Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the royal family are a bloody embarrassment THREAD 2

957 replies

MyOhMySimon · 19/09/2021 06:47

Carrying on from Thread 1.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4347032-To-think-the-royal-family-are-a-bloody-embarrassment?msgid=110733144#110733144

Haven't seen the OP around, thread 1 is about to run out and someone asked for a new thread.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/09/2021 13:41

If (Charles) comes up with a variety of ideas like that it can only be a good thing

But Charles "comes up with" a lot of ideas, often it seems as a result of the last person he spoke to, and he doesn't hesitate to prate on and on about them ... so isn't it a little odd that there seeems nothing on record that he's said himself about wanting to slim down the monarchy?

Granted a lot has been attributed to him (and some of the job's already done with Harry and Andrew going AWOL) but then many other things have been said to be "Charles's views" and the reality doesn't necessarily match

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 13:34

It certainly would. If he comes up with a variety of ideas like that it can only be a good thing.

ponyexpress22 · 22/09/2021 13:34

I think we should at least let them live off their own huge wealth now and take back some of the many homes that belong to the nation. The queen has use of so many mansions, fully staffed and maintained regardless of whether she stays in them or not. Everything else is being cut to the bone, why not the monarchy.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/09/2021 13:33

A slimmed down monarchy could easily be done without any of the other points being addressed
So that could be a short to medium term compromise until the other aspects change, however long that takes

Yes, that could make sense for the time being, and it's probably why the spin is that Charles wants this - though I'm not aware he's ever actually said anything about it himself?

However with his well known profligacy and entitlement, I'm not convinced it would be anything except window dressing, or that he wouldn't use it to simply keep more of the spoils for himself and his ghastly partner

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 13:32

If Charles has been quoted correctly and he means what he says about turning Buck House into a museum, that to me would be a very good start.

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 13:26

A slimmed down monarchy could easily be done without any of the other points being addressed.

I entirely agree. That’s what I’d like to see.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/09/2021 13:26

... my defence is of the monarchy, not the current royal family

I know, Blossom, and though I'm coming at it from the other point of view I actually agree that the whole thing is about the institution rather than individuals, hideous as many of them are (and rightly criticised for it)

I can even go along with the cost/stability concerns, except that first of all nobody suggests doing this overnight - impossible anyway - and that, for me at least, the issue is important enough to be worth the cost

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 13:24

A slimmed down monarchy could easily be done without any of the other points being addressed.

So that could be a short to medium term compromise until the other aspects change, however long that takes.

From the 1832 Reform Act (where a few more people got the vote) to the Representation of the People Act 1928 (where almost everyone did) was almost a 100 years so I'm not holding my breath! Grin

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 13:23

I think it would cost an eye watering amount because the monarchy is, in one way or another, bound up in so much in this country: the judiciary, land management and ownership, political process, the military, currency, the postal system, the commonwealth, charities, heritage assets and art, huge portfolios of property, religion - the list’s endless.

Disentangling it would be a gargantuan task. It would involve setting up a new department to oversee it and recruiting hundreds of civil servants. Doubtless the big four management consultancies would take a chunk too. It would take decades, if not centuries, to recoup the costs.

Hortibunda · 22/09/2021 13:23

Derxa Accusations of misogyny are valid because of what is required of royal wives. Put up and shut up. Adultery permissable for men and not for women.

Ableism - well sorry but think what many people could do given an Eton or Cambridge education compared with what they have in reality done with it.

And accusing posters of snobbery towards the royal family is frankly laughable. Seriously? That is the definition of a contorted argument!

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 13:09

What do you think the costs would involve, Blossomtoes?

I know we can only surmise, but for me I feel that if done in a gradual way, the costs would be offset by the savings.

I will say that other reform has to be made first. Brexit has been a shambles because of our unfit for purpose political system, so yes dismantling the monarchy with that same structure in place would also be shambolic.

My preference would be:

  1. Change to proportional representation for MPs
  2. Move Parliament to a modern building and construct the physical part of it to a nonconfrontational model
  3. Abolish House of Lords
  4. Do we need an upper house? If so, elected on different terms to MPs
  5. Change Head of State model
Roussette · 22/09/2021 13:06

@Evesgarden

'It' ?

I more than anyone do not want this to be an M&H thread. However, I am allowed to take issue with someone who takes issue with the vicious playground bully attacks on female members of the RF, whilst obviously excluding Meghan Markle from that statement.

Anyway, back to the thread.

Evesgarden · 22/09/2021 13:01

@Roussette

But hey.... maybe Meghan deserved it Hmm
Oh no @rousette has turned this back to round another Meghan thread...

Dont feed it people.

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 13:00

@Roussette

As many billions as Brexit?
At least. Probably more.
Roussette · 22/09/2021 12:58

As many billions as Brexit?

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 12:55

@Roussette

The amount of time, money and upheaval involved in getting rid of it altogether when the country’s already on its knees makes no sense to me

Seriously Blossom it would take decades. If some sort of process were started it just doesn't happen just like that! The unravelling and unpicking of it all would probably span 20 years in my estimation.

Precisely my point. It would cost billions too. I can come up with a huge list of things I’d rather see that time and money used for.
Roussette · 22/09/2021 12:53

But hey.... maybe Meghan deserved it Hmm

Roussette · 22/09/2021 12:53

Years of personal attacks on all the female members of the Royal family. It's quite legitimate to attack their deeds and words IMO but all the rest of it? Some posters are just personally vicious and act like playground bullies

Bloody hell derxa

I cannot believe you wrote that. I just have two words to say to you.

Meghan and Harry.

Absolutely nothing in comparison to what has been said here and elsewhere on them.
Vile disgusting personal comments. There is one I would like to quote here that was said about Meghan but to be honest, I would be annihilated if I repeated it.
I never saw you come out and say.... hang on that's a bit much, this is personally vicious.

Roussette · 22/09/2021 12:50

The amount of time, money and upheaval involved in getting rid of it altogether when the country’s already on its knees makes no sense to me

Seriously Blossom it would take decades. If some sort of process were started it just doesn't happen just like that! The unravelling and unpicking of it all would probably span 20 years in my estimation.

Roussette · 22/09/2021 12:48

Gold piano or not... isn't it always the straw that broke the camel's back?
My defining moment was this....

Maitlis interview 16th January.

This picture of PA and his mother going to Church, him grinning ear to ear 19th January. With no sympathy to the victims and no regrets of the friendship. The Queen did not have to do that.

I felt differently from that moment on.

To think the royal family are a bloody embarrassment THREAD 2
derxa · 22/09/2021 12:44

On this thread? Years of personal attacks on all the female members of the Royal family. It's quite legitimate to attack their deeds and words IMO but all the rest of it? Some posters are just personally vicious and act like playground bullies.

Blossomtoes · 22/09/2021 12:42

I appreciate not everyone shares this view, but for those who do - plus those coming to it - the RF really are the gift that keeps on giving

That’s unarguable. Which is why my defence is of the monarchy, not the current royal family. And why I want to see some pretty radical modernisation. The amount of time, money and upheaval involved in getting rid of it altogether when the country’s already on its knees makes no sense to me.

HarrisonStickle · 22/09/2021 12:39

@derxa

However, over recent years that's changed. It wasn't even Andrew that changed it. I remember the photo of the Queen in front of a gold piano, I think it was her Christmas message two or three years ago, and I felt physically sick at the ostentatious nature of it, how on earth did she feel it was appropriate? It didn't feel Christian at all, and she purports to have great faith in her god, and I think has mentioned Jesus, too, in messages to the nation. That really struck a sour note. You changed your mind because of a piece of furniture?
Yes @derxa, that's right. eyeroll
ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 22/09/2021 12:36

Derxa, no RF woman has been "singled out", they've collectively been slated for the different ways they misuse public funds.

The men have been completely roasted. Deservingly in many posters' views it would seem.

MyOhMySimon · 22/09/2021 12:35

@ChurchofLatterDayPaints

Asking a poster why s/he insists on churning out the same tired and oft-refuted unsubstantiated arguments in defence of people who lie, steal and abuse teenagers is not in my view "offensive in the extreme", but each to their own.
Hyperbole is a lazy but effective weapon for some people. Luckily, all the posts are still here for people to read and make up their own minds.
OP posts: