Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the royal family are a bloody embarrassment THREAD 2

957 replies

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 06:47

Carrying on from Thread 1.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4347032-To-think-the-royal-family-are-a-bloody-embarrassment?msgid=110733144#110733144

Haven't seen the OP around, thread 1 is about to run out and someone asked for a new thread.

OP posts:
Seventhascent · 19/09/2021 15:30

Also interesting BeckytheAvenger!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 19/09/2021 15:29

Barbados has dropped the Queen with no input from the UK

Not quite; it's true that their GG said last September that they'd do it, and that it would be sorted by this November, but how it's going is anyone's guess (there doesn't seem to be anything current online)

I agree, though, that it can't be long

Seventhascent · 19/09/2021 15:29

V interesting Puzzledandpissedoff and Harrisonstickle

BeckyWithTheAverageHair · 19/09/2021 15:27

@Puzzledandpissedoff The model presented to Australia was flawed - what was proposed was that the PM and politicians would elect a head of state. The people weren't happy with this as, naturally, they wanted a say in who the HoS would be. Can't blame them really.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 15:23

[quote BeckyWithTheAverageHair]@HarrisonStickle I think the PP meant will the British public get a chance to vote on abolishing the monarchy in the U.K.[/quote]
Ah, right! Not at the moment, perhaps one day. Too many people still want them.

Although as I said in the first thread, Northern Ireland will soon flip to a republican majority, and in Scotland less than half the population currently fully supports them. In Wales, the country's divided with a chunk of it having less than 50% support for the RF.

Who knows what will happen in the next couple of decades. I think it may go the way of religious belief eventually.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 19/09/2021 15:21

I'm pretty sure Australia will decide to become a republic after the Queen is gone

I'd like to think so, but Australia seems a little bit ... odd on this subject
Many of us remember the Governor General sacking the PM in '75, and the outcry about a republic being needed NOW. Except that, when they finally got their referendum they decided to keep the monarchy

Another thing which isn't factored in is the absolute blizzard of PR spin we'll get when Charles takes over. I don't imagine even he's ignorant of his "popularity scores", and after all the peasants will have to be placated somehow

BeckyWithTheAverageHair · 19/09/2021 15:17

@HarrisonStickle I think the PP meant will the British public get a chance to vote on abolishing the monarchy in the U.K.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 15:15

Gosh, I hardly think the UK would have a vote in whether or not Australia ditches the monarchy! A country deciding how to move forward on this issue is none of the UK's business.

Barbados has dropped the Queen with no input from the UK, and Jamaica could be next, with the majority of Jamaicans wanting her removed.

Seventhascent · 19/09/2021 15:10

However, I'd urge you to think more widely about the system of governance in the UK, and the non democratic nature of a RF. When people feel reliant on an unelected person with soft power, who because of luck has an interest in this (he could have been a climate change denier and nothing anyone could have done about it), to help save a national and vital industry, then we're in a worse mess than I feel most of us realise.

^^Totally agree with this! Farmers are the true custodians of the land and in most cases get less and less reward for it.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 15:05

it comes to something when the only people sticking up for the family farm are Prince Charles and Jeremy Clarkson

Indeed it is, and I think it's because the UK is one of the most corrupt States in the world. However, we are the experts at PR (this thread highlights that) and fooling the world into thinking we are a beacon of democracy. The wheels of that particular bus have only started to come off because Brexit is shining an unwelcome torch into the true machinations of power and corruption in the UK.

LivingOnAnIsland · 19/09/2021 15:05

@Whinginadeville

What a vile thread it's also the unpleasant minority shouting the loudest
This - as usual on Mumsnet. Luckily, those of us that live in the real world realise that opinions on Mumsnet are just minority rantings most of the time.
Seventhascent · 19/09/2021 15:01

The monarchy seems to do everything within its power to defend its own existence and I'd be fascinated to know if any of the individuals involved occasionally have a dark night of the soul and wake up at 3 am and think "it's my duty" or "it's what they people want". Is that how they justify it to themselves I wonder? I imagine that is what they will have been told all of their lives and they will have received a lot of counsel and obsequiousness that won't exactly have been unbiased. They will get used to certain aspects of their privilege too I suppose. It must almost be mental torture knowing that you are an ordinary failing human being inside. And having to "fake it" in public. But perhaps aristocrats don't "do" introspection Grin

To be fair it can't be an unadulterated joy to wake up knowing you are born to be the monarch. And all that implies , just dawning in your adolescence. I don't think all the privilege and wealth would make up for loss of privacy and never knowing if your friend or staff member will sell something about you to the papers.

I think you can see the cracks showing a little in Charles and Edward. It's interesting that the Queen is admired because she doesn't appear to be the least bit conflicted! I wonder why that is?

Anyway, my point is that threads like this are justified because it does make us think about the "will of the people" on which the monarchy depends.

I'm pretty sure Australia will decide to become a republic after the Queen is gone. And I wonder if the UK will get a vote? And if so how will that happen? Will it be a referendum after Charles has ascended to the throne or before? (Coronations take a few months to organise I think.) Will there be campaigns representing either side? Will overseas citizens be allowed to vote? It's all unprecedented territory. Fascinating though! I would love to know if anyone has an idea how it would theoretically come about? Who decides if we get a vote in the first place for example?

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 19/09/2021 15:01

Not just swans! Since 1324, during the reign of King Edward II:

"all sturgeons [except Nicola obv], porpoises, whales, and dolphins are recognised as 'fishes royal': when they are captured within 3 miles (about 5 km) of UK shores or wash ashore, they may be claimed on behalf of the Crown. Generally, when brought into port, a sturgeon is sold in the usual way, and the purchaser, as a gesture of loyalty, requests the honour of its being accepted by Elizabeth."

derxa · 19/09/2021 14:52

@HarrisonStickle

"If you were offended then I apologise. It's nothing to do with you but farming is under attack from all quarters. 'area of outstanding natural beauty' sends me into a complete rage I'm afraid. Along with 'rewilding'"

You're absolutely right about this. And I can see why you may think that Charles with his interest in farming could be a good figurehead.

However, I'd urge you to think more widely about the system of governance in the UK, and the non democratic nature of a RF. When people feel reliant on an unelected person with soft power, who because of luck has an interest in this (he could have been a climate change denier and nothing anyone could have done about it), to help save a national and vital industry, then we're in a worse mess than I feel most of us realise.

Yes your comments make sense but it comes to something when the only people sticking up for the family farm are Prince Charles and Jeremy Clarkson.
HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 14:47

Oh, and btw, another thread about ducks has reminded me that the Queen owns pretty much all the unmarked swans.

I mean, WTF! Grin

There is also, believe it or not, an official role connected with this: Queen's Swan Keeper.

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 14:47

and the non democratic nature of a RF. When people feel reliant on an unelected person with soft power, who because of luck has an interest in this (he could have been a climate change denier and nothing anyone could have done about it), to help save a national and vital industry, then we're in a worse mess than I feel most of us realise.

Spot on. You said it better!

OP posts:
HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 14:41

"If you were offended then I apologise. It's nothing to do with you but farming is under attack from all quarters. 'area of outstanding natural beauty' sends me into a complete rage I'm afraid. Along with 'rewilding'"

You're absolutely right about this. And I can see why you may think that Charles with his interest in farming could be a good figurehead.

However, I'd urge you to think more widely about the system of governance in the UK, and the non democratic nature of a RF. When people feel reliant on an unelected person with soft power, who because of luck has an interest in this (he could have been a climate change denier and nothing anyone could have done about it), to help save a national and vital industry, then we're in a worse mess than I feel most of us realise.

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 14:32

@Blossomtoes

The institution is unnecessary and makes a mockery of equality and democracy.

And I pointed out several posts ago that we don’t even have authentic democracy when electing politicians so there’s absolutely no prospect of it with a head of state. But that’s clearly too inconvenient to address.

But this has been addressed, particularly on the first thread.

You're absolutely correct about the UK Government, the whole charade from top to bottom is a cesspit. In their defence, the RF is only doing what it can get away with, just like many of our politicians. And because the whole set up is corrupt to its core, it's made easy for them to do so.

Seventhascent · 19/09/2021 14:29

If you were offended then I apologise. It's nothing to do with you but farming is under attack from all quarters. 'area of outstanding natural beauty' sends me into a complete rage I'm afraid. Along with 'rewilding'

I understand those issues Derxa but why not address those rather than make personal (incorrect) comments? And yes I was offended so will accept your rather grudging apology! Smile

HarrisonStickle · 19/09/2021 14:26

@derxa

Despotic state = Nicola Sturgeon's rule of Scotland
What on earth??????????????

We're here on this thread talking about the Royal family, as part of that the lack of democracy in UK general elections has been mentioned. Namely because of the FPTP voting system.

In the Scottish Parliament, the D'Hondt system is used whereby some MSPs are elected by FPTP and the rest by this particular form of PR.

If FPTP only was used, only about a dozen MSPs would be of parties other than the SNP. Instead it's pretty much fairly distributed across the percentages. It's not perfect but it's pretty proportional in terms of how people voted. (As an aside I really dislike the way many SNP supporters criticise the likes of Murdo Fraser for "getting in on the list" and come across as wanting FPTP because their Party is in ascendancy at the moment, but that's another matter.)

Anyway. The Scottish elections were four months ago, so it's not even as if they were four years ago and the political landscape has changed completely and an election is now needed to reflect the new state of affairs.

Yes, the current make up of the Scottish Parliament is not how you would like it to be. Yes, the Scottish Government is doing things you do not agree with. That's how it works.

But to say Nicola Sturgeon rules Scotland and rules it as the leader of a despotic state is absolutely ludicrous. How can anyone discuss the monarchy with you when you A. Come out with stuff like this and B. Try to derail the thread with it.

SprayedWithDettol · 19/09/2021 14:01

The fact that we are currently seeing someone avoid legal processes, purely because of his fortune of birth, must make even the most devoted royalist have some doubts about the concept of and the democratic reality of a monarchy.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 19/09/2021 13:59

@Blossomtoes

The institution is unnecessary and makes a mockery of equality and democracy.

And I pointed out several posts ago that we don’t even have authentic democracy when electing politicians so there’s absolutely no prospect of it with a head of state. But that’s clearly too inconvenient to address.

No, actually it's addressed by quite a few people in this thread and previously.

FPTP needs to go and the electoral system needs to be replaced.

There has to be a full overhaul of our political institutions but nobody really wants to get started, all the more so because of Brexit, Covid and Toryshambles.

www.electoral-reform.org.uk/take-action/

www.republic.org.uk/britains_daft_constitution

SpindleWhorl · 19/09/2021 13:55

@derxa

Despotic state = Nicola Sturgeon's rule of Scotland
I can well imagine my Scottish nationalist-leaning Glasgow shipyard worker granddad, RIP, absolutely detesting Sturgeon; although possibly not for the same reasons as me.

But we'd both agree that the monarchy has absolutely no business having 'subjects'.

Evesgarden · 19/09/2021 13:55

@Blossomtoes

The institution is unnecessary and makes a mockery of equality and democracy.

And I pointed out several posts ago that we don’t even have authentic democracy when electing politicians so there’s absolutely no prospect of it with a head of state. But that’s clearly too inconvenient to address.

This.

I dont want one person to head out country. The Monarch can't decide the laws so isn't all powerful, an elected official isn't head of state so isn't all powerful. No one gets too big for their boots. It works.

And that @MyOhMySimon is my point.

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 13:52

Well, talking about "hate thread" but only here for name-calling. Just realised I'm wasting words on hall monitors. No wonder - I could explain myself from now till tomorrow and the two would twist my words to suit their agenda.

Not today, Satan.

Moving on...

OP posts: