Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending 43k savings on a wedding.

364 replies

Cosmos123 · 19/09/2021 06:59

I know a couple who are spending 43k (all savings) on a wedding yet have no where to live.
He is a 1st year nursing student on a bursary she is looking for work as a nursery nurse.
They are currently looking for 1 bed flat with a budget of £500pcm as that is all they can afford on his bursary. For which they have asked myself to be a guarantor.
Yet they are have an expensive wedding in 6 weeks.

I did discuss to them about spending less and perhaps the money as a deposit on a property further down the line. They seem to agree then bang this is what they decided.

OP posts:
MarySlater · 20/09/2021 18:19

Blimey. Registry office then reception in Wetherspoons. Change out of £300. Boom! Job done.
Wonder if the marriage will last longer than it took to save the £43k?
Irony is that if you don't act as guarantor and they still have a £43k wedding the OP won't get invited

LowlandLucky · 20/09/2021 18:18

Bigger the bill, quicker the divorce.

RoSEbuds6 · 20/09/2021 18:17

This is not what I would spend my saving on, but I guess it's their choice. Maybe some of it has been inherited. Maybe they will expect to recieve cash gifts for the wedding?
If you were guarantor, how much would be guaranteeing? if it was £500 I might do it (if I really liked them) but any more and I wouldn't.

ChocChipPancake · 20/09/2021 18:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

ChelleMum85 · 20/09/2021 18:04

@Cosmos123

I know a couple who are spending 43k (all savings) on a wedding yet have no where to live. He is a 1st year nursing student on a bursary she is looking for work as a nursery nurse. They are currently looking for 1 bed flat with a budget of £500pcm as that is all they can afford on his bursary. For which they have asked myself to be a guarantor. Yet they are have an expensive wedding in 6 weeks.

I did discuss to them about spending less and perhaps the money as a deposit on a property further down the line. They seem to agree then bang this is what they decided.

Normally you would only need a Guarantor if your credit check failed?

Advise them they are spending 43K on one day of their lives, instead of investing it in a home which lasts forever and could possibly make them an even bigger profit in the future if they put effort into their home and increase the value?

I'm confused how a first year nurse and someone without a job could have saved all of that. I'm thinking it's saved grants/loans/bursaries etc and money from family? It sounds a bit immature so definitely don't sign!

DreamTheMoors · 20/09/2021 18:03

I was guarantor for friends with a brand new baby for a living room suite.
Four months and no payments later I had a living room suite I would never have chosen for myself, didn’t want and didn’t need.
I’d advise caution on the guarantor bit - at the very least, prepare for the worst.
Can you afford to be guarantor?

LalalalalalaLand123 · 20/09/2021 18:01

I agree OP. But apparently the average wedding spend in the UK is £30k! I certainly wouldn't spend anywhere near that, but many people do, and more, it would seem.
They sound very immature and perhaps don't really understand the realities of money / supporting themselves if they've been living with parents with most expenses paid. I'm glad you're not going to be their guarantor, or lend £3k for the honeymoon - that should definitely be part of the £43k.

onlychildhamster · 20/09/2021 17:56

@cherish123 when did you get married? my MIL got married in 1989 in London. Her wedding was a ceremony in someone's back garden followed by a reception in a london hall with kosher food for 100 guests. This cost £4000. Today, the ceremony cost alone is £1500 (for my synagogue). Kosher food has gone down in price (relative to income) in general due to more imports from Israel/America but kosher wedding catering is easily £100 per person (and Jews have large families).

Just like property, weddings have increased in cost relative to income. I think it is why middle class people tend to marry in their 30s when they have saved up quite a lot of money for the dream wedding. Or the parents pay. I had the civil registry office ceremony at 22 and waited to buy my home before planning a wedding. In my impression, a lot of poorer people are put off weddings due to the cost. Yes I know a lot of people say you can just sign papers at the civil registry office and go out for a meal afterwards. I did that in 2015 and honestly DH and I felt there was something missing. We want to celebrate our commitment to each other. We are trying to do it as cheaply as possible but I wouldn't pretend its easy, as parents all had different expectations. My parents wanted a hotel banquet lunch in my home country (we limited numbers to extended family only- 50 people to afford this), MIL wanted kosher food (we are doing afternoon tea and not full menu). 43k is insane money, but the average wedding in the UK costs over 25k. I don't think its because we are all feckless spenders. I started out wanting to only spend 10k,, I hope that we would keep to it but if we don't, it wouldn't be because we wanted to blow our savings. And its also why i made sure we bought our flat before doing any serious wedding planning.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/09/2021 17:55

43k on a wedding is utter madness and if this is an indication of how they spend their money, then I definitely wouldn’t be a guarantor.

Carpedimum · 20/09/2021 17:50

If how they’ve made financial decisions about their wedding is anything to go by, I absolutely would not be legally associated with them for any financial dealings. Spoilt kids expecting parents to bail them out when they’re keeping up appearances?

cherish123 · 20/09/2021 17:35

They are being ridiculous. 43k on what is effectively a party. The nicest and classiest weddings I've been to were small intimate affairs. What on earth are they spending 43k on? Food is usually the expensive part of a wedding. They must have an awful lot of guests. Given it's a long time since I got married but this is ridiculous.

dementor72 · 20/09/2021 17:17

I wonder if they have to ‘blow it’ so that they too can claim benefits after the marriage ? Having that amount in the bank would preclude any claim.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 20/09/2021 14:06

If this is how they prioritise their spending Definitely don't be a guarantor

DangerMouse5 · 19/09/2021 23:21
  • Last not lady Hmm
DangerMouse5 · 19/09/2021 23:20

No normal person would think oh this is a couple who are responsible with money so it isn't a risk for me to be guarantor for then. You'd think the opposite! The lady people you'd ever guarantee!!

DangerMouse5 · 19/09/2021 23:18

@RedHelenB

But the money has already been spent, presumably before OP was asked to be guarantor. So, as I say an irrelevance. The only bit that concerns the OP us of she trusts them to pay the rent.And as people on mumsnet have no idea on this it's a decision the OP needs to come to for herself.
I think MN can

The couple had sufficient funds not to need a guarantor

They spent it recklessly and now want OP to help them out. Nope no and no

They are not an impoverished couple that have no chance of starting afresh they had £43 grand and decided to BLOW it!!

RedHelenB · 19/09/2021 22:12

But the money has already been spent, presumably before OP was asked to be guarantor. So, as I say an irrelevance. The only bit that concerns the OP us of she trusts them to pay the rent.And as people on mumsnet have no idea on this it's a decision the OP needs to come to for herself.

dayslikethese1 · 19/09/2021 16:44

They shouldn't have asked OP (or anyone) to be a guarantor. With that amount they could easily have paid 6 months rent upfront and not needed a guarantor. Or saved it for a deposit. That's more than enough for a deposit, even in London.

Lightisnotwhite · 19/09/2021 16:20

@HollowTalk

If their parents are on benefits then how honest are they letting them live there rent and bills free for years? That doesn't make sense.
Agreed. Do the parents own their house then? Otherwise I think they’d have to charge as benefit wouldn’t cover it.

I remember that woman who lived in absolute poverty to save up her benefit. She was done for fraud for having too much in savings she hadn’t declared even though it was all her benefit money !

onlychildhamster · 19/09/2021 16:11

@the80sweregreat I just looked it up and average Asian British wedding is £50k in the UK- Sikh, Hindu etc. Average British Jewish wedding is in excess of 50k, no wonder my SIL thought she was being frugal at 33k! So if you have any Asian or Jewish friends, chances are half of them spent that much or even more on their weddings and they probably aren't all feckless either!

But these are huge family affairs. When I asked my DH if this was a huge sum for a wedding, he said no, it isn't, it's normal but it isn't a personal expense, that is a family expense. So parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles all pitch in. But he added that he would never spend that much as he doesn't have the whole family offering to help him pay. Which is why our wedding is budgeted to cost £10k (synagogue ceremony in London, banquet lunch in Singapore for my extended family of 50) and will probably happen 7 years after our civil registry ceremony (in part due to covid but also because we saved for and bought our flat before even thinking about a wedding).

User4378645 · 19/09/2021 15:47

Why would anyone spend that on a wedding when they haven't even got proper jobs

User4378645 · 19/09/2021 15:45

I wouldn't be a guarantor, they are not even properly employed

VestaTilley · 19/09/2021 15:41

YANBU. They are being ridiculous and insane.

Do not be the guarantor on their flat - they should have thought about that before they committed all their life savings to a wedding they can’t afford.

Most people don’t spend anywhere near this much - it’s madness! £43k is a house deposit!

MargosKaftan · 19/09/2021 15:33

Yes but most "useless with money" people would have spent it along the way, a £2k holiday a year. A car for work "needs to be reliable and I can afford it without credit" - £10/15k easily without being fancy. A few big nights out a year, gig tickets, etc. If its been 9 years in the saving, that's less than £400 a month, you'd barely notice or £200 a month each. You'd barely notice most people "wasting" that. They set a target and saved for it. They haven't been silly with money throughout their 20s.

the80sweregreat · 19/09/2021 15:24

I cannot get my head around anyone wanting to waste that amount of cash getting married!
It's mind boggling ( and mostly for other people too !)