Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the royal family are a bloody embarrassment THREAD 2

957 replies

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 06:47

Carrying on from Thread 1.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4347032-To-think-the-royal-family-are-a-bloody-embarrassment?msgid=110733144#110733144

Haven't seen the OP around, thread 1 is about to run out and someone asked for a new thread.

OP posts:
StormzyinaTCup · 22/09/2021 08:04

[quote ChurchofLatterDayPaints]@StormzyinaTCup When the first "elected royal" died, what would you do then? Carry on an X-Factor system where we just vote for anyone from the Windsors who can be arsed to turn up and perform?
[/quote]
Unlikely someone would die during their tenure, the Windsors are blessed with rude health. It may be that they are good at the role and are revoted in over several tenures so health could become an issue but I don’t think we would be voting in at first knockings a nearly 80yr old as the US have done with Biden, so it wouldn’t be a problem that is likely to crop up in the short term. It doesn’t need to be all X factor style and it may be the case that the Windsor dynasty gradually fades out and then you run with something more akin to Ireland etc.

Roussette · 22/09/2021 08:02

She only started paying income tax and capital gains tax in 1993 after forty odd years of being monarch. She's also had a 'monarch to monarch' deal in place since then to not pay inheritance tax (which her mother also had despite not being the monarch)

@HarrisonStickle

Thank you for saying this. It annoys me intensely when anyone says... but the Queen does pay tax. She was forced to pay income tax back in the 90s, after an investigative programme on the telly that I remember seeing, and so the non payment of tax was rescinded due to public opinion.

And the two Duchies (Cornwall and Lancaster) pay no CGT or Corporation tax. Why? They are run exactly like Companies, why should they be exempt?

Today the Duchies also benefit from these two massive tax breaks but it doesn't ring true. Although they operate like land companies they don't pay corporation tax nor capital gains tax. The supposed reason for this immunity is that the Queen’s estate is akin to Crown property and the Crown cannot tax itself. But if it aspires to be Crown (i.e., state) property, then that makes it a public and not private estate— so the RF manage to flip the status of these duchies depending on whats advantageous at the time.

On IHT... the Queen Mother leaving the whole of her estate to her daughter saved her £30million in IHT thanks to the sovereign to sovereign tax break set up for the RF in 1993. QMother set up some trusts for her GC but that was it.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 22/09/2021 06:17

@StormzyinaTCup When the first "elected royal" died, what would you do then? Carry on an X-Factor system where we just vote for anyone from the Windsors who can be arsed to turn up and perform?

Hertsgirl10 · 22/09/2021 00:53

I don’t think that they’re as embarrassing as the media that report on them, for instance one of these day time shows today had a reporter or some royal expert, she genuinely sat on live tv and called Andrew a worried father & grandfather and that it’s hard for his kids at this point, basically there was a whole bunch of sympathy for him and his poor kids 😂
AND then said it’s not been proved BUT ..... we must be careful because the same girl that’s accusing Andrew is an actual victim of Epstein soooooo someone please make this make sense 😂 innocent till proven guilty for the Grand old nonce of York but not the billionaire than can’t defend himself?

We all can see clear as day how manipulative the media are but somehow it still manages to carry on, of course the Royals and super rich will always get away with all this while they’re protected.

StormzyinaTCup · 22/09/2021 00:52

Yes, and I think the same could be said for Margaret too.

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 00:42

Talking of heir and a spare, I think it should be law that anyone in the direct line of succession has to have at least three children. Joking aside, I think Harry has suffered from being the only 'spare'. I think things would've been easier for him mentally had he had another sibling around who wasn't on course to be monarch.

StormzyinaTCup · 22/09/2021 00:36

@HarrisonStickle

It wouldn't need to be a majority, just the most votes. And that could be pretty few if a number of them decided to stand for election.
I don't think it would run into Grand National numbers more likely just a few runners and riders.

It would certainly do away with the whole heir and spare which seems to cause a lot of angst. Everyone in the immediate family, if they want the role has an equal chance (so long as they keep their powder dry) and us plebs have the final say.

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 00:20

It wouldn't need to be a majority, just the most votes. And that could be pretty few if a number of them decided to stand for election.

StormzyinaTCup · 22/09/2021 00:17

@HarrisonStickle

If you're restricting voting to one family how long do you envisage the tenure to last? Ten years would mean eight different people over the average lifetime. Why not allow all nobles to put themselves up for the vote? All the duchesses and earls and marchionnesses and viscounts and baronnesses. Or we could have another It's a Royal Knockout and the Captain of the winning team could be monarch.

BTW people could vote for Andrew in the same way they voted for Boaty McBoatface...

Can't say I have given it anymore thought than the time it took to post quite honestly but tenure would be longer than 10 years but not as long as 70. Nobles, Duchesses or second cousins twice removed wouldn't meet the voting criteria. Definitely no to to the royal ''its a knockout', the one was more than enough.

If the majority of people voted for Andrew then we deserve everything that follows.

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 00:05

If you're restricting voting to one family how long do you envisage the tenure to last? Ten years would mean eight different people over the average lifetime. Why not allow all nobles to put themselves up for the vote? All the duchesses and earls and marchionnesses and viscounts and baronnesses. Or we could have another It's a Royal Knockout and the Captain of the winning team could be monarch.

BTW people could vote for Andrew in the same way they voted for Boaty McBoatface...

StormzyinaTCup · 21/09/2021 23:50

Why can't we vote for a royal to take the 'head of state position' that way we get a say and we do away with the 'first to fall out of the vagina' model. They do a tenure of xxx number of years? That would cut out anyone unsuitable (Andrew for example) because who on earth would vote for him. If the popular vote is Anne or Charles or William then that's what it is.

I get that if you are a staunch republican it probably won't cut the mustard but it would give us more of a say. I'm certainly not convinced that booting them out and taking back 'what's ours' is going to make the country any better off.

NemoSurprise21 · 21/09/2021 23:48

I joined www.republic.org.uk as a lifetime member in 2019.

I hope to live to see the abolition of the Monarchy in the UK.

PC on the throne is a step too far for me. Opinion polls (YouGov etc.) consistently poll him and Camilla as very unpopular with the general public.

I am sad for HMTQ that it has come to this, but I believe that she is shrewd enough to know that it has run its course and is now an anachronism.

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 23:43

@TheKeatingFive

The problems arise when I, for instance, consider a palace, a castle, and other properties, unfettered (and solely for you and your family) access to an enormous jewellery collection, and everything else to be the perks. Whereas she believes that not paying tax and lobbying for exemption from legislation are the perks.

Yes, fair.

I also think it’s a bit strange that she didn’t get any of this sense of duty and sacrifice (albeit on her own terms) through to Charles. And also Andrew obvs, but that’s a whole other story.

I wonder if it's because her father wasn't the monarch when she was born and only became so when she was 10. So she saw first hand that her father had that sense of duty, too. Although not prepared for it, and with his own difficulties (e.g. his stammer), he stepped up.

If you're born into the succession it may be different. Plus different personalities of course.

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 23:37

@TheKeatingFive

Anne maybe.

Wills I get no sense of that at all. He comes across as constantly a bit pissed off and massively entitled. There are also quite a lot of underground rumours now that point to a pretty unpleasant personality.

Yes, I agree that he comes across as entitled. Both him and Kate.

Although with at least one affair under his belt he is keeping up the male family tradition.

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 23:34

@Plumtree391

She does pay tax.

The Queen is not the only royal with a sense of duty, Princess Anne definitely does, so does Prince William.

She only started paying income tax and capital gains tax in 1993 after forty odd years of being monarch. She's also had a 'monarch to monarch' deal in place since then to not pay inheritance tax (which her mother also had despite not being the monarch).

William has a sense of duty? I disagree most strongly on that point.

TheKeatingFive · 21/09/2021 23:34

Anne maybe.

Wills I get no sense of that at all. He comes across as constantly a bit pissed off and massively entitled. There are also quite a lot of underground rumours now that point to a pretty unpleasant personality.

TheKeatingFive · 21/09/2021 23:30

The problems arise when I, for instance, consider a palace, a castle, and other properties, unfettered (and solely for you and your family) access to an enormous jewellery collection, and everything else to be the perks. Whereas she believes that not paying tax and lobbying for exemption from legislation are the perks.

Yes, fair.

I also think it’s a bit strange that she didn’t get any of this sense of duty and sacrifice (albeit on her own terms) through to Charles. And also Andrew obvs, but that’s a whole other story.

Plumtree391 · 21/09/2021 23:23

She does pay tax.

The Queen is not the only royal with a sense of duty, Princess Anne definitely does, so does Prince William.

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 23:19

@TheKeatingFive

I think Elizabeth honestly believes she has a duty to uphold the institution of monarchy and she has prioritised that over most other things, for most of her reign. There is a sincerity there. She doesn’t appear to be purely on the make.

I absolutely do not get the same sense from her children and grandchildren. I don’t think they have the same respect and commitment to the institution.

And I think the public pick up on that. So many people today who call themselves monarchists actually mean they like having Elizabeth as HoS.

Yes, I agree with you about her sense of duty. For a long time, in fact up till fairly recently, I was one of those people who felt an elected Head of State was better but didn't mind the Queen.

However, with that sense of duty there is also a sense of entitlement. And why not, because if you're going to give up your whole life to do what you perceive to be your duty (and what your god has decreed), then I don't blame her for wanting a few perks in exchange.

The problems arise when I, for instance, consider a palace, a castle, and other properties, unfettered (and solely for you and your family) access to an enormous jewellery collection, and everything else to be the perks. Whereas she believes that not paying tax and lobbying for exemption from legislation are the perks.

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 23:07

@derxa

Have you been at the sherry *@derxa*? I suspect you're not from a 'humble' background,
Very working class background here. First generation university as a mature student. Very long lineage of labouring class.

The entire class sytem in this country stinks. That it allows so many of our elected representatives (yes, and the judiciary) to come from the privileged backgrounds they do is abhorent to me.

What is your point @derxa? It's ironic that just after I posted about monarchists' arguments consisting of "I support a monarchy because the electoral system and judiciary are not fit for purpose", along you come with....."look at what schools our prime ministers attended".

Privilege for prime ministers = bad.

Privilege for monarchy = good.

Or are you saying that you don't care if the royal family are privileged because lots of politicians are too.

These bizarre ideas don't even deserve the title of 'arguments'.

TheKeatingFive · 21/09/2021 23:04

I think Elizabeth honestly believes she has a duty to uphold the institution of monarchy and she has prioritised that over most other things, for most of her reign. There is a sincerity there. She doesn’t appear to be purely on the make.

I absolutely do not get the same sense from her children and grandchildren. I don’t think they have the same respect and commitment to the institution.

And I think the public pick up on that. So many people today who call themselves monarchists actually mean they like having Elizabeth as HoS.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 21/09/2021 23:03

Except you don't really know, Harrison, because every so often one of them will abdicate, die young or alternatively live till they're 132, go insane etc. So you get what you get but not necessarily what you thought you were going to get, iyswim.

Alien abduction hasn't happened to any of them yet. Maybe that's next. We could lobby some aliens, can they fit more than 1 in the craft do you think?

TheKeatingFive · 21/09/2021 22:58

You know where you are. Once the Queen dies, the next Head of State is Charles. Then William. Then George. It's not a lottery like voting is, there are no surprises or upsets

This is why monarchy was valuable in the Middle Ages. That certainty eliminated chaos when the king died, constant war and power grabs. I get why that was important back then. I don’t see why we need that now. But I know that isn’t the intention of your post, sorry.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/09/2021 22:55

If the monarchy continues, the Queen, Charles, William and George are what we have

But not what we have to have
If we want to get all historical about it, we could get in a more suitable monarch from elsewhere, as we did with William of Orange and George of Hanover, both times to avoid catholic sovereigns

Then there's the often-touted Sweden, who got in the Frenchman Jean Barnadotte (his descendants are still there) ... Greece, who imported first a Bavarian and later a Dane ... and Spain, who deposed their own Queen and brought in an Italian

It's a bit "out there" I know, but just another example of how things can be done if the will is there

HarrisonStickle · 21/09/2021 22:48

I'd like to hear some positive arguments in support of a monarchy, not ones that start with the premise of other institutions being unfit for purpose, therefore... Genuinely positive reasons.

Here's one I thought of. You know where you are. Once the Queen dies, the next Head of State is Charles. Then William. Then George. It's not a lottery like voting is, there are no surprises or upsets. (Unless one of them abdicates, but then it would just pass to whoever was next.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread