

Are you a relative then? An aunt, cousin, sibling?

They must have a close relationship with you to ask for something as serious as being a guarantor

.Presumably their own parents have refused.

Or they could make equally foolish decisions about money, have a bad credit history and wouldn't be accepted as Guarantors. Even more reason to say no in that case.

KittyKattyKate · 19/09/2021 11:26

Weirdly enough, I would have no problem if they spent 3K on the wedding and 43K on the honeymoon.

TheNoodlesIncident · 19/09/2021 11:26

OP have they considered the cost of living when they will have to pay for everything for themselves? Has nobody pointed that out to them?

I can see them getting into debt very quickly, when they discover that they will have to pay rent, council tax, gas, electricity, water, phone/internet, food, household goods, travel/commute, etc etc out their own pockets and they have no savings to fall back on.

It's not your responsibility obviously, but an appointment with an IFA would probably be an eye-opener if they genuinely have not thought about how they will fund themselves going forward.

DH and I had foreign wedding which was cheaper than a comparable UK wedding at the time, but we both owned our own houses and had jobs and savings. Flash wedding would have been way down the priority list if we didn't have jobs or properties already...

MrsScrubbithatescleaning · 19/09/2021 11:25

@bobandhisburgers

Maybe they can't get a mortgage at the moment or for a good few years?!

I get the feeling you're related to one of them so I think it's very unkind to deny them moving to a new home just because you don't like the way they have spent their own savings. They are clearly able to save up a substantial amount, so will be able to do it again when they need to.

I don’t think you’ve read all the updates?

OP isn’t stopping them doing anything, hence the ridiculous splurge on the costs of the wedding.

Refusing to act as a guarantor for a property rental is extremely prudent given they only managed to save this sum because they’ve not paid a penny in rent, bills, food etc. for a few years by living for free with their parents.

OP also mentioned that the costs were spiralling because they’re keen to not look cheap and keep up with the Jones’s/ Insta mob.

Once they move into their own place and have to pay all their own bills, they’ll need to start living within a tight budget especially given their earnings will be fairly low to start with.

At what point are they going to admit to themselves that trying to maintain a champagne lifestyle on a tea budget isn’t realistic. How much debt will they accumulate before they get their ‘ah ha’ moment, if they ever do?

I don’t think OP should act as guarantor but I do think they should ask the couple to work out what their actual budget for everything will be when they move into rented accommodation on the premise that they’re thinking about it.

If the couple have never paid a penny in bills and rent, they are probably completely clueless about how much these things actually cost.

I actually feel sorry for the couple as once financial reality hits, they’re going to be very unhappy.

JinglingHellsBells · 19/09/2021 11:24

So you are not a parent of either of them @Cosmos123?

Are you a relative then? An aunt, cousin, sibling?

They must have a close relationship with you to ask for something as serious as being a guarantor.

Presumably their own parents have refused!
Why did you need to ask on a forum?

They are clearly living in cloud cuckoo land and are high risk with a low credit score, hence the need for a guarantor.

I wonder if they have debts as well?

Booknooks · 19/09/2021 11:21

Each to their own, I think its absolute madness and I wouldn't offer any financial support etc if they're going to be so ridiculous.

RickySpanishhh · 19/09/2021 11:19

3. Yes they are related

To you? Not to each other?

Warmduscher · 19/09/2021 11:18

I would not be a guarantor for anyone except one of my DC.

If they default on their rent you will be 100% liable to pay it for however long it takes for them to accumulate enough money to pay off the arrears.

Why can’t their parents be their guarantors?

onlychildhamster · 19/09/2021 11:16

@Zenithbear I can confirm it's easy to save that kind of money. DH and I lived at home for 3 years, saved £60k in 3 years. We even went abroad regularly to see my family so spent at least £1000 on flights every year.

Of course we used the money for a house deposit! And we are in London so 43k is not small money even in London!.in fact it could probably be a ok deposit in some of the cheaper areas of London.

ejhhhhh · 19/09/2021 11:15

Ah, just seen they haven't done university yet so probably haven't been earning that much per year. But still, the same argument still applies, they won't find it very easy to save that sum again when they're paying all their bills.

Closetbeanmuncher · 19/09/2021 11:15

I'm glad you've decided not to be a guarantor there's no way I would put my neck on the line for a couple of people that stupid.

They're priorities are pretty backwards.

ejhhhhh · 19/09/2021 11:12

@Zenithbear just for argument sake, lets say they have both saved £22k each. They've both been earning £20k per year since leaving university, and have had zero living expenses. Of course a person in that situation could save £23k relatively easily, it would only take a few years, and that's even with plenty of fun money. If they've no experience of budgeting when they actually have all their bills to pay, I predict that they will find it incredibly difficult to save that sum again soon, if ever.

ddl1 · 19/09/2021 11:10

Well, it's up to them, but I agree that it's not the wisest use of money. I wouldn't interfere in their choices (probably too late anyway); but I wouldn't be their guarantor.

RedHelenB · 19/09/2021 11:09

If you trust them to pay the rent then be their guarantor. Paying money they already have on a wedding is an irrelevance although it could easy pay almost half of a starter home where I live.

Cam77 · 19/09/2021 11:06

Just read they’re 29/30. So they’re planning to effectively blow their entire life (so far) savings on a wedding while scraping together enough for rent? Hope it’s a sunny day!

Cam77 · 19/09/2021 11:04

@SandysMam
If they have saved it themselves then they are obviously good with money and will probably save it again in time. If they inherited/won it then yes, they are foolish really

Throwing £40k on a wedding while planning to burn £500 on rent for years and years doesn’t suggest they’re good with money.

Cosmos123 · 19/09/2021 11:03

@Zenithbear

This post makes zero sense to me. People who are financially capable of saving that amount of money at their ages tend to be savvy with money. Yet now they are making very stupid feckless money decisions all of a sudden. They can't be both. They would never have got the 43k together with the latter attitude imo and experience. Sorry not buying it.
If you don't pay rent, contribute for food and bills and have had a job since 21 you can save that kind of money. You can also easily blow it on one day.
OP posts: