Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending 43k savings on a wedding.

364 replies

Cosmos123 · 19/09/2021 06:59

I know a couple who are spending 43k (all savings) on a wedding yet have no where to live.
He is a 1st year nursing student on a bursary she is looking for work as a nursery nurse.
They are currently looking for 1 bed flat with a budget of £500pcm as that is all they can afford on his bursary. For which they have asked myself to be a guarantor.
Yet they are have an expensive wedding in 6 weeks.

I did discuss to them about spending less and perhaps the money as a deposit on a property further down the line. They seem to agree then bang this is what they decided.

OP posts:
KaptainKaveman · 19/09/2021 09:29

Run a mile, OP. They clearly see you as an easy source of ££££.

MaggieFS · 19/09/2021 09:28

I'm assuming it's your DC otherwise I can't think why you'd even consider being a guarantor.

I agree the spending priorities are off kilter but their choice and not your business in isolation.

The big question for me is if they would still need a guarantor anyway and what the cost risk to you is. It's very easy to look at the black and white and say never be a guarantor for anyone. But if it's your own DC and they need help then it's more complex.

DominicRaabsTravelAgent · 19/09/2021 09:22

2. I have refused to lend them 3k for a honeymoon. They have the 3k but want to use that for their deposit and rent

I wouldn't have either, how would they pay it back?

RandomMess · 19/09/2021 09:22

No way would I be guarantor. They have the money to buy into shared ownership or pay rent in advance but want to spend it all on a party.

Their choice.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 19/09/2021 09:21

Absolutely do not be their guarantor.

This can’t be repeated too often!

PooWillyNameChange · 19/09/2021 09:18

Gosh, some people's priorities. Ours was a registry office job and we already had about 60k equity in our first house by that point. I'm obviously not very romantic, for us it was just a sensible next step, but have to question the point of marriage without any assets or kids of the near horizon anyway.

Nothing wrong with a huge expensive party, but it will be obvious to guests who know their employment status that it's all a bit charade and, if the 'savings' were indeed an inheritance (if not I'd put money on the fact they've taken out a loan on the sly) it's not unreasonable for close family to be a bit Hmm

flowerlass · 19/09/2021 09:18

Having seen their recent spending attitude I will consider carefully whether to be a guarantor

What is there to consider? If they are unable to get a rental they should have used some of the savings to pay up front rather than expect friends to act as an insurance policy.

Consider what might happen if you fall out with the couple in future. They could stop paying the rent and you have to foot the bill.

legalseagull · 19/09/2021 09:15

The money is theirs to do what they want with , but I wouldn't act for a guarantor for anyone ever. I wouldn't risk having to pay someone else's rent arrears. Or my house being at risk if they need debt repaying. They might say they won't need you to pay anything, but they can't predict the future

Goingdriving · 19/09/2021 09:12

I lived in a country with great poverty where people had massive fund raisers for huge weddings and then after returned to restricted lives. Seemed bonkers to me, but it was the done thing.

AlexaShutUp · 19/09/2021 09:11

@category12

Everyone who is saying "don't be their guarantor" - are you assuming it's a distant relative or friend or something?

Because I would think this is OP's adult child, and are you really saying you would refuse to be guarantor? You might be really pissed off at their choices, but presumably the money is already spent - so you'd leave them unable to rent somewhere?

I can't ever imagine getting into a situation with my own dd where she made such poor financial decisions. If the OP has plenty of money to spare and could afford to step in and pay her child's rent, including any arrears, if they failed to do so, then maybe she is OK to act as their guarantor, but if there is any danger of her potentially putting her own financial security at risk by being a guarantor for someone so utterly lacking in financial capability? No, I wouldn't recommend that. And yes, it's shit if they're left unable to rent somewhere, but how else will they learn to make better decisions? I presume that they're living somewhere now and won't be out on the street.
onlychildhamster · 19/09/2021 09:11

My SIL spent £30k on her wedding and that was a 'relatively simple' wedding in a restaurant at a out of town retail park. She lives in Tel Aviv . The £30k would not have been enough for a deposit in Tel aviv but apparently they made back the money from the wedding due to gifts.they afforded to pay for the wedding using inheritance and contributions from family members. They are renting a flat in the most dangerous part of the city 2 years on; maybe they are not financially worse off than if they had a cheap wedding. Their family (BIL's side) demanded the wedding as they wanted a holiday after travelling in all the way from America.

And here I am, married 6 years on (just had a registry office ceremony with 0 family present) and still no wedding cos I chose to wait until I bought my flat in London and had 10-20k left over from the purchase. Now delayed indefinitely due to covid and travel restrictions from my home country. Other people think we are very very weird to have been married so long without celebrating as that is not the natural order of things. So I think what we did is relatively uncommon and most people would choose to have a big bash and then worry about the housing situation later. And weddings are so expensive now that it is tempting to just forget the budget and just go the whole hog. My SIL had a £1500 dress from a bridal shop and she is right, you always pay with a bridal shop. My dress cost me £450 (it's hanging in my wardrobe yet to be worn) and I used an Indian tailor in Hayes (figured out Indian tailors charge much less as Indian weddings have more outfits, plus they have beautiful embroidery). But I probably did look like a very very stingy and poor person who was always trying to bargain down the price, but yeah at that time, I was buying a £400k property so every penny counted!

I would not be guarantor but go to their wedding and just not say anything about the 43k. It's very normal these days.

Cosmos123 · 19/09/2021 09:09

Hi ,
you are all absolutely all correct it is none of my business.

Answers to your questions.

  1. They manage to save as they have both lived at home without rent and board. They are are 29 &30.
  1. I have refused to lend them 3k for a honeymoon. They have the 3k but want to use that for their deposit and rent.
  1. Yes they are related.
  1. Having seen their recent spending attitude I will consider carefully whether to be a guarantor.
OP posts:
DominicRaabsTravelAgent · 19/09/2021 09:08

Everyone who is saying "don't be their guarantor" - are you assuming it's a distant relative or friend or something? Because I would think this is OP's adult child, and are you really saying you would refuse to be guarantor?

You might be really pissed off at their choices, but presumably the money is already spent - so you'd leave them unable to rent somewhere?

If it was one of my adult DC they could live with us until they'd saved up some money. I don't have enough spare money to be a guarantor for anyone.

daytripper28 · 19/09/2021 09:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

C8H10N4O2 · 19/09/2021 09:05

I'm also assuming one is the OP's DC - it would be unusual for students to ask anyone else to act as rent guarantor.

Otherwise not enough info.

Was it an inheritance intended to fund a wedding?
Do they believe they will never get a mortgage so no point in saving it for that?

Do they live in a country where long term rental is usually the more sensible option than buying when still young?

I'm generally of the view that inflated frou frou weddings are a bad thing, not just because of the £££ involved but because it seems to make people lose sight of the purpose of the wedding. However if its their money its their choice, just as being guarantor or not is the OP's.

category12 · 19/09/2021 09:04

Everyone who is saying "don't be their guarantor" - are you assuming it's a distant relative or friend or something?

Because I would think this is OP's adult child, and are you really saying you would refuse to be guarantor? You might be really pissed off at their choices, but presumably the money is already spent - so you'd leave them unable to rent somewhere?

Gorl · 19/09/2021 09:03

I wouldn’t be their guarantor. They don’t sound very fiscally responsible.

Granllanog · 19/09/2021 09:01

No way would I agree to be a guarantor for someone so financially inept!!!!
Of course they can spend their own money on any way they want but actions have consequences............. a roof over your head should always be your first priority!

careerchangeperhaps · 19/09/2021 09:01

It's entirely up to them how they spend their money. However, they seem not to be hugely sensible when it comes to financial decisions so there is no way I'd be wanting to act as a guarantor for them.

HarrisMcCoo · 19/09/2021 08:57

A home is an investment. The money would be better spent on a property. I just don't understand the mentality of some folk these days.

Dguu6u · 19/09/2021 08:53

@annie335

Totally bonkers to spend that amount on a wedding but then again I'm a bit tight - mine was only 4K 😁

I agree with others - definitely don't be a guarantor.

‘Only’ 4K? Shows how brainwashed people are by the wedding industry!
the80sweregreat · 19/09/2021 08:53

It's money that could be put elsewhere and to much better use than a wedding for one day.
I would not be a guarantor for them , not at all.

JinglingHellsBells · 19/09/2021 08:52

It's quite strange that a couple would go to the effort of planning such a lavish wedding (which must have been in the planning for a long time) yet have nowhere to live (other than with their parents, one assumes).

They sound incredibly immature.

Why the rush to marry so lavishly yet not put a roof over their heads?

AgentJohnson · 19/09/2021 08:51

It’s their money but don’t be their guarantor. I don’t believe that they’re spending 43k on their wedding.

LawnFever · 19/09/2021 08:48

@JinglingHellsBells

I think the OP is not going to add much to this, as IMO it's one of her children.
Which is a shame because I’m dying to know how they’ve even got so much in savings in this situation!