Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the royal family are a bloody embarrassment THREAD 2

957 replies

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 06:47

Carrying on from Thread 1.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4347032-To-think-the-royal-family-are-a-bloody-embarrassment?msgid=110733144#110733144

Haven't seen the OP around, thread 1 is about to run out and someone asked for a new thread.

OP posts:
gibletjane · 19/09/2021 09:15

Who are you to tell people what they ‘should’ do?

Exactly

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 09:15

@HarrisonStickle

I agree with this, although the monarch is heavily governed in what they can and can't do, they still have to follow rules too.

They Queen lobbies to have the rules changed just for her.

Yes, the "they always follow rules and we can decide what they can/can't do" is another information they peddle to get the public off their backs. It will be mind-blowing to know they can get around many/most "rules", afterall who really makes them or is part of the approval community?
OP posts:
WhatWouldKalindaDo · 19/09/2021 09:13

That should have said CAN'T be charged with a crime.

gibletjane · 19/09/2021 09:13

Questioning the Monachry would be comparing the benefits between a Republic & Monarchy. This is just personal attacks.

So we shouldn't personally attack Andrew? why not?

gibletjane · 19/09/2021 09:11

The thing is though Idyllic they are not unpopular. They may appear unpopular on hate threads like this but in reality they are not. Just like Brexit was never going to happen on MN, the RF are not going away anytime soon.

Personally I think a lot will change upon the Queens death. I think younger generations are less dazzled by it.

WhatWouldKalindaDo · 19/09/2021 09:10

Evesgarden

I agree with this, although the monarch is heavily governed in what they can and can't do, they still have to follow rules too. Trump is a bad person but he was still elected in.

Trump was voted out too. That's democracy at work. Sometimes good people get voted in, sometimes bad. And sometimes a good person gets voted in who goes on to do bad things in office. The point is that we get to kick them out again at the next election.

Regarding having rules to follow, the Queen can't be changed with any crime so we're just lucky she's chosen not to break those 'rules', because honestly, how are you going to reprimand or remove someone who can be charged with a crime? (Even murder?)

SpindleWhorl · 19/09/2021 09:10

The Telegraph online today has a very prominent story headlined:

Prince Andrew is being failed by his legal team's strategy, fear courtiers

Concern growing that Duke of York’s ‘wall of silence’ over sexual assault case is increasingly damaging the monarchy

So it's not just we silly little women on MN thinking like this. The monarchy is genuinely in serious trouble. The Queen's support for Andrew actually revolts me, whereas I was fairly indifferent to her before. I have friends who feel similarly, like they've seen her in a new, unflattering light.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 09:10

I agree with this, although the monarch is heavily governed in what they can and can't do, they still have to follow rules too.

They Queen lobbies to have the rules changed just for her.

TheKeatingFive · 19/09/2021 09:09

Andrew is never going to be King

All it would have taken would have been Charles dying childless.

Then all hail our glorious king Andrew til he died

Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 09:07

@TheKeatingFive

People shouldn't focus on their dislike for the RF, they should look at how unstabliising a Monarchy referendum would be after the awful five years we have had Brexit and Covid.

Who are you to tell people what they ‘should’ do?

Yes there are two issues here.

Is it right it the right thing to move on from monarchical government? Yes in my eyes, without question.

How do you go about it? That’s obviously really challenging, you’re right.

We cannot trust the current Politicians to be head of state. Would you want people like Boris as head of state? Sturgeon? Trump? Really?

But please stop trotting out these lazy ass arguments. Google ireland the type of people they elect as president.

And quite honestly, I’d prefer a Sturgeon or Boris president we could get rid of than Andrew as king until he died. It could have easily happened.

Andrew is never going to be King @TheKeatingFive Confused

Maybe you should google that.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 09:05

William charmed his wife's (ex) friend well enough. Just because they used their might to keep it out of the press here, doesn't make it not true btw. He was obviously keeping up the family traditions practiced by the men in his family for generations! Grin

Yes, republicans are in a minority in the UK. However, that's going to flip soon in Northern Ireland, and in Scotland fewer than half the population actively support having a monarchy, so they're less Royalist than England and Wales.

Someone mentioned that they do a lot for charity. When you look at the court circular, you see they have plenty of time to themselves. In exchange for their inherited wealth, income from us and the vast resources (property, jewels, art) available to them it's a pretty good exchange. And if they did nothing at all more of the time more people would question why they didn't have jobs and earn their own money.

Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 09:04

@WhatWouldKalindaDo

Evesgarden

My take on that thick/useless/unpopular comment is that it isn't directed at any member of the Royal Family, just a hypothetical what if?

Thankfully the Queen appears to be none of those things, but the question of who comes after her and if they possess any of those traits is a pertinent question!

I think we have been lucky so far with the monarchs we have had, but all it takes is for the title to be passed to someone who is not a good person, and suddenly you have a problem (especially with Sovereign Immunity). It's important we discuss this.

I think we have been lucky so far with the monarchs we have had, but all it takes is for the title to be passed to someone who is not a good person, and suddenly you have a problem (especially with Sovereign Immunity). It's important we discuss this

I agree with this, although the monarch is heavily governed in what they can and can't do, they still have to follow rules too. Trump is a bad person but he was still elected in.

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 09:00

Questioning the Monachry would be comparing the benefits between a Republic & Monarchy

It's good to question the people behind the Monarchy, those who've been peddled as blameless for ages. Now that people can see they're far from it, you think they shouldn't focus on that? They should keep their eyes closed and fawn over the very definition of self-appointed, entitled and filthy-rich while the country is barely scraping by?

OP posts:
WhatWouldKalindaDo · 19/09/2021 09:00

Evesgarden

We cannot trust the current Politicians to be head of state. Would you want people like Boris as head of state? Sturgeon? Trump? Really?

The difference is that we get to vote for them, and get rid of them at the next vote if they're shit.

TheKeatingFive · 19/09/2021 09:00

People shouldn't focus on their dislike for the RF, they should look at how unstabliising a Monarchy referendum would be after the awful five years we have had Brexit and Covid.

Who are you to tell people what they ‘should’ do?

Yes there are two issues here.

Is it right it the right thing to move on from monarchical government? Yes in my eyes, without question.

How do you go about it? That’s obviously really challenging, you’re right.

We cannot trust the current Politicians to be head of state. Would you want people like Boris as head of state? Sturgeon? Trump? Really?

But please stop trotting out these lazy ass arguments. Google ireland the type of people they elect as president.

And quite honestly, I’d prefer a Sturgeon or Boris president we could get rid of than Andrew as king until he died. It could have easily happened.

BeckyWithTheAverageHair · 19/09/2021 08:59

That's just stating a fact isn't it @Evesgarden? We don't get a choice. Sure we're lucky with Elizabeth II but we might've just as easily got the king of Sweden who's consorted with prostitutes, the former king of Spain whose dodgy financial dealings led to his abdication or a drunken boor like Ernst of Hanover. In fact, if Britain had had laws like other countries that didn't let women inherit the throne then Ernst would be our king now!

WhatWouldKalindaDo · 19/09/2021 08:58

Evesgarden

My take on that thick/useless/unpopular comment is that it isn't directed at any member of the Royal Family, just a hypothetical what if?

Thankfully the Queen appears to be none of those things, but the question of who comes after her and if they possess any of those traits is a pertinent question!

I think we have been lucky so far with the monarchs we have had, but all it takes is for the title to be passed to someone who is not a good person, and suddenly you have a problem (especially with Sovereign Immunity). It's important we discuss this.

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 08:57

I didn't read that bit as a personal attack. It was saying even if they are, it still wouldn't matter. However, report it if you read it as a personal attack.

Is that what makes this whole thread a hate thread then? One or two posts that you interpreted as personal attacks? That would render all of MN a hate site if we go by that logic.

OP posts:
Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 08:55

People shouldn't focus on their dislike for the RF, they should look at how unstabliising a Monarchy referendum would be after the awful five years we have had Brexit and Covid. People need to look at larger Republics ( not just the tiny Ireland one) and see what a republic offers and how stable that country is compared to larger countries with long reigning Monarchies.

Monarchies tend to fair much better than republics. I dont love the queen and adore Charles and wave little union jack flags, I just want stability for the country. We cannot trust the current Politicians to be head of state. Would you want people like Boris as head of state? Sturgeon? Trump? Really?

TheKeatingFive · 19/09/2021 08:54

This isn't questioning its unpleasant

Nope, it’s just fact. Do you have an issue with facing fact?

The whole point of a monarchy is that you get who fell out of the right vagina. Doesn’t matter how thick or mean. That’s your lot. And you have no rights to depose them.

Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 08:50

Monarchy**

Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 08:49

@MyOhMySimon

Lol@ "hate threads..." So far I haven't seen anything here that constitutes 'hate'.

Fair is fair, if you call this rather tame thread a 'hate thread' when it's just discussing the other side of the RF, you must surely be able to say the same thing (worse, even) when you encounter an actual hate thread - and they pop up on mn regularly. It can't only be 'hate' when it's someone you follow without question.

On the flipside, if the monarch is thick /useless /unpopular it doesn't matter, we don't get a say

This isn't questioning its unpleasant and this was just scrolling back a couple of messages. This and the other thread is just the same.

Questioning the Monachry would be comparing the benefits between a Republic & Monarchy. This is just personal attacks.

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 08:44

Lol@ "hate threads..."
So far I haven't seen anything here that constitutes 'hate'.

Fair is fair, if you call this rather tame thread a 'hate thread' when it's just discussing the other side of the RF, you must surely be able to say the same thing (worse, even) when you encounter an actual hate thread - and they pop up on mn regularly. It can't only be 'hate' when it's someone you follow without question.

OP posts:
BeckyWithTheAverageHair · 19/09/2021 08:42

They may appear unpopular on hate threads like this

So any criticism of the monarchy is "hate"? Give over 🙄

SpindleWhorl · 19/09/2021 08:41

@Whinginadeville

What a vile thread it's also the unpleasant minority shouting the loudest
It's a thread. Report it if you think it breaks Talk Guidelines.

In my mind what's actually vile is Andrew and his behaviour, and the Queen supporting him, and Charles and his dodgy mates, and William's less than uxorious behaviour, and the Queen and Charles interfering in politics to their own advantage, the Queen being head of the established church and the state like God put her there, and the country paying for all that crap.

I've had enough of the lot of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread