Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU

62 replies

Yankee63 · 18/09/2021 14:56

Partner & I together 20 yrs living together 18yrs
I out deposit down from equity from my previous house 80k
He got mortgage for his part, but BOTH names on mortgage . Mortgage is tenants in common
My 80k is protected, albeit learning my solicitor chose the wrong wording at the time!

This as been a massive argument with us in past & more recently!
Him saying, this should not be there anymore,
I get this 100% , after 18 yrs.
But my reason being it’s still there is
He cheated 5 yrs ago

In order to NOT let this be a big hindrance/sore point any longer and to put it behind us

Do I get rid of protection 80k ? and things get better between us financially?
Or what ??

I

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChargingBuck · 24/09/2021 16:39

Yet OP wants to keep her £80k plus half of the rest

I don't think she does ...
iirc she simply prefers to wait out the 18 months remaining on the mortgage, at which point her ringfence is removed, & the value of the house is split 50/50.

Aprilx · 24/09/2021 11:24

@SarahBellam

I'd say there was a reason he wants to be able to get his hands on some of that £80k and I wouldn't let him near it with a barge pole.
What is it people don’t understand on this thread.

They have both contributed £80k, OP had hers in cash, the partner took out a mortgage, but it was still split equally between them. Yet OP wants to keep her £80k plus half of the rest, he wants a 50:50 split representing their equal contributions.

Other than he was a bit dumb to agree to set it up this way in the first place, OP is being immoral to take advantage in this way … even if he did cheat, this is not excuse to rip somebody off financially to this massive extent.

SarahBellam · 24/09/2021 05:51

I'd say there was a reason he wants to be able to get his hands on some of that £80k and I wouldn't let him near it with a barge pole.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 21/09/2021 17:19

What’s the value of the house now?

Saz12 · 20/09/2021 16:25

If you’ve both paid in £80k of capital, then surely you both own 50% of the house (ie if he paid the mortgage himself)?

If you were paying half of the mortgage (ie your £80k deposit then £40k if the £80k mortgage) then you own 75% of the house, surely - you paid £120k if the capital and he paid £40k if the capital.

TempName01 · 20/09/2021 16:14

Pay the remaining 7k off yourself then see what he wants to do (assuming you have some savings). It’s not worth 18 months of anguish. If you’ve each paid in 80k then the house value should be split 50/50.

billy1966 · 19/09/2021 19:10

@Aquamarine1029

I think your partner is shady as fuck. I wouldn't trust him any further than I could throw him. Protect your money/assets at all costs.
This OP.

Wouldn't change a thing.Flowers

BraveGoldie · 19/09/2021 18:27

@AcrossthePond55

Maybe you should mention to him the interest you've LOST because you didn't invest your £80K and just take out the mortgage with him.

I wouldn't change a damn thing. He's a cheat therefore he cannot be trusted. And he's pressuring you to make a decision that is disadvantageous to you and very advantageous to him. No fucking way.

She hasn't lost interest. The money was previously invested in a house allowing her to live somewhere. It Was reinvested in a house, allowing her to live somewhere. Where was she meant to live if she kept that money in cash in a bank?

Also, the 80k has grown with property price increases, thus increasing in value much more than it would while sitting in a bank earning a tiny amount of interest due.......

ThinWomansBrain · 19/09/2021 00:58

sounds like you should think about whether you want the relationship to continue or not, regardless of the financial position.
don't stay tied in a relationship you're not happy in because of who put in what deposit 18 years ago.
If you decide you want to walk away, maximise your financial position - if you stay together, maybe be a bit more magnanimous.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 19/09/2021 00:49

@RandomMess

At the end of the day you sacrificed a mortgage free home I order to let him gain an asset and he sacrificed nothing.

I too would be very concerned he's waiting to pull the plug otherwise why does it matter? He wants a bigger share for his DC to inherit/pay for his care?

This is worth repeating and may have been a factor in writing the original agreement.

Arguably, you risked more in purchasing a joint property than he did and therefore should be rewarded accordingly. It is common in investment terms to expect more reward when you take more risk.

In your case, the risk of stumping up a deposit which you may later lose due to the vagaries of the property market, inability to pay mortgage etc is greater than working to pay off a monthly mortgage, the amount of which is within a few hundred pounds of rent.

Whilst I do understand the viewpoint of those posters saying that the agreement seems unfair towards your DP, risk needs to be factored in which might not make it fair but at least makes it slightly less unfair. And the there is the fact that he signed a legal agreement to that effect without coercion. And he has still made a profit from that agreement. It is just that now, he wants to make more profit.

RandomMess · 19/09/2021 00:40

I would refuse to discuss it anymore and sort it out with his solicitor to claim against the original one if he didn't understand the agreement.

Shut him down every time.

He isn't going to end it because he will be left in a worse financial position than you.

It's really sad he expects you to forgive him for an affair 5 years ago yet refuses to accept he made a choice over the house over 20 years ago and now regrets it.

Yankee63 · 19/09/2021 00:34

Exactly why does it matter, it’s in the event off
As I’ve said all along

He as NO children, if anything it’s to buy a property as before as I said he rented.
Though my own stupid fault I suppose I’ve always said “ if you rent, you’ll never feel safe/settled
Because owner may want to sell.
So at aged 67, he wants to be safe/settled

OP posts:
RandomMess · 19/09/2021 00:11

At the end of the day you sacrificed a mortgage free home I order to let him gain an asset and he sacrificed nothing.

I too would be very concerned he's waiting to pull the plug otherwise why does it matter? He wants a bigger share for his DC to inherit/pay for his care?

DifficultBloodyWoman · 19/09/2021 00:05

After affair we both went to solicitors, his pointed out to him that the said deed was written wrong

It isn’t ‘wrong’. It was what was you both legally agreed to when you bought the property.

It may not seem fair to him now but there are conditions under which it would be fair. Some of which, or none of which, may apply to your relationship. For example, if the property is consider an asset of the relationship, you may have contributed to the relationship in other ways, such as the majority of housework, maintenance, housekeeping, cooking, caring responsibilities, wife work for his family, support for him in his work, paying for holidays and other treats, buying the food, paying council tax and utilities, an extension etc. Perhaps you even agreed to this ring fencing because you knew you would be contributing to the property in other, non financial ways.

But at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter. What does matter is that there was a legal agreement that only comes into force if you split up. If he wants to challenge that agreement because he alleges that you and the solicitor conned him, then his first step is to contact another solicitor to find out how to challenge the agreement. To do that, he needs to prove that he was badly advised and the solicitor was therefore negligent or that the solicitor disregarded instructions. Solicitors do keep records so if that happened, then he does stand a chance of proving it. If not, then he is stuck with the agreement he signed.

I find it interesting that he had legal advice from an independent solicitor when you were considering separating and he has since been badgering you to agree to a change rather than alleging malpractice on the part of the solicitor. It suggests that he already knows he would be in a hiding to nothing.

RandomMess · 19/09/2021 00:04

If the trust has gone (clearly has) then pull the plug now.

Thanks
Yankee63 · 18/09/2021 23:52

His argument is
After affair we both went to solicitors, his pointed out to him that the said deed was written wrong
Ie no set date or regardless of how much he had paid off his mortgage!

As that now is 7k

My now fear is
Is he just waiting the 18mth out and then when I say ok “ you have now paid 50/50 “
he pull the plug “ it’s over “
££££ I’ve made 150k from her

I’m I bitter/selfish off thinking this ??

OP posts:
DifficultBloodyWoman · 18/09/2021 23:36

First, under no circumstances should you agree to anything without speaking to a solicitor and, possibly, an accountant or financial advisor,

Now, I am using ball park figures here based on your post.

You put down a deposit of 80k (and lost out on any interest that would have gained if it had been in a bank/other investment) and he is paying off a mortgage of 80k (plus interest because he didn’t have 80k at the time.

Is that right?

Let’s say the house is now worth 300k.

With ring fencing, you get 80k plus 110k (total 190k) and he gets 110k.
Without ring fencing, you each get 150k. What you lose, he gains.

Actually, OP ignore the above. I’ve reread your post and think it is irrelevant.

Your DP is using this as a stick to beat you with. But he signed the agreement, right? In fact, I assume you both did. I also assume you both jointly instructed the solicitor. Therefore it wasn’t a case of you and the solicitor conning him. In fact, if he really thinks that, he (or possibly both of you) need to report the solicitor and seek damages. Im curious as to what his response would be if you said that to him.

He knew what he was getting into because he purposely refused your offer to help pay off the mortgage. He is trying to renege on the contract. I wouldn’t let him. If you stay together, it makes no difference. If you split up, you have just given him a boat load of money.

Given that he is instigating fights over this, I think your long term further is in doubt and would suggest you hang on to as much money as is legally yours as possible because you might need it sooner than you think.

nokidshere · 18/09/2021 23:28

Maybe you should mention to him the interest you've LOST because you didn't invest your £80K and just take out the mortgage with him. Well it won't be much given that the interest rates have been spectacularly low for so,e time now.

I wouldn't change a damn thing. He's a cheat therefore he cannot be trusted. And he's pressuring you to make a decision that is disadvantageous to you and very advantageous to him. No fucking way.

As long as the 7k is still protected there is no advantage to either of them? Just a fair 50/50 split.

AcrossthePond55 · 18/09/2021 23:13

Maybe you should mention to him the interest you've LOST because you didn't invest your £80K and just take out the mortgage with him.

I wouldn't change a damn thing. He's a cheat therefore he cannot be trusted. And he's pressuring you to make a decision that is disadvantageous to you and very advantageous to him. No fucking way.

nokidshere · 18/09/2021 22:54

If you have no intention of screwing him over and this is something that's causing considerable rows in your home why wouldn't you change it now?

As it stands you have now only paid 7k more than him so have that amount ring fenced until the end of the mortgage. That's fair.

Voice0fReason · 18/09/2021 22:45

I think he needs clarity on his position. I understand why he thinks this is unfair.

The house should be split 50/50 as you have both contributed 50% of the cost of it.
His 50% should be less 7k to repay the outstanding mortgage.
Your 80k should not be ringfenced.

Is your deal 80k + 50% of the equity or 50% of the house?
His deal should be 80k + 50% equity less any outstanding mortgage.

BraveGoldie · 18/09/2021 21:27

OP, I am not suggesting you had the intention of screwing him and it was absolutely right to ringfence your investment at the start.

However, the document is at this point unfair for him. You yourself say:

I know if anything happened by what is written at this moment in time I would get my 80k + half off equity
But
I don’t want that,

So why wouldn't you adjust the document or tell him at least informally that you would divide the capital in a fair way if you broke up?

Him cheating/ possibly being a scumbag in different ways is a totally different issue... but I do agree with him that this document is not fair on a financial level.

RandomMess · 18/09/2021 20:56

He is absolutely just using this as a stick to beat you with. I really think he is trying to deflect that it's his behaviour of cheating that risked the relationship.

You can iterate - once you have paid in as much as me £80k each I am very happy to change ownership to 50:50.

You could remind him that he wouldn't even be getting that without you because he needed your name and earnings for the mortgage and your deposit to get a better deal.

If he can carries on then I'd seriously think about pulling the plug on the relationship. He has far more to lose at this point than you - that £80k

Yankee63 · 18/09/2021 20:39

House deeds & mortgage are in both names. He wouldn’t of got mortgage alone back then he wasn’t earning enough.

I have /had NO intention off screwing him over.
At the time I didn’t know it was going to last
Ie it may of only lasted 3 years, so if I hadn’t off had protected my 80k he would off got half of what house was worth.
I didn’t do what any other intelligent person would of done surely?? All off this was
“in the event off” it wasn’t brought to life again until he cheated and we both went to see solicitors. Where his said it had been worded wrongly!!
I was very cautious at this time, wanted to wait until he’d paid his half which was also 80k mortgaged over 20 yrs= 18 mths left 7k

I know if anything happened by what is written at this moment in time I would get my 80k + half off equity
But
I don’t want that, I want him to stop going on about how I screwed him over getting that written
I didn’t word the protection letter solicitor did
but he says WE conned him, he read it and signed it .?I didn’t force him, in fact when he realised he was paying the mortgage himself I offered to pay half but then said that would mean I would end up eventually owning 75%. So he said NO to me paying half off mortgage.

OP posts:
BraveGoldie · 18/09/2021 20:29

OP, I have to agree with your husband.

If I understand correctly: House cost 160k. You put yours in in cash. He got 80k mortgage. You have not paid towards the mortgage. He has paid mortgage entirely.

Then it isn't fair that if you split, you would get 80k plus half the remaining value of the house. Let's imagine house has increased in value to 300k over 18 years. That would mean you get 190k and he gets 110k..... Why should you get more ? You both contributed 80k, just financed it differently.

If you split now, then I can see it being fair that you have 7k ring fenced, because he has only contributed 73k capital into the house (the interest payments are his problem as he had to do the loan, not you).

So I agree the document is unfair.... you are both responsible for signing an unfair document.

And I don't see the logic of accepting you should cancel the document when the mortgage is paid off, but not adjusting it to a lower ring fence amount now.

This is parking any issues like if you stopped work (and therefore didn't contribute to mortgage to care for children) etc...

Swipe left for the next trending thread