Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd is sick, lateral flow negative, PCR necessary?

37 replies

ThesecondLEM · 18/09/2021 17:00

Do I need to get PCR? Local testing centre is 20 miles, she is really poorly and has slept all day?

Obviously I will keep her out of school as if she is positive. She has had covid before but I know that means nothing, I am assuming that she has it again? Will do daily lateral flow tests

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThesecondLEM · 20/09/2021 09:50

Test was negative, good news, although she is quite unwell. There is a nasty bug going around school apparently.

OP posts:
Lucythewonderdog · 19/09/2021 21:36

[quote ThesecondLEM]@Lucythewonderdog excuse me but as a result of this thread I got a PCR for my child.

This isn't working because the government are incompetent and are shifting the blame onto the public.

I have been told I have to go into work even if DD tests positivewhilst I await my own PCR results which of course I haven't done yet as I have no symptoms.[/quote]
Yes you have got her a PCR test as a result of this thread but there are plenty of clueless parents out there not posting here and relying solely on LFTs when symptoms are present.

Justwingingit13 · 19/09/2021 21:23

Same here (Wales), not allowed to attend in a “patient facing role” if household member positive.

Anise7438 · 19/09/2021 20:08

Interesting all you hospital workers having to go to work. Our trust specifically states household positive contact means employee stays off work for full 10 days.

Yellow85 · 19/09/2021 20:03

@brazenandstrange

Can anyone tell me why a lateral flow won't pick up the virus if you already have symptoms? Surely that would be positive if you're in the first couple of days of having symptoms?
Lateral flow tests are antigen tests, so they are testing for your bodies immune system response to the virus, rather than testing for the virus itself. They are only as good as your immune system/response and are massively dependant on timing of the test too. PCR tests are testing for live virus.
tigger1001 · 19/09/2021 19:43

@Lucythewonderdog

Threads like these are exactly why this stuff isn’t going away. The reliance on LFTs is ridiculous. Symptoms? PCR and stop dicking about with LFTs
The problem is what are you classing as symptoms?

In order to get a pcr the symptoms are still

Cough
Temperature
Lost sense of smell/taste

Lots of people have none of these symptoms and it does seem every conceivable thing could possibly a symptom of covid. People would never be away from test centres if every single time they felt under the weather they got a pcr. Not only that lots of people just can't afford the time off while waiting on the results.

My son tested positive. He had a headache. Not unusual for him at all as he gets migraines and the presentation was the same to him. We did a lateral flow just to check and there was a faint line so we followed that up with a pcr.

I also was suffering from headaches at the same time as my son. But far more likely to be related to Peri menopause and I've had a negative pcr.

ThesecondLEM · 19/09/2021 19:09

I was torn to be honest, but I know someone who had a negative pcr only to later test positive so I didn't want to get false negative if that makes sense.

Am hoping to get DDs results before I go to work tomorrow as I'm on a late shift

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 19/09/2021 18:59

[quote ThesecondLEM]@NuffSaidSam but we don't have symptoms. Hopefully she will be negative.

We currently have a covid positive staff member who was advised to do LFTs for three days because they were negative. So that's three days of exposure for the team because of pressure from management.

If DD tests positive I will refuse to go to work until I get negative test.[/quote]
Sorry, I misunderstood I thought you meant you couldn't get a PCR for DD.

TBH though I would have just said you had symptoms/had been in contact with someone and ordered tests for all of you at the same time. It may be technically against the rules, but it's infinitely more sensible!

ThesecondLEM · 19/09/2021 18:51

@NuffSaidSam but we don't have symptoms. Hopefully she will be negative.

We currently have a covid positive staff member who was advised to do LFTs for three days because they were negative. So that's three days of exposure for the team because of pressure from management.

If DD tests positive I will refuse to go to work until I get negative test.

OP posts:
CraftyGin · 19/09/2021 18:48

You can get a PCR by post.

ThesecondLEM · 19/09/2021 18:47

@Lucythewonderdog excuse me but as a result of this thread I got a PCR for my child.

This isn't working because the government are incompetent and are shifting the blame onto the public.

I have been told I have to go into work even if DD tests positivewhilst I await my own PCR results which of course I haven't done yet as I have no symptoms.

OP posts:
Lucythewonderdog · 19/09/2021 16:18

Threads like these are exactly why this stuff isn’t going away. The reliance on LFTs is ridiculous. Symptoms? PCR and stop dicking about with LFTs

NuffSaidSam · 19/09/2021 16:13

'we can't get a pcr unless she is positive'

That's not correct you can get a PCR if you have symptoms, regardless of LFT results.

Moraxella · 19/09/2021 16:08

@ThesecondLEM it’s mad isn’t it, my OH PCR positive and I had to go to work (in a hospital) and then positive three days later 🤦‍♂️

ThesecondLEM · 19/09/2021 15:52

We decided to drive to the test centre in the end as DD is wanting to return to school as soon as she can and we can't get a pcr unless she is positive. I am still expected to go to work though and the guidance confirms that this is OK 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
FlatteredFool · 18/09/2021 17:49

Lots at school have had negative lfts followed the next day by positive PCRs. No symptoms.

ThesecondLEM · 18/09/2021 17:40

Thanks guys, have sent for a PCR for her.

OP posts:
Snufkin2 · 18/09/2021 17:33

@ThesecondLEM

We didn't get her tested last time as we all had it, dp and myself tested positive so seemed pointless. We were all isolating.

The guidance has changed though, I don't have to isolate as I'm double jabbed which is weird if you ask me.

If hers is positive you should still isolate till you have a PCR yourself. The difference now is that you don't have to then continue to isolate if yours is negative and you're fully vaccinated.
tigger1001 · 18/09/2021 17:25

When did the rest of you test positive? If you suspect she was positive in the last 90 days you shouldn't do a pcr as could be a false positive.

EatYourVegetables · 18/09/2021 17:23

@brazenandstrange

Mathematically this is what happens. (I will make up all the numbers but you can get the idea from them, they are very approximately right.)

The LFT has something like 20% false negatives, meaning that in about 20% of infected people it incorrectly gives a negative.

If you give such a test to a group that is likely to be infected, that will be a lot of false results. Eg, take a group of 1000 people with symptoms such that 500 of them don’t have covid and 500 have covid. Say they all take LFT. It will tell all 500 people without covid that they are negative, it will tell 400 of the people with covid that they are positive, and it will tell 100 of the people with covid that they are negative. So you end up with 100 people with covid walking around convinced they are negative and spreading it (bad).

If you give this test to a group which is not likely to have covid, you will get fewer false negatives. Eg, take a group of 1000 people with no symptoms, and in that group 10 people have asymptomatic covid and 990 don’t have covid. The test will correctly say that 990 are negative, it will tell 8 asymptomatic people with covid that they are positive, and it will tell 2 asymptomatic people with covid that they are negative. So, you end up with 2 people walking around with covid convinced they are negative and spreading it (which is bad but not as bad as having 100).

Hope this helps.

jacks11 · 18/09/2021 17:15

Lateral flow tests have a high false negative rate (some studies suggest as high as 48%)- if you have symptoms you need a PCR to be sure you are negative. Equally, if you have a positive lateral flow, you need a confirmatory pcr as you can have positive lateral flows for weeks after infection has resolved.

In short- lateral flows are screening tests and the PCR are the more accurate diagnostic tests.

Dunrovi · 18/09/2021 17:13

@brazenandstrange

Can anyone tell me why a lateral flow won't pick up the virus if you already have symptoms? Surely that would be positive if you're in the first couple of days of having symptoms?
It might well show up. Certainly did for my Dd and her friend who both thought they had a cold. All they're saying is that it's not as sensitive as a PCR test so you can't trust a negative LFT as a definitive answer as to whether the symptoms you are suffering are Covid or not.
MrsAvocet · 18/09/2021 17:12

My DS started feeling non specifically unwell on Weds afternoon.LFT was negative. By Thursday morning he was coughing so we took him for a PCR which was positive. My adult DD also had a negative LFT and a positive PCR and I have heard of quite a lot of similar experiences. I would get it done if I were you. The postal ones take a bit longer obviously but only a day or two so you could do that if you dont want to go to a testing centre. Hope she feels better soon.

MsAwesomeDragon · 18/09/2021 17:09

@brazenandstrange

Can anyone tell me why a lateral flow won't pick up the virus if you already have symptoms? Surely that would be positive if you're in the first couple of days of having symptoms?
The lateral flow tests just aren't sensitive enough to pick up all infections. If you get a positive LFT then you're not than likely to have it, but if you get a negative LFT that means you could still have it but the test has missed it.
ThesecondLEM · 18/09/2021 17:08

@EatYourVegetables oh that's really helpful, thank you I'll send for that now.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread